Court hears Kelly Smith's timeline of the day Joshlin went missing, with gaps in evidence
In her warning statement given to police, Racquel 'Kelly' Smith provided a timeline of the day Joshlin Smith went missing. She didn't describe Joshlin's possible whereabouts, and the statement is inconsistent with evidence before the court.
'I'm going to write up what happened on the day's events,' said Racquel 'Kelly' Smith in a statement to police about 19 February 2024, the day her six-year-old daughter Joshlin Smith went missing, 'in my own handwriting.'
The statement, however, did not provide any clues to Joshlin's whereabouts.
On Tuesday, 22 April 2025, Smith's warning statement was entered into the record by State prosecutor Zelda Swanepoel in the Western Cape High Court, sitting in Saldanha Bay. Smith's counsel, Rinesh Sivnarain, had no objections.
Smith made the warning statement on 6 March 2024 after being interrogated by the investigating team between 4 and 5 March at the Family Violence, Child Protection, and Sexual Offences (FCS) offices on the Sea Border Office grounds in Saldanha Bay.
Similar statements were obtained from her co-accused, Jacquen Appollis and Steveno van Rhyn, on the same day. In their confessions, the two claimed that Smith told them to take Joshlin to a purported sangoma, Phumza Sigaqa, known as Makalima, who would have allegedly paid Smith R20,000.
On Thursday, 17 April, Judge Nathan Erasmus ruled that the confessions of Appollis and Van Rhyn were admissible and could be used as evidence against them.
Appollis, Van Rhyn and Smith face charges of human trafficking and kidnapping after Joshlin's disappearance from the Middelpos informal settlement in Saldanha Bay.
The three, who have pleaded not guilty, have denied the serious allegations against them. The State alleges that the accused 'sold, delivered or exchanged' Joshlin, a Grade 1 learner at Diazville Primary, for money.
Smith's timeline
On Tuesday, the court heard more details about Smith's version of what happened on the day Joshlin went missing. Her warning statement included more detail, particularly specific times, than her plea explanation in court.
The court did not deal with the entire statement, but only with the parts handwritten by Smith.
Her timeline of 19 February 2024, the day Joshlin went missing, reads:
7am: 'I got up and dressed my minor daughter and prepared myself for work.'
7.15am: 'I gave Joshlin and her minor brother food and told them their school clothes are dirty, so they won't go to school.'
8.15am: 'I took my other minor daughter and walked to Diazville, where I took her to the crèche. I got the keys and went to Kelly Zeegers' [where she was employed as a domestic worker] home to go and work.'
9am: Smith claims to have arrived at work.
11.30am: 'I borrowed R50 from aunt Carlien Zeegers and went to buy a packet of crystal methamphetamine known as tik, from [the dealer] Gums. Boeta and I smoked the tik alone.'
12.10pm: 'I finish[ed] and went back to work.'
12.30pm: 'I went and left [one of my other children] with her grandmother and went back to work.'
2pm: 'I finished working and dropped off the key.'
2.30pm: 'I went to go fetch my other minor daughter at the crèche.'
4.30pm: 'I borrowed R200 from aunt Carlien to refill gas.'
4.45pm: 'I arrived at home and asked Boeta, 'Where are the children?' He told me my minor son is with brother Louw and that Joshlin is around, her hair hanging loosely.'
5pm: 'I called out Joshlin and she did not respond.'
5.15pm: 'Boeta, Steveno and I went to go buy gas. Came back and again at Gums bought a packet of tik. We smoked it and then I called again out to Joshlin.'
6pm: Smith's minor son came home and she told him he had to call his sisters. He said he knew where his minor sister was, but he did not see Joshlin. He went to fetch his other sister
7pm: 'My neighbour and I went to go and look for Joshlin in Diazville.'
8.30pm: 'We were back in Middelpos and further looked for Joshlin.'
9pm: 'I called the police.'
9.30pm: 'The police came and we went to go and search for Joshlin.'
