Archaeologist refuses to revise Keeladi report, writes back to ASI quoting excavation's integrity

Amid renewed scrutiny from the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), archaeologist K Amarnath Ramakrishna has written a strongly worded letter, refusing to revise his final report on the Keeladi excavations. The letter, sent to ASI's Director (Exploration and Excavation) Hemasagar A Naik, defends the findings and methodology employed in documenting one of Tamil Nadu's most consequential archaeological sites.
More than two years after Ramakrishna submitted his 982-page final report in January 2023—after previous preliminary and interim submissions in 2016 and 2017, respectively—the ASI had written to him on May 23, 2025, asking for corrections to 'make the report more authentic'. In response, Ramakrishna offered a point-by-point rebuttal in a letter that stops short of confrontation but leaves little room for reinterpretation.
'After a gap of two and half year of my submission,' Ramakrishna wrote, 'you have again raised some query on my final report…In this regard, it is informed you that already accepted nomenclatures of the changes in the period was agreed and accordingly the changes of the same was communicated', referring to a letter in April 2023. Responding to the ASI's request for fresh justification of the earliest dating—spanning 8th to 5th century BCE—Ramakrishna wrote: 'It is to inform that regarding the period of Keeladi excavation has been evaluated (as per) the archaeological excavation procedure. Here the period of the site was reconstructed as per the stratigraphic sequence, cultural deposit available with material culture and with AMS date found during the excavation. Based on the findings and facts the final outcome of the observation of the excavator was incorporated in the final report with all documentary evidence, and the chronological sequence of the Keeladi site was clearly explained in the report. The view expressed by you for further examination of sequence is against the well reasoned conclusive finding of the excavator of the site.'
'The tone of Ramakrishna's reply is notably formal, but his words make clear he sees the ASI's intervention as redundant and unnecessary,' said a source known to the letter's content.
Agreeing to minor procedural updates, he wrote'layer numbering will be done if it is found missing'. On the issue of visual data, which the ASI had previously said needed replacements or were missing, Ramakrishna clarified: 'All relevant maps, plates and drawing were given in high resolution format in soft copy as well as in hard copy to the H.Q. at the time of submission of the report. Hence there is no chance of any missing happens, however if anything is found missing will be corrected.'
The ASI's original letter, dated May 15, had asked for a reassessment of the site's chronological brackets, particularly the proposed 8th century BCE dating. It had suggested the earliest date 'can be, at the maximum, somewhere in pre-300 BCE', citing concerns that the three cultural periods required 'proper nomenclatures or re-orientation'. It also cited feedback from two unnamed experts, which sparked disquiet among several independent scholars who viewed the delay and revisions as attempts to dilute Keeladi's significance.
Keeladi has long been politically charged. Following Ramakrishna's sudden transfer to Assam in 2017, ASI closed the excavation citing 'lack of significant findings'. Only after a Madras High Court intervention was the Tamil Nadu State Department of Archaeology allowed to resume digging. Later findings—including over 13,000 artefacts—strengthened Keeladi's claims of being a significant urban settlement from the Sangam era or earlier.
When contacted, Ramakrishna told The Indian Express that he was not allowed to comment on his official transactions.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Time of India

