Charges dropped against Massachusetts college students over alleged 'catch a predator' plot
Hear this story
Kidnapping and conspiracy charges against five Assumption University students accused of being part of a plan to "catch a predator' in October have been dropped.
Charges were dropped against Kelsy Brainard, 18; Kevin Carroll, 18; Easton Randall, 19; Joaquin Smith, 18; and Isabella Trudeau, 18, according to court documents obtained by USA TODAY and the Worcester County District Attorney.
'The kidnapping and conspiracy charges against all five of these defendants were dismissed by Worcester Central District Court Judge Michael Allard-Madaus,' Lindsay Corcoran, spokesperson for Worcester County District Attorney Joseph D. Early Jr.'s office, told USA TODAY Thursday morning in a statement.
Corcoran said the court cannot provide details on the other defendant, a juvenile.
Kelsy Brainard, Kevin Carroll still facing criminal charges
Brainard is still facing a charge of intimidating a witness, police, or court official, Corcoran said, adding that Carroll is still facing a charge of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon.
Christopher S. Todd, a lawyer representing Brainard, said Thursday morning that the team is 'very pleased that the court applied the law properly in this case.'
'We look forward to resolving this matter, and hopefully everybody can move on with their lives,' he said.
Robert J. Iacovelli, who is representing Trudeau, said Thursday that the case was simply about 'the judge applying the law and recognizing there just simply wasn't enough there.'
Lawyers for Carroll, Randall, and Smith did not immediately respond to USA TODAY's requests for comment Thursday morning.
Kelsy Brainard said 'a creepy guy came to campus' to meet a 17-year-old girl
The man campus police said was falsely labeled a sexual predator is a 22-year-old U.S. Army member who was visiting from North Carolina, reported the Worcester Telegram & Gazette, part of the USA TODAY network.
The students involved were accused of assaulting the man on the Assumption University campus on Oct. 1, university police wrote in court documents. The man allegedly met a student on the dating app Tinder.
Investigators spoke to Brainard, who told them "a creepy guy came to campus looking to meet an underage girl' who he believed was 17, the documents show. She said she texted Randall to come and help her, and Randall chased the man off campus.
Brainard later told investigators her profile listed her age as 18, and when confronted about her story having discrepancies, she "acknowledged that to be true," documents show.
Tinder date said a group of 25 or more ambushed him on campus
According to court documents, the man called Worcester police for help after the incident. When officers met with him, he said he was in the area to attend his grandmother's funeral and wanted to "be around people that were happy."
He said he had been communicating with Brainard on Tinder and they planned to "try and hook up." When she invited him to come and meet her at Alumni Hall, he said she let him inside the building. Suddenly, a group of 25 or more people showed up and started saying he 'liked having sex with 17-year-old girls,' court documents show.
The man said he got scared when group members began holding him back and wouldn't let him leave, but once he broke free, he was attacked, according to the court documents.
He said he eventually made it back to his car where the group punched him in the back of the head, slammed his car door on his head and kicked his vehicle, the documents say.
He called the police when he was able to drive away, and according to the court documents, Carroll later confessed that he slammed the man's head in the car door.
Surveillance footage shows incident on campus
Investigators viewed surveillance footage starting just after 10:30 p.m. that night. The footage showed Brainard leading the man into the building and down a set of stairs to the lounge area, court documents read.
Eventually, the footage showed the man running up the stairs as a group of people chased him with their phones out. The group later re-entered the frame laughing and high-fiving each other, court documents show. Investigators also found footage circulating online of first-hand recordings of the incident, court documents say.
According to police who reviewed the Tinder messages between the man and Brainard, nothing indicated that he was looking to meet minors, and the profile he interacted with listed the individual's age as 18.
Investigators said the ordeal was inspired by a "catching a predator" trend on social media, particularly TikTok, where content creators chat with adults online and pretend to be minors. When the adults show up to meet, the content creators confront them about their conversations and attempts to meet.
The trend is similar to the format of the Dateline NBC show 'To Catch a Predator,' hosted by Chris Hansen, which originally ran from 2004 to 2007.
Group member used the term 'underage' and things got out of hand: Defendant
In the Assumption University case, investigators spoke to Randall, who said he worked with Brainard, Trudeau, Smith, Carroll, and an unnamed boy from start to finish on the "to catch a predator" plot.