Smith's statement appears to contradict both State witness Laurentia Lombaard's version of what happened to Joshlin and evidence from Kelly Zeegers, at whose home Smith said she worked on that day.
Lombaard, who was initially accused number four in the kidnapping and human trafficking trial, told the court how Smith allegedly plotted to sell the six-year-old to a sangoma for R20,000.
Zeegers, however, told the court that Smith had not worked at her house at all on that day. CCTV footage has indicated that Smith was not at Zeegers' home.
Sangomas, seers and international help
On Tuesday, Captain Wesley Lombard, the investigating officer in the Joshlin case, told the court about the extensive and international hunt for the missing girl, which included satellite assistance, help from Interpol, and 'online researchers', so-called seers and sangomas.
'During the investigation, various seers approached the team with differing perspectives about Joshlin's whereabouts and what happened to her. Some of the seers were from our country, while others were from other countries. What was interesting about these seers is that every second day they basically come with information on Joshlin's whereabouts.
'People who introduced themselves as sangomas said they are going to use their traditional practices to help the police to determine where Joshlin might be or can get the body,' he told the court.
Other 'internet researchers' assisted the investigating team by analysing web content and reporting their results.
Lombard said people with access to satellites scanned the Diazville dunes and sent photographs to the authorities, revealing where items might be buried under the sand.
'We followed up on that information since they provided us with GPS locations. The K9 dog squad, as well as forensic professionals who analyse bones, were involved in the hunt. Again, no results,' he told the court.
The investigative team turned its attention to people in the area who had been convicted of crimes against minors and women. Again, this turned up no leads.
The team tried to find out whether CCTV in Diazville and the wider Saldanha Bay area could help.
'We found that there were no municipal cameras in the streets where Kelly lived, as there are in Cape Town. We located one camera in the area, but it only worked within the working site and did not capture footage of the streets,' he told the court.
Lombaard said the investigating team received information that Interpol, with the help of the UK's National Crime Agency (NCA), suspected that Joshlin may have been taken aboard a ship.
According to Lombard's testimony, on Saturday, 16 April 2024, the NCA informed SAPS they had boarded the ship after it docked in Port Talbot, Wales. The authorities searched the boat for nearly two days, but only 21 Philippines nationals were found on the vessel.
Lombard told the court the search for Joshlin continued.
State closes its case
On Tuesday, State prosecutor Swanepoel told the court that the State would close its case on Wednesday.
The outstanding issues to be dealt with are the TikTok videos that went viral on social media, which have been handed in as exhibits. Van Rhyn's counsel indicated that he wanted to see the videos, which will be played in court on Wednesday.
Judge Erasmus said that the court would also consider any section 174 petitions presented by counsel for the accused for the dismissal of charges against their clients based on the lack of evidence to substantiate the charges.
The matter continues. DM
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Dirty deals uncovered in Deneysville
His statement, which was shared with the council and then published by Speaker, councillor Lucas Fisher, followed the municipality's release of a new tariff list for the removal of sewerage from greater Deneysville households and businesses, and the depositing of the same into the recently revamped sewerage plant in neighbouring Refengkgotso. The area does not have piped sewerage and is, therefore, reliant upon the municipality or private companies to suck their septic tanks and remove the effluent. (Over the past decade, the municipality has come under criticism by residents for an unreliable service with trucks unavailable due to breakdowns over extended periods.) However, the release of the new tariffs was accompanied by a moratorium on private dumping until July 1. The aim of this, according to Ramabitsa, was for the municipality to reestablish its client base and recoup monies spent on upgrading the Refengkgotso sewer plant. This effectively cut out private vendors from servicing households for at least the month of June, with no apparent undertaking by the municipality of future business. Ramabitsa was adamant that no informal, private contracts would be considered until July 1. He said that, thereafter, the council would look at negotiating new contracts with licensed vendors. The statement followed an incident at the purification plant when the new guidelines were enforced, and some private vendors who were outraged insisted that they could continue to release their effluent as was previously the case. One vendor allegedly tried to bribe a municipal worker at the plant, offering him R16 000, according to Ramabitsa. After threatening to complain to the authorities about the recent spillage at the station, the vendor approached Ramabitsa directly and offered him R20 000 to allow the continued release of effluent at the plant. Ramabitsa reported the matter to the council. At the time of going to press, the municipality was conducting meetings to determine how to handle the alleged bribe. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Eyewitness News
