Decision blocking Irish investors from pursuing Cork developer of Polish shopping centre overturned
The Supreme Court has overturned a decision that an Irish developer of a shopping centre in Poland could not be pursued here for a €6.3m judgement obtained against him in Poland on behalf of 57 Irish investors.
Last year, Michael Scully won an appeal in the Court of Appeal (CoA) over the enforcement of the Polish judgement here.
Coucal Ltd, a company to which the investors had assigned their rights, appealed that decision to the Supreme Court.
A five-judge Supreme Court yesterday overturned the CoA decision and said Mr Scully could be pursued for enforcement of the judgement here.
Mr Scully, a Clonalkilty farmer who also co-owned Castle Carbery Properties Ltd which built the shopping centre in Opole, Poland, in 2009, had appealed a decision of the High Court that a Polish judgement over the investment scheme against him could be enforced here. Some €48m was borrowed for the purpose of funding the shopping centre.
The CoA allowed Mr Scully's appeal after finding that the use of Coucal, a Polish special purpose vehicle company set up by the investors, which brought the case against him in Poland, represented 'the commodification of litigation' which was clearly prohibited by Irish public policy.
The 57 investors alleged they were defrauded by Mr Scully when he induced them to divest themselves of their investments in the shopping centre, on terms which were very unfavourable to them and very favourable to Mr Scully. Those claims were denied.
While proceedings against Mr Scully in Poland were initially unsuccessful, by 2021 the Warsaw Court of Appeal found that Mr Scully had wrongfully and without authority purported to enter into agreements on behalf of Coucal's shareholders. It awarded judgement against him for some €6.3m.
The Warsaw appeal court also permitted Coucal to bring proceedings in Ireland to enforce the judgement against assets he owns here, including a farm in Co Cork.
Mr Scully then brought proceedings here against Coucal Ltd seeking refusal of recognition and enforcement of the Polish judgment. The application was brought under an EU regulation, called Brussels I Recast, relating to enforcement of civil and commercial judgements across the EU.
In the meantime, Mr Scully had appealed the judgement to the Polish Supreme Court, which decided to make a reference to the Court of Justice of the EU relating to issues concerning judicial independence and impartiality and, in particular, the claimed lack of independence of one of the Polish Court of Appeal judges.
Mr Scully's case here was rejected by the High Court in November 2022 and he appealed, winning the appeal in the CoA just over a year ago.
Coucal then sought, and was granted, an appeal to the Supreme Court.
In two separate concurring judgements on behalf of the Supreme Court, Chief Justice Donal O'Donnell and Mr Justice Gerard Hogan allowed the appeal.
The Chief Justice said it was clear that enforcement of the judgement in this case did not approach the required standard for being an exceptional case in which recognition of a foreign judgement should be refused on grounds of public policy.
Mr Justice Hogan said in the circumstances of this case, one cannot say that the recognition of the Polish judgement should be refused on the ground that to do so would be 'manifestly contrary to public policy' in this State within the meaning of the Brussels Recast regulation.
He said his judgement was subject to the caveat that, while the CoA declined to adjudicate on this issue of Polish judicial independence, which had been argued by Mr Scully in the case, he now invited the parties to make further submissions on this issue.
Read More
Cork farmer wins appeal preventing €6.3m Polish judgment being enforced
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
New larger Child Benefit payments plan with extra top-up rate on €140 cash for families with three or more kids
FAMILIES with three or more children could soon be receiving larger Child Benefit payments under new plans being examined by the Government. The move is being looked at to try and boost birth rates, it has been reported. Advertisement This week, The €140 flat payment will still be paid to everyone, regardless of income. The €140 payment per child is currently the same regardless of the number of However, a higher top-up rate could also be paid for the third and subsequent children to encourage more births. Advertisement Read more in Money A policy paper is currently being worked on to set out the options ahead of the budget. Other areas being examined to reduce child poverty levels are payments for children of primary-school age, lone parents, working families on low incomes and children with disabilities. The Taoiseach has also pointed to initiatives such as free He said: 'We are looking at a range of measures, in respect of the next budget, to bring down child poverty.' Advertisement Most read in Money Child Benefit payments are universal, and are paid to parents regardless of their income - but it has risen by less than €10 in the last 20 years. Little known social welfare benefits thousands are entitled to The monthly payment for a first child was €131.60 in 2004 and stands at €140 now, just six per cent higher. CHILD BENEFIT PAYMENT DATES THERE are five Child Benefit payments left in the year. July 1 August 5 - may be paid early due to August Bank Holiday September 2 October 7 November 4 The Child Benefit rate reached €166 during the Celtic Tiger era, but was reduced during the recession to its current rate. Research by the State's economic think tank looked at the effect of bringing in a second tier of Child Benefit to address child poverty, at a cost of €800m. Advertisement NO SUMMER DOUBLE CHILD BENEFIT BOOST A DOUBLE €280 August Child Benefit promised by Fine Gael leader Simon Harris last year is unlikely to hit the accounts of the over 650,000 Irish families who benefit from the boost. In November 2024, then Taoiseach In a post on Instagram, he said: "A double child benefit payment every August to help parents with costs, particularly around the costs of schools and the additional costs parents often face over the summer. "Please share to spread the word. I need your support for Fine Gael so I can get on with delivering on this agenda." However, his proposed August double payment is unlikely to happen. When asked this month if the double August Child Benefit is being considered, the Department of Social Protection confirmed that the boost is not outlined in the Programme for Government. 