Zerodha CEO Nithin Kamath shares pitfalls of broking business, wonders: Why the brokerage business looks so sexy
Nithin Kamath, the co-founder and chief executive officer (CEO) of discount broking firm Zerodha, recently highlighted the risks of running a broking business, which often appears attractive on the surface — fast-growing revenues, rising trader numbers, and increasing volumes.
The 45-year-old entrepreneur warned the broking business faces massive concentration risk—where a single change can wipe out a big chunk of revenue. 'I wonder why the brokerage business looks so sexy from the outside,' he quipped.
In a social media post on X on Friday, June 20, Nithin Kamath shared an anecdote wherein he said that back in 2008, a private equity veteran decided against investing in a broking firm due to a glaring issue: revenue was highly concentrated among just a handful of clients.
This concentration risk was a major red flag, signaling vulnerability to client attrition or market shifts.
"As I've mentioned numerous times, a small number of active traders contribute to most of the exchange turnover. This was a lot worse back then. Fast forward to today, it's still concentrated, but in a different way," Kamath's post read.
One might wonder that with the active clients on NSE rising steadily (to 49.2 million in fiscal 2025), these risks must be dissipating, but Kamath claims the situation remains largely similar.
"While the number of traders has gone up, but for both exchanges and brokers, the bulk of revenue now comes from just two contracts: Nifty and Sensex F&O. For us, it's over 80%, and it's similar for other brokers as well," Kamath said.
This means any regulatory change, market disruption, or shift in trading behaviour affecting these contracts could wipe out a substantial portion of brokerage income overnight. Kamath, however, wonders if this risk is factored in when brokerage businesses are valued.
Adding to these risks is the unique Indian regulatory environment, which differs starkly from global markets, as highlighted by Kamath.
India does not permit payment for order flow, a practice common in the US that can provide additional revenue streams for brokers. The prohibition limits brokerage firms' ability to diversify revenue sources. Additionally, the quarterly fund settlement mandate — requiring brokers to return all client funds to their bank accounts every quarter — imposes cash flow constraints and operational challenges, akin to a forced 'bank run' scenario.
There is also no significant exposure to emerging asset classes such as cryptocurrency, which in other markets offers new growth avenues.
Against this backdrop, Kamath wonders what makes the broking business look "so sexy from the outside".
Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations made above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, and not of Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
27 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Magnets in limbo: No rare earth nod yet from China for Indian auto suppliers
No Indian auto component or vehicle manufacturer has received approval from the Chinese government to procure rare earth magnets so far, Times of India reported citing sources. Despite efforts by Indian officials to intervene, the sources said there is "no clarity as yet" on when a meeting with Chinese representatives might happen. The applications for sourcing magnets were submitted primarily by auto component makers who manufacture complete, high-tech assemblies. These include speedometers, electric motors, e-axles, electric water pumps, automatic transmission kits, speakers, sensors, and ignition coils used in engines. Among the companies that have applied are Uno Minda, Bosch, Mareli, TVS Group, Motherson Sumi, and Sona Comstar. Economic Times reported this week that the number of India-based firms awaiting approval from China's ministry of commerce to import rare earth magnets has nearly doubled—from 11 two weeks ago to 21 now. This list includes Bosch India, Marelli Powertrain India, Mahle Electric Drives India, TVS Motor, and Uno Minda. Sona Comstar, whose earlier application was rejected due to procedural issues, has reapplied and is now among the 21 companies awaiting clearance, a senior industry executive told ET.'There were no approvals so far, according to the latest assessment we carried through interactions with industry representatives,' one source told TOI. 'The situation is grave, and there is now massive uncertainty regarding manufacturing schedules and factory output.' The request for a meeting with Chinese representatives is being followed up not only by leading industry bodies such as the Auto Component Manufacturers Association (Acma) and Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (Siam), but also by government ministries including heavy industries, external affairs, and commerce. Senior officials from major automobile companies such as Maruti Suzuki, Mahindra & Mahindra, Tata Motors, Bajaj Auto, and TVS are also involved in pursuing the matter with the government and diplomatic this week, the auto industry held a meeting with top officials at the Ministry of Heavy Industries as the government examined possible solutions to the crisis. 'However, not much headway was made so far,' an official source told the executives said that Ernst & Young has been brought on board by the ministry to assist with the issue. During the meeting, officials also reviewed the current preparedness of some Indian companies that are working in the field of magnet urged local magnet producers to provide a firm supply timeline, if at all possible, stating that uninterrupted production lines depend on timely procurement of components. According to the report, both Acma and Siam have drawn up a list of delegates they hope to send to China if the Indian government is able to facilitate such a restrictions were formally issued through a notification on April 4 this year. The new rules apply to medium and heavy rare earth metals, their alloys, magnets, and related products under the country's export permit prevent diversion of these materials to defence and weapons production, China now requires exporters to secure a licence. This licence depends on an End User Certificate (EUC), which must be approved first by India's Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) and the Ministry of External Affairs, and then also endorsed by the Chinese Embassy in after these steps are completed can the EUC be sent to China for the final stages of approval—first by the provincial government where the exporting company is located, and then by China's Ministry of Commerce. Rare earth magnets are critical components used in permanent magnet synchronous motors (PMSMs), which are widely applied in electric vehicles because of their compact size, high torque, and energy efficiency. Hybrid vehicles also rely on these magnets for efficient propulsion systems. While parts manufacturers based in Europe have recently received approval from Chinese authorities to source rare earth magnets, their Indian counterparts—despite being part of the same multinational corporations—are still waiting for the go-ahead from Beijing. According to experts, this delay is worsened by the strained political and commercial relationship between India and companies have been attempting to build local capabilities to reduce reliance on imported rare earth materials, but experts say this effort remains extremely challenging and is unlikely to provide immediate relief. (with ToI inputs)
New Indian Express
31 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
54 institutions from India make it to QS World University rankings, IIT Delhi highest at 123rd spot
NEW DELHI: Prime Minister Narendra Modi has lauded the performance of Indian educational institutions in the World University 2026 Rankings, which were made public on Thursday. In a post on X, the PM said, 'The QS World University Rankings bring great news for our education sector. Our government is committed to furthering research and innovation ecosystems for the benefit of India's youth.' India is the fourth most represented in the list with only the United States, United Kingdom and China surpassing it, said an official release from the PIB. A total of 54 Higher Educational Institutes (HEIs) from India featured in the rankings with IIT Delhi emerging as the country's top-ranked institute by securing the 123rd position. Twelve IITs have made it to the ranking list. Compiled by Quacquarelli Symonds (QS), the internationally recognised ranking system compares HEIs worldwide on an annual basis. Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan in a statement said, 'From just 11 universities in 2014 to 54 in the latest rankings, this five-fold jump is a testament to the transformative educational reforms ushered by PM Narendra Modiji's government in the last decade. National Education Policy 2020 is not just changing our educational landscape, it is revolutionising it.
Hindustan Times
34 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Rejected for living too far? Indian job seeker shares bizarre HR excuse: 'Never tell them…'
In the early 2000s, Goa's party scene excluded Indians, with foreigners dominating spaces like Anjuna beach. Today, Aman Gupta notes a shift, with Indian tourists now welcomed warmly and able to pay more, reflecting India's evolving tourism landscape.
