Despite Ceasefire, India and Pakistan Are Locked in a Cultural Cold War

Saumya Khandelwal/For The Washington Post
A house in Indian-run Kashmir was left in ruins by cross-border shelling during the recent tensions between India and Pakistan.
NEW DELHI – Even during the darkest moments of India and Pakistan's volatile history – through wars, terrorist attacks and diplomatic breakdowns – artists and activists tried to keep the countries connected.
Mumbai's plays found an audience in Karachi. Lahore's painters held shows in New Delhi. Activists walked across the disputed border, past soldiers marching in elaborate drills, hoping to bridge one of the world's most intractable divides.
'When you travel, and meet the other side, it gives them a human face,' said Suhasini Mulay, an Indian actor and co-founder of the Pakistan-India Peoples' Forum for Peace and Democracy (PIPFPD).
'All that demonization that you've been fed – it just begins to melt away.'
But after years of declining relations, punctuated by the latest eruption of violence between the nuclear-armed neighbors, even the smallest cultural exchanges have all but vanished. In more than a dozen interviews, Indian and Pakistani artists, musicians, diplomats and academics reflected on how the countries became so cut off from one another – and how much has been lost.
Trade between India and Pakistan had already shriveled to almost nothing in recent years. Postal routes were suspended in 2019. The final tightening came last month, after gunmen killed 26 tourists in a meadow near Pahalgam, in Indian-administered Kashmir. Cultural ties, already threadbare, frayed further.
'Even a simple thing like sending a book to a friend across the border is impossible,' said Ritu Menon, an Indian publisher who has helped Pakistani writers come to India.
Salima Hashmi was 4 when her father – the celebrated Pakistani poet Faiz Ahmed Faiz – moved the family from New Delhi to Lahore in anticipation of the bloody partition of British India in 1947.
'A guy who had never been here drew an unthinking carving line over a gin and tonic,' she said, referring to Cyril Radcliffe, the British judge who divided the subcontinent. 'His hand, I'm sure, wavered a bit.'
She grew up watching India and Pakistan try to make sense of their sudden separation. The first field hockey match between the newly created countries in 1948 was, for her, a moment of 'realization that something had happened that alienated us from our own humanism.'
It inspired her to organize the Faiz Festival – an annual cultural festival in Lahore, named for her late father – which became one of the most consistent venues of cultural exchange. Starting in the 1980s, she hosted Indian icons almost every year, including filmmaker Shyam Benegal, poet Kaifi Azmi, and screenwriter-actor couple Javed Akhtar and Shabana Azmi.
'If you put people together, they always find reason to enjoy the same music, the same food, the same films – [they] dance together, read together.'
She also made a point to travel frequently to India – for lectures and festivals, and as part of a Pakistani peace delegation after the 2008 terrorist attacks in Mumbai. Since 2016, though, her cross-border trips have ceased.
Four years ago, when she inquired about visiting India for a wedding, and to see a dying friend, she was swiftly told that a visa was out of the question. Works of art she had once shipped to India for exhibitions were slapped with 200 percent duties in 2019, then banned altogether.
'Art is not lethal,' she said, laughing. 'But it had clearly become a freeze.'
The freeze has only intensified in the intervening years. Goods that once flowed via third countries have faced heightened scrutiny.
After the Pahalgam attack, a painting by a Pakistani artist was confiscated by Indian customs officials. A movie with Pakistani actor Fawad Khan was denied theatrical release. Social media accounts of Pakistani actors were blocked in India.
In April, India's government sent out an advisory telling streaming platforms in the country to 'discontinue' carrying Pakistani content – even soap operas, which have long been popular across the border. Mulay remembers a Pakistani diplomat telling her once that the serials had done more for the India-Pakistan relationship than any diplomatic mission ever could.
Sports had been one of the most enduring links between the countries, but, outside of multinational tournaments, India and Pakistan have not played a cricket match against each other since 2013.
In April, Indian Olympic medalist Neeraj Chopra, who has praised Pakistani javelin thrower Arshad Nadeem, invited him to India, only to be met with severe blowback online. After Pahalgam, Chopra said, a visit by Nadeem was now 'out of the question.'
Bani Singh, an Indian filmmaker, grew up hearing about her father's former hockey teammate from Lahore who switched teams after partition. A friend, her father told her, suddenly became a foreigner.
When she traveled to Pakistan six decades later to find him, she found warmth and hospitality – but also loud silences. 'We never discussed terrorism or the political situation,' she said.
'When you are in a state of trauma, you cannot have a conversation about peace,' she continued. 'You have to first feel secure.'
Every time there has been a flicker of 'possibility' between the countries, she said, it has been derailed by violence, and the cycle of mistrust is renewed.
'Then there's no point even going there, because you almost feel that it would be disrespectful of the people who've lost their lives and the families that are suffering,' Singh said.
Lalita Ramdas remembers a different time. Her late husband, Adm. L. Ramdas, rose to become the head of India's navy, decorated for his service in the 1971 war against Pakistan.
When their daughter told them that her Pakistani boyfriend had proposed, the admiral requested – and received – permission from India's defense minister and prime minister for the couple to wed.
'There didn't used to be this kind of hostility and suspicion with the layers of evil or anger that we have seen over the last 10 to 15 years,' Ramdas said.
After retiring, the admiral joined PIPFPD, the coalition of Indian and Pakistani peace activists, with encouragement from the home secretary.
In 1999, Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee – the first from the now-ruling Bharatiya Janata Party – traveled to Pakistan with an entourage of celebrities on a bus painted with the colors of the two nations. He was welcomed by Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif.
'Back then, it was a very different understanding of what relationship we should have with our neighbors,' said Ramdas. 'Things were civil, and conversations could happen.'
PIPFPD, founded in 1982, hosted at least eight peace conferences. Ramdas and her husband helped organize dialogues among educators, writers, artists and lawmakers.
Shoaib Iqbal, a Pakistani theater actor, said performing in Indian cities used to feel like just another stop on the tour: 'It wasn't like we were going into enemy territory or anything like that.'
But in 2004, in the western city of Pune, angry protesters showed up at Iqbal's hostel. Now, he refuses invitations to return to India – not because he doesn't want to go, he said, but because he's afraid.
Beena Sarwar, a Pakistani professor who has taught journalism at Princeton and Brown, spent four years in the early 2010s running a media organization launched by leading media houses in India and Pakistan. She even organized a delegation of Indian students to Pakistan after the Kargil War in 1999.
'Back then, it just wasn't so difficult,' she said.
The shift happened gradually. PIPFPD saw a growing number of visa requests declined, said Mulay; the group held its final peace conference in 2013. Sarwar saw her own visa to India denied for the first time the day after the Pahalgam attack, she said.
Pakistani Sufi Muslim singers Fareed Ayaz and Abu Muhammad, who lived in India before partition, once described to an audience in southern India their feeling of living in suspension between the two countries. It was 2008, just after the attacks in Mumbai.
'In Pakistan, they call us 'those from Delhi,'' Ayaz said. 'In India, they call us 'those from Pakistan.''
And then they began to sing: 'Today, we sit in an undivided land and tell you, Oh my beloved, please come visit my country.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Tokyo Weekender

