‘I have a £10k house deposit. Should I pay off my £45k student loan first?'
Receive personalised tips on how to improve your financial situation, for free. Here's how to apply or fill in the form below.
Imogen Cromack faces a dilemma typical for her generation.
The 26-year-old, who works in communications in London, would like to buy a house with her partner before she turns 30.
She has around £10,000 saved in cash, which she has put away in a two-year fixed-rate savings account, where it will earn decent guaranteed returns.
However, she's also saddled with £45,000 student loan debt, having completed a three-year business course at the University of the West of England.
Repayments are taken from her salary each month, at 9pc on anything earned over the Plan 2 threshold of £28,470. Thanks to the interest charged, for many graduates, the prospect of never paying off a student loan is all too real.
She asks: 'My main question, really, is: should I look at paying off my student loan faster, or should I save instead for a deposit and other house buying expenses?'
Ms Cromack spends less than £2,000 a year on holidays, choosing to go on one 'big' holiday a year, usually lasting a week.
She pays £1,000 a month in rent and bills, and prioritises a £80-a-month gym membership, which she gets heavily discounted through work.
She says: 'I don't frequently go out for big expensive dinners. I probably spend more on just seeing my friends and doing some activities and stuff like that. I am more of a homebody personally.'
As she looks towards the next five years, Cromack says her priority is to be financially stable, adding: 'I would like to be prepped to be able to stand on my own two feet.'
Lucie Spencer, financial planning partner at Evelyn Partners, said:
Ms Cromack lives a relatively conservative lifestyle in terms of expenditure, so it is sensible to consider the implications of paying off her student loan early versus saving to buy her first home.
What she must remember is that student loan repayments can affect the size of the mortgage she can secure, though it won't have as heavy an impact as other personal debts.
While student loans do not appear on a credit file, and therefore won't affect her credit rating, they can impact her affordability level, as the student loan repayment counts as a regular outgoing in the same way her gym membership does.
However, in contrast with other debts, it is the amount which you repay which gets factored into this assessment rather than the total outstanding debt.
In essence, the student loan system works more like a graduate tax on earnings than a conventional loan. Like income tax, the more you earn the more you pay, so it is the higher earners that will end up paying the most.
But, while Ms Cromack qualifies for repayments and may want to consider repaying her debt earlier, the savings she has now won't be enough to clear her outstanding liabilities, and she will continue to repay the same amount each month.
If she chooses to take time out from her career at any point, perhaps to raise a family or take a sabbatical, her repayments will stop for that period.
The current interest rate on a Plan 2 student loan is relatively high at 7.3pc, as of September 2024, but this typically resets every September and is linked back to the RPI of the previous March, so it should lower later this year.
With that in mind, it may make more sense for Ms Cromack to prioritise short-term financial priorities such as raising a deposit to buy a home rather than clearing her student debt.
If she wants to focus on building up a deposit, then she could consider a lifetime Isa (Lisa), where she will attract not only interest on her savings, but also an additional 25pc top-up from the Government of up to £1,000 on the maximum annual contribution of £4,000.
Savings rates are in retreat mode, and it is important to keep savings as tax efficient as possible – something a Lisa can offer.
A Lisa pot can be invested in stocks and shares or held in cash, but if Ms Cromack plans to purchase a home within the next five years, it may be better to stick with a cash option to ensure she is not impacted by any stock market fluctuations.
Darius McDermott, managing director at Chelsea Financial Services, said:
It's great to see someone in their 20s balancing both ambition and financial discipline. The desire to save for a home while also thinking about clearing debt is admirable, but it's important to be realistic and strategic with priorities.
With £10,000 already saved in a two-year fixed-rate account, the foundation for a house deposit is in place.
However, the student loan repayment at 9pc is a significant cost. Put simply, if the interest on the loan is higher than the return on your savings, it often makes financial sense to prioritise debt repayment, especially with high inflation eroding savings in real terms.
That said, student loans are unlike other forms of debt – repayment is tied to income and is eventually written off. So rather than rushing to pay it off entirely, a balanced approach might be wiser, continuing to save steadily, while ensuring you're not accruing more expensive interest than necessary.
