After the last word
On April 22, nearly two and a half years after Joan Didion's death, a slim but arresting volume titled Notes to John appeared on shelves. Published by Knopf, the collection comprises fragments: personal memos, tender jottings, reminders to herself, and letters addressed to her late husband, John Gregory Dunne, after his death in 2003. In true Didion style, even her unfinished, offhand scraps shimmer with clarity and literary precision. But reading Notes to John is a disquieting experience: you are tugged in close, into the bone of her grief, and yet held at arm's length. It is as if you've found someone's diary under their pillow and, despite knowing better, can't stop turning the pages.
That tug-of-war between public and private, between a writer's legacy and their consent, is the central tension in publishing a dead person's notebooks. It's a literary act and a voyeuristic one. Notes to John may be the catalyst, but the phenomenon is hardly new. From the exhaustive curation of Virginia Woolf's diaries to the belated release of Franz Kafka's letters (which he explicitly asked to be destroyed), publishing posthumous writing has become a well-oiled machine. The ethics, however, remain as blurry as a half-erased pencil note in the margin of a draft.
The author is absent
There is something particularly vulnerable about the genre of the note. Unlike novels or essays, letters and diaries are not written with an audience in mind; at least, not a public one. And yet, perhaps paradoxically, they often reveal more than an entire memoir. In Didion's Notes to John, her sentences are brief, sharp, sometimes halting. "I never feel guilty about working," she writes, somewhere between dream and discipline. It's devastating in its casualness. But should we be reading this?
When you hold a writer's diary, you are confronted with the illusion of intimacy. But the writer is gone. They cannot clarify, redact, or resist. Their editor is often a family member, a literary executor, or a publisher with contractual rights but not always moral ones. Shaun Usher's Lists of Note and More Lists of Note anthologise lists written by the famous and the long-dead: Da Vinci's shopping notes, Marilyn Monroe's acting prep, Isaac Newton's sins, presented with curatorial glee. They're fascinating, yes, but they also decontextualise deeply personal documents into coffee-table curiosities.
Dead men do tell tales
In Kafka's case, the betrayal was flagrant. He instructed his friend Max Brod to burn all of his unpublished manuscripts. Brod didn't, and the result is that much of Kafka's genius, The Trial, The Castle, his heartbreaking letters to Milena and Felice, came to light only after his death. Without that breach of trust, there would be no Kafka in the canon. So was Brod wrong? Legally, no. Literarily, certainly not. Ethically? Well.
Virginia Woolf's diaries and letters were curated posthumously first by her husband Leonard Woolf, and then by his nephew, Quentin Bell. Leonard admitted to cutting large swathes of material. Her personality, her flirtations, her frustrations with the Bloomsbury crowd, these only surfaced in later, more complete editions. Each round of publication brought her closer to her readers and arguably farther from the version of herself she wanted to project.
We are reading a Woolf curated by Leonard, filtered through edits and omissions; we are mourning a Didion arranged by her editor, not by Didion herself. The issue at hand is not just literary but legal. The ownership of the "self" after death falls into ambiguous hands, sometimes the estate, sometimes the publisher, sometimes the reader's projection. In Didion's case, her longtime editor Shelley Wanger helped assemble the notes, presumably with care and intention. But Didion, famously in control of her image and language, is no longer here to confirm whether she wanted these fragments to be seen.
The romance of rawness
There's something addictive about the "raw" version of a writer. We crave the uncut, the messy, the bloodied first draft. That desire is partly what fuels the publication of these private documents. They allow us to feel like we've accessed something real, beyond performance. The literary world, in turn, benefits from this hunger. Editors gain prestige for unearthing unpublished material. Publishers reap sales from both completists and the newly curious. Fans post screenshots of notes that feel like confessions. Everyone wins, except maybe the person who wrote them.
This urge isn't limited to literary estates. Think of how Anne Frank's diary was originally edited by her father to remove parts about her sexuality and frustration with her mother. Later, full editions emerged, richer and more complicated. Readers rejoiced, but the diary's shift from personal record to historical document carries a cost. Somewhere, the lines blur between honouring a voice and exploiting it.
