Scotland's Schrödinger's Schools – both succeeding and failing?

Ms Duncan-Glancy said that the proportion of school leavers in positive destinations has gone down, that more pupils than ever before are leaving school without qualifications, that fewer are leaving having secured at least one qualification at levels five and six (the latter of which includes Highers), that the attainment gap in relation to passing those qualifications has increased, that the number of Modern Apprenticeship starts has declined, and that youth unemployment has increased.
Earlier this week in the Scottish Parliament, two politicians clashed over the state of Scottish education. During a meeting of the Education, Children and Young People Committee, Labour's Pam Duncan-Glancy asserted that things are getting worse for the country's school pupils, asking education secretary Jenny Gilruth to explain why education is 'declining' and opportunities 'narrowing.' Ms Gilruth, as you would expect, rejected this framing and claimed that we are in fact seeing progress and improvement across the system.
Lessons to Learn | Did the Scottish Government mislead me or are they just incompetent?
It's not like there's a shortage of available information: the 'school education statistics' of the Scottish Government's website has more than twenty different datasets covering areas like school leaver destinations, literacy and numeracy levels, teacher numbers, pupil exclusions, the state of school buildings, parental engagement and much more.
But that's easily solved, right? If we just stick to the facts then we'll be able to figure exactly what's going on, won't we?
And with an election not too far away, it'll only get worse.
Sometimes these distinctions are strictly political. It suits the Scottish Government , and supporters of the SNP , to believe that things are good and getting better, just as it suits opposition parties and their backers to tell you that the opposite is true. Education is inherently political, but the way in which education is treated within Scotland's awful, insular, and claustrophobic political culture, with it all-too-often reduced to petty point-scoring by politicians, is a significant problem.
Depending on who you listen to, the Scottish education system can be a huge and ever-improving success, a catastrophic failure in continuous decline, and pretty much everything else in between.
It all sounds pretty damning.
But Ms Gilruth responded that more pupils than ever are reaching expected levels in literacy and numeracy, that the attainment gap for literacy has fallen to the lowest level recorded, that this is also true for secondary school numeracy, that the percentage of leavers going to positive destinations is at the second-highest level on record, and that we have seen improvements in exam results during the post-pandemic period.
And here's the thing: almost all of those claims are demonstrably true, as shown by our fact-check article on the matter – in fact, the only egregiously incorrect assertion was the one about exam results, which is definitely not correct.
This would appear to suggest that, at least according to the cited statistics, both Pam Duncan-Glancy and Jenny Gilruth are mostly correct: things are getting worse, and they're also getting better.
Scotland has apparently managed to build Schrödinger's Schools, which are both succeeding and failing at exactly the same time.
This mess is partly explained by the fact that too much of our information is of limited use, and some is effectively meaningless, which leaves us constantly operating in a frustrating fog.
To make matters worse, most politicians and commentators clearly aren't able (or willing) to properly understand what that data is even supposed to be showing them, because they've never managed (or in some cases even tried) to wrap their heads around the nuances that underpin it.
But beyond all of that, the exchange between Ms Gilruth and Ms Duncan-Glancy was a stark reminder that cherry-picking statistics in the service of a political back-and-forth is a huge waste of everyone's time that makes it near impossible to have proper, grown-up conversations about a matter of the utmost importance. Sign up for a weekly expert insight into Scottish education.
If side A wants to be able to 'prove' that things are going wrong then they won't have any trouble finding a few bits of information to back that up, and when side B wants to 'prove' the exact opposite, that won't be a problem for them either. They'll very often even be able to use the exact same spreadsheets to do it, either by concentrating on a different section to the one their opponent is looking at, or sometimes just by choosing a different detail from the very same page.
That suits politicians, researchers, speech writers, press officers, special advisers and more than a few columnists just fine, because it keeps them all looking busy without actually having to do much serious work.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

