New poll shows Scots overwhelmingly back independence over direct rule
A Norstat survey, for which the Wings of Scotland blog contributed a question, found that 63% of Scots would back independence if the other option was direct Westminster rule.
37%, meanwhile, said they would back direct rule again.
The question asked, specifically: 'If there were to be a second independence referendum tomorrow and the ONLY options on the ballot paper were full independence or the permanent closure of the Scottish Parliament at Holyrood and a return to direct Westminster rule, how do you think you would vote?'
READ MORE: Scottish MPs panned over up to £3500-a-month taxpayer-funded London homes
Interestingly, Labour voters during last July's General Election are quite split on the issue – narrowly backing direct rule by 51% to 49%, according to the survey.
The same Norstat survey, which was initially commissioned for The Sunday Times, found that overall support for Scottish independence is at 54% but would rise even further if Reform UK's leader, Nigel Farage, were to become the next prime minister.
Data from the poll, which was published Saturday evening, shows the Yes side has opened up an eight-point lead, sitting at 54%, when undecided voters are excluded.
But this would rise to 58% if Farage were to be in power.
It comes after the Clacton MP hinted that he would scrap the Scottish Parliament's funding mechanism if he were Prime Minister.
Asked during a rare appearance in Scotland on Monday about whether he would get rid of the Barnett formula, which is used to fund Holyrood, Farage said the mechanism was 'out of date'.
He added: 'What I'd like to see is a Scottish Government that's able to raise a bit more of its own revenue and a Scottish economy that's actually got genuine growth and I don't believe that can happen without this sector [oil and gas] booming.
'I think, you know, the Barnett formula goes back to the 1970s. Is there an argument it should be looked at again? Of course there is.'
Norstat polled 1007 Scottish adults between May 27 and May 30.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
19 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Mairi McAllan must end 'political choice of homelessness'
More than 16,000 households live in temporary accommodation, including 10,000 children, with another 5,000 children thought to be homeless. Gordon MacRae, assistant director of Shelter Scotland, accused Scottish ministers of 'maintaining' homelessness by managing the decline in the housing sector. He said the Housing Bill, currently being considered in Holyrood, fails to 'stop anyone becoming homeless'. In a scathing assessment, he said: "We have nothing on the table right now that will reduce the probability of homelessness occurring over the next 12 months. "This is a political choice. We have a programme for managing homelessness and managing decline in the housing sector." He added: 'The seriousness and the energy and relentlessness to drive change, I'm afraid it's not there. 'I don't think it's an unfair challenge to say that the Scottish Government's comfort zone is managing the problem not ending the problem and that is what we hope for with Mairi McAllan.' Read more: He said Ms McAllan must reduce homelessness and increase the number of council and social homes by the end of the parliamentary year. 'This is the opportunity that is available to her but it requires political choice to do things differently and up until now ll of the working groups, all of the meetings – and there has been many of them since the declaration – have really focused on doing better with what we have. 'We need to accept that there is not enough homes, there's not enough good quality services to stop the continued growth in homelessness. 'We also need to accept that if homelessness increases, then the harm increases. More people will die, more people will be on the streets, more children's life opportunities will be reduced because of the experience of homelessness.' Last month, it was revealed that every council except Edinburgh will receive less money for social housing this year compared to four years ago. Scotland declared an official housing emergency in May 2024, following in the footsteps of a dozen councils, including Glasgow and Edinburgh. Ms McAllan's predecessor Paul McLennan informed the First Minister he did not wish to continue in government following a brief period of ill health. Since taking office, Ms McAllan said she will "advocate for the greatest possible funding" for her new portfolio. In response, Ms McAllan said: 'Having a safe, warm and affordable place to call home is critical to a life of dignity and opportunity. Therefore providing this and tackling the housing emergency head on will be my top priority. "It will be essential in ensuring everyone in Scotland, and in particular our children, have the opportunity to thrive and I am focussed on delivering that real change. 'A major key to tackling the housing emergency is delivering affordable homes - and fast. We have a good track record in this, but we must now step up our efforts. "To that end, we will invest £768 million this financial year in the affordable housing programme, including £40m targeted towards acquisitions to support the local authorities to tackle the most sustained homelessness and temporary accommodation pressures. 'I am also focussed on preventing homelessness in the first place. Local authorities will be provided with £15 billion this financial year for a range of services, including in homelessness services. "There is also an additional £4 million invested in the Ending Homelessness Together budget for 2025-26 to help local authorities, frontline services and relevant partners prepare for the new measures in the Housing Bill - measures which will help to prevent homelessness before it occurs. 'I am squarely focussed on the task in hand, am open minded about how to approach matters and look forward to working with Shelter Scotland and others in this vital task.' Ms McAllan faced criticism last week after she was unable to say how many people in Scotland were on a social housing waiting list. She told STV News: 'It's not that I don't know it, I don't have the figure with me today.'