Afterlife in the internet age
Today, we all keep fragments: Google Docs with no title, iPhone notes about dreams or shopping or shame. If we're writers, perhaps we think some of these might be useful for a future essay, a novel, a letter we mean to write but never do. But what if, after we die, someone else decides what deserves to be seen?
The politics of posthumous publication are not just about famous authors; they are about all of us. In the digital age, where drafts and thoughts live forever in clouds and caches, anyone's notes might outlive them. The desire to know a person more "authentically" can too easily become a desire to know them without their permission.
Copyright adds another layer of complexity. A note never meant for publication occupies a murky legal space; its ownership is uncertain. Grief, nostalgia, even a stray sentence from a dead woman to her dead husband all become subject to claims, though they resist easy commodification.
In The Year of Magical Thinking, Didion wrote about keeping John's shoes after he died, irrationally believing he might need them. Notes to John feels like an extension of that magical thinking, a belief that speaking to the dead can somehow keep them present, or that reading their words might bring them back. Yet publishing such words transforms a private ritual into a public spectacle.
The dynamics of posthumous publication often benefit publishers, estates, and readers, while consent from the author remains absent. As readers, we inherit both the privilege and the burden of that imbalance. We are owed nothing, and yet we often take everything. To read Notes to John is to be moved, but also to be implicated. The dead may not speak for themselves, but they wrote. That, sometimes, must be enough.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jonathan Toews joins hometown Winnipeg Jets in return to NHL
Jonathan Toews is coming home. The Former Chicago Blackhawks captain and three-time Stanley Cup champion has agreed to sign with the Winnipeg Jets but can't put ink to paper until July 1. "We are excited to add a proven winner like Jonathan Toews to the Winnipeg Jets," general manager Kevin Cheveldayoff said in a news release posted on the Jets website. "It will be a unique opportunity for Jonathan to play for his hometown team. His talent, drive and experience will be a great complement to our club. We will withhold further comment until July 1." Free agents aren't allowed to put ink to paper until July 1, so the official signing has to wait just over a week. The Jets posted several messages on X on Friday morning, including one that said, "Can't believe this is a real post from @nhljets tbh." Toews, who was born in Winnipeg and played youth hockey in the city, has a sportsplex named in his honour in the St. Vital neighbourhood where he grew up. On Friday, a message on the electronic sign for the facility said "He's home." In a statement included in the Jets release on Friday, Toews said he is grateful to be making his return to the NHL with the club. "It's very special to come home and play in front of my family and friends in Manitoba. The Jets have been on the rise over the last few seasons, and I'm eager to join the group and help however I can." Toews, 37, was drafted third overall by the Blackhawks in 2006 and spent his entire career there, winning three Stanley Cups (2010, 2013 and 2015), before stepping away from the game in February 2023, saying he was suffering from symptoms of long COVID and chronic inflammatory response syndrome. "It has reached the point where I had no choice but to step back and concentrate on getting healthy," he said at the time. He returned to the Blackhawks' lineup on April 1, and about two weeks later, the team announced it would not re-sign Toews after his contract expired at the end of the season. In August 2023, Toews said he intended to sit out the 2023-24 season to focus on his health, but that he was not retiring from the NHL. In March 2025, he announced in an interview with The Athletic that he intended to return for the 2025-26 season, prompting speculation among hockey writers and fans about where he might land. Winnipeg was always considered a front-runner. Toews is a two-time Olympic gold medallist for Canada in hockey (2010 and 2014), won the 2010 Conn Smythe Trophy as the MVP of the Stanley Cup playoffs, the 2013 Frank J. Selke Trophy as the league's best defensive forward, and the 2015 Mark Messier Leadership Award. He's been a Selke finalist three other times and been in four NHL all-star games. Towes also won the gold medal at the 2016 World Cup of Hockey, back-to-back gold medals at the 2006 and 2007 World Junior Championships and gold and silver medals at the 2007 and 2008 World Championships, respectively.
