Shostakovich: Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk album review
Performing Shostakovich has been one of Andris Nelsons' calling cards during his first decade as music director of the Boston Symphony Orchestra. What began as a project to survey all of the symphonies, with recordings of them subsequently released by Deutsche Grammophon, was extended to include all the concertos, and ended in spectacular fashion in January last year with concert performances of Shostakovich's most ambitious and controversial stage work, the 1934 opera, Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk.
Surprisingly for a work of such notoriety and historical significance, this is just the fourth recording of Lady Macbeth (there's also one available version of Katerina Izmailova, the revision of the score that Shostakovich produced in 1962 in an attempt to rehabilitate it with the Soviet authorities after its official condemnation in 1936). But unfortunately this new version, taken from one of the Boston performances, does not seriously challenge the existing choices.
Oddly, each of the three previous commercial recordings, conducted by Mstislav Rostropovich, Myung-whun Chung and Ingo Metzmacher respectively, all take exactly the same time over the complete opera: 155 minutes. Here, Nelsons takes a whole 20 minutes longer. Though few passages seem to drag unduly, the difference in timings does confirm a lassitude in his performance; despite some of the individual contributions, there's a flatness to the proceedings, a lack of urgency, that undermines their dramatic impact.
And, even though there's no shortage of loud, brash playing, Nelsons and the BSO tend to neuter a score that includes some of Shostakovich's most savagely ironic and parodic invention, a radical extreme from which he was forced to retreat. Hearing this account of the score, it's sometimes hard to understand why it should have offended Stalin so much. And while Kristine Opolais has her moments in the title role, her characterisation of Katerina is rather one-dimensional, doing a good line in the character's self-pity but little else. Brendan Gunnell is plausible enough as her lover Sergey, Peter Hoare suitably complaisant as her husband, Zinovy, with Günther Groissböck completing the menage à quatre as her bullying father-in-law Boris.
All in all it's a disappointing ending to the Boston Shostakovich series.
This article includes content hosted on embed.music.apple.com. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as the provider may be using cookies and other technologies. To view this content, click 'Allow and continue'.
Listen on Apple Music (above) or Spotify
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
5 days ago
- Spectator
Astonishing ‘lost tapes' from a piano great
These days the heart sinks when Deutsche Grammophon announces its new releases. I still shudder at the memory of Lang Lang's 2024 French album, in which he drooled over Ravel's Pavane pour une infante défunte; when I reviewed it I suggested that if the poor girl wasn't dead when he started, then she certainly was by the time he'd finished. Now she's been killed again, this time by the guitarist Robin Scherpen, whose Ravel Reimagined offers us 'a peaceful and serene soundscape'. Then there's Rêverie from Nemo Filou, a trio whose cocktail-lounge noodling allows 'the listener to drift off into bliss', and Sleep Circle, a 're-recorded version of the 2012 project Sleep' by DG's in-house snoozemeister Max Richter. But the funny thing is that over the past year I've spent more on DG products than I have for decades. Like its competitors, the company is frantically mining its back catalogue. That isn't exciting: I don't need fancy new packaging for CDs I bought in the 1990s. But there are also recordings remastered by Emil Berliner Studios, named after the man who founded Deutsche Grammophon in 1898 – and the results are stunning. EBS revisits the peaks of DG's catalogue, going back to the master tapes to recover audio information that was lost because the original sound engineers didn't have the right technology to extract it, or messed things up at the mixing desk. Although many of these new remasterings have been issued as CDs, SACDs or downloads, the cream of the crop is available only as pure analogue vinyl. Trust me: you haven't really heard Karajan's Mahler Fifth until you've invested £80 in the 'Original Source' LPs and played them with the best stylus you can afford. But now EBS has worked a digital miracle that you can hear on any streaming service. The Lost Tapes is an album of four Beethoven sonatas performed by Sviatoslav Richter in 1965, recorded for possible release but then mysteriously forgotten for nearly 60 years. They are taken from live concerts in France and Switzerland in which we hear the pianist at the top of his form in terrific sound – a frustratingly rare combination. Richter felt suffocated by microphones and you can hear a lack of spontaneity in many of his studio recordings. In contrast, some of his supreme flights of imagination are found in live concerts captured by wretched equipment. For example, his legendary 1958 Sofia performance of Pictures at an Exhibition, praised by critics for its 'staggering breadth of colour' and 'frenzied grotesquerie', sounds muffled or strident, depending on how you twiddle the knobs. In 1960 Richter made his American debut with six concerts in Carnegie Hall. Gripped by stage fright, under heavy KGB surveillance, he tore through Beethoven and Prokofiev sonatas, Schumann's Novelletten and Rachmaninov Preludes with a mixture of savagery and feathery delicacy. The end of Beethoven's Appassionata comes so close to breaking the sound barrier that you scarcely notice the finger-slips. Alas, the microphone was in the hands of a clueless stagehand – and when Sony reissued the recordings on CD they drained the colour out of the abrasive but vivid LP originals. But I was lucky enough to stumble on a version beautifully renovated by an amateur from an internet forum, and that sent me down the rabbit hole of the vast Richter discography. Thanks to years of obsessive-compulsive collecting, I can compare the four Lost Tapes Beethoven sonatas – opuses 31 no. 3, 90, 101 and 110 – with other Richter performances. The last of these, in A flat major, represents a unique milestone in the composer's journey; Antony Hopkins once suggested that the transformation of the fugue subject into ecstatic rhapsody is the moment when Beethoven – and music itself – finally severed the shackles of the classical style. A fanciful theory, perhaps, but that's how Richter plays it, the final bars exploding with joy. Is it a finer performance than the one he recorded in Moscow in the same year? No – it's almost identical, and the same is true of Op. 101 in A major, which Richter described as 'horribly difficult… even riskier than the Hammerklavier'. To quote Jed Distler's liner notes on this previously lost tape, we hear a 'bracingly effortless traversal of the Finale', in which the pianist 'untangles the knotty counterpoint with insouciant ease'. Richter was on fire in 1965, and his achievement in Moscow is every bit as jaw-dropping. The difference is the sound; in all the sonatas the pounding of Richter's left hand jolts you out of your seat and his ability to sustain a whisper at lightning speed defies belief. It's hard to think of other Richter recordings in which technique and sound quality are so gloriously matched. We're told that Emil Berliner Studios removed the tiniest pitch fluctuations and audience noises, something that wouldn't have been possible until recently and other technicians probably couldn't replicate. So, all things considered, perhaps we should be grateful that some idiot at Deutsche Grammophon left these tapes gathering dust until precisely the right moment.
