Watchdog warns over common payment method where you 'need protection'

Watchdog warns over common payment method where you 'need protection'
Which? has raised concerns over the 'protection gap' for shoppers who will not be covered by consumer rules
Items purchased through online shopping
Shoppers are being urged to consider what protections they have when making payments, with the rise in 'pay by bank' as an option. Pay by bank allows people to quickly and securely pay money directly from their bank account without needing to enter the recipient's bank details or use a card.
But Which? raised concerns that people may be unaware of a 'protection gap' if something goes wrong with a purchase. People may be familiar with using pay by bank to settle credit card balances or pay bills, and it has also become an option for retail purchases, the consumer group said.
‌
But Which? warned that the option lacks the Section 75 and chargeback protections that people may have when using some other payment methods. Under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act, a credit card company can be held jointly and severally liable for a purchase that turns out to be shoddy or does not materialise, in certain circumstances.
‌
This means that a shopper could potentially get a refund from the credit card company if they cannot recoup their costs from the retailer. People using a debit card or a credit card for purchases could also potentially get their money back via the voluntary chargeback scheme.
Which? said pay by bank is a 'potential game changer' for businesses as they can sidestep card transaction fees and also benefit from receiving customer funds immediately. There is also appeal for consumers too as refunds can be processed instantly, and card details are not shared when making a transaction – eliminating the risk of them being stolen or compromised.
People do have general purchase rights under the Consumer Rights Act, meaning that goods must be fit for purpose, as described and of satisfactory quality. But Which? said these protections are not always easy to enforce and in some cases may end up with people needing to go to a small claims court.
Article continues below
People may also face difficulties in the event of a business going bust, particularly if there is an issue with a future-dated purchase such as a flight, a festival, or a household big ticket purchase such as a kitchen or a sofa, the consumer group said. Jenny Ross, Which? Money editor, said: 'Innovations like pay by bank present opportunities for businesses and consumers alike, but they're not without risk, particularly as they lack the rigorous purchase protections you get when paying by card.
'We're calling on the regulator to act to ensure consumers can use pay by bank with confidence, but in the meantime, we'd urge consumers to think carefully before using it to book events or make substantial purchases – for now, your good old-fashioned credit or debit card may be the best option.'
A spokesperson for banking and finance industry body UK Finance said: 'There are a range of options for making payments online which provides customers with choice as to how they wish to pay. Different payment methods do come with different levels of protection and it's worth being aware of these when shopping online, particularly when making higher value purchases.'
‌
Riccardo Tordera-Ricchi, director of policy and government relations at the Payments Association, said: 'Pay by bank offers real advantages – from lower merchant fees to faster settlement and improved security through reduced reliance on card details.
'But as it becomes more widely used, especially for high-value or future-dated purchases, it's essential that consumers understand the protections associated with different payment methods. As payment options diversify, making informed choices is just as important as the technology behind them.'
Mr Tordera-Ricchi described Section 75 as 'a powerful example of how regulatory frameworks can meaningfully protect consumers'.
Article continues below
Tom Burton, director of external affairs and public policy at bank payment company GoCardless, said: 'Open banking payments are good news for British consumers: they offer bank-grade security measures, instant refunds, reduced fraud risk and, crucially, small businesses that use them don't face the same high fees as they do for card acceptance. Lower merchant costs mean shoppers get cheaper prices – a real win-win.
'There is more to do though if open banking is to genuinely compete with cards, including building on the foundations of the consumer protections that are already in place. GoCardless is working hard to make that a reality for consumers and merchants by closely collaborating with the Government, regulators and others.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Wales Online

a day ago

• Wales Online

ATOL protection - what to do if your travel company goes bust

ATOL protection - what to do if your travel company goes bust There are various measures in place to protect consumers Things can go wrong (Image: Liam McBurney/PA ) Berkshire-based travel company Great Little Escapes collapsed earlier this week, leaving thousands of holidaymakers in limbo. When a travel company goes bust, suddenly people who were looking forward to their escape abroad are left facing a confusing and stressful situation. When booking a holiday, the last thing on your mind is the possibility that your airline, hotel, or cruise company could collapse. Unfortunately, it happens - and when it does, the result can be both stressful and expensive. This is where end supplier failure comes into play. ‌ What happens when a travel company goes bust - end supplier failure Chris Payne, compliance expert at Total Travel Protection, explained: 'End supplier failure refers to the insolvency or financial collapse of a travel service provider - such as an airline, hotel, ferry operator, car hire company, or cruise line - that was supposed to deliver a part of your travel plans. If they cease trading, you may be left without the service you paid for." ‌ What to do if your travel firm goes bust The first thing you should do is check if you booked a package holiday - known as ATOL Protected. If you booked a package holiday through a UK travel company and received an ATOL certificate, you're in luck. The ATOL scheme, run by the Civil Aviation Authority, protects you if the travel company or one of its suppliers goes bust. Did it happen before travel? You should get a refund. Already abroad? ATOL will arrange for you to return home. ATOL only applies to air travel packages sold in the UK. Article continues below Did you pay by credit card? Under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974, if you paid £100–£30,000 using a UK credit card, the card provider is jointly liable for the failure of the supplier - even if you booked through an intermediary. You can claim a full refund from your card issuer if the service isn't provided due to insolvency. Look for ABTA protection. If you booked land- or sea-based travel (e.g., coach tours, cruises, rail), and the company is an ABTA member, you may be entitled to refunds or alternative arrangements under their protection scheme. ABTA does not cover flight-only bookings. Contact the insolvency practitioner. In cases where ATOL, ABTA, or the Consumer Credit Act doesn't apply, you can contact the administrator or liquidator handling the collapsed supplier's insolvency. They may be organising limited refunds or arrangements. Article continues below What if you're already abroad? Chris said: 'If your end supplier fails while you're away, you should reach out to ATOL or ABTA if applicable. Contact the UK consulate or embassy if you're stranded with no support.' More help and advice can be found at:

