MRT3 plans must manage costs, accessibility and safety
The MRT3 project is still in its planning phase, a stage that is both vital and delicate.
This is the time when critical decisions are made to determine the most effective route alignment, connectivity options, and how best to integrate with the current public transportation systems, namely the LRT, MRT1, MRT2, and the KTMB commuter lines.
The challenge, however, is immense.
Planners are juggling between two conflicting objectives: achieving the highest possible ridership, and simultaneously, keeping construction costs within a reasonable range.
These are goals that are often at odds with each other, and based on insights shared by experts, the planning process so far appears to fall short on both fronts.
Questionable station locations
A senior traffic analyst who wished to remain anonymous, has raised red flags about the location of several proposed stations.
One of his primary concerns revolves around stations that are positioned parallel to existing highways.
He argues that placing MRT stations adjacent to major roadways may look efficient on paper, but, in reality, they are often inaccessible to pedestrians, limiting ridership.
According to him, it defeats the very purpose of having a mass rapid transit system.
'If the goal is to draw more people into public transport and reduce car dependency, stations must be placed within easy walking distance of dense population or high-activity zones,' he says.
Planning stations in highway corridors —without proper last-mile connections — risks turning these multimillion-ringgit investments into white elephants.
From the publicly available documents, it appears there are several instances where such poor location choices are being considered, raising further concerns about the decision-making framework being applied at this early stage.
Neglected ground realities
Another voice of experience, Monsieur Herve — a veteran geotechnical expert who has been involved in Kuala Lumpur's rail development since the days of the first LRT tunnel from Pasar Seni to Damai, via Masjid Jamek, KLCC and Ampang Park — cautions that the planning currently underway is ignoring crucial geotechnical considerations.
He highlights the importance of conducting preliminary soil investigations before any alignment is finalised.
While full soil testing along a long corridor may be expensive, Herve suggests that a handful of strategic boreholes, each costing less than RM10,000, could help uncover potential geological obstacles early.
This would be a small price to pay to avoid much larger issues down the line.
Geological formations around Kuala Lumpur are known to be particularly difficult to tunnel through—consisting largely of Hawthornden Schist and Quartz veins, highly fractured and unstable rock layers that have historically posed challenges for civil and structural engineers.
Yet, astonishingly, MRT3's Environmental Impact Assessment reports confirm that no boreholes have been drilled thus far.
This lack of basic groundwork is deeply worrying, as it suggests that cost estimates, construction timelines, and even the feasibility of certain segments of the alignment are being decided without a full understanding of the ground conditions.
Environmental, safety oversights
In addition to soil-related concerns, Monsieur Herve also points out the need to avoid alignment through Class 4 slopes — areas highly prone to landslides and soil instability.
In fact, residents in Setiawangsa have voiced similar concerns about soil stability, referencing the Highland Towers disaster and landslides that frequently happen in that part of the Klang Valley which MRT3 will traverse through.
These pose enormous safety risks and should be avoided, especially in an urban environment where the margin for error is razor-thin.
Another serious omission is the lack of studies on the water table across Kuala Lumpur.
Disturbing underground water flow, especially in a flood-prone city like KL, can lead to severe, long-term consequences.
Altering subterranean hydrology without thorough investigation and mitigation plans could result in worsening urban flooding, sinkholes (as in the case of Jalan Masjid India), or infrastructure damage occurring years after the project is completed.
Conclusion
To summarise, no alignment should be deemed final until thorough ground and environmental investigations have been conducted.
Authorities like Agensi Pengangkutan Awam Darat, which is ultimately responsible for this railway scheme, have to take note.
Local authorities—including Majlis Perbandaran Ampang Jaya, DBKL, MBPJ and MPSJ—responsible for approving building plans, structures, and columns requiring planning permission should take note of potential pitfalls. Ideally, they should have been involved in the planning process from the outset.
Without their participation, any proposed route risks becoming not only more expensive during construction, but also operationally flawed and unsafe.
It is evident that the current MRT3 planning efforts require urgent strengthening.
The incorporation of proper technical studies, stakeholder engagement and feedback, early collaboration with the various local authorities and pragmatic design thinking must happen now, while the project is still in its early phases, before irreversible decisions are made.