As Ms Cromack's income grows, gradually increasing contributions to savings, and eventually exploring investment options, could help build momentum towards her long-term goals. She's already made a strong start with her fixed-rate savings.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
3 days ago
- The Sun
The best and worst degrees that could see you earn huge salary – with top job landing graduates nearly £70,000 a year
GOING to university costs an eye-watering £68,000, so it pays to pick a degree that will bank you a healthy paycheck. Here we take a look at the best and worst courses for earning a higher salary after graduation - and the difference in pay is a whopping £46,600. 2 While many students end up paying out £68,000, which is the total cost of studying. University costs have soared in recent years and the average student in England is now expected to graduate with a debt of £43,700. This sum includes maintenance and tuition loans. Most students will need to pay back their student loan over 30 years, after which point it is written off. This applies to graduates who are on a repayment scheme called Plan 5. Meanwhile, those who applied for a student loan after August 2023 will now need to pay it back over 40 years. These students are on the Plan 2 repayment scheme. Repaying such large debts can make it much harder to save for a house deposit or start a family. So, if you are weighing up your options after school or college, or even considering a career change, then our guide could help. Recruitment website Adzuna has crunched the numbers to reveal which degrees offer the best - and worst - value for money. The company analysed more than 100,000 CVs from job seekers between 2020 and 2025 to figure out how much they earned five years after graduation. Five of the degrees will lead to a job with a salary of more than £60,000 within five years - here's what you need to know. Which degrees lead to top-paying jobs? Unsurprisingly, students who study STEM subjects (Science, Technology, Engineering and Maths) are most likely to pocket the best pay checks. Students with Computer Science degrees are likely to earn the most out of anyone, and can expect to pocket an enormous £69,692 a year. That's £32,262 more than the average national salary, which is £37,430, according to the Office for National Statistics. 2 Figures provided by Adzuna Close behind were graduates with Biomedical Sciences degrees, who could earn around £67,792 a year. Meanwhile, students on Data Science degrees can expect to earn £64,412 a year. Financial Management graduates could pocket £63,662 a year. Hot on the heels are Business Analytics students, who can expect to earn £62,537 a year. Plus, Economics and Politics students can bag a pay check of £55,520 a year. How to find the right job for you Simon Fabb, CEO of shares his tips to help you find the right role. Get experience "Something I'd suggest every student do is start gaining relevant experience while they're still studying. "The job market is so oversaturated and having a degree on its own doesn't hold the same weight it used to, so have a look for internships, part-time work, freelance projects and volunteering opportunities to bolster your CV while reading for your degree. "Employers will want to see evidence of initiative and a real-world application of the skills you've been learning - especially is competitive sectors like tech or finance." Consider your location "Graduate salaries can vary hugely depending on where you're willing to work so have a think about location. "Large cities and major hubs, particularly London and parts of the South East, tend to offer significantly higher starting salaries than other regions. "Being flexible about location will gives you access to better-paid opportunities, especially in industries where demand is concentrated geographically." Look for remote jobs "In some sectors, remote roles are now common at entry level too, which opens up national and even international job markets." Work on your communication skills "Strong communication skills, confidence in interviews, adaptability, and a clear understanding of the role and company carry just as much weight. "If you can demonstrate that you understand the specific challenges and goals of a business you're much more likely to be offered higher starting package." Meanwhile, Accounting graduates have an average salary of £55,375 while those who study Big Data can earn an average of £54,075 a year. Engineers are also highly sought after, with two degrees in this subject leading to a high pay packet. Electronics and Communication Engineering students could walk away with £57,287 a year. Meanwhile, Industrial Engineers could earn slightly less, at £53,536 a year. Which degrees lead to the lowest paying jobs? There are certain degrees to swerve though if you're wanting a big bank balance. It may come as no surprise that those who studied the Arts will be the worst off. Graduates who studied Photography will earn the lowest salary of all students, with an average pay packet of £23,030 a year. That's £14,400 less than the national average. Several creative degrees will also lead to low-paying jobs. Among them is Textiles, which comes with an average salary of £23,837 after five years. Music and Fine Art graduates can also expect to earn less than their peers. A graduate with a music degree can expect to earn £23,903 a year, while Fine Art students can expect to pocket £24,020. I'm using my music degree to get into marketing MUSIC graduate Shakila Karim is using her degree to get a job in marketing. The 27-year-old graduated from ICMP with a Music Degree in 2019. Shakila had hoped to launch a successful music career and perform at venues across the UK, but the pandemic made this impossible. Instead, she