Times

a day ago

• Times

Top of the pension pots: the best place for your Sipp

B arclays Smart Investor and Fidelity International have been crowned the top investment platforms for self-invested personal pensions (Sipps) by the consumer group Which?. Which? compared charges across 18 platforms for seven different sizes of pension pot, from £25,000 to £1 million. It also asked about 3,000 customersto rank firms on their customer service and value for money. Sipps give savers control over how their retirement savings are invested, with a broad range of options to invest in, including regulated and unregulated products. Since their introduction in 1989, Sipps have soared in popularity, particularly since 2015, when it became possible to leave your pension money invested after you retire. The Financial Conduct Authority, the City regulator, said more than 1.7 million people held a total of £205 billion in Sipps in 2023.

Daily Mirror

2 days ago

• Daily Mirror

'I saved over £1,300 by cancelling payments and cutting my bills'

Every year I grit my teeth and go back through all of my accounts to look for sneaky subscriptions hiding in my regular payments, says consumer rights expert Martyn James If you want to save some cash, then cancelling subscriptions and regular payments that you no longer want or need is the most effective way to do it. In fact, you can even claim money back. Every year I grit my teeth and go back through all of my accounts to look for sneaky subscriptions hiding in my regular payments. This is worth doing, because a few years back I managed to save over £1,300 by getting rid of subscriptions I didn't want or need and by renegotiating contracts. ‌ Spotting regular and unauthorised payments isn't easy. Most of the banking apps I've seen that list subscriptions seem to only highlight obvious direct debits, standing orders or utility bills. ‌ However, businesses are often able to disguise the money they debit from you in the depths of your accounts with cryptic terms. So for now, you'll still need to go back through your bank and credit card accounts for a year to find all these debits. Shockingly, payments can even be taken from your mobile phone bill! Above all else, keep an eye out for subscription traps. What is a subscription trap? The term 'subscription trap' is most commonly used to refer to offers where you sign up for a free trial, like an online shopping membership scheme or an annual contract for goods or services. Many subscriptions are legitimate, but others are outright rip-offs, charging you for things you neither want or need. Citizens Advice estimated that people were forking out £160 on average on unwanted services. The good news is the law is clamping down on subscription traps, thanks to the Digital Markets, Competitions and Consumers Act 2024. We are still waiting to find out precisely how the new law will work, however, anyone trading in the UK should be aware that trapping people in to regular payments and making it hard to get out of these agreements is going to be more or less banned – so you can fight back now! ‌ What are my rights with subscriptions? A subscription is any service where you pay up front or a regular fee to receive a product or service in return. Subscriptions most commonly bill you monthly, annually or irregularly. When you buy things, you enter in to a contract with the business or organisation. A contract is any agreement where the seller agrees to provide goods or services in return for payment. This doesn't have to be in writing. A contract occurs when you buy in a shop, online or over the phone – even if you don't get a formal, written agreement. ‌ I often mention them in this column, but the Consumer Rights Act and the Consumer Contract Regulations are the laws that protect you when you are paying for goods and services. These laws cover things you've bought and paid for don't turn up, aren't as advertised, are damaged or don't work or don't last a reasonable period of time – and that includes subscription services. You may find that some subscriptions charge you different amounts each month, but only businesses are only allowed to do this if they give you advance notice or seek your permission. One of the most notorious subscription trap scams is where you sign up for a free trial of goods or services, only to be hit with major debits when the trial period ends – often for substandard goods or things that don't even turn up. ‌ This practice is likely to be massively clamped down on in the coming year. But if you've been affected now, cancel the payment with your card provider or bank straight away and demand your money back. Can I cancel a contract or subscription if I'm not happy? You certainly can! If you want to leave a contract that you are 'locked in to' for a longer period, like a gym membership or a magazine subscription, you can leave without paying a penalty if you demonstrate you aren't getting what you paid for. For example: If you aren't getting what you were explicitly told you would get when you signed up to the subscription. The service has changed significantly over time. The quality of the goods or services has been misrepresented. You can also ask for a refund if you've paid up front for an annual subscription. ‌ Dealing with a difficult retailer Sometimes shops refuse to refund you or let you out of contracts even though you have every right to. They are usually gambling on the fact that you'll shut up and put up. Don't! If the business isn't playing ball, ask for an email address so you can make a formal complaint. Cite the laws I mentioned in this article and why you are unhappy with the service and why you don't think it's what you paid for. Make it clear what you want to resolve the complaint too. This might be a full refund, a partial or proportional refund or simply to exit the agreement without fees or charges. ‌ If they are still being difficult, you'll need to threaten the business with the Small Claims Court. You can read my guide about how this works. How do I deal with dodgy subscription trap firms? If you've spotted that you've been paying for a subscription trap after a free trial – or even when you're being debited for a service you never wanted or needed – play hardball. These contracts can be cancelled immediately with your bank, card provider or e-payment service. If you were misled in to taking out a contract or you didn't authorise a business to charge you, you can ask for a full refund. The firm has to be able to prove you agreed to the contract. Even if you signed up to a free trial, you can ask for your money back if you are being charged amounts that you never agreed to.