2 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Four men sentenced to long-term imprisonment after murdering woman for funeral policy money
CAPE TOWN - An adoptive father of a mentally disabled woman and three hitmen have been sentenced to long-term imprisonment after murdering the woman for funeral policy money. The four men were sentenced in the Knysna High Court on Friday. Mboneleli Msila was handed two life sentences for masterminding the murder of his adopted daughter, 22-year-old Nosipho Mafana in Plettenberg Bay. National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson Eric Ntabazalila says Mboneleli Msila says hitman Monde Tshemese will also serve two life sentences for his role in Mafana's murder. "Msila arranged for Mafana to take out three funeral policies with three different banks which would pay out an amount of R600,000 if she died an unnatural death." Ntabazalila says Msila and Tshemese planned Mafana's murder along with Mbulelo Jack and Lungisile Lucas. Jack and Lucas were sentenced to 17 years in prison for conspiracy to commit murder and 17 years for murder. After Mafana's murder in April 2022 Msila's claim for the policy was rejected after it became the subject of a police investigation.
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
EFT payments and cybercrime: Court says car buyer is liable to ensure money is paid into the correct account
In a case involving cybercrime, the Supreme Court of Appeal ruled that it is the duty of a buyer to ensure that the money is paid into the seller's correct bank account. Image: File Cybercrime was once again the topic of a legal wrangle - this time before the Supreme Court of Appeal, which found that payment via electronic transfer (EFT) is only complete when the funds are received by the correct account holder. This judgment followed legal proceedings between two car sale companies – with the one who bought two bakkies from the other only to discover after delivery of the vehicles that cybercriminals had intercepted the electronic payment made for the vehicles. None of the parties were prepared to take the financial loss, and the seller initially turned to the regional court in Louis Trichardt to get its R290,000 back – the price at which it sold the two bakkies. The lower court earlier ruled that Hyundai Louis Trichardt had to pay Northcliff Nissan the R290, 000 for the vehicles. The magistrate reasoned that the two car dealerships had a contract in place and, cybercrime or not, Northcliff Nissan was due payment for the two bakkies. Aggrieved with this judgment, Hyundai successfully turned to the Limpopo High Court, sitting in Thohoyandou, to appeal the lower court's verdict. But Northcliff Nissan took the matter on appeal to the SCA. The risk of erroneous payment due to the cybercrime was that of the payer in this instance, the SCA found. 'A debtor bears the risk of misdirected EFT payments and must ensure that the payment is made to the correct bank account,' it said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading The court added that the onus of proof in contract disputes over payment lies with the payer (debtor). 'Cybercrime risks do not automatically shift liability to the payee, and the courts will not impose an overarching legal duty on creditors to protect debtors from cyber fraud,' the court said. The court was told that in October 2018, Hyundai purchased two Nissan bakkies from Northcliff Nissan for the sum of R145,000,00 each. Northcliff Nissan emailed the invoices for both vehicles to the buyer. The invoices provided details of the nominated bank account for payment of the purchase price for the bakkies. On the same day, Hyundai paid for one bakkie and emailed proof of payment to Northcliff Nissan, after which the bakkie was then delivered. A few days later, Hyundai made another payment and took delivery of the second bakkie. At that stage, no one realised that cybercriminals were at work. Approximately a week later, Northcliff Nissan told Hyundai that payment of the purchase price for the bakkies had not been reflected in its bank account. It then became clear to the parties that the emails had been intercepted and the bank account details on the invoices were altered by a cyber fraudster. The parties realised that they were victims of business email compromise (BEC), a cybercrime that has become popular in this technological age of electronic communication and payment.