Only then can the finance ministry have the comfort of financing the project, and MRT3 deliver on its promise of being a transformative public transport solution for the Klang Valley.
The author can be reached at: rosli@mdsconsultancy.com
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BusinessToday
an hour ago
- BusinessToday
Malaysia DPM Heads To Uzbekistan
Malaysia's Deputy Prime Minister (DPM) and Minister of Energy Transition and Water Transformation Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof will lead a high-level delegation to the Republic of Uzbekistan from June 21 to 24, 2025, as part of a strategic mission to strengthen bilateral cooperation in energy, trade and public service innovation. The visit, which underscores Malaysia's deepening engagement with Central Asia, will see Fadillah holding key discussions with Uzbek leaders, including a courtesy call on President Shavkat Mirziyoyev on June 23. He is also scheduled to meet Uzbekistan's Minister of Energy Mirzamahmudov Jurabek Tursunpulatovich to explore collaborative opportunities in renewable and clean energy, sectors central to Malaysia's energy transition roadmap. Accompanied by Deputy Foreign Minister Datuk Mohamad Alamin, Fadillah will also deliver a keynote address at the United Nations Public Service Forum 2025 in Samarkand, where he will highlight Malaysia's innovations and best practices in governance and public sector reform. Rounding off the visit, the DPM will participate in the Malaysia-Uzbekistan Business Forum 2025 in Tashkent on June 24. The forum aims to foster new business linkages and expand economic cooperation between the two nations. Trade between Malaysia and Uzbekistan reached RM369.8 million in 2024, with Malaysian exports accounting for RM365.1 million. From January to April 2025, bilateral trade has already hit RM106 million, signalling growing commercial potential. The four-day visit reaffirms Malaysia's commitment to advancing strategic partnerships with Uzbekistan and promoting sustainable, mutually beneficial growth in both the public and private sectors. Related
Malay Mail
2 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Malaysia to extend anti-dumping duties on Chinese, Japanese steel imports through 2030; ends measures on S. Korea, Vietnam
KUALA LUMPUR, June 21 — The government has completed the administrative (sunset) review and made an affirmative final determination to continue imposing anti-dumping duties on imports of cold rolled coils (CRC) of iron or non-alloy steel (over 1,300mm wide) from China and Japan, excluding those used for automotive and transformer finwall applications, or tin mill black plate. The Ministry of Investment, Trade and Industry (MITI) said the rate of anti-dumping duties for the Chinese companies are; Angang Steel Company Limited at 4.82 per cent, Maanshan Iron and Steel Co., Ltd (4.76 per cent), Shougang Jingtang United Iron & Steel Co., Ltd (8.74 per cent), and other producers and exporters (26.38 per cent). 'The rate of AD duties for Japanese producers and exporters will be imposed at 26.39 per cent. 'The Royal Malaysian Customs Department will enforce the collection of the anti-dumping duties on the imports of the subject merchandise for a period of five years, effective from June 23, 2025 to June 22, 2030,' it said in a statement today. MITI also noted that the government has made a negative final determination to terminate the imposition of anti-dumping duties and the investigations on the imports of the subject merchandise originating or exported from South Korea and Vietnam, effective from June 23, 2025. 'Interested parties such as local producers, importers, foreign producers and exporters and associations related to the administrative (sunset) review can have access to the non-confidential version of the final determination report by submitting a written request to MITI director of trade practices section,' it said. — Bernama
Malay Mail
2 hours ago
- Malay Mail
KLIA Aerotrain to resume service for travellers on July 1, Transport Ministry announces
SEPANG, June 21 — The new Aerotrain service at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport (KLIA) will officially begin operations come July 1. Confirming service resumption next month, Transport Minister Anthony Loke said he is hopeful the latest development would allow a greater comfort for travelling passengers transiting between the main terminal and the satellite building. 'I am happy to announce that we are entering the final phase of testings in the coming days. 'If all goes smoothly, we have decided to reopen the train service at 10am on July 1,' he told a press conference after attending a trial-run at the KLIA Terminal 1 building here. The Aerotrain, a key component of KLIA's internal transport system since 1998, was suspended in March 2023 following a breakdown. The new Aerotrain system is expected to improve the passenger experience, reduce operational disruptions, and support the anticipated increase in air passenger traffic in the coming years. MORE TO COME
