Lions player ratings as Jac Morgan gets mixed reviews from British and Irish media

Lions player ratings as Jac Morgan gets mixed reviews from British and Irish media
The Welshman produced some bright moments in the defeat to Argentina on Friday, but might need to offer a little bit more Down Under
British and Irish Lions' Welsh flanker Jac Morgan runs by Argentina's lock Pedro Rubiolo
(Image: Getty Images )
The British and Irish Lions began their summer in somewhat disappointing circumstances on Friday night, with Andy Farrell's side going down to a 28-24 defeat at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin.
Farrell pulled no punches in his post-match assessment, admitting his team made too many errors on the night, and there are a few things to digest ahead of the opening match of the tour in Australia next weekend. Sign up to Inside Welsh rugby on Substack to get exclusive news stories and insight from behind the scenes in Welsh rugby.
‌
As such, it was something of a mixed bag in terms of individual performances, with some players likely in need of a big performance or two if they are to be considered for Test selection against the Wallabies.
‌
Among them, the only Welshman in Friday's starting XV.
Despite some bright moments, it seems Jac Morgan still has some work to do before he cements his place.
The Daily Telegraph handed the Wales captain a rating of 6/10, saying Morgan "migrated to the wide channels when the Lions had possession from the very outset and won a sharp jackal penalty in the 34th minute as the Lions were scrambling. Among the first Lions to be replaced."
Article continues below
On Morgan's Test chances, they added: "Clearly smart and athletic, but there is ferocious competition and he will need a big performance in Australia."
Winning that penalty just before half-time was a moment others noticed too.
The Irish times, who picked Tommy Freeman and Tom Curry as the standout players, gave Morgan 6/10 and said: "Got involved in everything early in the game and won an important turnover in the first half that could have been a try. Probably didn't show as much as he is capable of in a frustrating first half. Replaced by Henry Pollock 49 minutes in."
‌
Ruck.co.uk, who gave Morgan a slightly higher mark of 6.5, noted: "Lions debut for the only Welshman in the starting XV. Morgan made a crucial turnover at the 33rd minute, as the Pumas started to gain momentum in the Lions 'red zone'. Not the highlight reel he'd been in Wales' latest Six Nations campaign, with his wait for a Test match victory extending even now in Lions colours."
The Irish Mirror handed him a 7, and were comparatively full of praise for his performance, however, labelling Morgan "the best of the Lions back row", and that he had "fought hard in a losing breakdown battle".
Interestingly, Planet Rugby took a slightly dimmer view, giving him a 5. "A slow start from the Welshman who was one of the Lions who grew into the game as it went on," they said. "He pilfered over the ball well in the latter stages of the half and impressed more with ball in hand. Replaced early in the second half for Henry Pollock."
‌
Meanwhile, the same outlet heaped praise on Ellis Genge, claiming the England star 'bullied' the Pumas on the night, giving him a stand-out score of 8/10.
Genge was at the heart of Tadhg Beirne's second-half try, although it was Beirne's countryman Bundee Aki who seemed to really catch the eye.
Indeed, the centre partnership with Sione Tuipulotu was heralded as one of the key positives on what was otherwise a slightly disappointing evening.
‌
"A stand-out performer in a well-tested Lions side, Aki was the best attacking option for Andy Farrell once again," said Ruck.co.uk, while the Telegraph claimed: "Aki's distribution tied together some bright moments for the Lions".
Elsewhere, Tomos Williams, the only other Welshman involved, was handed similar marks to his countryman after coming off the bench.
Ruck.co.uk noted that he "lifted the attacking tempo upon his hour mark arrival, as the Lions chased the game into the last 20 minutes", handing him a 6.
Article continues below
The Lions kick off their tour of Australia next Saturday by taking on Western Force in Perth.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

BBC News

2 hours ago

• BBC News

What did the pundits think of the Lions' opening match?

The Rugby Union Weekly podcast team were in Dublin on Friday to see Argentina pull off a famous win over the Lions at the Aviva Stadium. Chris Jones and Ugo Monye were joined by former Lions Dwayne Peel and Anthony Watson to debate what went wrong - and right - for Andy Farrell's side, and what they need to fix once they arrive in Australia. Did the Lions attack actually show plenty of potential? Will that accuracy come in time? And they pay homage to the Pumas who made a mockery of the bookies' can find out what they thought here.

