British laws are not fit for social media age: Report on UK riots
LONDON — British laws restricting what police can say about criminal cases are 'not fit for the social media age,' a government committee said in a report released Monday in Britain that highlighted how unchecked misinformation stoked riots in the summer.
Violent disorder, fueled by the far right, affected several towns and cities for days after a teenager killed three girls on July 29 at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in Southport, England. In the hours after the stabbings, false claims that the attacker was a Muslim immigrant in the country illegally spread rapidly online.
In a report looking into the riots, a parliamentary committee said a lack of information from authorities after the attack 'created a vacuum where misinformation was able to grow.' The report blamed decades-old British laws to prevent jury bias that stopped police from correcting false claims.
When police announced the suspect was British-born, those false claims had reached millions.
The Home Affairs Committee, which brings together lawmakers from across the political spectrum, published its report after questioning police chiefs, government officials, and emergency workers during four months of hearings.
Axel Rudakubana, who was sentenced to life in prison for the attack, was born and raised in Britain by a Christian family from Rwanda. A judge later found there was no evidence he was driven by a single political or religious ideology, but was obsessed with violence.
Karen Bradley, the Conservative Party lawmaker who leads the Home Affairs Committee, said 'bad-faith actors' exploited the attack. But she added that a lack of accurate information allowed lies to proliferate.
'By failing to disclose information to the public,' she said, 'false claims filled the gap and flourished online, further undermining confidence in the police and public authorities.'
The committee's report pinpointed two false claims that were shared on social platform X. One, posted about two hours after the attack, claimed the suspect was a 'Muslim immigrant.' It received more than 3.8 million views.
The second, posted about five hours afterward, falsely suggested the suspect was an asylum-seeker named 'Ali-Al-Shakati' who was on an 'MI6 watch list.' The post received about 27 million views on X within a day. Merseyside Police, the local force investigating the attack, did not announce that the name was wrong until midday on July 30.
Hours later, the first riot broke out in Southport. The disorder continued in multiple towns and cities, and many protests targeted mosques and hotels housing asylum-seekers. Two buildings were set on fire while people were inside. More than 300 police officers were injured during the riots, and the response cost police an estimated 28 million pounds (about $36 million, the report said.
It added that Merseyside Police 'were put in a very difficult position' because officers were legally barred from disclosing the suspect's identity and received 'inconsistent advice' from prosecutors about whether they could confirm he was not Muslim.
The committee's report acknowledged that it was impossible to determine 'whether the disorder could have been prevented had more information been published.'
But it concluded that the lack of information after the stabbing 'created a vacuum where misinformation was able to grow, further undermining public confidence,' and that the law on contempt was not 'fit for the social media age.'
In Britain, a law bans the naming of suspects younger than 18 unless a judge makes an exception. Rudakubana was 17 at the time of the attack. Another law, designed to protect the right to a fair trial, bans the publication of information that could influence a jury. That rule, part of the 1981 Contempt of Court Act, is lifted once a defendant is found guilty or innocent.
Serena Kennedy, Merseyside's chief constable, told the committee that police disclosed on the evening of July 29 that the attacker had been born in Wales, but misinformation had already proliferated.
Kennedy said she had planned to make an announcement two days later, clarifying that Rudakubana was not Muslim and that his parents were Christian. After notifying the Crown Prosecution Service, the body that brings criminal charges in England, an official told her the information should not be made public, she said.
'This case highlights why we need to look at how we handle releases of information to the public, while also making sure that we do not impact on the criminal justice trial,' Kennedy said, adding that contempt laws did not 'take account of where we are in terms of the impact of social media.'
In a statement, the Crown Prosecution Service said that although an official expressed 'different views' on the disclosure of Rudakubana's religion, they did not tell police it would bias a jury.
The statement added, 'We support proposals for law reform which will make the application of contempt law clearer and simpler — especially when linked to heightened matters of general public interest such as public safety or national security.'
Since the Southport attack, the Law Commission of England and Wales has been conducting a review of the Contempt of Court Act.
