After 50 years, is our comprehensive system still fit for purpose?
I have every sympathy for our schools. Staff and students are facing significant challenges – challenges aggravated by the demoralising effects of poverty punishing so many decent families. It is very much to the credit of our schools that they continue to have the positive support of parents and their local communities, conscious that they are trying their best in challenging circumstances.
Things were so different when I started teaching in 1969. Yes, there were undoubted challenges but there was a sense of excitement that positive changes were on their way.
In just a few short years, our old selective system with junior and senior high schools had changed to a national comprehensive system. New schools were being built; the school-leaving age was raised to 16 and a new system of examinations was introduced that was designed to offer national qualifications to students of all abilities.
In addition, corporal punishment was abolished and supportive Guidance systems introduced. For young probationer teachers there was a network of invaluable support. Each secondary school was staffed with a team of subject principal teachers who really were the backbone of the school. They were the subject experts familiar with the curriculum and the various exam requirements; they offered encouragement to the members of their departments and used their experience to support the effective running of the school.
The removal of these posts to save money was a serious mistake which has had a negative effect on academic results. In addition, the loss of these promoted posts has made teaching a less attractive career option for graduates.
So what needs to be done? It seems that there is an administrative mindset at all levels of government that we don't need to look elsewhere for answers to our challenges. It's almost as though Johnny foreigner can't teach us anything.
So for example, after over 50 years, is our comprehensive system still fit for purpose? Are there lessons to be learnt from different models of school organization?
Our two grandchildren both attend their local schools in Japan. As grandparents my wife and I are impressed with what we have learnt about Japanese education. One feature that we should seriously consider is the emphasis in Japan on team work rather than here, where we still cling to the notion of child-centered education. Interestingly your education feature commented very positively on education in Finland ('Why Finland's real innovation is putting students first', May 17)
Our son in Tokyo reports that there has been a recent visit from a team of Finnish educationalists to look specifically at the place of team work in Japanese schools. We really have to be honest rather than defensive when considering changes to our education system.
Eric Melvin, Edinburgh.
In defence of Sir Walter Scott
Robin Dow's letter regarding Sir Walter Scott ('Great Scott? No, not really', June 11) needs a response.
During the Covid period I decided to read all of Charles Dickens's novels. I thoroughly enjoyed this undertaking and revisited many well-loved characters.
I then decided to do the same with Walter Scott's works, which are naturally very different in subject and style to Dickens.
Having already read 10, I decided to go back to Waverley and to read the full opus in chronological order.
Unlike Mr Dow, who says he has read many, I have now read the vast majority of the 27 works (only two to go!) so I think I have the right to esteem Scott. Also – unlike him, but like Rosemary Goring – I find Scott page-turning stuff.
I find Mr Dow's comparison of other artistic figures somewhat unfortunate.
For a start, Milton and Spenser lived in different centuries; Constable and Turner painted in different genres; and Handel was first and foremost an opera composer. Bach wrote none.
Of course , personal taste along with some knowledge is the ultimate determinant.
Linda Hoskins, Houston.
Searching, sadly, sans success
May I award Jody Harrison a gold medal for his most alliterative heading – 'Summer solstice sees searches spike for Scottish standing stones' (June 12)?
I have, alas, failed in my search for a word beginning with 's' to replace Mr Harrison's 'for'.
Something to concentrate the mind over my cornflakes.
David Miller, Milngavie.
Fuelling a debate over winter payment
I have worked for the Department of Work and Pensions for 40 years, currently dealing with Pension Credit. I am paid the minimum wage of £12.21 per hour.
I find it hard to understand why so many think that Paul McCartney, Baron Sugar, and indeed Brian Wilson ('A universal truth: not all pensioners deserve the winter fuel allowance. But U-turn is welcome', June 12) should get £200 every year in the winter fuel payment.
Dougie Mac Nicol, Glasgow.
Musk has blown his credibility
Elon Musk has realised that he must be more careful with what he says, as his latest post admits: 'I regret some of my posts about President Donald Trump last week. They went too far.'