2 hours ago

• Time of India

Hirebenakal eyes Unesco heritage tag through site upgrade

Koppal: Development initiatives are being planned at Hirebenakal, a 3,000-year-old megalithic site in Gangavathi taluk, with the goal of securing Unesco World Heritage status. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Situated 40km from the district headquarters, it requires a 10km uphill trek to reach the archaeological site. The site, under the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), Hampi Circle's protection, sits atop a castellated granite hillock, accessible from 3km southeast of the village. British officer Philip Meadows Taylor first discovered these monuments in 1835 while serving at the court of Nizam of Hyderabad. He presented the site internationally through a research publication in the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society. Locals describe the site, spanning over 20 hectares, as 'Morera houses'. The site's information board indicates these stone structures were built as memorials for the deceased. Some suggest Stone Age dwarfs inhabited these house-like formations. A large pond exists near the structures, indicating Neolithic Age inhabitants, primarily farmers, occupied this area. These rock tombs and cave art are currently on Unesco's World Heritage tentative list. The site houses the second-largest collection of monuments after Madhya Pradesh's cave paintings. Termed 'Rock monuments of early man', numerous well-preserved tombs exist here. Experts estimate approximately 500 tombs at this megalithic site. The site displays rock paintings depicting dancing, hunting, and weapon-wielding figures. Additional artwork includes geometric patterns and mystical designs of deer, peacocks, humped bulls, bullocks, horses, and cows. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now "If properly excavated, more important things can come to light at this site," says Dr Sharanabasappa Kolkar, a historian from Gangavathi. A hemispherical kettledrum stone, strategically positioned on a hillock, measures 2.2m in diameter with 1.5m radial height. It sits on a 10m high monolithic boulder with a beating surface. When struck with stone or wooden implements, it produces musical sounds audible beyond 1km. Dr Sharanabasappa Kolkar mentions that during Rajnish Goyal's visit, the Kalaburgi regional commissioner, in 2010, they proposed including the site in the Unesco World Heritage list. The archaeological department forwarded the application, but Unesco rejected it. "Due to persistent efforts, two years ago, Unesco added the Hirebenkal megalithic site to its provisional list, and we must accelerate efforts to secure its place on the permanent list," he emphasised. Tourism minister HK Patil, during his recent visit, announced plans to develop the site to international standards. He assured that govt would undertake all necessary steps to achieve World Heritage List recognition. Additionally, Patil announced that to educate Bengaluru residents about the site's importance, they would organise a photographic exhibition of the rock tombs at the Venkatappa Art Gallery by Aug 15. Plans are under way to conduct further research within a 5km radius of the hill.

The Hindu

6 hours ago

• The Hindu

Yoga Day marks confluence of cultural and architectural heritage

Yoga, which is recognised by the UNESCO as an intangible cultural heritage, unfolded at heritage sites in a blend of the living tradition of spiritual growth and wellness, with the architectural legacy of India, on Saturday. The International Day of Yoga was held at the UNESCO World Heritage Sites of Keshava temple at Somanathapur in Mysuru district, Hoysaleshwara temple complex at Halebid in Hassan district, and at the Dariya Daulat Bagh, the summer palace of Tipu Sultan, in Srirangapatna, Mandya district. An official from the Archaeological Survey of India said that yoga day celebrations used to be conducted at various heritage sites in the past as well. But this year, it was conducted on a larger scale as it was the 11the edition of the International Day of Yoga. In Somanathapur, the Yoga Day unfolded against the backdrop of 13th-century Keshava temple, which was built during the Hoysala period, and is renowned for ornate sculptures and unique architectural style. The event was organised under the supervision of staff from Regional Institute of Education, Mysuru, representatives from Archaeological Survey of India, and there were about 750 participants in all. The Yoga Day was also celebrated on the Halebid museum premises within the Hoysaleshwara temple complex. In Srirangapatna, the event was organised in the sprawling gardens of Dariya Daulat Bagh which is a protected monument under the ASI. MLA Ramesh Bandisidde Gowda, ASI official A. Sunil and others led the event, and there were nearly 350 participants, including students from Government PU College and High School. Mr. Sunil said arrangements were made for viewing the Yoga Day celebrations led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi from Vishakapatnam, on giant LCD screens. The yoga performance commenced soon after and followed the common yoga protocol issued by the Ministry of Ayush. The theme for this year's event was 'Yoga for One Earth One Health'. Apart from yoga in heritage sites, the event was organised across the region including in educational and government institutions. In Mandya, the district administration conducted the event at the PET cricket grounds. Deputy Commissioner Kumar said that India has become synonymous with yoga and described it as a slice or a symbol of the country's culture. He underlined the importance of incorporating yoga into one's lifestyle to reap its health benefits. Purushotamananda Swami of Adi Chunchanagiri Mutt Educational Trust said yoga should not be confined to one day in a year, but should be part of one's lifestyle. Trinetra Mahant Shivayogi of Chandravan Ashram said yoga day was an Indian festival celebrated across the world. The Yoga Day was also celebrated at various places in Chamarajanagar and Kodagu districts.