South Wales Argus

42 minutes ago

• South Wales Argus

Monmouthshire Council considers sports and play facilities

Monmouthshire County Council has produced an action plan and assessment of playgrounds, parks and public areas known as a 'play sufficiency assessment' to give an overview of opportunities to play outdoors. The council also has £182,619 available this financial year, from a £5 million funding pot agreed between the Welsh Government and local authorities, to improve the quality of play spaces, refurbish playgrounds and support the creation of accessible play spaces and opportunities for children. How the funding is spent in Monmouthshire is due to be determined by the council's Labour-led cabinet while members of the people scrutiny committee discussed the play report at their June meeting. Llanelly Hill independent Simon Howarth said more sporting facilities are needed in the north of the county such as a 'three G, four G or whatever five G pitch'. He said: 'In the winter a lot of children can't do sport and do not have the facilities up here. 'It's virtually impossible in this part of the county. Hockey, football, rugby you name any sport in the winter, in rural locations, it becomes virtually impossible.' Cllr Howarth said he was also concerned some children prefer to 'go up to their bedroom and go on the telephone or computer' but said that is expensive and not all are able to afford such items. READ MORE: ALN sessions at Newport splash park face offensive comments Conservative councillor for Goytre, Jan Butler, asked if the council's play service could run some play sessions in its park, which has been revamped with funding from the community council. Cllr Butler said when the park was upgraded, using money as a result of a housing development, the local council had also been mindful to include older children which she called in the 'awkward' ages of 10 through to 12. She said: 'A survey was done and it showed we were missing out on the 10-12 age group, the equipment we've got in now is suitable and they've come back in.' Play manager Becky Hall said holiday activity days are dependent on funding, with staffing a significant cost, but said she could contact the council in Goytre for further discussion. It was also noted the quality of play areas are about more than equipment and could also include access to nature and open space with accessibility also an important factor.

Daily Record

an hour ago

• Daily Record

Banning strangling in porn will help tackle violence against women, says Scots MP

EXCLUSIVE: Joani Reid said online videos are "influencing real-world behaviour" and hailed the UK Government's decision as "a step in the right direction." Banning strangling in pornography will help tackle violence against women, a Scots MP has said. Joani Reid said online videos are "influencing real-world behaviour" and hailed the UK Government's decision as "a step in the right direction." ‌ Last week the Labour Government announced it would outlaw "the depiction of strangulation in pornography" as part of its Crime and Policing Bill. ‌ East Kilbride and Strathaven MP Reid said the ban would "stop the normalisation of violence through pornography." violence against women should never be entertainment. "We now have clear evidence that violent and degrading pornography is influencing real-world behaviour. "Non-fatal strangulation is a serious and dangerous offence yet, until now, online platforms have been free to promote and profit from its depiction as a form of sexual gratification. That's indefensible. "This isn't about being prudish or anti-sex. It's about protecting women and girls from harm and stopping the normalisation of violence through pornography. For too long online platforms have operated without scrutiny, spreading extreme content with no accountability. "If we are serious about tackling violence against women we can't ignore the role the online world plays in shaping attitudes and behaviour. The decision is a big step in the right direction but there's much more to do.' ‌ It is already a criminal offence to possess porn depicting life-threatening acts, such as graphic strangulation. But the Government will tighten up the law to now criminalise the depiction of strangulation completely. A ban had been campaigned for by group of Labour MPs who had backed an amendment to the Crime and Policing bill. These included seven Scots MPs: Reid, Katrina Murray, Tracy Gilbert, Patricia Ferguson, Johanna Baxter, Kirsteen Sullivan and Richard Baker. ‌ The UK Government announcement follows the Independent Porn Review, which was conducted by Tory peer Gabby Bertin. The review found that pornography has effectively established strangulation during sex as a 'sexual norm'. ‌ It also found that pornography has helped cause a belief that strangling a partner during sex is 'safe' because it is believed to be non-fatal. This is despite overwhelming evidence that is is believed there is no safe way to strangle a person. UK Minister for Victims and tackling Violence Against Women and Girls Alex Davies-Jones said: "Depicting strangulation during sex is not only dangerous, but also degrading, with real life consequences for women. "Cracking down on the appalling rise of strangulation pornography will protect women and send a clear signal to men and boys that misogyny will not be tolerated." This pledge by the Labour Government is part of its vow to halve violence against women and girls during its time in office.