Metro
5 days ago
- Metro
Classic 80s sci-fi thriller removed from Disney Plus over 'unacceptable' scene
A 1980s sci-fi movie nominated for four Oscars has been taken down from Disney Plus due to a controversial scene. Released in 1989, The Abyss was written and directed by James Cameron, who went on to direct blockbusters like Titanic and the Avatar franchise. The movie followed a US search and recovery team working with an oil platform crew to save people onboard a submarine after it sinks in the Caribbean. At the same time, they are racing against Soviet vessels to recover the boat, but, deep in the ocean they face an unexpected encounter. The Abyss starred Ed Harris, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio and Michael Biehn. It was met with mixed reviews, but grossed $90million (£66million) and was nominated for four Oscars, winning Best Visual Effects. In 2023 Cameron announced that a 4K remastered version would return to cinemas for a one-night-only event. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video A DVD version was then rolled out in March last year, however a UK release for the 4K restoration was cancelled due to production company Lightstorm Entertainment's refusal to cut a scene involving a rat. The scene in question showed the character, Navy SEAL Ensign Monk (Adam Nelson) submerge a rat in a small tub of breathing fluorocarbon liquid, trying to demonstrate how a human might be able to breathe underwater. The film used five real rats for the scene, with the animal shown in the scene struggling and panicking when it thinks its drowning. However it eventually calms down and starts breathing the liquid, which contains oxygen. This scene was banned in the UK by the British Board of Film Classification on animal cruelty grounds. That ruling meant the scene needed to be cut from any theatrical, home video or terrestrial cuts of the film. However, when the remastered movie version was rolled out on Disney Plus in April, it showed the scene, as streaming services were not bound by the ruling. A few months on, the movie has now completely disappeared and can't be found on the platform. Although Disney Plus is yet to comment on why the film has been pulled entirely, the RSPCA has weighed in on what it believes is a wider issue. In a statement, the RSPCA's head of public affairs David Bowles said: 'The RSPCA is really concerned that a loophole currently exists allowing animal abuse scenes deemed unacceptable elsewhere to be streamed freely and legally into our homes. More Trending 'The Abyss' controversial rat scene has long concerned the RSPCA and has always been deemed unacceptable by BBFC – so it's hard to fathom why Disney Plus decided to broadcast it. 'We need to ensure people are not being exposed to content which promotes or showcases cruelty to animals. As the way millions of households consume entertainment changes, it's vital the legal framework is responsive to that.' Despite the backlash, The Abyss has been called a 'totally gripping, claustrophobic thriller, complete with an interesting crew of characters' on review site Rotten Tomatoes, where it holds a score of 89%. Metro has contacted Disney Plus for comment. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: Controversial Snow White remake finally hits Disney+ and fans are split MORE: How to get 4 months of Disney+ for £1.99 a month in time for The Bear's new series MORE: Doctor Who is in peril – but I'm not worried
The Guardian
12-06-2025
- The Guardian
The Lost Tapes, Beethoven sonatas 18,27, 28 & 31 album review – Richter always found something fresh to say
Though he claimed to dislike performing in a studio, Sviatoslav Richter became perhaps the most intensively recorded pianist of the 20th century. But while his studio work was extensive, it was the huge volume of recordings made officially and unofficially at his recitals across more than 40 years that really bulked out his discography, with multiple versions available of many of the core works in his repertory. For those reasons the rediscovery of 'Lost Tapes' might not initially seem so remarkable. The performances, of four Beethoven piano sonatas, Opp 31 no 3, 90, 101 and 110, are taken from recitals that Richter gave in 1965. Op 110 comes from a performance at the piano festival he had founded the previous year at La Grange de Meslay near Tours, the others are taken from a concert in Lucerne three months later. There are recordings of Richter's performances of all four sonatas already in the catalogue, but the immediacy of these versions is startling. He was never content to keep on replicating the interpretation of a particular work; temperamentally, I suspect, he could not contemplate such lazy routine. Instead, each work was approached afresh each time he played it, always finding something new, whether it's the joy that courses through the third of the Op 31 set, the myriad colours and subtleties he brings to Op 101, or the serene, almost liturgical seriousness with which he presents the fugues in the finale of Op 110. The original recordings were made by Deutsche Grammophon engineers, who were following Richter around Europe that year, and the sound has been refined for this release. What has proved more intractable has obviously been the piano tone itself, which, in the Lucerne performances especially, seems very bright and rather shallow, sometimes sounding almost like a mid 19th-century instrument. It does take a bit of the gloss off the performances, but the playing is still glorious. This article includes content hosted on We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as the provider may be using cookies and other technologies. To view this content, click 'Allow and continue'. Listen on Apple Music (above) or Spotify