Many people have regrets; some acknowledge them and a few do something about it beyond a cursory apology.
The world's wealthiest man is attempting to restore his 'buddyship' with the world's most powerful man but it might be too late.
It seems be a case of checking your parachute after you have jumped off a cliff: it's a bit too late.
Musk has blown up his credibility and diminished his wealth while others are blowing up his Tesla vehicles.
Oh well, he has about a dozen children that will take care of him in his dotage.
Dennis Fitzgerald, Melbourne, Australia.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
How to prevent and report Japanese knotweed amid fly-tipping
Fly-tipping is the illegal dumping of waste on public or private land – and its on the rise across the UK with more than one million incidents reported over the last two years. Now, experts are warning of another element that could add to the issue blighting areas. Fly-tipping often involves rubble, soil and plant cuttings which is then dumped and left to rot. If Japanese Knotweed is either fly-tipped or unknowingly part of dumped soil within the waste – then there's a problem. 'Fly-tipping and Japanese knotweed is a big problem in the UK,' reports. 'Because it leads to the spread of this invasive species. 'If plant material is present in the fly-tipped waste, it can quickly establish itself in the new location, creating a new infestation. 'Japanese knotweed is an extremely resilient plant. Furthermore, it can grow in a wide range of soil types and conditions. 'It spreads by producing new shoots from its wide root system, which can extend up to 7m from the main stem. 'This means that if Japanese knotweed is brought to a new area, it can quickly colonize the entire site, out-competing native vegetation and causing some environmental damage.' The fly-tipping of Japanese knotweed can also occur when commercial site owners are unwilling to pay for the treatment of knotweed on their land. By excavating and fly tipping the contaminated area, they promote the spread of knotweed root fragments and rhizomes which regrow after lying dormant for 20 years. Just last month, the invasive plant was said to be in "super growth" across the UK due to the dry and warmer conditions. Craig Godbehere, a site supervisor and certified surveyor in Japanese Knotweed at Thomson Environmental Consultants, said: 'Japanese knotweed has now become widespread in a range of habitats, particularly roadsides, riverbanks and derelict land, where it can cause serious problems by displacing native flora and with the potential to cause structural damage. 'It spreads rapidly in the wild by natural means or as a result of human activity.' How to remove Japanese knotweed Japanese knotweed, which was introduced to the UK as an ornamental plant in the nineteenth century, can only be removed with costly specialist treatment. It requires a multi-pronged approach, often involving herbicides and potentially excavation, depending on the extent of the infestation. Professional advice and support is required. Recommended reading: How do I report Japanese knotweed fly-tipping? If you suspect the act of fly-tipping of Japanese knotweed you should contact the Environmental Agency by email (enquiries@ or via their 24-hour freephone number (0800 80 70 60). It is a criminal offence to fly tip any material containing Japanese knotweed, and doing so is punishable with up to two years' imprisonment and an unlimited fine.