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Sales for this $69 portable AC unit are up 25,000% — here's what shoppers are saying
If you're tossing and turning at night thanks to rising summer temperatures, you're not alone. With heatwaves sweeping across the country and air conditioning units flying off the shelves, shoppers are turning to more affordable, space-saving options to stay cool. Enter this portable air conditioning fan, which is currently surging in popularity on Amazon Canada. Sales have surged a jaw-dropping 25,000 per cent, landing it a top spot on the retailer's Movers & Shakers list — and it's not hard to see why. Small but mighty, this baby offers instant relief without the hefty price tag or complicated installation, making it a must-have for bedrooms, offices, dorms and anywhere you need extra airflow. Shoppers say this AC unit is "perfect for small spaces." This portable air conditioner is a compact 3-in-1 device that delivers serious cooling power in a small, easy-to-use package. Acting as an air cooler, fan and humidifier, it's designed to sit comfortably on desks, countertops or bedside tables, making it ideal for personal use in bedrooms, offices, dorms or small apartments. Just fill the 1100ml water tank, plug it in and enjoy an instant, refreshing breeze. With three fan speeds, three mist settings (including an ice option for extra chill) and a timer, it offers customizable comfort that can run continuously for up to 8–10 hours without the need for constant refills. While it's not meant to cool your entire home, its lightweight and portable design makes it easy to move from room to room. Thought it couldn't get any better? The unit also comes with a remote control that works from up to 16 feet away, so you can adjust settings without getting up! 🧊 40+ reviews ⭐ 4.9/5 stars 🏅 "Cools the room down so quickly!" More than 500 Amazon shoppers purchased this portable AC unit in the past month, and now, the reviews are pouring in. Customers love how easy it is to set up and use — just fill the water tank, plug it in and enjoy the cooling mist. 'Super easy to use and perfect for small spaces,' one reviewer wrote. 'This mini air conditioner surprised me with its impressive power for its size!" Others praise its portability and quiet operation: 'I have it on a basic low setting, it is very quiet — I don't need to turn up the TV and it keeps me cool all night.' Some even say it's become "a summer essential" for working from home: 'Works great on my desk and it makes afternoon meetings way more bearable.' Sales for this customer favourite are up 25,000 per cent. While most shoppers are thrilled with their purchase, a few reviewers pointed out that the unit's reliance on a USB cable for power can be a drawback. One user noted, 'The only limitation is it always needs to be connected to a power outlet through a USB cable, which limits the placement a bit.' With sales skyrocketing and rave reviews, this portable mini AC might just be the summer upgrade your space needs, especially if you don't want to splurge on a full unit or install anything permanent. And for $70, it's a simple, sleek solution to beat the heat. But with numbers like these, we wouldn't be surprised if it sells out soon. ⭐️ 4/5 stars 💬 5,000+ reviews Like having your own personal cooling system on wheels, this unit functions as an air conditioner, fan and dehumidifier, so you can stay cool and dry even on the stickiest summer days. With a modern look and handy remote control, it's a stylish and convenient way to beat the heat without breaking a sweat. ⭐️ 4./5 stars 💬 48,000+ reviews This powerful unit is a total game-changer that keeps you cool in the summer and cozy in the winter. With its easy-to-read LED display and remote control, adjusting the temperature is just one click away. ⭐️ 4.6/5 stars 💬 600+ reviews This compact cooler is like a personal breeze machine, turning stuffy summer air into a refreshing mist with just the push of a button. Plus, it includes ice packs and reviewers note that 'set up is a breeze!' ⭐️ 4.1/5 stars 💬 1,200+ reviews Designed to cool large spaces quickly and efficiently, this programmable unit delivers icy relief exactly where you need it. Shoppers love its Arctic Whisper Extreme Technology, which provides powerful performance while staying impressively quiet, so it gets the job done without drawing attention for the wrong reasons. ⭐️ 4.6/5 stars 💬 100+ reviews Small but surprisingly powerful, this portable air cooler does it all. Acting as a mini air conditioner, cooling fan, air humidifier and even an LED night light, it runs quietly and efficiently to keep you cool and comfortable no matter how hot it gets outside. ⭐️ 4.5/5 stars 💬 110+ reviews Delivering the best of both worlds, this heat wave hero combines the power of a tower fan with the cooling comfort of an air conditioner. It features four wind speeds, customizable mist settings, a built-in air purifier and a sleek touchscreen interface for effortless control. Whether you're looking to cool down, clean the air or add a bit of moisture to dry spaces, this all-in-one has you covered. ⭐️ 4.3/5 stars 💬 970+ reviews This portable unit delivers ice-cold air circulation with wide coverage and an oscillating fan for even cooling. With included ice packs, multiple fan settings and a quiet sleep mode, you can enjoy refreshing comfort without ever sacrificing a good night's sleep. ⭐️ 4.1/5 stars 💬 40+ reviews Uneven airflow is about to be a thing of the past. This baby delivers 1.5-2X higher wind speeds and ensures full room coverage in minutes. In addition to its many features, the included ice boxes are filled with a unique cooling gel that stays cooler for longer and drops water temps by 8-12°C. ⭐️ 5/5 stars 💬 70+ reviews Don't be fooled by its size — stay cool anywhere with this mini air cooler that works tirelessly. With three adjustable fan speeds and 60° vertical oscillation, it provides icy cold air precisely where you need it, whether that's your desk, bedroom or office.
