University under fire from parliament over failure to recognise students' previous qualifications
The University of Limpopo is under mounting pressure from parliament's higher education portfolio committee over its alleged failure to understand and apply the national qualifications framework (NQF), resulting in students being barred from graduating.
Chair Tebogo Letsie said the committee was alarmed by the growing number of complaints from former students. The committee had received nine grievances from students so far. His comments come as the university faces two more letters of demand from students who were informed shortly before graduation that their degrees would not be conferred because their previous qualifications were not recognised.
The students' lawyer Godrich Gardee said the university had less than 10 days to respond to the letters of demand. Letsie said the university was showing a worrying disregard for the national qualifications framework. 'We are extremely concerned,' he said.
Letsie said the university CFO, Mamokgadi Masete, had disclosed to the committee that Limpopo had spent R14.7m on legal fees to defend cases from students and staff.
'We then asked for a breakdown of each case. We never received it. We wrote three times and received no response. On March 21, the committee summoned the university to send a detailed report on the matter, as the institution said there had been consequences for people [staff] who accepted students who did not meet the requirements.
The report would include details about other issues of governance. 'We had given them seven days to respond. They ignored us. I then wrote to the speaker [Thoko Didiza] but she was away, and after that we went on recess ...'
Letsie said he hoped to get responses from Didiza this week. 'I have also written to the minister of higher education [Nobuhle Nkabane] to ask that she appoint an independent assessor to investigate these cases. She did confirm that she would look into the matter and is waiting for external legal opinion.'
In March, the Limpopo high court ordered the university to reconsider a decision on two other students whose qualifications from the Durban University of Technology were not recognised, despite them having studied for two years.
Nkabane's spokesperson Camagwini Mavovana acknowledged Sowetan's questions sent on Tuesday but had not responded by the time of publication. University spokesperson Victor Kgomoeswana said: '... if you get a letter from a client written by their lawyers, we are not responsible for ventilating the merits of the case to the media'.
'I would say let's wait for the VC [vice-chancellor] to receive the letters, look at them, and he will attend to it. I don't think it's fair to discuss the matters of students.'
Kgomoeswana said every case was different in terms of its merits. 'Every student who applies to the university will present their qualifications, and every qualification has its [specific] requirements.
'Some students will meet the requirements, some will not; there is no general rule.'
He did not say how many students were affected or what measures have been put in place to avoid enrolling students whose qualifications were not recognised.
Dikeletso Madigoe said she had obtained a four-year diploma in nursing from the Limpopo College of Nursing and completed a postgraduate diploma at Stellenbosch University. In 2018, she enrolled at the University of Limpopo for a master's in public health.
She said she was depressed as the university ignored her request for an explanation as to why her previous qualifications were not recognised. 'I spent more than R50,000 on my studies, excluding travelling and accommodation,' she said. 'I am a breadwinner and take care of my family of more than five.
'I get so emotional around graduation season and want to know what might have gone wrong.'
Victor Teffo, who completed a BEd honours in natural sciences at the Tshwane University of Technology in 2019, enrolled at the University of Limpopo in 2021 for a master's degree.
His research was approved in 2022. When the university requested verification of his previous qualifications in March 2024, the SA Qualifications Authority confirmed them, and the university acknowledged receipt. Despite this, he too was told just weeks before graduation he would not receive his degree.
'I worked sleepless nights to meet my deadlines. I've applied for jobs that require a master's degree. I missed out on career-changing opportunities,' said Teffo.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
3 hours ago
- The Herald
Case of five men accused of murdering Aserie Ndlovu, partner postponed
A fifth accused joined four men who have been charged with the kidnapping and murder of journalist Aserie Ndlovu and his partner Zodwa Mdhluli when they appeared in the KwaMhlanga magistrate's court on Friday. 'Four of the accused, Father Samuel Mogowe, Lucky Sikhosana, David Madisha and Sello Skhalo Uoane, previously abandoned their bail applications. They have now been joined by Thabang Isaac Hlophe, who is the fifth accused in the matter,' National Prosecuting Authority spokesperson Monica Nyuswa said. All five are facing two counts of kidnapping and two counts of murder. The accused were arrested separately during an intelligence-driven operation by the police. 'Today's court appearance was for the formal joinder of Hlophe to the matter and a possible bail application on his behalf. However, the application did not proceed as Hlophe opted to appoint a private attorney to represent him,' Nyuswa said. Ndlovu and Mdluli were last seen on February 18 and were reported missing shortly thereafter. Their remains were discovered three months later in Rust de Winter, along the Limpopo-Gauteng border. DNA analysis confirmed the identities of the deceased. The accused have all been remanded. The case was postponed until July 4 to allow Hlophe to secure legal representation. TimesLIVE
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Walter Sisulu University staff member killed outside entrance