This article originally appeared in
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Observer
15 hours ago
- Observer
Israel says it killed top Iran commander during attacks by both sides
JERUSALEM/ISTANBUL/WASHINGTON: I srael said on Saturday it had killed a veteran Iranian commander during attacks by both sides in the more than week-long air war, while Tehran said it would not negotiate over its nuclear programme while under threat. Saeed Izadi, who led the Palestine Corps of the Quds Force, the Iranian Revolutionary Guards' overseas arm, was killed in a strike on an apartment in the Iranian city of Qom, said Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz. Calling his killing a "major achievement for Israeli intelligence and the Air Force", Katz said in a statement that Izadi had financed and armed the Palestinian militant group Hamas ahead of its October 7, 2023, attack on Israel, which triggered the war in Gaza. The Revolutionary Guards said five of its members died in attacks on Khorramabad, according to Iranian media. They did not mention Izadi, who was on U.S. and British sanctions lists. Iranian media said earlier on Saturday that Israel had attacked a building in Qom, with initial reports of a 16-year-old killed and two people injured. At least 430 people have been killed and 3,500 injured in Iran since Israel began its attacks on June 13, Iranian state-run Nour News said, citing the health ministry. In Israel, 24 civilians have been killed by Iranian missile attacks, according to local authorities, in the worst conflict between the longtime enemies. Israel says Iran was on the verge of developing nuclear weapons, while Iran says its atomic programme is only for peaceful purposes. Israel is widely assumed to possess nuclear weapons, which it neither confirms nor denies. IRAN: NO TALKS DURING ATTACKS Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi said Israel's aggression, which he said had indications of U.S. involvement, should stop so Iran can "come back to diplomacy". "It is obvious that I can't go to negotiations with the U.S. when our people are under bombardments under the support of the U.S," he told reporters in Istanbul where he was attending a meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). On Friday in Geneva, Araqchi met European foreign ministers who were seeking a path back to diplomacy. President Donald Trump has said he would take up to two weeks to decide whether the United States should enter the conflict on Israel's side, enough time "to see whether or not people come to their senses", he said. He said on Friday he thought Iran would be able to have a nuclear weapon "within a matter of weeks, or certainly within a matter of months", adding: "We can't let that happen." Iran's Fars news agency said Israel had targeted the Isfahan nuclear facility, one of the nation's biggest, but there was no leakage of hazardous materials. Israel said it had launched a wave of attacks against missile storage and launch infrastructure sites. Ali Shamkhani, a close ally of Iran's supreme leader, said he had survived an Israeli attack. "It was my fate to stay with a wounded body, so I stay to continue to be the reason for the enemy's hostility," he said in a message carried by state media. INTERCEPTIONS OVER TEL AVIV Early on Saturday, the Israeli military warned of an incoming barrage from Iran, triggering air raid sirens across parts of central Israel and in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. Interceptions were visible in the sky over Tel Aviv, with explosions echoing as Israel's air defence systems responded. There were no reports of casualties. The Human Rights Activists News Agency, a U.S.-based rights organisation that tracks Iran, gave a higher death toll than Tehran, saying Israeli attacks have killed 639 people there. Those killed in Iran include the military's top echelon and nuclear scientists. Israel said it also killed a second commander of the Guards' overseas arm, whom it identified as Benham Shariyari, during an overnight strike. Nour News on Saturday named 15 air defence officers and soldiers it said had been killed in the conflict with Israel. Iran's health minister, Mohammadreza Zafarqandi, said Israel has attacked three hospitals during the conflict, killing two health workers and a child, and has targeted six ambulances, according to Fars. Asked about such reports, an Israeli military official said that only military targets were being struck, though there may have been collateral damage in some incidents. An Iranian missile hit a hospital in the southern Israeli city of Beersheba on Thursday. At the OIC meeting, where the Israel-Iran conflict topped the agenda, Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan said Israel's attacks on Iran right before a planned new round of nuclear talks with the U.S. aimed to sabotage negotiations and showed Israel did not want to resolve issues through diplomacy. Turkey, Russia and China have demanded immediate de-escalation. The Geneva talks produced little signs of progress, and Trump said he doubted negotiators would be able to secure a ceasefire because "Iran doesn't want to speak to Europe. They want to speak to us." Trump said he was unlikely to press Israel, its close ally, to scale back its air strikes to allow negotiations to continue in part because it was "winning". "But we're ready, willing and able, and we've been speaking to Iran, and we'll see what happens," he said. Israel has said it will not stop attacks until it dismantles Iran's nuclear programme and ballistic missile capabilities, which it views as an existential threat. A senior Iranian official told Reuters that Iran was ready to discuss limitations on uranium enrichment but that it would reject any proposal that barred it from enriching uranium completely, "especially now under Israel's strikes".