2 days ago

• Tokyo Weekender

The World's 50 Best Restaurants List 2025 Features Four From Japan

Tokyo is well known as one of the world's culinary capitals. It has the most Michelin stars across the globe, beating cities like New York City and Paris. From modest, hole-in-the-wall izakaya to elegant omakase sushi establishments and innovative fusion cuisine, Japan's capital holds endless intrigue for gastronomes everywhere. Eateries in Tokyo regularly feature on the World's 50 Best Restaurants list. One of the most respected and influential scales in the culinary world, the list is produced by the UK media company William Reed. With a panel of over 1,000 experts made up of food writers, critics, chefs and well-travelled gourmets, the organization releases it every year to celebrate historic and unique culinary experiences. This year, four restaurants in Japan — three from Tokyo and one from Osaka — made the World's 50 Best Restaurants list. Read on to learn about each establishment's specialty. List of Contents: Sézanne (No. 7) Narisawa (No. 21) Florilège (No. 36) La Cime (No. 44) Related Posts courtesy of four seasons hotel tokyo at marunouchi courtesy of four seasons hotel tokyo at marunouchi courtesy of four seasons hotel tokyo at marunouchi Sézanne (No. 7) Two-Michelin-starred Sézanne opened in July 2021, on the seventh floor of the Four Seasons Hotel Tokyo at Marunouchi. With British chef Daniel Calvert at the helm, the modern French restaurant quickly generated buzz for its incredible 12-course tasting menu that pays tribute to Asia's deep culinary cultures. Calvert previously led the acclaimed neo-Parisian bistro Belon in Hong Kong, after honing his skills at New York's Per Se and Epicure in Paris. At Sézanne, he curates each dining experience to reflect Japan's finest seasonal ingredients, highlighting elements such as bouillabaisse with saffron from Saga Prefecture and fugu (puffer fish) from Yamanashi Prefecture. Narisawa Dish "Satoyama Scenery and Essence of the Forest" Narisawa Dessert dish "Camellia and Koji" Narisawa (No. 21) Most gastronomes around the world would have heard of satoyama cuisine, and chef Yoshihiro Narisawa's vanguard cooking style. Traditionally, satoyama refers to rural landscapes where humans live in harmony with nature; in recent years, it has come to symbolize sustainability, a deep respect for the earth and the integration of humans and the natural world. Established in 2003 in Tokyo's elegant neighborhood of Aoyama, Narisawa has an omakase-style menu that fuses a variety of culinary techniques with the concept of satoyama. The two-Michelin-starred restaurant has earned international recognition for its quality, innovation and commitment to environmentally conscious gourmet dining — securing a Michelin Green Star, 14 consecutive years on the World's Best Restaurants list and numerous other accolades. You can learn more about Narisawa from our conversation with Chef Narisawa . courtesy of florilège courtesy of florilège Florilège (No. 36) Situated in the stylish Azabudai Hills, the two-Michelin-starred Florilège is a creative French-Japanese restaurant led by chef Hiroyasu Kawate, who comes from a family of chefs. He trained at Le Jardin des Sens in Montpellier, France, before working as a sous-chef at Quintessence in Tokyo. Kawate has a strong focus on sustainability when it comes to curating his menu, highlighting locally sourced ingredients and experimenting with plant-forward tasting menus. The restaurant promises to portray 'a new side of vegetables that everyone knows,' reducing the amount of meat, fish and dairy products used. courtesy of la cime courtesy of la cime La Cime (No. 44) Modern French restaurant La Cime is located in the business district of Honmachi, which is considered the heart of Osaka. Established in 2010, the restaurant is headed by chef Yusuke Takada, who trained in Lyon and worked at renowned Parisian establishments such as Le Taillevent and Le Meurice. Takada gained global recognition after receiving the Inedit Damm Chefs' Choice Award in 2020. La Cime's menu spotlights seafood and produce from the Kansai region, as well as citrus and other ingredients from the subtropical island of Amami Oshima. The menu's signature dish is the Boudin Dog, a batter-fried boudin noir (blood sausage) colored with edible bamboo and charcoal. Related Posts Narisawa: Where Foraged Flavors Become Culinary Art Osaka's Best Restaurant and Bar Openings: Spring 2025 Michelin Guide Introduces New Restaurants in Kyoto and Osaka for 2025