worked at her local Tesco and gave music lessons to students online. When restrictions lifted she did several local performances, including at a charity gig in Bishop's Stortford. Shakila, from Hertfordshire, has now used her degree to get work experience in music marketing. She said: "I worked for a year at a radio plugger service, which pitched new music to heads of music, producers and DJs. "Now I've got marketing experience I'm trying to use it to find a full-time job in marketing. "I want to make sure my skills are transferable across all marketing industries and find a full-time marketing job." Several humanities degrees including Geography, Politics and History also made the list. A Geography graduate will earn an average salary of £23,445 a year, while Politics and History students will walk away with an average salary of £24,094. Meanwhile, graduates with specialist degrees also often earn low salaries. Criminology students earn a salary of £23,420 five years after graduation. Translation graduates can earn a salary of £23,498 while American studies students can expect to earn £23,924. Plus Zoology graduates can expect to earn £24,297 a year on average. How can I make myself stand out? When applying for a job, it's important to make sure you stand out. Tailor your CV and cover letter to the role you are after. Highlight your skills, experience and qualifications and make it clear that they match the job. Emphasise what makes you the right candidate for the role. In your cover letter and interview explain clearly why you are excited about the role, company and industry. You should also make it clear how your values align. You can find this information on the company's website and in the job description. If you do not have the right experience, then emphasise the skills you do have. Think teamwork, communication and problem-solving. You can also mention soft skills such as time management, communication and resilience. You can also highlight the ways that you have continued to learn and improve yourself. This could be through courses or workshops at university or hobbies. Do you have a money problem that needs sorting? Get in touch by emailing money-sm@
Telegraph
5 days ago
- Telegraph
Families hit with higher inheritance tax bills after HMRC disputes property values
HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) hit 1,500 families with higher inheritance tax bills last year after disputing the value of their properties. The tax office challenged property valuations in 7,500 death duty cases last year, according to data revealed by The Telegraph in a Freedom of Information request. Under inheritance tax rules, when a person dies, the executor must declare the value of the estate to HMRC. But if that property later sells for a higher price, then the tax office may open an investigation to claw back unpaid inheritance tax. Of the 7,500 disputes, HMRC concluded that 1,500 families had underestimated the value of the property, which resulted in the tax office pursuing them for extra inheritance tax. Ian Dyall, of wealth manager Evelyn Partners, said: 'HMRC now has a significant amount of available data at its disposal. 'If that data points towards undervaluation of an asset, or even assets omitted from the inheritance tax submissions, then they are likely to investigate.' Mr Dyall said high-value properties in particular would be 'carefully scrutinised' by the tax office given the potential revenue at stake. To work out whether an executor has underestimated the price of the property, HMRC will refer to the Valuation Office Agency (VOA). This government agency was recently scrapped as part of a cost-cutting drive, and will be subsumed into HMRC by April 2026. In about half of cases last year, the VOA agreed with the valuations given by the taxpayer. But in over 3,500 cases, the VOA pushed ahead with an investigation. This three-month process typically involves a physical inspection of the property, as well as requests for further information from the taxpayer. Sean McCann, of the insurer NFU Mutual, said: 'The valuation office is instructed to consider any features that might make it attractive to a developer, such as a large garden or access to other land suitable for development.' In over 1,500 cases, the VOA decided the property value was higher than the taxpayer had said. Mr McCann said: 'Valuation of property is not an exact science. Negotiation will often occur where the executors have obtained a professional valuation which differs from HMRC's.' If they cannot come to an agreement about the value of the property, then the dispute can be escalated to the First-tier Tribunal Hearings. This comes amid a rise in inheritance tax investigations by HMRC. The tax office launched 3,961 investigations in the 12 months to April 2025, up 31pc on the previous tax year. By comparison, the number of property valuations referred to the VOA has fallen in recent years, from almost 16,000 in 2021-22. However, the proportion resulting in the VOA suggesting a higher property price has increased. For the best chance of defending an enquiry by HMRC, Mr Dyall recommended getting two independent valuations from qualified surveyors. Inheritance tax is charged at 40pc on the value of an estate worth more than £325,000. However, homeowners can claim an extra £175,000 if they leave their main home to their children, giving couples a £1m allowance. An HMRC spokesman said: 'The majority of people pay the correct amount of inheritance tax. In cases where it is suspected someone has not, investigations can be opened, including referrals to the Valuation Office Agency.'
Daily Mail
6 days ago
- Daily Mail
I don't currently work and draw a monthly income through my savings - will I be hit with a tax bill for the interest?