Glasgow Times

2 hours ago

• Glasgow Times

Bundee Aki urges Lions to learn from Argentina defeat

The Lions slipped to a 28-24 defeat against Argentina in Dublin as they lost their tour opener for the first time since 1971, albeit against dangerous opponents whose surgical finishing demonstrated why they are ranked fifth in the world. Andy Farrell's men fly to Perth on Saturday and have four weeks to find the improvements needed to turn their ambitious but error-strewn performance into a formula capable of toppling the Wallabies. 'Faz set out the aim for us to win every single game. To not be able to come out with the result that we wanted in the first game…this has got to be one of those things that we learn from quickly,' Aki said. A big thank you to our incredible fans 🫶🦁#Lions2025 — British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) June 20, 2025 'We're adults, we're old enough to be able to take it on the chin and move on quickly. Faz gives it to us straight, there's no mucking around or no hiding here, he just tells you how it is. 'There's no point in trying to sulk about it. If we bounce back quickly and try to get better every single day, this will only make us stronger and tighter.' Aki's heavyweight centre partnership with Sione Tuipulotu generated the most excitement in selection ahead of the sold-out clash at the Aviva Stadium, but the combination failed to add up to the sum of its parts. While the Ireland centre showed his strength as a carrier to surge over in the first half and Tuipulotu had his moments with the ball in hand, together they were unable to link in the way the Lions were seeking and are unlikely to be used in tandem in the Test series. British and Irish Lions head coach Andy Farrell (Brian Lawless/PA) 'We all know how Sione is as a player, he's class. The frustrating thing for me was I wasn't able to connect well with him,' Aki said. 'He's an unbelievable player and there's no excuses, we've got to get better as a partnership going forward. 'Whoever plays – Garry Ringrose, Huw Jones, Elliot Daly – as a unit we've got to make sure we gel together and try to get that cohesiveness fairly quickly because we need to be better. 'Sione has been my roomy lately. He snores a fair bit at the moment, so he keeps me up at night! But he's a great man. It's all over in Dublin. Congratulations on the win @lospumas, that was some contest 🤝#Lions2025 — British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) June 20, 2025 'He speaks out loud, which is good because we need him to be himself. I just feed off him and he feeds off me. So it's brilliant, but we've just got to be better and keep learning together.' Aki, fly-half Fin Smith, prop Ellis Genge and wing Tommy Freeman were among those to advance their claims for a spot against Australia in the first Test on July 19, while Duhan van der Merwe and Ben Earl took a step backwards. Aki admits that when they arise, chances to impress selectors during the 10-fixture itinerary must be taken. 'When there's a group of 38 players from four different countries, you've obviously got to make sure you perform,' he said. 'Every single player that's been picked in the squad has to be able to do a job and if you don't deliver, there are guys who are willing to put their hand up and take that opportunity.'

Wales Online

3 hours ago

• Wales Online

Heartbroken Welsh star issues emotional message as video shows moment it all went wrong

Heartbroken Welsh star issues emotional message as video shows moment it all went wrong The eight-cap international's impressive season ended with a crushing disappointment The moment Davies dislocated his shoulder against Perpignan (Image: Instagram: @samdavey1993 ) Welsh fly-half Sam Davies has issued an emotional statement to Grenoble supporters after his team suffered double Top 14 promotion heartbreak for the third year in a row. The 31-year-old had another impressive campaign in the Pro D2 as he pulled the strings for his side, helping them to finish top of the league table in the regular season. Having made it through to the play-off final to face underdogs Montauban, it looked as though Grenoble were finally going to jump up to the top flight, but it soon began to go wrong for Davies' side. ‌ A shock defeat to Montauban meant that Grenoble's last chance to win promotion came in the Top 14 Access Match play-off final, where they faced Perpignan, who had finished second from bottom in the top flight this season. ‌ However, after missing out in the Access Match for the last two years, it wasn't to be yet again for Grenoble, as they fell to a narrow 13-11 defeat to consign them to another season in the second tier. That match saw the talismanic Davies leave the field with a shoulder injury minutes into the contest, only to return to the action later on as he tried but ultimately failed to rally his side and lead them to victory. Having initially said that he had "no words" to convey his heartbreak in the wake of the defeat, the eight-cap Wales international has now taken to social media to issue a full statement to supporters. Article continues below He has also confirmed that he dislocated his shoulder moments into the Perpignan match, sharing a video of the incident on Instagram. "The pain never stops, but the motivation grows," he wrote. "Thank you to our wonderful supporters. I assure you, we will be back stronger. "After dislocating my shoulder four minutes into the final, here's to a challenge that raises many questions. It was difficult to play through the pain, but I would do it again and again for this team." ‌ Content cannot be displayed without consent It comes after former Ospreys and Dragons star Davies admitted he had "found the spark again" since leaving Wales for France in the summer of 2023, with the fly-half now playing the best rugby of his career. 'I wouldn't go as far as to say that I have been reborn, but rather that I found the spark again,' he told RugbyPass.'I feel appreciated and respected. Article continues below "I think I've been playing some of my best rugby. I feel I have been unshackled. I am now allowed to make mistakes without someone immediately putting me back in my place. "Grenoble allowed me to follow my instincts, while in Wales every mistake I made was put under the magnifying glass," he added. "It was a complete change of pace. "The Grenoble staff try to value the positives more than the negatives. It pushes us to be better individuals and team players."