Police declined to confirm the identity of the victim, and authorities have warned against speculating over a possible motive. A Walter Sisulu University staff member was fatally shot outside the Nkululekweni gate at the Mthatha campus in the Eastern Cape. Police launched an investigation on Thursday night after being alerted to a shooting incident outside the university's campus. The victim is believed to be a senior member of the faculty, but police have not yet confirmed the deceased's identity out of respect for the family. 'Motive remains unknown' Police were called to the scene shortly before 6pm on Thursday after another staff member passed by the victim's stationary vehicle. 'Preliminary forensic analysis confirms the victim sustained multiple gunshot wounds while seated in the driver's position. The motive remains unknown,' confirmed Eastern Cape police spokesperson Brigadier Nobuntu Gantana. Police state that 'maximum resources' will be deployed to pursue all leads as a matter of urgency. They asked members of the public to share any information they may have with authorities. 'Forensic experts and detectives are actively processing the secured crime scene. Public speculation must be avoided to preserve the integrity of the investigation,' said Eastern Cape provincial commissioner Major General Thandiswa Kupiso. The victim's seniority and the possibility of a targeted motive have been suggested on social media, but Gantana would not confirm any details. 'At the moment, I cannot reveal the identity of the victim. I think I will leave that to the family and the Walter Sisulu University as the employer,' Gantana told eNCA on Friday. Second shooting in three months Chairperson of the higher education portfolio committee, Tebogo Letsie, shared his shock at the incident, stating that violence had no place in education. 'We are devastated to learn that an official of the Walter Sisulu University has been brutally murdered in such a callous and inhumane manner,' Letsie said. The same campus was the scene of another fatal shooting in April and Letsie urged the university to strengthen security to protect staff and students. 'The latest tragedy is deeply concerning and raises questions about safety at the institution. Our thoughts and prayers are with the family, friends and colleagues of the deceased,' Letsie concluded. NOW READ: Walter Sisulu University murder case: Magistrate accused of bias after employee granted R10k bail
Mail & Guardian
3 days ago
- Mail & Guardian
Malatji: Nkabane ‘cowardly' for withdrawing ANC linked appointments as Seta board chairs
ANC Youth League President Collen Malatji (@ANCYLhq) 'If I were her, I would not have withdrawn those appointments of chairpersons. She has weakened herself and will never appoint anyone again. What she did is cowardly,' Malatji told the Mail & Guardian . He said cabinet ministers and deputy ministers considered to be part of the youth in the ANC should only fear him, as ANC youth league leader, and not opposition parties. 'They are my deployments, and the only person they must fear is me. They must consult me on everything. Luthuli House is open for them to come and we will defend them, because there is nothing wrong with deploying qualified people who are aligned with the ANC,' he said. Nkabane faced criticism in May over her appointment list, which included Buyambo Mantashe, the son of Mineral and Petroleum Resources Minister In parliament, Nkabane refused to give the names of members of the independent panel that selected the initial names she had appointed for the Seta positions. In a statement on Tuesday, Nkabane said she had disclosed a members panel for the selection and recommendation of Seta board chairs to the portfolio committee on higher education and training and was ready to account to the committee and to respond to further requests for information. In a separate statement, also on Tuesday, the chairperson of the committee, Tebogo Letsie, welcomed the submission of a letter containing the names of panel members appointed to oversee the selection and recommendation of board chairpersons for the Seta boards. The panel members are Terry Motau (chairperson), Asisipho Solani, Nelisiwe Semane, Mabuza Ngubane and Rhulani Ngwenya. The committee said that it had consistently held the view that Nkabane was constitutionally obligated to disclose the names of the panel members to parliament. 'We are pleased that sanity has prevailed, and that the minister has now complied with this requirement. The committee believes this disclosure should have occurred from the outset,' said Letsie. 'We are dealing with public institutions funded through parliamentary appropriations. It was therefore baffling that the committee had to strongly remind the minister of such a basic accountability requirement in our democratic governance system.' During a meeting of the higher education committee last month, Malatji told the M&G that he would never have withdrawn the appointments, asserting that opposition parties have created a false narrative that anyone associated with the ANC is corrupt. 'The ANC contests elections to control power, and every party wants control. This is why parties, including the 'I will never withdraw appointments. You make a decision as a leader, and you stick by it. Why is she apologising for powers given to her? Those people meet the criteria; they are qualified and everything. Anyway, the most educated people are in the ANC, not the DA or EFF.' Malatji said he considered Buyambo Mantashe as having an unfair advantage and would never have considered him for the post. 'Mantashe's child is something else. I was never going to appoint Mantashe's child because he is a minister — not that he is not qualified or not a comrade, but morally wrong,' he said. 'Unfortunately, when your father is a minister or president, you lose certain privileges in life. You can't compete with a child of a president; it is an unfair competition.' On calls for Nkabane to be removed from her position, Malatji said she was a good and qualified minister who had been caught off guard. 'She is good for the sector and is also learning higher education needs a person like her,' he said. 'She is not doing badly; just a few things, small things, and over time, she does not consult the youth league, which gets her into trouble.'