South Wales Argus
2 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
How to prevent and report Japanese knotweed amid fly-tipping
Fly-tipping is the illegal dumping of waste on public or private land – and its on the rise across the UK with more than one million incidents reported over the last two years. Now, experts are warning of another element that could add to the issue blighting areas. Fly-tipping often involves rubble, soil and plant cuttings which is then dumped and left to rot. If Japanese Knotweed is either fly-tipped or unknowingly part of dumped soil within the waste – then there's a problem. 'Fly-tipping and Japanese knotweed is a big problem in the UK,' reports. 'Because it leads to the spread of this invasive species. 'If plant material is present in the fly-tipped waste, it can quickly establish itself in the new location, creating a new infestation. 'Japanese knotweed is an extremely resilient plant. Furthermore, it can grow in a wide range of soil types and conditions. 'It spreads by producing new shoots from its wide root system, which can extend up to 7m from the main stem. 'This means that if Japanese knotweed is brought to a new area, it can quickly colonize the entire site, out-competing native vegetation and causing some environmental damage.' The fly-tipping of Japanese knotweed can also occur when commercial site owners are unwilling to pay for the treatment of knotweed on their land. By excavating and fly tipping the contaminated area, they promote the spread of knotweed root fragments and rhizomes which regrow after lying dormant for 20 years. Just last month, the invasive plant was said to be in "super growth" across the UK due to the dry and warmer conditions. Craig Godbehere, a site supervisor and certified surveyor in Japanese Knotweed at Thomson Environmental Consultants, said: 'Japanese knotweed has now become widespread in a range of habitats, particularly roadsides, riverbanks and derelict land, where it can cause serious problems by displacing native flora and with the potential to cause structural damage. 'It spreads rapidly in the wild by natural means or as a result of human activity.' How to remove Japanese knotweed Japanese knotweed, which was introduced to the UK as an ornamental plant in the nineteenth century, can only be removed with costly specialist treatment. It requires a multi-pronged approach, often involving herbicides and potentially excavation, depending on the extent of the infestation. Professional advice and support is required. Recommended reading: How do I report Japanese knotweed fly-tipping? If you suspect the act of fly-tipping of Japanese knotweed you should contact the Environmental Agency by email (enquiries@ or via their 24-hour freephone number (0800 80 70 60). It is a criminal offence to fly tip any material containing Japanese knotweed, and doing so is punishable with up to two years' imprisonment and an unlimited fine.
North Wales Chronicle
15 hours ago
- North Wales Chronicle
How to prevent and report Japanese knotweed amid fly-tipping
Fly-tipping is the illegal dumping of waste on public or private land – and its on the rise across the UK with more than one million incidents reported over the last two years. Now, experts are warning of another element that could add to the issue blighting areas. Fly-tipping often involves rubble, soil and plant cuttings which is then dumped and left to rot. If Japanese Knotweed is either fly-tipped or unknowingly part of dumped soil within the waste – then there's a problem. 'Fly-tipping and Japanese knotweed is a big problem in the UK,' reports. 'Because it leads to the spread of this invasive species. 'If plant material is present in the fly-tipped waste, it can quickly establish itself in the new location, creating a new infestation. 'Japanese knotweed is an extremely resilient plant. Furthermore, it can grow in a wide range of soil types and conditions. 'It spreads by producing new shoots from its wide root system, which can extend up to 7m from the main stem. 'This means that if Japanese knotweed is brought to a new area, it can quickly colonize the entire site, out-competing native vegetation and causing some environmental damage.' The fly-tipping of Japanese knotweed can also occur when commercial site owners are unwilling to pay for the treatment of knotweed on their land. By excavating and fly tipping the contaminated area, they promote the spread of knotweed root fragments and rhizomes which regrow after lying dormant for 20 years. Just last month, the invasive plant was said to be in "super growth" across the UK due to the dry and warmer conditions. Craig Godbehere, a site supervisor and certified surveyor in Japanese Knotweed at Thomson Environmental Consultants, said: 'Japanese knotweed has now become widespread in a range of habitats, particularly roadsides, riverbanks and derelict land, where it can cause serious problems by displacing native flora and with the potential to cause structural damage. 'It spreads rapidly in the wild by natural means or as a result of human activity.' Japanese knotweed, which was introduced to the UK as an ornamental plant in the nineteenth century, can only be removed with costly specialist treatment. It requires a multi-pronged approach, often involving herbicides and potentially excavation, depending on the extent of the infestation. Professional advice and support is required. Recommended reading: Japanese knotweed in 'super growth' across UK expert warns Is Himalayan balsam illegal in the UK? What a fine could be What to do if you see Himalayan balsam? Advice for gardeners If you suspect the act of fly-tipping of Japanese knotweed you should contact the Environmental Agency by email (enquiries@ or via their 24-hour freephone number (0800 80 70 60). It is a criminal offence to fly tip any material containing Japanese knotweed, and doing so is punishable with up to two years' imprisonment and an unlimited fine.