It all began when Brainard began chatting with the man on Tinder, Randall said, adding that it was similar to the trend where people "catch a predator and either call police or kick their (expletive)."
Randall said they already had a group chat for Alumni Hall residents on the third floor and eventually used that chat to talk about the man on Tinder.
A group chat member named 'Smitty' mentioned the term "underage,' causing a "mass of people' to gather. Randall also admitted texting "you have to come down here," and "we're catching a predator," court documents show.
Assumption University said in a statement to USA TODAY on Thursday that what the students are accused of doing does not represent the school.
'The Assumption University Police Department … fulfilled its duty as an accredited law enforcement agency by filing charges describing the facts of the incident,' the university said.
Contributing: Brad Petrishen, Worcester Telegram & Gazette
Saleen Martin is a reporter on USA TODAY's NOW team. She is from Norfolk, Virginia – the 757. Email her at sdmartin@usatoday.com.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
20 hours ago
- USA Today
Colorado man arrested again in wife's murder, three years after charges dropped
A Colorado man was arrested again in connection with the murder of his wife years after previous charges were dropped, according to authorities. A grand jury indicted Barry Morphew on a charge of first-degree murder on Wednesday, June 18. He was taken into custody in Arizona on Friday, June 20, according to the Chaffee County Sheriff's Office. In 2021, Morphew was charged with first-degree murder and tampering with physical evidence after his wife Suzanne went missing on Mother's Day 2020. Those charges were later dropped in April 2022 before his trial date and a year before her remains were found. The charges were dropped without prejudice, leaving room for prosecutors to charge him in the future with new evidence. "Federal, State and local law enforcement have never stopped working toward justice for Suzanne," Twelfth Judicial District Attorney Anne Kelly said in a news release. Officials plan to extradite Morphew, whose bail price has been set at $3 million, to the San Luis Valley in Colorado where he will face charges. It's unclear why he was in Arizona at the time of the Friday arrest. "Yet again, the government allows their predetermined conclusion to lead their search for evidence," Morphew's attorney David Beller told USA TODAY in a statement. "Barry maintains his innocence. The case has not changed and the outcome will not, either." Suzanne's remains found after three year search Suzanne Morphew, 49, was last seen on Mother's Day, May 10, 2020 in Maysville, Colorado after leaving her home for a bike ride. Neighbors reported the mother of two missing that same day, according to the indictment, which states her husband was the last person to see her alive. Barry Morphew was the only other occupant in their home, as their daughter was out of state on a road trip, the indictment states. Suzanne's mountain bike was found near the home later that evening and her helmet was found in a different spot nearby a few days later. A search for Suzanne went on for over three years until Sept. 22, 2023, when human remains were found in a shallow clandestine grave in Saguache just few hundred feet down a dirt road, the indictment states. The majority of her bones were found. A 2024 autopsy found drugs typically used to tranquilize animals in her system. It was determined she died by homicide. The indictment also cites a deleted text chain with Suzanne found on Morphew's phone during a forensic download. A single text message from Suzanne on May 6, 2020 read: "I'm done. I could care less what you're up to and have been for years. We just need to figure this out civilly." Morphew has repeatedly denied involvement The initial charges against Morphew were dropped after a judge barred prosecutors from calling most of their key witnesses, USA TODAY previously reported. The judge said prosecutors failed to properly overturn evidence including DNA found in Suzanne's SUV from an unknown male linked to other sexual assault cases in different states, raising the possibility of another suspect. Morphew has heavily denied having anything to do with her disappearance. In May 2023, he filed a $15 million lawsuit against prosecutors and investigators, accusing them of violating his constitutional rights. That same month, he spoke with ABC News, saying it was beyond hurtful to see his reputation and integrity battered by the accusations. He also insisted that prosecutors and investigators are too ignorant to look at other suspects and knew it was a possibility for him to be charged again one day. "They're wrong. They got tunnel vision. They looked at one person and they got too much pride to say they're wrong and look somewhere else," he told ABC News. "I was innocent the first time they arrested me so I'm sure it's possible (to be arrested again) but I don't have anything to worry about. I've done nothing wrong." Contributing: Vanessa Arredondo and Elinor Aspegren, USA TODAY
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
Grand jury indicts accused leader of cultlike 'Zizian' group
