Exclusive: Russia's contradictory messaging on Pope Francis's death — and the strategy behind it
What should have been an apolitical moment—the death of Pope Francis on April 21—quickly turned into a battleground for Russia's information war.
As conspiracy theories and AI-generated content flooded social media worldwide, Russian state media launched a targeted campaign that both criticised the Pope's perceived progressivism and highlighted his alleged ties to Moscow, according analysis seen exclusively by The Independent.
While routinely monitoring Russian state media and analysing content posted on social media, disinformation advocacy group The American Sunlight Project identified inconsistent messaging across various state-run outlets in the hours and days following the death of Pope Francis.
This apparent contradiction wasn't an accident, according to the group. They claim it may reflect a broader geopolitical strategy: tailoring messaging to appeal to different audiences.
On social media, narratives portraying Francis as 'woke' targeted right-wing, MAGA-affiliated communities. While portrayals of a 'special relationship' between Russia and the Vatican aimed to resonate with the Global South, where large Catholic populations live and where Russia Today (RT) target their programming — such as the Philippines and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Endorsing anti-woke cardinals
Within a day of the Francis's death, RT, Russia's state-controlled news network, flooded X and Telegram with content accusing him of being 'woke' or a 'globalist.' According to The American Sunlight Project analysis, this content often included selectively edited or manipulated quotes from prominent critics of the Pope, framing them as having moral authority.
RT and Pravda, a Russian news outlet once tied to Soviet communism, also amplified the views of Alexander Dugin, a far-right 'philosopher' dubbed Vladimir Putin 's 'brain,' who criticised the Pope and endorsed the conservative Cardinal Robert Sarah.
Pravda also accused French President Emmanuel Macron of interfering with the papal election, despite a lack of evidence to support these claims.
Portraying a special Russia-Vatican relationship
In stark contrast to the negative narratives circulating on social media, TASS, a Russian state-owned news agency, consistently emphasised a close personal connection between Putin and Pope Francis, according to the analysis.
TASS reported that Putin 'held deep respect for Francis,' and highlighted their three in-person meetings and frequent phone calls, claiming that Putin called the Pope every March to mark his ascension to the papacy.
In his official condolence message, Putin described Francis as a 'remarkable man' and claimed he would 'forever keep warm memories' of him, also praising the Pope for fostering 'constructive cooperation' between Russia and the Vatican, something that The American Sunlight Project says falsely suggested an alignment of moral authority between the Kremlin and the Vatican.
Flip-flopping on Ukraine
Following Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Russian state media has consistently downplayed or ignored these tensions. Outlets like TASS and RT excluded Pope Francis's 2022 criticism of a Russian Orthodox bishop Patriarch Kirill—who supported the war—in which Francis warned him not to become 'Putin's altar boy.'
Instead, Russian coverage has tended to frame such disputes as minor, according to the analysis.
RT gave significant attention to Francis's February 2024 remark suggesting Ukraine might need 'the courage of the white flag' to pursue peace negotiations, a comment that sparked backlash in Ukraine.
Russia has a well-documented history of using disinformation campaigns to influence global events. Most notably, during the 2016 US presidential election, Russian interference in favour of Donald Trump was described as "sweeping and systematic" by a special counsel investigation, though it did not establish any conspiracy or coordination between the Trump campaign and the Russian government.
"The Kremlin and its entities have long played 'both sides' of various political issues, attempting to cause as much political division as possible in the democratic world' Benjamin Shultz from The American Sunlight Project told The Independent.
'We saw this in the US in 2016, for example, when they simultaneously created pro-Trump and pro-Clinton Facebook pages. It is, therefore, not surprising to see Russian state media simultaneously maligning and praising Pope Francis. To the Kremlin, his death is yet another opportunity to stir anger online and pit all of us against one another" he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
43 minutes ago
- The Independent
Marjorie Taylor Greene turns on Trump team over war with Iran: ‘A complete bait and switch'
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, one of President Donald Trump's biggest supporters, continued her criticisms of the administration's decision to strike Iran's nuclear facilities on Monday, saying Trump committed a 'bait and switch.' The Georgia Republican congresswoman posted on X her disappointment after having steadfastly supported Trump for year. 'I spent millions of my own money and TRAVELED THE ENTIRE COUNTRY campaigning for President Trump and his MAGA agenda and his promises,' she said. 'And Trump's MAGA agenda included these key promises: NO MORE FOREIGN WARS. NO MORE REGIME CHANGE. WORLD PEACE. And THIS is what the people voted for.' Greene, alongside Kentucky Rep. Thomas Massie, has become one of the most outspoken critics of Trump's policy towards Iran in the past month. She recently said she sided with Tucker Carlson over Trump in terms of supporting Israel as it conducted strikes against Iran. This came despite the fact Greene has been one of Trump's most steadfast supporters in Congress. 'Only 6 months in and we are back into foreign wars, regime change, and world war 3,' she said. 'It feels like a complete bait and switch to please the neocons, warmongers, military industrial complex contracts, and neocon tv personalities that MAGA hates and who were NEVER TRUMPERS!' In addition to the policy, Greene also criticized the changing narrative around the nature of the strikes. On Saturday evening, Trump said that Iran's nuclear facilities in Natanz, Esfahan and Fordow had been 'completely and totally obliterated.' But the next day, Gen. Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said that the mission inflicted ' extremely severe damage and destruction.' 'Let me be very clear,' Greene said. 'My children are 22, 25, and 27. I will literally fight ANYONE for their future. And their future and their entire generation's future MUST be free of America LAST foreign wars that provoke terrorists attacks on our homeland, military drafts, and NUCLEAR WAR.' Greene has previously criticized U.S. efforts to support Ukraine in its war against Russia. Last year, she joined Massie to file a motion to vacate House Speaker Mike Johnson, which ultimately failed after Democrats teamed up with Republicans to keep Johnson in the chair. 'I am FIGHTING for them to have a future where they can afford to buy a home, afford insurance, invest for retirement, enjoy life, retain their God given freedoms, afford to raise a family under their Christian faith, not be in debt, safety and security, AND NOT HAVE OUR OWN TAX PAYER FUNDED GOVERNMENT DESTROY IT ALL,' Greene said. But as of Monday, Greene has yet to join any resolution to rein in Trump's military powers. Still, she said she was independent of the president. 'Contrary to brainwashed Democrat boomers think and protest about, Trump is not a king, MAGA is not a cult, and I can and DO have my own opinion,' she said.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Trump slams Republican who opposed Iran strikes
President Donald Trump continued to express rage over Republican Rep. Thomas Massie's criticism of his decision to strike Iran. 'GET THIS 'BUM' OUT OF OFFICE, ASAP!!!' Trump posted to Truth Social Monday. In his fresh post, Trump had highlighted a Massie-themed tirade he had posted to his social media network the day before. 'Congressman Thomas Massie of Kentucky is not MAGA, even though he likes to say he is. Actually, MAGA doesn't want him, doesn't know him, and doesn't respect him,' the president had said. While other Congressional Republicans applauded Trump's Saturday action to send American bombers to take out a trio of Iranian nuclear sites, Fordow, Natanz, and Esfahan,' Massie was quick to complain. 'This is not Constitutional,' the Kentucky Republican wrote, sharing the Truth Social post that the president sent out Saturday night to announce the U.S. strikes. Ahead of Trump's military action, Massie was pushing other members of Congress to join a bipartisan effort to pass a resolution under the War Powers Act, in an effort for the legislative branch to have more control over any executive military action. 'This is not our war. But if it were, Congress must decide such matters according to our constitution,' he wrote last week. Massie also expressed that he was vehemently against Iranian regime change, which Trump floated in a Truth Social post on Sunday. 'This is not America First folks,' the Kentucky Republican said. 'Worth a listen. I will not vote for the United States to get dragged into another regime change war. In fact, I will actively oppose it,' he had previously said. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt massaged Trump's statement Monday morning during an appearance on Fox News Channel. 'The president believes the Iranian people can control their own destiny,' Leavitt said. 'And what he said last night makes complete sense. If the Iranian regime refuses to come to a peaceful diplomatic solution, which the president is still interested and engaging in, by the way, why shouldn't the Iranian people take away the power of this incredibly violent regime that has been suppressing them for decades?' Leavitt also took on Massie during the Fox & Friends segment. 'He should be a Democrat because he is more aligned with them than with the Republican Party,' she said. She also pushed back on Massie's claim that Trump's action was unconstitutional. 'The White House was not obligated to call anyone because the president was acting within his legal authority under Article 2 of the Constitution, as commander-in-chief of the president of the United States,' Leavitt argued. The day before, Trump had dedicated 328 words to telling off Massie. 'He's a simple minded "grandstander" who thinks it's good politics for Iran to have the highest level Nuclear weapon, while at the same time yelling 'DEATH TO AMERICA' at every chance they get,' Trump complained. 'Massie is weak, ineffective, and votes "NO" on virtually everything put before him (Rand Paul, Jr.), no matter how good something may be,' he also said. Trump called Massie 'disrespectful to our great military' and pointed out he didn't 'acknowledging their brilliance and bravery in yesterday's attack, which was a total and complete WIN.' 'MAGA should drop this pathetic LOSER, Tom Massie, like the plague!'
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Ukrainian forces attack oil depot in Russia's Rostov region
June 23 (Reuters) - Ukrainian forces on Monday attacked and set ablaze an oil depot in Russia's southern Rostov region used to supply Russian forces in occupied parts of Ukraine, the Ukrainian military said. The General Staff of Ukraine's Armed Forces said the military's special operations units, in conjunction with rocket forces and artillery, had hit the Atlas plant in the Rostov region, not far from Ukraine's eastern border. "A strike by our forces in the area of the target has been confirmed," the General Staff said in a statement on Telegram. "A fire has been observed. The results of the strike are being clarified." The statement said the facility was used to provide fuel and lubricants to Russian units operating in Russian-occupied parts of the Luhansk and Donetsk regions on the war's eastern front. Ukrainian forces have been engaged in cross-border attacks, including energy industry targets, which the General Staff said was aimed at curbing Russia's economic potential to proceed with the more than three-year-old war in Ukraine. Ukrainian military bloggers had earlier reported on the raid on the oil depot, saying fuel tanks had been engulfed in a blaze in the incident.
