Chicago's identity crisis: Who's leaving and who's staying
A new global report suggests Chicago is in the midst of an identity crisis.
The big picture: When asked what they love about the city, people's answers were split by how long they've lived here, according to City Pulse 2025: The Magnetic City from Gensler Research Institute, an arm of the design firm that has built several projects in Chicago.
Some say they would grow old here while others were making moving truck reservations.
Methodology: Gensler surveyed 33,000 anonymous urban residents in 65 global cities in 2024, including over 500 people in Chicago.
By the numbers: Residents who have been here fewer than 10 years show a 13% likelihood of leaving compared with those living in other major cities.
They are 16% more likely to leave than someone who's been here for more than a decade.
Older adults surveyed were more concerned about the city's future.
Zoom out: Chicagoans were above the national average in saying their city is a strong place to socialize and find connections. They also said walkability was a huge positive, higher than in most cities.
The biggest factors in staying in a city are cost of living, level of crime, healthcare costs, job opportunities and taxes.
Respondents said the city is a good place to grow old, showing confidence in affordability, aging and safety.
Yes, but: Some were concerned that the city's reputation and identity is getting worse.
Zoom in: The report comes days after U.S. News & World Report ranked Illinois toward the bottom of its latest best states ranking.
Also, the newly passed state budget calls for more taxes, while Cook County residents are seeing increases to their property taxes and utility bills.
The other side: Chicago has been named "Best Big City in the U.S." by Condé Nast Traveler for eight straight years.
And our cost of living and tax burdens are less than in Los Angeles and New York City and other global cities.
What they're saying: Gensler Chicago's Brian Vitale sees the results as a chance to keep Chicagoans interested in the city. "Chicagoans clearly feel the magic of their city, and that's something to build on," Vitale tells Axios.
"We can turn these strengths into lasting experiences by continuing to create neighborhoods that are dynamic, inclusive and welcoming at every stage of life."
Tell us Chicagoans: Should you stay or should you go? We'll publish results later in the week.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
6 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Embattled Kenwood shelter housing migrants and homeless Chicagoans to close in coming months
A Kenwood shelter housing both migrants and Chicagoans experiencing homelessness will close in the coming months following a divide amongst neighbors, according to an email update from state Sen. Robert Peters. Located at 4900 S. DuSable Lake Shore Drive, the shelter opened in summer 2023 to accommodate migrants sent to Chicago by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott. Its opening drew sharp pushback from residents concerned about how newcomers from crisis-affected regions would integrate into the neighborhood. Tensions deepened when the facility was later expanded to include homeless Chicagoans, part of the city and state's One System Initiative aimed at merging shelter services for both populations. Early months of combined migrant, homeless shelters in Chicago see success, structural challengesPeters said he was notified of the closure by city and Illinois Department of Human Services officials at 3:15 p.m. Friday. Those currently housed at the shelter will move to new facilities over the next three to six months, he said. Neither the city nor the state was immediately able to provide a comment Friday afternoon regarding the reason for the closure or the number of people affected. 'We've always believed that housing is a human right,' Peters said. 'But also, at the end of the day, what matters most is being transparent with everybody.' As tens of thousands of people arrived by bus over roughly two years, the city and state scrambled to open enough shelters to stave off a full-blown homelessness crisis in Chicago. The city and state were running 28 migrant-exclusive facilities at the peak of arrivals in January of last year, according to city census data. The idea of a combined system was championed by some who said it would spread out resources to a wider range of people. There are dozens of shelters in the new system. The closure announcement also comes as President Donald Trump has ramped up immigration enforcement in and around the city, targeting courts and offices where people are reporting for check-ins. Many of the migrants being housed by the city are from Venezuela, a country that Trump has repeatedly singled out in immigration policy.
