For Women Scotland mull new legal action against Scottish Government
The anti-trans campaign group who took the case over the meaning of biological sex to the UK's highest court, and won, has now claimed the key motivation of the case has been lost amongst a growing debate on toilets.
The Supreme Court ruled that under the Equality Act 2010, a woman was defined by biological sex, excluding trans people with a gender recognition certificate (GRC).
Following the judgment in April, the Equalities and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) issued interim guidance that banned transgender people from using the toilets of their acquired sex.
READ MORE: Ian Murray 'does not understand how devolution works', minister says
The contentious guidance was branded as 'cruel', and now a consultation, which has been extended, is now underway before full guidance is published.
The fallout from the ruling also saw trans women banned from taking part in women's football and cricket.
Speaking at a fringe event at the Scottish Conservative conference in Edinburgh this weekend, For Women Scotland (FWS) co-director Susan Smith claimed there has been 'extraordinary pushback' following the judgment.
'We don't want to go back to court, we really, really don't, but if we don't see some action that may be something we will have to consider,' she told journalists afterward.
Smith (below, left) said there were concerns about the lack of action by the Scottish Government on prisons and school guidance.
'We have spoken to the Scottish government and asked them to withdraw some of this guidance, just to say that it's under review – they don't have to re-issue anything at this point – because it's clearly unlawful, we really do need some action,' she said.
'They're telling us they have to wait for the EHRC revised guidance and we don't believe this is true.'
The EHRC guidance said that it is 'compulsory' for workplaces to offer single-sex toilets and changing facilities.
It said that trans women should not be allowed to use women's facilities and trans men should not be allowed to use men's facilities as 'this will mean that they are no longer single-sex facilities and must be open to all users of the opposite sex'.
The guidance then went on to say that trans people 'should not be put in a position where there are no facilities for them to use'.
READ MORE: UK jets being sent to the Middle East as Keir Starmer refuses to rule out defending Israel
Smith claimed there has been too much focus on the issue of toilets.
'I wish we could stop talking about toilets all the time, because that wasn't really the reason we went to court,' she said.
'We went to court about the prisons, about the rape crisis centres, about the hospitals, where people are uniquely vulnerable.'
It comes after Harry Potter author JK Rowling, who donated to FWS crowdfunder to take their case to the Supreme Court, set up a fund to challenge public service providers and employers over the issue.
'We really need people to start challenging where they feel that organisations, local councils are not implementing the law,' Smith said.
'We're very fortunate to have the fighting fund that JK Rowling set up and that will make a massive difference because when people start to realise that there's a cost maybe they will start to apply the law.'
Current Scottish Prison Service (SPS) guidance states trans women prisoners cannot be housed on the female estate if they have been convicted of serious offences.
A spokesperson for SPS said: 'We have received the supreme court's judgment and are considering any potential impact it may have.'
The Scottish Government said it has 'been clear that we accept the supreme court judgment'.
'As the judgment relates specifically to the guidance issued under the Scottish Government's Gender Representation on Public Boards 2018 Act and stated that it was incorrect in relation to the definition referred to of 'woman' under the Equality Act, the guidance has now been removed and will be updated shortly to reflect the judgment,' a spokesperson said.
'The Scottish Government has already begun work on implementation. We have established a Short Life Working Group to ensure support and consistency across Government.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
28 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Humza Yousaf is quite right to caution against any involvement in action against Iran
Anyone who remember the built up to the disastrous Iraq War will have a feeling of deja vu as events in the middle east unfolded last week. Just like in 2003 the public are being warned of an existential threat from weapons of mass destruction - this time unless we rush headlong into war with Iran on the side of Israel. Humza Yousaf is quite right to caution against any involvement at this point in what could well be an illegal action against a country which - while undoubtedly a threat - was at the negotiating table until Israel began launching missiles into its territory. The US Air Force has already been moving jets closer to the middle east which could be used to facilitate dropping bunker buster bombs on nuclear facilities. And the Scottish Government should think very carefully over whether it wants Prestwick Airport - which it owns - to continue to be involved in that operation. Earlier this year Donald Trump famously accused Volodymyr Zelensky of 'gambling with World War III' in Ukraine. But it is now surely the US President who is engaged in a high stakes game of poker which could ignite a global conflict if things spiral out of control. Israel is a country which stands accused of horrifying crimes in Gaza where over 50,000 people have now been killed. The utterly despicable October 7 attacks on Israel cannot be used as justification for the massive loss of civilian life. And Benjamin Netanyahu's clear desire to now drag western allies into the conflict with Iran should be rejected in favour of diplomacy. The last 20 years of wars in the middle east involving the US and UK have been an economic and humanitarian disaster for millions of people and have undoubtedly fuelled uncontrolled immigration to Europe. To get involved in yet another due to pressure from a country accused of war crimes by the International Criminal Court would be an unforgivable misjudgment. Legal aid for FAI families Losing a child or relative is one of the most difficult things anyone will have to experience. When a death happens at work or unexpectedly in hospital it's right that Fatal Accident Inquiries (FAI) take place to make sure it wasn't preventable. Grieving families who are faced with having to attend an FAI should not have an added financial burden to do so. Understandably relatives want to ensure their questions are answered. What isn't guaranteed is that they'll qualify for legal aid or have the funds to pay for a lawyer themselves. As the parents of baby Freya Murphy point out, the thought of having no representation while a room full of lawyers discuss what happened to your relative is unthinkable. That's why they are calling for government support to pay for lawyers for families in that situation. The Sunday Mail back their call. The government has already granted legal aid for relatives of those who die in custody. It's right they extend this to cover anyone whose relatives deaths are being probed by an FAI.