Indian Express

6 hours ago

• Indian Express

International Yoga Day: Why is it hard to pinpoint the origin of yoga?

People from around the world celebrated the International Yoga Day on Saturday (June 21) with large scale gatherings, virtual events, and messages of peace and harmony. The genesis of yoga can be traced to ancient India. But it is impossible to pinpoint exactly how old it is. While the words '5,000-year-old tradition' are often thrown around, available evidence simply does not allow for such specificity. Here's why. Two key pieces of archaeological evidence are often cited as proof of yoga's antiquity. * The first is a small staetite seal recovered from the Indus Valley Civilisation (IVC) site of Mojenjodaro (now in Pakistan). Dated to circa 2,500-2,400 BCE, the seal 'depicts an impressive seated figure… sitting with legs crossed in what many have taken to be the mulabandhasana, a posture later to be much favoured by tantric yogis,' historian Alistair Shearer wrote in The Story Of Yoga: From Ancient India To The Modern West (2020). But ascribing meaning to millenia-old objects whose contexts are not fully understood, especially given that the IVC script is yet to be deciphered, is not sound historical practice. Could the so-called Pashupati seal be depicting a yogic pose? Yes. But it could also simply be depicting someone sitting cross-legged, as is common across South Asia till date. * The other, more recent, archaeological find comes from Balathal, Rajasthan, one of the 90-odd sites of the chalcolithic Banas culture. Excavated from the site was a roughly 2,700-year-old skeleton 'sitting in the samadhi position,' a posture 'that many yogis adopt for meditation and it is also assumed at the time of their burial,' Shearer wrote. The exact posture of the buried figure — 'cross-legged, hands resting on his knees with thumb and index fingers touching in the yogic jnanamudra' — makes this piece of evidence more credible. Nonetheless, this only helps establish a baseline date of the yoga's origin: logically, the genesis of yoga would predate what is preserved in the archaeological record. In ancient literature The word 'yoga' finds mention in the Vedic corpus (1,500-500 BCE), the earliest (surviving) literature from the sub-continent. But it appears in a context far removed from postural or even meditational exercise — the sense in which it is understood today. It is in the Mahabharata, composed over six centuries from 300 BCE to 300 CE, that yoga is used in a sense that would be familiar today. 'Some of these citations [in the Mahabharata] refer to yoga in a philosophical sense,' while others use the word 'when describing arduous physical penances and austerities performed by holy men,' Shearer wrote. Contemporaneous and later texts, such as the Upanishads, also use the term similarly. One school of thought states that yoga is not of Vedic provenance at all, but has its origins in heterodox traditions of the first millennium BCE (and before), most notably Buddhism and Jainism. 'The unifying feature of this freelance religious movement was the practice of yoga,' Vivian Worthington asserts in A History of Yoga (1982). Various Buddhist and Jain texts mention yoga. The Yoga Sutra of Maharishi Patanjali is the most well-known text on the matter, and composed around 350 CE, the oldest text dedicated solely to the subject. Most scholars agree that the present understanding of yoga is shaped by this text. What is an 'origin'? None of the texts mentioned above provide definite, empirical answers on the origin of yoga. This is largely because India does not have a tradition of history-writing like in the West, where a sharp distinction is drawn between history, based on empirical evidence, and myth, whose credibility lies in its meaning rather than veracity. As Worthington wrote, 'One of the difficulties of tracing a history of yoga has been that by its nature it leaves nothing behind except myths and legends of miraculous powers possessed by some of the more accomplished practitioners of the art.' There are no contemporary sources on yoga which can provide empirical specifics on its provenance. While analysing textual evidence can provide clues about the evolving meaning of the term and the evolution of the practice, it cannot with certainty provide a singular point in time when yoga originated. Like any other facet of culture, yoga is a product of diverse, interacting influences. And just as it continues to evolve today, it underwent constant in the past. As such, it is often impossible to determine any facet of culture distinguishes itself from antecedents that shape it.