Daily Record

an hour ago

• Daily Record

How the Scottish MPs voted in the assisted dying debate

Scottish MPs rejected the bill, with 29 of the 57 voting against. MPs voted by 314 to 291 - a majority of 23 - to legalise assisted dying in England and Wales last week But Scottish MPs rejected the bill, with 29 of the 57 voting against. ‌ Some 22 of the Labour MPs voted against while 15 voted for. ‌ All five Scottish Tory MPs voted against, while the SNP abstained. Two Lib Dems voted against and three voted for. One Lib Dem abstained by voting for and against the bill. The legislation doesn't apply in Scotland, as Holyrood has its own bill which is going through at the moment. But how did your MP vote? For Douglas Alexander - Lothian East, Labour Maureen Burke - Glasgow North East, Labour ‌ Irene Campbell - North Ayrshire and Arran, Labour Alistair Carmichael - Orkney and Shetland, Lib Dem Graeme Downie - Dunfermline and Dollar, Labour ‌ Alan Gemmell - Central Ayrshire, Labour Tracy Gilbert - Edinburgh North and Leith, Labour Christine Jardine - Edinburgh West, Lib Dem ‌ Chris Kane - Stirling and Strathallan, Labour Kirsty McNeill - Midlothian, Labour Chris Murray - Edinburgh East and Musselburgh, Labour ‌ Ian Murray - Edinburgh South, Labour Susan Murray - Mid Dunbartonshire, Lib Dem Pamela Nash - Motherwell, Wishaw and Carluke, Labour ‌ Gregor Poynton - Livingston, Labour Joani Reid - East Kilbride and Strathaven, Labour Euan Stainbank - Falkirk, Labour ‌ Elaine Stewart - Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock, Labour Against Zubir Ahmed - Glasgow South West, Labour Scott Arthur - Edinburgh South West, Labour ‌ Richard Baker - Glenrothes and Mid Fife, Labour Johanna Baxter - Paisley and Renfrewshire South, Labour Andrew Bowie - West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine, Conservative ‌ John Cooper - Dumfries and Galloway, Conservative Torcuil Crichton - Western Isles, Labour Harriet Cross - Gordon and Buchan, Conservative ‌ Patricia Ferguson - Glasgow West, Labour John Grady - Glasgow East, Labour Lillian Jones - Kilmarnock and Loudon, Labour ‌ John Lamont - Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk, Conservative Brian Leishman - Alloa and Grangemouth, Labour Angus MacDonald - Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire, Lib Dem ‌ Douglas McAllister - West Dunbartonshire, Labour Martin McCluskey - Inverclyde, Labour Blair McDougall - East Renfrewshire, Labour ‌ Gordon McKee - Glasgow South, Labour Frank McNally - Coatbridge and Bellshill, Labour David Mundell - Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale, Conservative ‌ Katrina Murray - Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch, Labour Martin Rhodes - Glasgow North, Labour Michael Shanks - Rutherglen, Labour ‌ Kenneth Stevenson - Airdrie and Shotts, Labour Jamie Stone - Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross, Lib Dem Kirsteen Sullivan - Bathgate and Linlithgow, Labour ‌ Alison Taylor - Paisley and Renfrewshire North, Labour Imogen Walker - Hamilton and Clyde Valley, Labour Melanie Ward - Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy, Labour ‌ Abstain Kirsty Blackman - Aberdeen North, SNP Wendy Chamberlain - North East Fife, Lib Dem Dave Doogan - Angus and Perthshire Glens, SNP ‌ Stephen Flynn - Aberdeen South, SNP Stephen Gethins - Arbroath and Broughty Ferry, SNP Chris Law - Dundee Central, SNP ‌ Graham Leadbitter - Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey, SNP Brendan O'Hara - Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber, SNP