The ‘sacrifice zone': villagers resist the EU's green push for lithium mining

Filipe Gomes had been craving fresh air and quiet routine when he and his partner quit the chaos of London's catering industry for the fog-misted hills of Covas do Barroso, the sleepy Portuguese farming village in which he was raised.
But his rural idyll has been disturbed by miners drilling boreholes as they push to dig four vast lithium mines right beside the village. The prospecting has sparked resistance from residents who fear the mines will foul the soil, drain the water and fill the air with the rumbling thunder of heavy trucks.
'They are destroying everything,' said Gomes, who runs the only cafe in the village with his partner. 'They are taking our peace.'
Covas do Barroso is among the first villages caught up in Europe's efforts to green its economy. As the continent weans itself off fossil fuels that poison the air and heat the planet, demand for lithium is surging, to build batteries that can run electric vehicles and balance renewable-heavy power grids.
Across Europe, people living near lithium deposits appear unconvinced that mines will bring good jobs and are unmoved by pleas to stop a bigger ecological threat. Attempts to push projects through in the face of local resistance have been met with cries of 'colonialism'.
In Serbia, broad swathes of society have taken to the streets over the past year to protest against a lithium mine planned for the Jadar valley. In France, a lithium mine planned beneath a kaolin quarry in Allier has alarmed activists and divided residents. In Covas do Barroso, in northern Portugal, people say their village – at the heart of a heritage farming region recognised by the United Nations – has been turned into a 'sacrifice zone'.
'You're talking about destroying an area that has been classified as a globally important agricultural heritage site, an example of sustainability, an area with a system of water management that is at least over 500 years old,' said Catarina Alves Scarrott, a member of the protest group Unidos em Defesa de Covas do Barroso (UDCB). 'You're going to sacrifice all of this for open-pit mines. And then, you start to ask: for what?'
The answer, for EU officials and the Portuguese government, is to obtain a soft white metal that is needed to stop burning fuels that make extreme weather dramatically worse – and do so without relying exclusively on foreign suppliers. Europe produces almost no lithium itself. More than three-quarters of the world's raw supply comes from just three countries: Australia, Chile and China. The latter dominates the refined supply of lithium too.
Anxious about energy security and scrambling to get more mines dug at home, the European Commission set a target last year of meeting 10% of demand for critical raw materials from domestic sources by 2030. In March, it listed the planned mine in Covas as one of 47 strategic mineral projects that would benefit from 'coordinated support' to become operational. The decision is being challenged by MiningWatch Portugal, ClientEarth and UDCB, which lodged a complaint with the commission in June.
Environmental concerns about waste and water are not the only factors that have left communities such as Covas wary of prospectors. Kwasi Ampofo, a metals and mining analyst at BloombergNEF, said the sales pitch had been made harder by the mining industry's historically poor reputation for safety and the lack of skilled domestic labour forces to profit from the work.
'It's going to be very hard for the EU to develop primary sources of lithium domestically,' he said. 'Not impossible, but very hard.'
In Covas, the long-running struggle between villagers and miners has intensified as political support for the project has grown. The Portuguese environment ministry granted the British mining company Savannah Resources a one-year 'administrative easement' in December that allows it to prospect in the land around Covas. The villagers filed an injunction that held up the process, but the ministry quickly allowed work to resume, arguing it was in the public interest.
People in the village, where a tattered banner declares 'no to the mine, yes to life', say they feel misled by the miners and betrayed by the government. They accuse the company of trespassing on land it does not own – much of which is held in common ownership – and downplaying the nature and scale of the project. But opinions in the surrounding Boticas region are mixed, with some hopeful the project will boost a neglected rural economy.
Savannah Resources declined to comment. It has previously told local media it is acting within the law and makes efforts to keep people informed. It projects the mine will produce enough lithium for half a million EV batteries a year and describes itself as 'enabling Europe's energy transition'.
But the continent-wide resistance to lithium mining reveals a snag that green groups and mining companies alike have been reluctant to acknowledge. While surveys find vast public support for stronger climate action – as much as 80-89%, according to a project by the Guardian and newsrooms around the world – the infrastructure for a carbon-free economy carries trade-offs that affected communities are often reluctant to bear.
Some residents of Covas, which is itself threatened by wildfires and droughts, say they recognise the tension, even if they consider the costs too great.
'Every village faced with a mine will say 'no, no, no', I get that,' said Jorge Esteves, a forestry worker. 'But what's different here is the proximity to our homes.'
Sign up to This is Europe
The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment
after newsletter promotion
Gomes, the cafe owner, said he would also have fought an oilwell if someone had tried to drill one in Covas.
'I don't agree with that either, though I have a car – but that's already happening,' he said. 'We do need to find a solution, but what we are doing now is not a solution.'
Studies have shown that a societal shift away from private cars – such as creating walkable cities with good public transport – would greatly limit the rise in demand for lithium, as would halting the surge in SUVs that need big batteries.
Analysts note there are also significant quantities of lithium in electronic waste such as phones and laptops that do not get recycled. For the lithium that does need to be extracted, harvesting it from brine does less damage to the environment than mining it from rocks.
But with 250m combustion engine cars on EU roads and next to no lithium produced at home, electrifying vehicle fleets without domestic sources of lithium would still mean extracting more abroad. Analysts fear this would largely take place in regions with weaker environment and human rights laws.
'It's not necessarily a dilemma with no exit, but it's a real one,' said Thea Riofrancos, a political scientist at Providence College who visited Covas and several others mining regions when writing a book about lithium extraction.
Mines were most likely to face resistance from people when developers failed to include them in the decision-making process, she added.
'It's not the environmental risks or the water risks on their own – if they're not combined with a sense of exclusion, then oftentimes those don't in and of themselves cause protests,' she said. 'It's the harm combined with the lack of voice to be able to say something about that harm.'
In the green hills of Covas, it is unclear whether a friendlier approach by Savannah and the authorities would have won people over or simply tempered their rage. But the anger at the process is palpable.
'The biggest shock initially was not even the impact of the mine,' said Alves Scarrott, who grew up in Covas and moved to London. 'It's the attack on democracy, and democratic processes, and the rights of the people that live there.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Times

