Evan Fitzgerald case shows why gardaí cannot operate on a ‘trust us' basis
The truism that policing exists in a state of perpetual controversy punctuated by crises has been brought into sharp focus recently. Controversies involving
An Garda Síochána
and the cases of
Tina Satchwell
(Dingivan),
Michael Gaine
and now Evan Fitzgerald are, to put it mildly, concerning.
It must irritate conscientious and professional gardaí to listen to those of us who do not have to contend with the varied and enormous challenges of policing as we comment with the benefit of hindsight or opine from a position of academic expertise.
But the unique nature of policing and the exceptional powers vested in sworn police officers require that a policing service is accountable whenever there is a question mark over its competence. Effective oversight and accountability are not an impediment to policing. These are, indeed, a necessary condition if it is to be done effectively.
It is simply untenable to seek to operate on a 'trust us' basis. Trust must be earned and not presumed and it must never be taken for granted even if surveys show a high degree of public trust in policing.
READ MORE
To operate as an accountable policing service, Garda management must be comfortable with the duty to provide evidence-based justification in various settings where transparency is required.
To be fair, the current Garda Commissioner has been diligent in his engagement with the
Policing Authority
(now the PCSA) and Oireachtas committees. His successor will also have to engage, perhaps less visibly, with the newly established Board of An Garda Síochána.
The media play a crucial role in ensuring robust accountability. But an appropriate balance is not always maintained between crime stories that are clearly Garda-sourced and investigative journalism that probes issues of competence or corruption in relation to policing.
Garda representative bodies will squander whatever political capital they have if they do not engage in a more constructive manner with the new commissioner
Both can coexist, but there is self-evidently a prevalence of what is called 'copaganda' in much coverage of crime and criminal justice matters. Influencing or shaping media coverage of crime is no proxy for accountability. Recently acknowledged improvements in the reliability and credibility of Garda crime data should be the primary basis upon which An Garda Síochána presents in the public square, not manipulative or salacious briefings. However, it is unlikely that these can ever be eliminated as a news currency of value.
The Tina Satchwell (Dingivan) case is now being reviewed at the request of the Garda Commissioner with a report to be presented in due course to the Policing and Community Safety Authority and the Minister for Justice. The Michael Gaine murder investigation, which is live, is being peer-reviewed in a routine manner.
The Evan Fitzgerald case – in which, thankfully, a higher victim count was avoided –
raises a number of disturbing questions
.
On what basis was the young man from Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, assessed as sufficiently low risk for gardaí to consent to bail being granted? Why did it take the public
intervention of the judge
involved to correct a media report that gardaí had objected to bail being granted?
Why did it take until the Garda Commissioner appeared before an Oireachtas committee for the story to emerge that non-functioning
ammunition had been supplied to Fitzgerald by An Garda Síochána
in a controlled delivery as part of an undercover operation?
On what basis did
Fiosrú
(formerly
Gsoc
) reach the conclusion, in uncharacteristically quick time, that no further investigation was required?
The
recruitment of a new Garda Commissioner
presents an opportunity, within the framework of new structures that should have been in place much sooner, to address problems of policing culture that have frustrated the efforts of the current commissioner to drive a reform agenda. The role of the new Garda Board will be of vital importance in this connection, and if there are tensions between Garda management and the board, that could actually be a positive sign.
Garda representative bodies will squander whatever political capital they may have if they do not engage in a more constructive manner with the new commissioner. Maintaining an oppositional stance to reforms that have been implemented and are unlikely to be reversed is futile. Personalising disagreements with garda management is a waste of energy.
In the period from 2017-2018 when the
Commission on the Future of Policing
consulted with rank-and-file members of An Garda Síochána and middle management, it was crystal clear that there was a keen appetite for reform within the policing service. Many ideas put forward, especially by younger gardaí, were excellent and were adopted enthusiastically by the commission.
The time lost in implementing the recommendations of the commission is regrettable, but many of the reforms implemented – which are probably not as transformational as sometimes claimed – provide a solid basis upon which to proceed with a degree of confidence.
The new commissioner will start with an unenviable list of ongoing controversies. Their job is to ensure that these do not become crises. This is a slightly better context than the one in which the current commissioner commenced his tenure, which was, most definitely, a context of deep crisis.
Donncha O'Connell is an established professor of law in University of Galway. He was a member of the Commission on the Future of Policing in Ireland
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Body recovered at Laytown beach, Meath after reports of swimmer in difficulty
A body has been recovered at Laytown beach, Co Meath after rescue services responded to reports of a swimmer in difficulty. The emergency services were alerted at 6.15pm to a teenage boy in difficulty on Friday evening. The Rescue 116 helicopter and Drogheda Coast Guard immediately responded to the incident. A body was recovered from the water at approximately 9.40pm on Friday night by the coastguard READ MORE and was taken to Navan Hospital where a post mortem will take place. In a separate incident, another teenager was airlifted to hospital with suspected multiple fractures and lacerations after falling 6m on to some rocks in Howth on Friday afternoon. The teenager had to be winched by helicopter from the White Water Brook, a remote beach below cliffs on the eastern side of the Howth peninsula. The RNLI lifeboat called out the Rescue 116 helicopter because of the swiftly rising tide. Rescue 116 deployed its winchman, who assessed the teenager's injuries, and co-ordinated with RNLI and Coast Guard crews to secure him in a rescue harness. The helicopter then repositioned over the scene and winched the casualty and winchman to safety. A teenager who went to help him made his way to the other end of the beach to be picked up. He was suffering from hypothermia. He was then transferred to the all-weather lifeboat and taken back to Howth Lifeboat Station, where he was transferred into the care of an ambulance crew. Both teenagers were taken to Beaumont Hospital in Dublin. In another, separate incident, the volunteer crew of the Howth RNLI rescued three children who had been cut off by the tide near Lion's Head – a popular swimming spot on the south side of the Howth peninsula, close to the Bailey Lighthouse. Helm of the inshore lifeboat, Killian O'Reilly, said it had been a 'challenging afternoon'. The Rescue 116 hospital winching a teenager off the rocks in the Howth peninsula on Friday afternoon during the hottest day of the year. 'The teamwork shown between the RNLI, Coast Guard units, and Rescue 116 was exceptional and ensured the best possible outcome in tough circumstances,' Mr O'Reilly said. 'During this spell of hot weather, we are urging everyone to be aware of the dangers and to know what to do should you find yourself in difficulty in the water.'