The Independent
8 minutes ago
- The Independent
Five prospects to watch on Yafai vs Rodriguez Jr undercard – including Olympian and ‘world-class' knockout artist
As Galal Yafai continues his charge towards a world title, a new wave of unbeaten prospects is ready to make a statement on Saturday's undercard in Birmingham. While most of the spotlight will fall on Yafai's headlining bout against Francisco Rodriguez Jr – his first defence of the WBC interim flyweight title – the undercard is packed with rising talent eager to follow in his footsteps. Among them: an Olympian, a knockout artist, and a fighter tipped as a future world champion by Eddie Hearn himself. Pat Brown – 1-0 (1 knockout) Like headliner Galal Yafai, cruiserweight Brown represented Team GB at the Olympics, competing in Paris last summer. While he exited in the first round of the heavyweight competition, expectations remain high for the Manchester fighter in the pro ranks. Brown made his debut in March with a fourth-round stoppage of Federico Grandone (7-4-2) and returns on Saturday against Croatia's Ivan Duka (5-5), with another outing already pencilled in for Manchester next month. Backed by Matchroom and close with fellow pro Dave Allen, Brown could be set for a busy 2025. Hamza Uddin – 4-0 (1 KO) Flyweight Uddin was a standout in the amateur ranks and part of the Team GB set-up before choosing to turn professional late last year. Since debuting with a third-round stoppage of Santiago San Eusebio, the 21-year-old British-Bangladeshi has consistently stepped up – fighting opponents with winning records and moving quickly to eight-round bouts. Trained by his father Raj and managed by Sam Jones, Uddin takes on Leandro Jose Blanc (8-2) on Saturday. With Matchroom behind him and home support in the Midlands, he's tipped for a rapid rise. Aaron Bowen – 5-0 (3 KOs) Middleweight Bowen returns to familiar ground on Saturday, fighting in Birmingham where he won Commonwealth bronze in 2022. The Coventry fighter has made a strong start to his pro career, racking up five wins and three knockouts, including stoppages against Wilmer Baron (6-1) and James Todd (4-5-2). Now 26, Bowen has been with Matchroom since turning pro and is steadily building a fanbase in the Midlands. He faces experienced Ukrainian Mykola Vovk (15-7) in his latest step up. Giorgio Visioli – 7-0 (6 KOs) One of the most talked-about prospects on the card, Visioli enters with six knockouts in seven fights and serious momentum. Promoter Hearn has described the super featherweight as 'world class' and predicted he'll be in the British title picture by the end of the year. Listed on The Independent and DAZN's 'Prospects of the Year', the 23-year-old from Aldershot seems unfazed by the growing attention. 'I go into each fight treating it like a world title,' he told BBC Sport. 'All it takes is one punch to derail you.' Visioli takes on Argentina's Elias Federico Duguet (7-1-1) over eight rounds. Ibraheem Sulaimaan – 7-0 (4 KOs) Nicknamed 'The Spider', Birmingham's Sulaimaan continues his steady rise at super-featherweight. The 24-year-old earned his spot on the Matchroom roster after impressing on earlier undercards and has since notched up four stoppages in seven wins.