A federal grand jury in Maryland has indicted an Alaska person linked to a series of nationwide deaths and violence in Vermont and California via the cultlike "Zizian" group they are accused of inspiring. Prosectors say the grand jury indicted Jack Amadeus LaSota, 34, on charges they possessed a .50-caliber rifle and several handguns while being a fugitive. Court records and interviews with people who know the group say LaSota was the intellectual leader of the largely online movement interested in artificial intelligence. Some of whose members lived full time in box trucks in several states. Lasota has also gone by the names Andrea Phelps, Ann Grimes, Anne Grimes, Canaris, Julia LaSota and "Ziz," prosecutors said. LaSota was assigned male at birth but uses female pronouns; federal and state court records refer to LaSota as a man. "LaSota was knowingly a fugitive from justice and therefore was not permitted by law to possess a firearm or ammunition," the U.S. Attorney's office in Maryland said in a statement. LaSota faces up to a 15-year prison sentence. According to court records and a USA TODAY investigation, the Zizian group is connected to at least six deaths, including the homicide of a U.S. Border Patrol agent in Vermont in January. Court records also indicate LaSota may have faked their own death in 2022. Many of the group members are vegan, and either have degrees in computer science or have studied related fields, according to court records. Some members of the group are transgender, or have rejected binary sexuality, and are interested in the role artificial intelligence may play in creating a new society, according to interviews and court records. In February, Maryland police arrested LaSota along with two other people, Michelle Zajko, 32, and Daniel Blank, 26, in a rural area after the property owner called police to report the black-clad suspects on his land. Blank is a suspect in the late 2022 shooting deaths of Zajko's parents in Pennsylvania, and authorities say LaSota and Zajko are being investigated in connection with other multiple deaths. In January 2023, Zajko was questioned by Pennsylvania State Police about the deaths of her parents, but disappeared with LaSota, leaving behind her car and $40,000 in cash, according to court records. Authorities said Zajko may have also supplied the guns used in the January shootout that ended with the death of Border Patrol agent David Maland and a German national, Ophelia Bauckholt. Arrested in that shooting was Teresa Youngblut, who is jailed and faces charges of using a deadly weapon. Zajko is also facing federal firearms charges. And a man that Youngblut last year got a license to marry, Max Snyder, is jailed in California on charges that he ambushed and fatally stabbed a landlord who had at one time allowed LaSota and other group members to park their trucks on his property. That landlord killed another member of the group in self defense after they attacked him over a planned eviction, according to court records.
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
DHS, Secretary Kristi Noem sued over actions against journalists in LA
The lawsuit contends federal officers used unconstitutional actions against journalists covering protests in Los Angeles. Several journalism and civil rights organizations sued the Department of Homeland Security and Secretary Kristi Noem over what they described as the unconstitutional actions of federal officers deployed to Los Angeles amid protests over immigration raids in the city. The American Civil Liberties Union is among the legal counsel representing the plaintiffs in the case, which include the Los Angeles Press Club and the NewsGuild-Communications Workers of America. The lawsuit accuses DHS officers of 'unnecessarily and indiscriminately' using less-lethal munitions against reporters, protesters and legal observers at the demonstrations. 'Suppressing the rights of the free press and protesters is the calling card of cowardly dictators and threatens to destroy our nation,' the lawsuit said. NewsGuild-CWA President Jon Schleuss referred to federal officers' actions as an 'assault on the rights of all Americans' in a June 19 news release. 'This state-sanctioned violence against journalists is meant to stop the public from learning the truth,' he said. 'We're proud to join this fight to demand accountability and end impunity for DHS officers who attack the workers who power our free press.' The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California in Los Angeles. USA TODAY reached out to DHS for comment. The lawsuit came a week after press freedom and civil rights groups sent a letter to Noem that warned the department of potential First Amendment violations in the city. The Los Angeles Press Club is also part of a June 16 lawsuit against the city of Los Angeles and its police department, as well as one filed June 18 against Los Angeles County and its sheriff's department over similar issues. Protests over immigration raids in the city started on June 6 and grew over the following days, prompting President Donald Trump to order both National Guard troops and Marines to the city. California Gov. Gavin Newsom referred to such moves as a 'blatant abuse of power,' and the state sued the administration over Trump's orders. BrieAnna Frank is a First Amendment Reporting Fellow at USA TODAY. Reach her at bjfrank@ USA TODAY's coverage of First Amendment issues is funded through a collaboration between the Freedom Forum and Journalism Funding Partners. Funders do not provide editorial input.