1 The move is being looked at to try and boost birth rates, it has been reported Credit: Getty Images - Getty
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
British Conservative Party leader says BBC 'should not show' Kneecap at Glastonbury
British Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch has said she thinks the BBC "should not be showing" Kneecap's performance at Glastonbury Festival next week. In a social media post on X, which was accompanied by an article from The Times that claimed the BBC had not banned the group, Ms Badenoch wrote: "The BBC should not be showing Kneecap propaganda. "One Kneecap band member is currently on bail, charged under the Terrorism Act. "As a publicly funded platform, the BBC should not be rewarding extremism." On Wednesday, Mr Ó hAnnaidh was accompanied to Westminster Magistrates' Court by his two other band members, JJ Ó Dochartaigh, whose stage name is DJ Próvaí, and Naoise Ó Cairealláin, whose stage name is Móglaí Bap. Mr Ó hAnnaidh is alleged to have displayed a flag in support of Hezbollah at a gig at the O2 Forum in Kentish Town in north London on 21 November last year. He was released on unconditional bail until his next hearing at the same court on 20 August. Following the hearing, the rapper said: "For anybody going to Glastonbury, you can see us there at 4pm on the Saturday. "If you can't be there we'll be on the BBC, if anybody watches the BBC. We'll be at Wembley in September." In November, Kneecap won its discrimination case over a decision made by Ms Badenoch to refuse them funding. A BBC spokesperson said: "As the broadcast partner, the BBC will be bringing audiences extensive music coverage from Glastonbury, with artists booked by the festival organisers. "Whilst the BBC doesn't ban artists, our plans will ensure that our programming will meet our editorial guidelines. Decisions about our output will be made in the lead up to the festival." During their sold-out gig at Fairview Park in Dublin on Thursday, DJ Próvaí thanked fans who turned out to support them during their bandmate's court case. Formed in 2017, the Belfast trio are known for their provocative lyrics in both Irish and English. Their best-known tracks include Get Your Brits Out, Better Way To Live, featuring Grian Chatten from Fontaines DC, and 3Cag.
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Man (23) caught with cocaine in his underwear ‘suffered racist bullying in school'
The defendant, who has one previous conviction for possession of drugs, was a front seat passenger in a car followed and stopped by Gardaí. A 23-year-old food delivery driver who had cocaine in his underwear has been remanded on continuing bail for a probation report. Nahid Duffy, Dowdalls Crescent, Newry Road, Dundalk, was before the circuit court for sentencing after pleading guilty to possession of 26.9g of cocaine for sale or supply. Further charges of possession of cocaine and possession of 'magic mushrooms' are being taken into consideration. The defendant, who has one previous conviction for possession of drugs, was a front seat passenger in a car followed and stopped by Gardaí. It was stated that he got involved in drug dealing to feed his own cocaine habit. Gda Daniel O'Connor testified that at 12.25am on April 5, 2021, he was observer in an unmarked car when he spotted a Ford Focus driving erratically after it exited Mourne View on the Dublin Road. This car was stopped at McSwiney Street. It contained the driver, Mr Duffy and a third person in the back. Gda O'Connor said he spoke to the defendant who appeared nervous. The car and its occupants were searched. Mr Duffy took responsibility for a bag of 'magic mushrooms' and for €825 cash which was in the centre console. Following his arrest and during a search at the garda station, cocaine was found down the accused's trousers in his underwear. Stock image News in 90 Seconds - June 21st The drugs were valued €1,883, and the 'magic mushrooms' €110. He told investigators that he used the mushrooms for anxiety. He also admitted using cannabis and CBD. He said the cash was his and admitted having the drugs for sale to fund a cocaine addiction. There was one previous conviction for Section 3 possession of drugs for which a €150 fine was imposed in the district court. For this case the DPP had directed summary disposal on a guilty plea only and the district court accepted jurisdiction. Mr Duffy initially pleaded 'not guilty'. A booklet of mitigation was handed into court on behalf of the defendant. Barrister Stephen Faulkner, instructed by solicitor Ciarán Mulholland, said that Nahid Duffy was of Bangladeshi/Irish descent and had suffered racist bullying in school. He had no trappings of wealth. The money was to feed his addiction. Judge Dara Hayes said that given Mr Duffy's age he would adjourn sentencing to November 11 for a probation report. The judge said it was a serious offence committed while on bail. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