Observer
15 hours ago
- Observer
Erdogan to Iran: Talks only solution
ANKARA: Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan on Saturday told Iran's foreign minister that resuming Iranian-US talks on Tehran's nuclear programme was the only way to achieve a solution to their dispute and the conflict with Israel, the Turkish Presidency said. Erdogan met Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi on the sidelines of an Organisation of Islamic Cooperation meeting in Istanbul. In a statement, his office noted that Erdogan said Israel had to be stopped immediately. Erdogan said Turkey was ready to play a facilitator role to help resume the nuclear talks, adding "steps should be taken as soon as possible to open up diplomacy via technical and leaders-level talks between Iran and the US," his office added. Meanwhile, the United Nations' Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA will open an office in Ankara, President Erdogan said on Saturday, urging Muslim countries to give the agency more support after Israel banned it. Israel last year banned UNRWA, saying it had employed members of Palestinian Hamas who took part in the October 2023 attacks on Israel that triggered the Gaza war. Turkey has called Israel's assault on Gaza genocide and its move to ban UNRWA a violation of international law, particularly amid worsening humanitarian conditions in Gaza, which has been reduced to rubble with millions displaced. Addressing foreign ministers of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation in Istanbul, Erdogan said opening an Ankara UNRWA office would deepen Turkey's support for the agency. "We must not allow UNRWA, which plays an irreplaceable role in terms of taking care of Palestinian refugees, to be paralysed by Israel. We expect our organisation and each member state to provide financial and moral support to UNRWA to thwart Israel's games," Erdogan said. A Turkish diplomatic source said Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan and UNRWA chief Philippe Lazzarini were expected to sign an accord on the sidelines of the OIC meeting in Istanbul on establishing the office. Turkey has given UNRWA $10 million a year between 2023 and 2025. In 2024, it also transferred $2 million and sent another $3 million from its AFAD disaster management authority. Israel has handed responsibility for distributing much of the aid it lets into Gaza to a new US-backed group, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which operates three sites in areas guarded by Israeli troops. The UN has rejected the GHF operation saying its distribution work is inadequate, dangerous and violates humanitarian impartiality principles. Previously, aid to Gaza's 2.3 million residents had been distributed mainly by UN agencies such as UNRWA with thousands of staff at hundreds of sites across the enclave. - Reuters
Observer
17 hours ago
- Observer
IAEA warns of nuclear disaster
UNITED NATIONS: The Middle East risks a nuclear catastrophe if Israel strikes Iran's southern nuclear plant of Bushehr, the head of the UN atomic watchdog warned on Friday. Rafael Grossi, director of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), told the UN Security Council that he has not yet detected radiation resulting from Israel's week-long military campaign against Iran, including attacks on nuclear sites. But he said that a strike on Bushehr, the Middle East's first civilian nuclear reactor, would spell the most serious consequences as it contains thousands of kilogrammes of nuclear material. "Countries of the region have reached out directly to me over the past few hours to express their concerns and I want to make it absolutely and completely clear — in case of an attack on the Bushehr nuclear power plant, a direct hit would result in a very high release of radioactivity," Grossi said. Grossi warned of equally dire consequences even if Israel strikes the lines that supply electricity to Bushehr, saying such disabling of power could trigger a meltdown. In a worst case scenario, evacuations and orders to take shelter would need to be issued for areas within several hundred kilometres of Bushehr. The population would also need to take iodine and may see restrictions in food supply, Grossi said. Meanhile, European powers began talks with Iran in Geneva on Friday, talking of a window of opportunity for a diplomatic solution while the United States weighs whether to join its ally Israel's bombing campaign. Israel came under renewed Iranian missile fire after carrying out dozens of strikes overnight on targets, including a suspected nuclear research centre. Top European diplomats opened talks with Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi in Geneva, saying they wanted to offer a "diplomatic solution" to the war, now on its eighth day. Ahead of the talks, French President Emmanuel Macron said it was "essential to prioritise" a return to negotiations and said European powers would offer Iran a "diplomatic solution". The foreign ministers of Britain, France and Germany; and the European Union's top diplomat have urged de-escalation, with British Foreign Secretary David Lammy saying the next two weeks are "a window... to achieve a diplomatic solution". Speaking to the UN Human Rights Council earlier, Araghchi condemned Israel for launching its military action while Iran was still in nuclear talks with the United States. "We were attacked in the midst of an ongoing diplomatic process," the Iranian minister said. As the Security Council prepared to discuss the war later on Friday, UN chief Antonio Guterres appealed to all parties to "give peace a chance". Israel's military said on Friday it struck missile launchers in its latest attack on Iran. In Israel, sirens sounded in the afternoon after missiles were launched from Iran for the second time on Friday and rescuers reported two wounded, including a 16-year-old in serious condition. A military official said that "approximately 20 missiles were launched towards Israel" in the latest salvo. — AFP -
