Petros vs Petronas: Failure to comply with DGO constitutes ‘unconscionable conduct', court told
Fong (right) exits the courtroom after the proceedings.
KUCHING (July 11): The Distribution of Gas Ordinance (DGO) 2016 is a written law passed by the Sarawak Legislature and is therefore a written law in force in Malaysia, the High Court here was told today.
State Legal Counsel Dato Sri JC Fong said Petroliam Nasional Berhad's (Petronas) failure to comply with the DGO and continuing to supply gas without a licence issued under the DGO, and then preventing other licensed gas suppliers or producers from selling gas to Petroleum Sarawak Berhad (Petros) as the state's gas aggregator, constitutes 'unconscionable conduct' on the part of national oil firm.
In his submission to the court in the lawsuit brought by Petros against Petronas, Fong, appearing for the Sarawak government, said Petros is invoking the court's inherent jurisdiction to declare that the demand by Petronas on a bank guarantee issued by Maybank Islamic Berhad is 'unconscionable, unlawful, null and void'.
He said all parties, including the federal and Sarawak governments, have agreed that 'unconscionability' is a ground to restrain a beneficiary of a bank guarantee or performance bond from making a call on a bank guarantee or performance bond.
'In this case, the underlying contract is the Sarawak Gas Sales Agreement (SGSA) dated Dec 30, 2019.
'The bank guarantee was issued pursuant to this underlying contract to secure payment for gas supplied by Petronas to Petros. Petronas is the beneficiary of the bank guarantee.
'Petronas did not sign the SGSA because the PDA (Petroleum Development Act) 1974 guarantees the role of Petronas nationwide,' said Fong.
He said Petronas entered into the SGSA because it had sold and transferred its business of supplying gas to customers in Bintulu and Miri to Petros, and is selling gas to Petros to enable the state-owned company to fulfil its obligations to its customers who were previously customers of Petronas.
'This SGSA has nothing to do with the PDA or the business of Petronas under the PDA, which had been sold and transferred to Petros. There is nothing in the SGSA which even suggests that Petronas entered into this SGSA in pursuance of the PDA.
'It was purely a commercial contract based on purely commercial consideration, but the mode of performance thereof must not contravene any written law in force in Malaysia.'
Fong said for Petronas to consciously disobey, disregard, and disrespect the DGO amounts to a contravention of an important constitutional safeguard and an attempt to undermine the Sarawak government's executive authority under Article 80(2) of the Federal Constitution.
'This itself is clearly unconscionable conduct which this honourable court should not condone at all.
'Consequently, the calling upon the bank guarantee by Petronas, in these circumstances to obtain payment from Petros for gas supplied in contravention of the DGO and also in breach of Article 24.2 of the SGSA, is clearly unconscionable and unlawful,' he said.
Article 24.2 of the SGSA stipulates that 'Nothing in this Agreement shall entitle the Parties (i.e. Petronas and Petros) to exercise the rights, privileges and powers conferred on it in a manner which would contravene any written law for the time being in force in Malaysia.'
Petros is seeking a court order for the return of RM7.95 million paid to Petronas under the bank guarantee.
The conflict began in October 2024 when Petronas called on the bank guarantee in response to a RM28.1 million demand from Petros related to gas supply.
Petros then initiated legal proceedings against Petronas and sought an injunction to stop the disbursement of the funds.
However, the injunction request became academic after Maybank Islamic Berhad released the payment to Petronas.
Petronas was represented by counsels Datuk Dr Cyrus Das and Khoo Guan Huat, while Petros was represented by counsels Tan Sri Cecil Abraham, Sim Hui Chuang and Lim Lip Tze.
The proceeding was heard before Judicial Commissioner Datuk Faridz Gohim Abdullah, who fixed Aug 25 and 26 for the next hearing. DGO Distribution of Gas Ordinance JC Fong Petronas Petros
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Sarawak holds potential as Malaysia, Asean energy hub, says PM Anwar
Sarawak Yang di-Pertua Negeri Tun Dr Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar and his wife Toh Puan Fauziah Mohd Sanusi, along with Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim and Sarawak Premier Tan Sri Abang Johari Openg, being served a welcome drink called "apat paman" upon arriving at the state Gawai dinner in Kuching. – ZULAZHAR SHEBLEE / The Star KUCHING: Sarawak has the potential to become the main energy hub for Malaysia and Asean, says Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. He said Sarawak could play a key role in the Asean Power Grid initiative with its rich energy resources, including hydropower, gas and hydrogen. "The Asean Power Grid will enable energy interconnections between member states "Sarawak's energy potential can be expanded to Sabah, Kalimantan and southern Philippines," he said at the state Gawai dinner here on Sunday (June 22) night. Anwar said he would bring up this matter in an informal meeting with Indonesian president Prabowo Subianto next Friday (June 27). "I have informed (Sarawak Premier Tan Sri) Abang Johari (Openg) that I will discuss an Asean Power Grid based in Sarawak for the benefit of both countries," he said. Sarawak Yang di-Pertua Negeri Tun Dr Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar and his wife Toh Puan Fauziah Mohd Sanusi were the guests of honour at the dinner. Also present were Sarawak Premier Tan Sri Abang Johari Openg, Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, Selangor Mentri Besar Datuk Seri Amirudin Shari and federal and state dignitaries. The Prime Minister also said the good relations between the Federal and Sarawak governments formed a strong basis for resolving issues. In this respect, he said PETRONAS and state-owned Petroleum Sarawak Bhd (Petros) would move forward on the issue of gas distribution in the interests of both the nation and the state. "The oil and gas industry needs PETRONAS and Sarawak needs Petros. We need both to work together for Sarawak and the nation," he said. Earlier, Abang Johari said Sarawak was ready to contribute to the Asean Power Grid. "We hope the vision of the Asean Power Grid will be realised as a catalyst for economic growth in the region," he said.