3 hours ago

• Times

From music to politics: week in pictures, Scotland — June 7, 2025

Veterans gathered in Normandy on Friday to mark the 81st anniversary of Operation Overlord, a pivotal moment that led to the end of the Second World War. Yves Holbecq, with the Somme Battlefield Pipe Band, played the bagpipes on the beach at sunrise. The group aims to promote the music and history of Scottish soldiers during their time fighting in France. Veterans and onlookers gathered along the coastline to watch the flyovers, ceremonies, parades, reenactments and commemorations. More than 4,000 Allied troops were killed on D-Day in 1944. For more pictures from The Times, follow us on Instagram

The Guardian

4 hours ago

• The Guardian

10 of the best climbing plants for your garden, from honeysuckle to sweet pea

Within a week of moving house, three years ago, I was dreaming of climbing plants: anything that could clothe the uninspiring domesticity of my new garden's bare fences. The Guardian's journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more. Three summers on, I have a good sense of which climbers thrust ahead and which take their time to get established; which spread thinly or densely; which annuals offer up a temporary, seasonal backdrop; which climb perfectly well unaided; and which benefit from a supportive frame. Here are 10 climbers I've enjoyed growing, and how to nurture them. Often slower-growing yet enduringly structural, woody climbers produce hardened stems that lignify in place. They include plants such as ceanothus, trumpet vine, wisteria, akebia and rose, many of which require the sturdy support of wire or trellis. Undoubtedly, woody plants demand more patience, but they can prove low-maintenance in the long term, and are easy to train and shape. From £7.99 at J Parker's£11.69 at B&Q A house-warming gift, one of the first climbers added to my garden was the cream yellow-flowered honeysuckle, Lonicera periclymenum Graham Thomas. A woodlander at home in low light, it was planted in the north-facing shade of our house, where its dark, glaucous-leaved stems clamber over horizontal wires, producing phenomenal, night-scented midsummer blooms visited by moths. £9.99 at Jacksons NurseriesFrom £11.24 at Crocus This one will take time to get going, but few climbing plants are as rewarding as Hydrangea petiolaris. Endlessly elegant with clusters of refined white, the deciduous petiolaris uses aerial roots to attach itself to surfaces, though wires can offer a leg up while it establishes itself. Growing happily in semi-shade, and relatively unfussy of soil preference, the only difficulty with this heavily set hydrangea is keeping it from bushing out from the wall or fence. To avoid this, prune outwardly extended stems back by a few buds right after summer flowering. The Pilgrim £33 at Burford Madame Alfred Carrière £21.59 at Carbeth plants£23.38 at B&Q Unlike the often untamable 'rambling' rose, climbers can be heavily micromanaged – so you can tie them into artful loops or swirls, which can become obsessive, trust me. The temptation with roses might be to direct the stems upwards for quicker results, but the key for maximum surface coverage is to get strong, long stems tied down horizontally, incrementally in succession up a wall or fence: horizontals promote more flowers and further vertical growth, which will add density at a surprising pace. Planted in full sun, favourites from my garden include bold-blooming, butter yellow the Pilgrim and fellow David Austin cultivar Mme Alfred Carrière, whose pink-tinged buds open a blushed, strongly scented white. £19.95 at Gardening Express £24 at Ornamental Trees Surprisingly hardy given its somewhat precious appearance, this thickly foliaged kiwi relative bears curiously white and pink-tipped heart-shaped leaves. Once established in a sunny yet wind-sheltered spot and supported with wires, its woody stems will quickly advance and offer up a foliar