In the financial year 2024/25, I was in employment until the summer of 2024 – I was a higher-rate taxpayer. Since then, I have been unemployed and am drawing an income from a substantial pot of savings. In terms of my savings, I definitely breached my £500 personal savings allowance for 2024/25. But now am I'm confused as to what my PSA is – and whether HMRC will hit me with a big tax bill somewhere along the line. I'm in my late 30s and don't draw an income from anywhere else, just from my savings – including easy-access, monthly income, NS&I income bonds, Premium Bonds and once a year from fixed rate accounts. I also have Isas and investments, but they are currently growing – I'm not drawing any income from them. Am I being paranoid, will HMRC send me a tax bill and how does it know how much interest I earn from my savings? Lucie Spencer, financial planning partners at wealth manager Evelyn Partners replies: Whether or not you have breached your Personal Savings Allowance (PSA) depends on how much taxable income you earn in the 2025/26 tax year. As you are currently unemployed and no longer working full-time, you may end up being a basic rate taxpayer depending on when you start working before the end of this financial year. In that instance, your PSA will have doubled to £1,000 from £500, which, put simply, means that you can earn up to £1,000 in interest on your cash savings before you are liable for tax at your marginal rate of tax. However, you could end up with an even bigger PSA than you realise. As you remain unemployed, you still have your personal allowance of £12,570 to swallow up some of your savings interest. Low earners can use their personal allowance of £12,570 to earn interest tax-free if it has not been used up by earnings or other income, such as a pension. Those earning less than £12,570 receive an extra £5,000 tax-free allowance for their savings income, known as the starting rate for savers. This means an individual can earn £12,570 in income and £6,000 in savings interest (£5,000 starting savings allowance plus the personal savings allowance of £1,000) - that's a total of £18,570 from wages and savings interest before tax is applied. However, things get a little more complicated for those earning between £12,570 and £17,570 as for every £1 of non-savings income above the personal allowance, they lose £1 of their starting savings allowance. There may be a challenge from your one-year fix. The point at which a nest egg is liable for tax can depend on the interest rate applied to the account so a fixed-rate account that pays out all the interest at maturity could create a tax headache if all the interest gets paid out in a tax year where you have a substantial income. Ultimately, how much tax you must pay on your savings at the end of this financial year will depend on your total taxable income, including any future employment that starts before April 6, 2026, and the level of interest you earn. Anna Bowes personal finance expert at The Private Office replies: I'd say you are being sensible rather than paranoid, as it is important to be aware of any tax that you might owe. And of course, it not that easy to navigate. The PSA is linked directly to your income tax band, which is based on your total taxable income for any given tax year (6 April to 5 April). And the PSA is different depending on the level of tax you pay in that year. If you are a basic rate taxpayer, your PSA is £1,000 of tax-free savings interest. It's £500 if you're a higher-rate (40 per cent) taxpayer. But if you are an additional-rate (45 per cent) taxpayer, you do not have a PSA at all. You mentioned that you were employed until the summer of 2024. If the income from your savings and your salary took you into the higher rate tax bracket in 2024/25 then your PSA was £500, regardless of whether you were only employed for part of the year. The PSA is based on your marginal rate over the course of the tax year. Onto the current tax year – if the total taxable income from your savings and investments is less than the higher rate tax threshold, but more than the personal allowance of £12,570, then you are likely to be a basic rate taxpayer. But again, it depends on what your income is over the whole tax year, so if your circumstances change before 5 April next year and your income takes you over the higher rate threshold, then your PSA will again be £500. One thing to note is that, of the savings accounts you have mentioned, Premium Bonds prizes, and any interest earned on Isas are tax-free and don't count towards your taxable income or PSA. As you are not currently earning anything from wages or pensions, you may be able to use the full £5,000 of tax-free interest from the starting rate for savers. Tom Minnikin, partner at tax firm Forbes Dawson replies: If your only income is from earning interest – and assuming the income is less than £100,000 – you will qualify for various tax-free allowances. These are: The personal allowance of £12,570; the starting rate for savings which is £5,000; and the PSA - £1,000 if you are a basic rate taxpayer or £500 if you are a higher rate taxpayer. If you earn more, you will be taxed at either 20 per cent or 40 per cent. This depends on whether the income falls into the basic rate or higher rate tax bracket. Interest is taxable in the tax year it arises. This is typically when the interest is credited into your account, provided it is available to draw. Some accounts prevent access to interest until the end of a fixed period. In these circumstances, the interest will only arise at the end of the period. However, if the interest can be freely drawn but will incur a penalty, this remains taxable at the point it is available. Prizes from premium bonds - like interest - are not taxable. Income earned through an Isa wrapper is also tax-free. Will HMRC send you a tax bill? Anna Bowes replies: Banks, building societies and NS&I report your taxable interest directly to HMRC each year. When HMRC receives this information, it checks if you've gone over your PSA. If you have, any tax due will usually be collected via a change to your tax code in the following year – assuming you're back in employment and therefore part of the PAYE scheme. If you are not employed, you may need to fill in a Self Assessment return and pay the tax due. The bottom line though is that it is your responsibility to make sure you pay any tax due - if your interest does exceed your PSA, you will owe tax at your marginal rate for that tax year on the excess. So, keep track of how much interest you are earning and estimate your overall likely tax rate. If you expect to exceed your PSA again and in the future, it may be worth putting more into Isas if possible, where interest and growth are sheltered from tax altogether. Lucie Spencer replies: If the interest you earn on savings is over £10,000 you need to complete a Self-Assessment tax return. If you remain unemployed and don't complete Self-Assessment to self declare the interest you earn, your bank or building society will inform HMRC at the end of the tax year of how much interest you earned. You will then be notified on how much tax you need to pay, though you may find, if your income is lower and you can boost the tax efficiency of your savings, that the amount may be negligible.