The National
25 minutes ago
- The National
SNP must woo voters to turn our indy hopes into reality
As we approach next year's election, polls suggest the notion has never been more popular – and yet the formation of a Unionist administration at Holyrood is more on the cards than at any time since 2007. We need serious action to prevent this outcome. And we don't have long. On Saturday, we made a start. The SNP's National Council meeting in Perth rightly was not open to the press or public. It provided a safe space for party activists to have a candid debate with its leadership, away from our opponents and detractors. READ MORE: US enters war with Iran after Donald Trump orders bombing of key nuclear sites I for one feel heartened at the tenor and content of the discussion. We haven't yet got the answers, but at least we are now asking the right questions. Over the months ahead, party members need to devise and unite behind a strategy to win a majority at next May's Scottish Parliament election. First things first. Political independence for our country will be central to the party's message. How could it be anything other than that? There is no point to the SNP if the party does not represent the ambition of self-government, now shared by a majority of our citizens. Frustration and fatigue have eaten away at our capacity in this movement. It has made us question the motivation and integrity of comrades. Repeated comments on social media – and indeed in the columns of this paper – suggest that the SNP has deprioritised independence. The party's leader is accused of shying away from the arguments. But no-one present in Perth on Saturday could have left with that impression. I saw a party leader there who not only demonstrated commitment to the political objective of an independent Scotland but who also offered a serious strategic assessment of how to achieve it. The internal chaos that consumed the party a year ago has dissipated; the haemorrhaging of support stemmed; the party in government stabilised. These were not ends in themselves but necessary steps to regroup and redeploy in the fight for our country's future. Now we need to get back to business: being the political leadership of the movement for national autonomy. It's time for phase two. The SNP need to convince people who want Scotland to be independent to vote for a party that will fight for their right to make that choice. That means confronting the yawning gap between support for independence and for the party. Awareness is growing that this needs a sophisticated approach – different people don't vote SNP for different reasons. So, we need to talk to them differently. Being performative isn't good enough. Just repeating the word doesn't make it happen. Two major groups of people matter in this. Firstly, those who tell pollsters that they think Scotland should be independent, but intend to vote for parties that are against it. It is not that their support for independence is weak, more that they don't see how independence is relevant right now. They are worried about paying this month's bills, about getting a health appointment, about their kids going to war. So, we need to talk about the why of independence. We need to make it relevant. We need to show how making our own decisions means we can make better ones. Our manifesto must spell out how control of our own resources affects key aspects of people's lives. It is about getting power for a purpose. The second group are those who want Scotland to be independent but do not vote. Some have never voted; some have given up because they no longer see how voting will achieve what they want. They have been ground down by the intransigence and denial of the UK state. For this group we need to talk about the how of independence. We need to make next year's vote an assertion of the Claim of Right. People have been denied the opportunity to consider this country's constitutional future not by the SNP government but by serial UK administrations, whose actions have been underwritten by the UK Supreme Court. This is unacceptable. It must change. And next May we need to invite people to demand that change. If they do, then we need explain our plans for executing their mandate. No more pretending that it will just happen because we vote for it. It will require a massive campaign to mobilise the political will of the people behind their government. This will be the time for civic conventions, for mass public information, for cross-party alliances, for legal and diplomatic effort at home and abroad. To do any of this we need to win the election. That is why the SNP must ask all those who want Scotland to be independent to give, indeed ,or lend, the party their vote. We need to do that with humility and without illusion. And those independence supporters who are thinking of not voting need to think again. Not because one vote changes the world, but because it creates the conditions where their hopes are more likely to become reality.
The National
29 minutes ago
- The National
Lesley Riddoch launches crowdfunder for Finland documentary
The film has already secured funding of £5000, with Riddoch hoping to raise the final £8000 to make the project a reality. Finland has been ranked the world's happiest country for eight years in a row, with Riddoch and young Scots filmmaker Gavin Hanigan, who is based in Helsinki, hoping to look at the parallels the country has with Scotland. Riddoch has previously made documentaries about Norway, Faroes, Iceland, Estonia and Denmark. READ MORE: UK providing 'political cover' for US and Israel after Iran attack The Denmark documentary now has 1.7 million views online. The documentary would be made available on YouTube. Within just a few days of being live, the crowdfunder has raised just over £750. In the crowdfunder, Riddoch explains: 'Do we know enough about the world's most successful societies? I don't think so. 'The Nordics are the happiest, most sustainable, most equal, democratic, literate societies on earth, yet remain remarkable mostly for their high beer prices. What a travesty. (Image: Lesley Riddoch) 'So, I've spent more than a decade running the policy group Nordic Horizons, writing book and paper articles, making podcasts and films to let countries in the doldrums (like the UK) see how we might get onto a Nordic path.' She adds that there are 'huge parallels' between Scotland and Finland. 'Finland quietly excels in education - something Scotland was once renowned for,' Riddoch wrote. 'The Finns like the Scots sometimes lack confidence, but their way of life is more equal, digital, cooperative, equal and relaxed than almost anywhere else on earth. Scotland rightly prides itself on having the lowest levels of child poverty in the UK at 22 per cent – the figure in Finland is 3.7 per cent.' READ MORE: Douglas Alexander refuses to set out route to Scottish independence Riddoch adds: 'So in the dog-eat-dog, adversarial days of Donald Trump, I'd guess the world might want to know more about the happy, equal, educated and slightly awkward Finns. 'This documentary is already part funded. If we can raise another £8000 we can make it happen, start filming in September 2025, show the film around Scotland and put it online for everyone by Christmas with gigs around Scotland if Yes groups fancy.' Riddoch told The National: 'The current situation with Russia highlights Finland's enduring problem of having to coexist with an occasionally belligerent, acquisitive former colonial power as the nearest neighbour. 'Anyone who has read the history of Finnish resistance during World War II will realise that a country with half its population volunteering to join an army that became the only one to ever repel the Red Army, will be no pushover. 'Today Finns like Gavin live with bunkers in the cellars of their houses and grab bags ready at the instruction of their government in case of attack. 'And yet their lives are relaxed, orderly, and chilled.' Those who choose to donate to the crowdfunder can get an early access film preview link and other benefits. You can contribute to the crowdfunder for the documentary here.