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Search under way for teenage swimmer in Laytown, Co Meath
A search is under way for a teenage swimmer in Laytown, Co Meath, while another teenager was hospitalised with multiple injuries following a fall from cliffs in Howth . At 6.40pm on Friday evening a search operation was launched after a swimmer was reported missing in Laytown, Co Meath. The teenage boy was reported missing by a member of the public just before 6.15pm. The Rescue 116 helicopter and the Drogheda Coast Guard unit were tasked to respond to the incident. READ MORE The search for the swimmer remains ongoing. In a separate incident, another teenager was airlifted to hospital with suspected multiple fractures and lacerations after falling 6m on to some rocks in Howth on Friday afternoon. The teenager had to be winched by helicopter from the White Water Brook, a remote beach below cliffs on the eastern side of the Howth peninsula in Co Dublin. The RNLI lifeboat called out the Rescue 116 helicopter because of the swiftly rising tide. Rescue 116 deployed its winchman, who assessed the teenager's injuries, and co-ordinated with RNLI and Coast Guard crews to secure him in a rescue harness. The helicopter then repositioned over the scene and winched the casualty and winchman to safety. A teenager, who went to help him, made his way to the other end of the beach to be picked up. He was suffering from hypothermia. He was then transferred to the all-weather lifeboat and taken back to Howth Lifeboat Station, where he was handed into the care of an ambulance crew. Both teenagers were taken to Beaumont Hospital in Dublin. Separately, the volunteer crew of the Howth RNLI rescued three children who had been cut off by the tide near Lion's Head – a popular swimming spot on the south side of the Howth peninsula, close to the Bailey Lighthouse. Helm of the inshore lifeboat, Killian O'Reilly, said it had been a 'challenging afternoon'. The Rescue 116 hospital winching a teenager off the rocks in the Howth peninsula on Friday afternoon during the hottest day of the year. 'The teamwork shown between the RNLI, Coast Guard units, and Rescue 116 was exceptional and ensured the best possible outcome in tough circumstances,' Mr O'Reilly said. 'During this spell of hot weather, we are urging everyone to be aware of the dangers and to know what to do should you find yourself in difficulty in the water.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Boston rape trial: Judge declares mistrial after jury unable to reach decision
A jury has been unable to reach a verdict in the case of the Dublin firefighter accused of raping a US woman in Boston over St Patrick's Day weekend last year. Terence Crosbie (38) was on trial for raping a 29-year-old attorney in a shared hotel room while his Dublin Fire Brigade colleague Liam O'Brien slept. On Friday afternoon, when the jury of eight men and four women returned to the courtroom to outline that they they could not reach a verdict, the judge said: 'I find that this jury is hung.' After more than 22 hours of deliberation over four days the jury of eight men and four women were unable to reach a decision. READ MORE On Friday afternoon, following queries by the jury and statements that they could not reach a verdict, judge Sarah Ellis said: 'I declare that this jury is deadlocked and I declare a mistrial.' His next trial is set for October 14th. After declaring a mistrial Judge Ellis increased Mr Crosbie's bail from $10,000 to $50,000 declaring Mr Crosbie to be a flight risk. 'The state of the evidence is no longer speculative in this case,' Judge Ellis said. Mr Crosbie was one of more than 10 members of Dublin Fire Brigade who flew into Boston on March 14th to participate in the St Patrick's Day parade. The woman alleged that later that night she met Mr O'Brien at The Black Rose bar, returned with him to the Omni Parker House hotel, had consensual sex and fell asleep in separate beds. She alleged she awoke to a man she did not know raping her and disparaging Mr O'Brien who was snoring. 'I know you want this; [Mr O'Brien] can't even do this for you – what a loser,' she claimed Mr Crosbie said. The complainant and Mr Crosbie both testified during the five-day trial. Prosecutors said the complainant's testimony that she 'woke up' with a man raping her was supported by CCTV footage of Mr Crosbie entering the hotel room at the time in question and the complainant leaving 20 minutes later. Just because the woman went home with Mr O'Brien 'doesn't mean that that man's hotel roommate gets to rape her', prosecutor Erin Murphy told the court. Mr Crosbie 'isn't the unluckiest man in the world; he is the man who raped,' she said. His defence lawyer Daniel C Reilly asked jurors to end Mr Crosbie's 'nightmare' with an acquittal. Mr Crosbie was steadfast in his denial of the assault, insisting through his attorneys, police interviews and his own testimony that he 'didn't touch' the woman. 'There was nobody in my bed - my bed was empty,' Mr Crosbie told the court. 'I had no physical or sexual contact with her at all'. Mr Crosbie insisted that words the complainant attributed to the assailant such as 'loser' was 'not an Irish term'. His defence team called into question DNA evidence collected from the woman. Analysts found two male profiles but could not conclusively identify Mr Crosbie as the second male contributor. The defence also sought to discredit the woman's account citing 'gaps' in her memory, insisting she was inebriated and questioning her about psychiatric medication in cross examination. Mr Crosbie has been held at the Nashua Street jail in Boston since his arrest on March 16th, 2024.