Chicago Tribune
3 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Jim Nowlan: With Illinois struggling, the Edgar Fellows could draft a vision for a positive future
Illinois doesn't know where it is going. Situation: After considering thousands of bills, the Illinois legislature paused its brief, frenetic spring session, putting off until the fall action on the really sticky issues, such as how to address a $770 million 'fiscal cliff' shortfall in funding for metro Chicago's critical mass transit. Legislative bodies exist to resolve conflict, which is time-consuming, challenging, even painful. Politics are largely a game of 'who gets what.' Granting additional money, say, to school kids, requires either, one, taking an equivalent amount from some other spending program; two, taking more in taxes out of the hides of voters; or three, transforming the equivalent expenditure into debt for future generations to pay off. (This assumes no or slow real economic growth in Illinois, as is the case.) Each of the 177 Illinois state legislators has his or her own bills to shepherd through the two houses of the legislature, and any bill that does anything has its pesky opponents. Members must feel as if they are running around like chickens with their heads cut off — scores of committees, floor sessions, meetings with constituents and lobbyists. Long-term thinking in Illinois is: 'How do we paper over next year's budget deficit?' There is never time for the big picture, 'the vision thing.' Where do we want the state to be in 10 to 20 years? How should we respond to climate change (which could be bad and good for Illinois)? What about our jerry-built revenue system, which is rather unresponsive in a services-driven economy? And an education system in which achievement for those on the lower half of the economic ladder is being devalued? (For example, achievement in our rural schools is abysmal, yet few seem to know or care.) How do we reverse state population decline and tepid job growth, which for decades has been slower than for the rest of the Midwest and nation? The singular piece of really forward thinking in Illinois history came with the Burnham Plan for Chicago of the early 1900s, led by architect Daniel Burnham and commissioned by the Commercial Club of Chicago. The effort followed on the heels of the stupendous Chicago World's Fair of 1893, visited by 27 million folks from around the world. So, the 'city of the big shoulders,' as poet Carl Sandburg described it, knew it could do big things. After much work, the plan was presented to the City Council, which also labored over the plan, ultimately adopting about half the recommendations. But what marvelous results: Thirty unbroken miles of lakefront open to the public; wide boulevards and spectacular parks, and more. Chicagoans and visitors have benefited every day since its adoption in 1909. Other states take the long look. With Texas 2036 (the state's 200th anniversary of nationhood), that state's civic and business leaders are shaping a stronger state for the long haul. I propose an idea for tapping into an incredible but underutilized resource for future thinking. Former Gov. Jim Edgar's greatest legacy may be his Edgar Fellows Program. Each summer for more than a decade, Jim gathers 40 of the state's young leaders, many of whom are now lawmakers, from all walks of life, political persuasions and geography. For a week, the fellows are sequestered near the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, where they learn about our state and its government from experts and national leaders. Over bourbon and branch water in the evenings, they bond and come to appreciate one another. But then they leave town and fail to build on their relationships and any aspirations for a state they will lead in the years to come. I propose that the 500 Edgar Fellows, rather than simply feel good about themselves, take on the task of creating a vision for Illinois, as with the Burnham Plan. This needs be done outside the hurly-burly of politics, after which they would take their vision into the political arena, where it would be wrestled with, and adopted, if only in part. The fellows have both the smarts to create a vision and the growing clout to see it enacted. Illinois needs to know where it should be going, for a change.
UPI
3 days ago
- UPI
Chicago relaunches 'Know Your Rights' campaign amid increased deportations
1 of 2 | Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson is warning President Donald Trump to "respect the Constitution" after the president ordered Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents to ramp up deportation efforts in Democratic-led sanctuary cities, including Chicago and Los Angeles. File Photo by Tannen Maury/UPI | License Photo June 17 (UPI) -- Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson is warning President Donald Trump to "respect the Constitution" after the president ordered Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents to ramp up deportation efforts in Democratic-led sanctuary cities, including Chicago and Los Angeles. In response, Johnson and city officials announced Tuesday they will relaunch a "Know Your Rights" ad campaign to educate Chicago residents. "Even if the federal government doesn't know or care about the Constitution, Chicagoans deserve to know their constitutional rights," Johnson told reporters at a City Hall news conference. The ads, which will educate residents about their rights if they are stopped or detained by ICE agents, will be displayed on more than 400 screens across the Chicago Transit Authority system. The ads direct transit riders to the campaign website with a more in-depth resource guide, which is translated in multiple languages. The guide instructs residents how to react if stopped, but warned the information "should not be construed as legal advice." "We can't tell people not to be afraid," said Beatriz Ponce de León, Chicago's deputy mayor of immigrant, migrant and refugee rights. "Folks are seeing what is happening here and in other cities. But what we can do is give people information. The best that people can do is be prepared." Earlier this month, Trump deployed National Guard troops to Los Angeles to help protect ICE agents and federal buildings after protests in the downtown area turned violent. Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass and California Gov. Gavin Newsom objected to the president's actions, calling the deployment unjustified. Other sanctuary cities, including Chicago, are now bracing for a similar crackdown. Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker has joined Johnson in opposing the president's actions, while Trump denounced state leadership. "I look at Chicago. You've got a really bad governor and a bad mayor. But the governor is probably the worst in history," Trump said. Pritzker responded by saying, "I think you can see that this has not gone well for him politically, and he's all about the politics." Acting director of ICE, Tom Homan, told CNN in January that Chicago's efforts to educated undocumented immigrants have made deportation efforts "very difficult." "For instance, Chicago is very well educated," Homan said. "They call it 'know your rights.' I call it how to escape arrest ... how to hide from ICE."