Borneo Post
17 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Petronas distributes 440 food baskets to rural families in Bintulu for Gawai
Thadeus (centre) presents a basket of essential goods to a beneficiary, as Shalby (fourth left) and others look on. BINTULU (June 22): As part of its commitment to community welfare, Petroliam Nasional Berhad (Petronas) is distributing 440 food aid baskets to selected families in the interior areas of Sebauh, Tinjar and Baram, in conjunction with this year's Gawai celebration. Sebauh District officer Thadeus Ling Bartholomew Allu emphasised that the initiative reflects more than just the act of giving — it represents a strategic partnership between the private sector and government agencies to strengthen the region's social support. 'This effort goes beyond physical assistance. It brings hope and assurance to our rural communities that they are not forgotten and remain a key focus of our development efforts,' he said at the 'Segulai Sejalai Memacu Kehidupan Gawai' programme held at Rumah Nikolie Nelly, Sungai Serakit, along the Bintulu-Sebauh road yesterday. The aid is expected to benefit over 400 families across the three districts — a meaningful undertaking that exemplifies shared responsibility and one that should be emulated. Describing Sebauh as a district rich in culture, strong family values, and a deep spirit of mutual support, Thadeus emphasised that the presence of a major corporation like Petronas is seen not just as an investor, but as a genuine development partner. 'At the local government level, we deeply value this kind of commitment to community-building,' he added. Thadeus also expressed confidence that such efforts would pave the way for longer-term initiatives, particularly in education, health, and economic opportunities that would benefit future generations. Earlier, Petronas Sarawak senior general manager Shalby Reduan reaffirmed the company's commitment to community empowerment, encompassing education, well-being, socio-economic development, and environmental stewardship. 'Through our social impact programmes under such initiative, we strive to ensure that every form of assistance provided creates lasting and meaningful impact.' He added that this Gawai season, the programme continues as an annual initiative dedicated to community well-being, aimed at alleviating the burden of those in need and sharing the joy of the festive season. Bintulu Gawai lead Petronas welfare aid
New Straits Times
2 days ago
- New Straits Times
A-GC denies flawed prosecution in Najib's SRC case, cites evidence constraints
KUALA LUMPUR: The Attorney-General's Chambers (A-GC) has refuted claims that the prosecution in the money laundering case involving funds from SRC International Sdn Bhd (SRC) was flawed. In a statement, the A-GC said it has consistently upheld the highest standards and quality in discharging its prosecutorial duties, in line with public expectations. "The A-GC remains committed to upholding the rule of law and will continue to carry out its responsibilities under the Federal Constitution with integrity, fairness and respect for judicial processes," the statement read. The statement followed the High Court's decision to grant a discharge not amounting to an acquittal (DNAA) to former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak over three money laundering charges involving RM27 million linked to SRC. High Court Judge K. Muniandy issued the ruling today after the prosecution failed to furnish the defence with hundreds of documents related to the trial, despite the charges being filed as early as 2019. Addressing the delay in trial proceedings, the A-GC said the case, first registered at the High Court in February 2019, was postponed on five occasions due to various factors, including the Covid-19 pandemic, defence requests and applications by the prosecution itself. The A-GC said that proceedings for the 1Malaysia Development Bhd (1MDB) trial had commenced while the first SRC case was still ongoing at the High Court, Court of Appeal and Federal Court levels. This overlap led to delays in the second SRC trial, as both cases involved the use of key material documents required for the prosecution, it said. Following this, it said, there was no choice but to wait until the documents were made available. "Both cases involved the use of certain material documents that were also intended to be used in the second SRC trial. "As the documents in question are material to the second SRC trial, the prosecution had no choice but to wait until those documents became available, which is after the 1MDB trial proceedings have concluded. "It must be emphasised that the material documents are already available but are currently being used as evidence in the ongoing 1MDB trial," it said. The A-GC also said the prosecution had requested additional time to compile all the material documents to present them as evidence in the second SRC trial.