Japan Today

15-06-2025

• Japan Today

Ezra Collective's infectious energy defies jazz 'elitism' to win new fans

By Clara LALANNE UK five-piece Ezra Collective has built up a loyal fan base with its upbeat jazz fusion, successfully challenging the genre's "elitism", saying that they embrace everyone. Over the last two years alone, "EZ" has become the first British jazz group to win the prestigious Mercury Prize and have a Top 10 UK album with 2024's "Dance, No One's Watching." Its crowning glory came in March when it was named group of the year at the 2025 Brit Awards, an annual celebration of UK music. "Jazz, when I was growing up, was an expensive thing to tap into. I couldn't afford to get into most jazz clubs, I definitely couldn't afford a drink," drummer Femi Koleoso told AFP at his small music studio in North London, close to where he grew up. "Jazz felt like an upper class, elitist high art form... so we're just making people feel like this is for everyone," he added. The story of Ezra Collective, named after the biblical prophet, began around a decade ago when Koleoso and his younger brother TJ, a bassist, began playing in teenage jazz clubs, where they met keyboardist Joe Armon-Jones and saxophonist James Mollison. They were later joined by trumpeter Ife Ogunjobi. "We learned jazz... but we fell in love with Afrobeat first. That was our first love, and infusing the two was the first sound," explained Koleoso. A decade later, the band, which will play at the Glastonbury Festival later this month, has incorporated other influences such as hip-hop, dub, reggae, Ghanaian highlife music and "most recently salsa music", he said. But jazz still "underpins" everything the band creates, added the drummer. Its danceable and inventive concoction has won fans far beyond jazz's traditional base, helped by the wild energy of its concerts where the charismatic Koleoso, like a preacher, exhorts the crowd to create a "temple of joy". One of the leading groups in an insurgent jazz scene, driven by a new generation of musicians, the quintet surprised everyone by winning the prestigious Mercury Prize for their second album, "Where I'm Meant To Be", released in 2023. The victory "finally acknowledges a golden age for UK jazz", said Guardian music critic Alexis Petridis. "A lot of us have a similar origin story in that a lot of us met in these youth clubs," which, according to bassist TJ Koleoso, have helped make London "the best place to be born in the world" for aspiring young musicians. The thriving community owes much to the "Tomorrow's Warriors" program established by Gary Crosby and Janine Irons. Attempting to address the lack of diversity in jazz, they founded the program in 1991 to provide young people with free spaces to practise, learn to play together and meet artists. It has fostered numerous talents such as Nubya Garcia, Kokoroko, and Ezra Collective, and the band's members now give lessons or donate instruments to the city's clubs, which have seen their numbers dwindle amid spending cuts. "This moment right here is because of the great youth clubs, and the great teachers and the great schools that support young people playing music," Femi Koleoso said at the Brits in March, as his band triumphed against music giants such as Coldplay and The Cure. Devout Christians and fans of Fela Kuti and Arsenal Football Club, the brothers grew up in the north London neighborhood of Enfield. "I grew up next to a Bangladeshi family, my best friend in school was Turkish, I'm Nigerian, my best mate is Ghanaian and (there's) Jamaicans everywhere you go," said Femi Koleoso. "That kind of melting-pot" has inspired "everything I wrote and created", added Femi Koleoso, who also toured with top group Gorillaz in recent years. When Ezra Collective takes to the stage, "the first part of the song will be played accurately" but "the moment the last note of the first part of the song is done, it's just a free-for-all, just see what happens, and long may that continue," said a smiling Femi Koleoso. "I don't know if AI could be doing that gig," added TJ Koleoso, addressing the debate about technology. He insisted that "real, authentic things survive" such upheavals. © 2025 AFP