blanket. While many climbing plants form a lasting framework, others can be cut down to regrow each year. These include some of the showiest varieties, whose well-established roots promote speedy, active growth each spring. From £3.99 at J Parker'sFrom £11.24 at Crocus By far the most vigorous shady climber in my – or indeed any – garden, virginia creeper (Parthenocissus quinquefolia) will attain heights by any means available. Often seen scrambling lamp-posts as it does woodland trees in its native Appalachia, this is one to keep in check, if necessary, by cutting back to a couple of feet each spring, once established. I got mine going on wires initially, however, it will self-adhere without fuss. Before shedding, its leaves blaze ochre through red across autumn. Sign up to The Filter Get the best shopping advice from the Filter team straight to your inbox. The Guardian's journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. after newsletter promotion Clematis tangutica From £7.99 at J Parker's£24.95 at Waitrose Garden Clematis Perle d'Azur £24.99 at Coolings Clematis are categorised into three key groups – those that flower in spring and in summer on the previous year's stems, and those that do all the work via the current season's growth. Cut down to 40-50cm from the ground in early spring and sending up energetic new shoots, this latter category includes popular viticella cultivars such as the blue-violet Perle d'Azur and the endearingly wild, lemony Clematis tangutica. £29.99 at Gardening Express Another vigorous contender, the grape relative Vitis coignetiae comes into its own in autumn, when its huge, lobed leaves become emboldened with dramatic hues of crimson, orange and plum. Grow on wires or up a tree in free-draining soil. In my view, annuals are often overlooked as fence-covering climbers. This might be due to their impermanence – here for one season and gone the next – but this can also be their strength. They are very quick growing, can act as temporary fillers while woodier climbers are getting going, and very often produce excellent flowers and attractive, sometimes edible seed pods. Although typically grown on 'teepees' or canes, by threading twigs (such as hazel or birch) through fence wires, they'll have lots to cling to, encouraging quick growth. 99p for 20 seeds at Thompson & MorganFrom £3.29 for 20 seeds at Crocus I'll never tire of growing sweet peas – their fragrance is alluring and their range considerable, from showy mauves and maroons to subtle whites and greens. Easily germinated on a windowsill indoors, they can be planted out in spring sunshine and, owing to grappling tendrils, scale a fence by midsummer. Among the copious options, I particularly like growing the profuse cultivars Cedric Morris (plum-purple) and Painted Lady (pink-white). From £3.69 for 15 seeds at Crocus£3.79 for 15 seeds at Waitrose Garden Commonly known as the cup-and-saucer vine and hailing from Mexico, where its large bell-shaped flowers in purple and cream are pollinated by bats, cobaea is a stunning single-season addition. Climbing its way up with anchoring tendrils, it blooms in late summer for an extended period. Performs best from early sowings, however, small plants can be bought about now, saving the trouble of home germination. £3.59 for 30 seeds at Thompson & Morgan£3.99 for 30 seeds at Amazon Despite the clear culinary associations, it is sometimes forgotten that runner beans were once cultivated as ornamentals, their vibrant scarlet, white and salmon flowers tumbling from twining vines. I say you can have both, and as anyone who has ever grown runner beans will attest, you can definitely have too many runners. Initially, deadhead the spent flowers before they can produce pods, and enjoy the rampant blooming before allowing them to fruit. Position in full sun if possible, and keep well watered. Matt Collins is a garden, nature and travel writer, and head gardener at the Garden Museum in London