Daily Record
28 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Scottish-Israeli citizen speaks out on 'dystopian' life in Tel Aviv amid missile strikes
Edinburgh-born Danielle Bet told of local firms shuttered and nightly trips to bomb shelters amid unprecedented barrages from Iranian ballistic missiles. A Scottish- Israeli living under daily bombardment in Tel Aviv fears Benjamin Netanyahu's strikes on Iran could lead to World War III. Edinburgh-born Danielle Bett, an opponent of the Israeli PM's 'horrific' military action in Gaza, said she worried the country's reputation could be tarnished forever. The 35-year-old, who lives in the Ramat Gan area, said residents were struggling to cope with their 'dystopian' new lives after Netanyahu plunged the nation into war against Iran on June 13. She told of local firms shuttered and nightly trips to bomb shelters amid unprecedented barrages from Iranian ballistic missiles. The Sunday Mail spoke to Danielle on Thursday hours after a missile strike injured dozens of people in a business district close to her home. Danielle, who works for a pro-peace Jewish charity and has taken part in protests against the assault on Gaza, said: 'It hasn't been a fun week. People are just incredibly exhausted. 'Obviously, this is a country that has gotten quite used to rounds of war and bomb shelters and whatever else, but this is one of the heavier bombardments of bigger missiles that we've had to deal with. "It's a lot scarier. Most nights, you're having to wake up once or twice or more, between 11pm and first thing in the morning. "And the actual bombings themselves are quite terrifying. You can hear very loud explosions from within the bomb shelter, and often you can hear the building shaking, even if it's a kilometre or more away. 'Already Netanyahu has left a pretty terrible legacy for this country, not just in terms of what has been done to Palestinians and the wider region but everything that's happened with democracy in this country. 'Democratic institutions have been worn down by his government and his willingness to legitimise the far-right and bring them into power. It's important to remember the difference between him and his government and ordinary civilians just trying to get through the day. 'We can't pick and choose when it comes to human lives, who we see as innocent when it comes to civilians, be it a hospital in Gaza or a hospital in Israel. 'We're so concerned with who are the bad guys and who are not that we've stopped separating governments who actually have the power and responsibility from populations. 'In this region, that's become incredibly dehumanising.' Danielle questioned Netanyahu's motives in escalating the Iran conflict at a time when he faces corruption charges and unpopularity at home. She added: 'It is both true - and it is true - that Iran is a serious threat and also that there are very big question over the current Israeli leadership. 'In the war in Gaza, Netanyahu has proven himself to be inadequate and unable to save the Israeli hostages who are still there. 'I can't say, even with the threat of Iran, that I can put my faith in what I see as a very dangerous leadership. 'Unfortunately, the same goes for Trump's interventions and his comments which have been so unclear.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Danielle, who is active on X as @daniellebett in opposing war and civilian suffering in the Middle East, added she was wary of any direct Western military involvement - including from Keir Starmer's UK Government. She said: 'I definitely have concerns about US involvement. 'We need to know if their end game is to reach a diplomatic resolution with Iran with regards to the nuclear programme, or if this is going to spill over into a regional war, or indeed, a global war. 'The level of instability in this region really needs to be taken into account. I'm very wary of this escalating without knowing what the plan is. 'Clearly, Iran is also a concern for the UK and others in Europe. "When it comes to helping with defence, defending civilians from missile launches which the UK has helped with in the past, that's one thing I would put support behind. I think protecting civilians on the ground is the most important thing, not just for us but for everyone. "But diplomacy is always the thing that's brought us the most security… that is what brings us safety, not war."