Japan Today

14-06-2025

• Japan Today

Arise Sir David! Soccer legend Beckham knighted

Britain's King Charles III speaks with former England captain David Beckham at the Chelsea Flower Show in London in May 2025 By James PHEBY Former England soccer captain and global fashion icon David Beckham was knighted on Friday for his services to sport and charity, with The Who singer Roger Daltrey and actor Gary Oldman also receiving the honor. Beckham, who played 115 times for England as well as for some of the world's most high-profile clubs including Manchester United and Real Madrid, will now be known as "sir" and his wife Victoria, a former member of the Spice Girls pop group, will be known as Lady Beckham. The 50-year-old, who has long been in the running for a knighthood, was appointed an officer of the Order of the British Empire in 2003 -- a lesser award in Britain's honors system. Victoria later received the same award for services to the fashion industry. "Growing up in east London with parents and grandparents who were so patriotic and proud to be British, I never could have imagined I would receive such a truly humbling honor," Beckham said in a statement issued to the Press Association. "I'm so lucky to be able to do the work that I do and I'm grateful to be recognized for work that gives me so much fulfillment," he added. Beckham's knighthood is the culmination of years of tireless efforts to transcend soccer and turn himself into a global icon at the intersection of sport, fashion and business. The honor, one of the highest bestowed by the UK state, "is a powerful symbolic marker", Marie Agnes Parmentier, professor of marketing at the University of Montreal and author of several papers on "Posh and Becks", explained to AFP. Even at the height of his career, Beckham was building his global brand with thought to his retirement. His appearance in a sarong, revelations that he used make-up and his eccentric hairstyles were all feverishly gobbled up by the UK's tabloid press. He also had to overcome the tag as England's "most-hated man" after being sent off during the 1998 World Cup in a knockout game against Argentina. Beckham is understood to have been on the verge of receiving a knighthood after helping London win its bid to host the 2012 Olympic Games. But UK authorities placed a red flag on his nomination due to his involvement in an alleged tax avoidance scheme, according to previous reports. He was subsequently cleared. Daltrey, who co-founded The Who in 1964, will also take the title of sir having been recognized for his services to charity and music in King Charles III's Birthday Honors list. The 81-year-old singer has been a patron of Teenage Cancer Trust since 2000, holding fundraising concerts at London's Royal Albert Hall for more than two decades. "It's kind of weird, but I am deeply honored to get this, especially for the charity for the Teenage Cancer Trust, and I accept it on their behalf really, because this honor is really for all unsung heroes," the "My Generation" singer told the Press Association. "It's a dream come true for me, but it's especially a dream because the charity means so much," he added. Oldman, who won a best actor Oscar for his portrayal of Winston Churchill in 2017's "Darkest Hour", also received a knighthood for his services to drama. The 67-year-old's films have earned over $11 billion, and his credits include the "Harry Potter" series, The "Dark Knight" Trilogy and "Air Force One", along with cameo appearances in sitcom "Friends" and music videos for David Bowie and Guns N' Roses. Stage star Elaine Page, who played Eva Peron in the first production of Andrew Lloyd Webber's "Evita", and novelist Pat Barker have both been made dames. Barker is known for her World War I "Regeneration Trilogy", the first book of which was turned into a Hollywood film starring Jonathan Pryce. © 2025 AFP