The Sun

5 hours ago

• The Sun

I tested fans to keep you cool in a heatwave the winner costs 1p an hour to run

SUMMER is finally here with temperatures all over the UK set to hit 30 degrees this week, if not hotter. Whilst we all love the sun, it can make us feel a little sticky and sweaty especially when trying to sleep at night. A good fan is a must if you want to keep cool. Electric fans are a good option as they are cheaper, smaller, lighter and more energy efficient than air conditioning. But prices of fans vary and some don't do much to keep you cool at all, which can make buying one a challenge. Pedestal fans are a great option and tend to be more powerful than tower or table top fans. We've tested top brands including Meaco, Morphy Richards and Daewoo. Here's how they compare: Morphy Richards Air Flex 9inch Circulating Pedestal Fan £149.99, Speed settings: 8 It's expensive, but this has a DC motor which enables the fan to use less energy whilst still giving an outstanding performance. In fact, DC motors are meant to be up to 70% more efficient than air conditioning units. So, with this, you'll get maximum cooling without the worry of soaring electric bills. It's reasonably quiet and offers eight speed settings as well as advanced oscillation, which means it can direct airflow both horizontally and vertically. The fan made the entire room feel fresher, cooler and more comfortable - even when it hit 30 degrees outside. Performance: 5/5 Value: 4/5 Total score: 9/10 Status 16inch Oscillating Stand Fan £19.99, Speed settings: 3 For the price, I can't really grumble. It's not the most aesthetically pleasing, but given this cost less than £20, this was surprisingly powerful. It blew enough air around to keep a reasonably-sized room cool and it wasn't overly intrusive, though the noise measures around 40 decibels, which was higher than most. The oscillating function was very effective. The frame was a bit flimsy and it wouldn't withstand much - a child or a pet bumping into it could easily knock it over. Performance: 3/5 Value: 3/5 Total score: 6/10 Daewoo Pedestal Air Circulator Fan £79.99, Speed settings: 3 This fan was easy to put together and at 5kg, it's not too heavy, so it was easy to move from room to room too if you needed to. For nearly £80, it looked pretty flimsy and it only had three speed settings - most of the pricier ones had more to choose from. It does have a built-in oil diffuser, which did make the cool air smell lovely and created a lovely relaxing vibe around the room. It also had dual oscillation - up and down and side to side - which was effective at keeping the entire room airy and cool. Performance: 3/5 Value: 3/5 Total score: 6/10 Vonhaus Air Circulator Pedestal Fan - 16 inch £74.99, Speed settings: 12 This fan is hard to beat. Not only was it one of the best at cooling me down, it's a real design feature too. The innovative blade design is engineered to evenly push the air in a way that bounces off walls and surfaces. It's sleek and stylish yet easily cooled my kitchen diner, which is the largest room in my house. At night, a soft ambient backlight kicks in which was so calming and perfect for winding down. It has 12 speed settings to choose from and is energy efficient. Even though it's reasonably powerful at 35 watts, it only costs around 1p an hour to run. It also has an aromatherapy function which allows you to add a few drops of your own essential oils and the fan will spray cool air, that also smells amazing. Performance: 5/5 Value: 5/5 Total score: 10/10 Zanussi 16inch Pedestal Fan £24.99, Speed settings: 3 For less than £25, you are getting a reasonably powerful fan. However, the legs were not very sturdy. They are hollow plastic and lack weight making the entire product a bit top heavy. I worried about it being knocked over. It's not the quietest but at the same time, the noise wasn't overly intrusive. It also has 90-degree oscillation and it gives out a decent breeze even on the lowest setting. For a budget option, it's alright. Performance: 3/5 Value: 4/5 Total score: 7/10 Meaco Sefte 10inch Pedestal Air Circulator with Storage