Daily Record
28 minutes ago
- Daily Record
US Air Force jets using Prestwick could make Scotland 'complicit in war crimes' says Humza Yousaf
Days after Israel launched its first strikes against Iran, the US sent dozens of military aircraft across Europe including to Prestwick Airport. Humza Yousaf has warned Scotland could become complicit in war crimes by allowing US Air Force jets to use Prestwick Airport as a base. It comes after dozens of American jets touched down at the government owned facility in Ayrshire amid speculation Donald Trump is preparing to enter Israel's war with Iran. In an exclusive interview with the Sunday Mail the former First Minister has called on John Swinney to do everything possible to distance himself from 'rogue state' Israel's 'genocide' in Gaza and 'illegal' strikes on Tehran. He said: 'I would hope the Scottish Government would take advice on its legal obligations and that includes planes refuelling at Prestwick. 'Scotland, including through the use of our publicly owned assets such as Prestwick, cannot be complicit.' 'The Scottish Government should be doing everything within its power to distance itself from Israel's illegal military actions, whether it's the assets we own, the limited foreign interventions we can make…Whatever we can do, we should be doing because this is the moral question of our time." Since the start of June, US military aircraft have stopped at Prestwick 39 times. Days after Israel launched its first strikes against Iran, the US sent dozens of military aircraft across Europe including to Prestwick Airport. Yousaf has spoken out as Israel and Iran continued to trade blows yesterday as the conflict enters its second week. Iran has insisted it won't enter into any talks with the US about its nuclear enrichment programme while the country continues to face bombardment by Israel. Donald Trump has set a two week deadline to decide whether the US will get involved with the conflict. Iranian media confirmed yesterday that a 10th nuclear scientist had been killed during Israeli strikes on the country while the health ministry said 400 people had been killed in total since the conflict started. Watchdogs confirmed Israel had struck an Iranian nuclear plant in Isfahan but no nuclear material was released. In Israel, 25 people have been killed by Iranian strikes and more than 2000 injured according to the Israeli government. In Tel Aviv explosions were heard and buildings set alight. Local media reported that the blaze was caused by debris falling from an intercepted Iranian missile yesterday. On Friday negotiations between Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and his UK, French, German and EU counterparts ended without agreement on whether the country would engage in follow-up talks. Houthis in Yemen have threatened to attack American ships if the US enters the war with Iran. Since the start of June, US military aircraft have stopped at Prestwick 39 times. Days after Israel launched its first strikes against Iran, the US sent dozens of military aircraft across Europe including to Prestwick Airport. The types of craft included several air-to-air refuelling KC-135 Stratotankers, a C-17A Globemaster III cargo plane and C-13- Hercules military transport plane. Military analysts fear it signals Trump is preparing to enter the war. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu previously claimed: 'If not stopped, Iran could produce a nuclear weapon in a very short time.' However Yousaf condemned Israel's attacks on Iran as 'illegal' and said there was 'no credible evidence that Iran is developing a nuclear weapon.' He said: 'If the US decides to join Israel and illegally strike Iran, it won't just have regional impacts but global ramifications as well. 'I note that Donald Trump has decided to give a 2-week window to decide what to do next. I would urge diplomacy. 'The UK should have nothing to do with any strikes on Iran, they should be leading the diplomatic effort, getting people round the table for diplomacy to prevail, to allow agreement and not air strikes to pave the way forward.' Yousaf insisted Israel had attacked Iran to 'distract from what is going on in Gaza'. He said: '[Gaza] continues to see hundreds, thousands of Palestinians murdered including when queuing for food. 'The second reason [for the strikes] is to quite literally blow up the talks taking place between Iran and the United States. 'The strike was three days before the US and Iran were due to have talks about the nuclear programme. It's not just illegal, it's deeply cynical, shameful and I can't understand why anyone would seek to defend it.' He said his criticism of Israel 'should not be confused with any support for the Iranian regime', and said the country must comply with nuclear inspections and stop enriching uranium to the levels they are currently. Yousaf said: 'But it does not give Israel the right to bomb nuclear sites and kill many civilians in the process.' Yousaf said Israel should be 'treated like a rogue nation' similar to South Africa during apartheid or Russia over its invasion of Ukraine, with any future diplomatic approaches to Scotland rejected. Last year Constitution Secretary Angus Robertson came under fire after it emerged he had met with Daniela Grudsky Ekstein, Israel's deputy ambassador to the UK. The meeting was only declared by the Scottish Government after the Israeli ambassador posted about the event on social media. Minutes of the meeting, published by the Scottish Government last week, show Robertson discussed that 'there was value in dialogue between Scotland and Israel as critical friends.' Robertson apologised after the meeting and said it was 'taken by many to represent a normalisation of relations.' Yousaf said: 'John Swinney has said we will not have normal diplomatic ties with Israel and I think every single country should be doing that. 'We should be treating Israel like a rogue nation, because that's what it is under Benjamin Netanyahu.' The former First Minister was more critical of the UK Government which he condemned for having a 'continuing relationship' with Israel. He said: 'What we have in the UK is not only a continuing relationship but a continued selling of arms to them, which is astonishing and frightening and should be condemned in the strongest manner. 'There is always more we can do, from a Scottish government perspective. 'I don't think we should be spending a single penny…we should be ensuring not a single penny goes to a company selling arms to Israel and that includes any company based in Scotland. 'There can't be any justification for selling arms to a country that is involved in a genocide.' His views on Israel have been echoed by former Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill who said the attacks on Iran were 'illegal and insane'. He added: 'Israel's strikes on Iran were a breach of international law. There's no doubt that the Iranian regime is not pleasant but there's no evidence of holding or planning for nuclear weapons. There should be no war for Trump or Israel. Nor should we collude in any way.' The UK Government has already been accused of assisting Israel in Gaza after it emerged the RAF had flown hundreds of surveillance flights over Gaza using Shadow R1 spy planes based in nearby Cyprus. Constitution Secretary Angus Robertson said: 'The First Minister has been clear that Israel's actions are beyond any justification and there must be action to bring them to account.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