Bag £179.99, Speed settings: 12 A super low energy fan that costs from just 0.1p an hour to run. It was easy to assemble, sleek and so quiet you'll forget it's even there - hence it's name 'Sefte' which is an old English word meaning 'quite, gentle and undisturbed'. It was very quiet and unobtrusive yet has a powerful airflow of 1,140m3ph, allowing it to cool a room quickly. Previously, fans I've used in the bedroom keep me awake at night with their flashy displays but this has a night mode, which switches off the display light, mutes the buttons and gradually reduces the fan's speed overnight. The handy remote means you can control it without getting out of bed. I'm not surprised it's proving very popular this summer. The only downside is the price. At nearly £180, it's a pricey purchase. Performance: 5/5 Value: 3/5 Total score: 8/10 Duux Whisper Pedestal Fan £179.99, Speed settings: 26 This Duux fan has some incredible features including 26 speed settings, horizontal and vertical oscillation and a 12-hour programmable timer. The 26 settings certainly give you plenty of options to choose from but I loved the natural wind mode which is designed to replicate outdoor cooling by varying the fan speed. It also has a night mode where the speed will decrease to the lowest setting over 2.5 hours. The breeze this creates is pleasant and it lived up to its "whisper" name as it was one of the quietest I tested. Even on the highest settings, the noise was not overly intrusive. The touchscreen panel was a little difficult to operate, it was easier to use the remote control. It's very energy efficient, only costing around 0.8p to run on the highest speeds. Performance: 5/5 Value: 3/5 Total score: 8/10 Air Craft LUME Quiet 2-in-1 Pedestal Fan £119 Speed settings: 12 Say goodbye to hot stuffy days with this cutting-edge fan, which did a brilliant job of cooling larger rooms. It's quiet. In fact, the manufacturers claim it's never louder than an electric toothbrush. You pretty much forget it's there though on its highest it does go up to 60 decibels. What I loved most was that it came with an illuminated backlight which was very calming and could be used even with the fan switched off. It's easily controlled with a remote control and has front and back guards for fan blades. It has three modes - normal, natural and sleep. Natural runs at alternating speeds to simulate a natural breeze with occasional gusts and in sleep mode, it gradually reduces speed every 30 minutes until it reaches the lowest level. Perfect for hot, restless nights. Performance: 4/5 Value: 3/5 Total score: 7/10 EcoAir Equinox 16inch DC Low Power Consumption Fan £49.99, Speed settings: 12 This product is easy to assemble, efficient and economical. I thought it had an impressive power output for less than £50 and just like the Morphy Richards' fan, it has an energy efficient DC motor. It has 12 settings but it did get a bit noisy once you get to level five and I wouldn't have wanted to keep this on through the night. The fan isn't as sleek and stylish as others but it's reasonable value for money and once you've paid for it, it will cost pennies to run. It also has an energy saver function and will turn off automatically within 12 hours of the last adjustment on the control panel. Performance: 4/5 Value: 4/5 Total score: 8/10 How to keep cool in hot weather Most of us welcome hot weather, but when it's too hot, there are health risks. Here are three ways to keep cool according to the NHS... Keep out of the heat if you can. If you have to go outside, stay in the shade especially between 11am and 3pm, wear sunscreen, a hat and light clothes, and avoid exercise or activity that makes you hotter. Cool yourself down. Have cold food and drinks, avoid alcohol, caffeine and hot drinks, and have a cool shower or put cool water on your skin or clothes. Keep your living space cool. Close windows during the day and open them at night when the temperature outside has gone down. Electric fans can help if the temperature is below 35 degrees. Check the temperature of rooms, especially where people at higher risk live and sleep.