Proposal to OK swimming in notoriously polluted Harlem River won't stop 2B gallons of sewage from being dumped there: activists

What a dump.
Bronx activists are fuming that a proposal aimed at opening up the notoriously polluted Harlem River to swimming won't do anything to keep raw sewage from being dumped there.
The state Department of Environmental Conservation said it wants to make the most polluted waterway in the city — and possibly all of New York — clean enough for swimmers to be able to take a dip in it.
Advertisement
But clean water activists are boiling mad about the effort, claiming the DEC's plan will effectively lock in poor quality standards, continuing to allow nearly 2 billion gallons of raw sewage to spill into the river every year.
3 An estimated 1.9 billion of raw sewage is dumped into the Harlem River every year.
The Harlem River's current classification, 'Class I,' means it only needs to be clean enough to allow for 'secondary contact recreation,' like boating and fishing.
Advertisement
The crux of the activists' outrage lies with a proposal released by the DEC in April to reclassify the river as a 'wet weather (WW) limited use' waterbody — that could allow swimming there on so-called dry days.
When it rains, the river routinely gets flooded with raw sewage and other pollutants because the overstrained systems cannot handle the additional stormwater, according to environmental advocates.
As a result, the activists are calling out state and city officials for the plan to open up the river to swimming — without investing time and money into overhauling the Bronx's outdate sewage systems that overflow when it rains.
It would cost around $9 billion to fix the outdated 'Combined Sewer Overflows' systems, which the DEC has ruled too costly.
Advertisement
'By using an all or nothing argument to sewage pollution reduction, the city and state are attempting to justify maintaining the status quo of poor water quality for the Harlem River generations to come, and that improving water quality really is not all or nothing effort,' Ruby said.
'They're trying to say this is an upgrade when it's not,' argued Ruby. 'They're not proposing to do pollution reduction. This 'reclassification' is going to take generations to come. They need to set the goal as swimmable 100% of the time.'
3 A reclassification for the waterway would mean that the state would suspend all required water quality standards up to 36 hours after it rains.
More than a dozen state and city politicians have already penned a letter to DEC Acting Commissioner Amanda Lefton demanding that the agency reconsider the proposed reclassification and replace it with a loftier goal — namely, to institute initiatives that would require the river to be swimmable at all times.
Advertisement
Two public hearings on the proposal are slated for the end of the month.
Other New Yorkers also accused the DEC of throwing the towel on cleaning up the river, including kayaking and rowing groups groups who currently try their best to avoid touching the polluted water during their excursions.
'This is not making anything better. It's essentially observing that if it hasn't rained in a while, the river might actually be clean enough to swim in — maybe. I wouldn't swim in it by choice,' said Joy Hecht, a member of the Harlem River Rowing Community.
3 'We know the status quo is not good. The Harlem River deserves better,' said Em Ruby.
metpromo_40733
'It's essentially saying, 'We give up. We're not going to try and improve it.''
A DEC spokesperson did not address the claims, saying the proposed 'landmark regulatory changes are unprecedented, building upon decades of ongoing progress to transform the Harlem River and other waters in and around New York City.'
'Collectively, New Yorkers are making significant progress in improving water quality, and the new requirements would provide additional ecological benefits and positive impacts to the region's fishing, boating, and swimming conditions,' the statement said.
Chauncy Young, a coordinator at the Harlem River Coalition, griped that the proposed change marks another injustice that the borough has been dealt, pointing to other waterways throughout the city that boast free, city-run kayaking and canoe programs in their cleaner-by-comparison water.
Advertisement
Even the Hudson River has numerous swimming spots and opportunities throughout the year.
'We definitely feel like the forgotten borough,' Young said.
'We've been advocating for access to the river for decades and decades and decades …We definitely feel like the Bronx and upper Manhattan have been left out of development and resources that have been provided to communities in terms of access and programming and just beautiful parks.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Insider

19 hours ago

• Business Insider

I turned my two-car garage into an Airbnb to afford living in my dream town. I've made $35,000 a year and get to share the area I love.

My husband and I are both New Yorkers, but we moved up to southern Vermont in 2002 or 2003. Having grown up as a renter my whole life, it was wild to see that you could — at the time, anyway — purchase a house in Bennington, Vermont, for less than $100,000. We weren't purchasing when we moved up there, but even the rents were so much more affordable. We were early in our twenties, just out of college, and trying to figure out where we would make a life. And a huge factor in that — and what's remained consistent throughout our choice of where we place ourselves — is whether or not it makes sense and you can afford to live there. We had a duplex property in Bennington a year into moving there because it was so cheap. That was literally how we, at 22 years old, afforded a house. One side paid the mortgage, and we lived on the other side for free. We knew it wasn't a long-term house, and that it was a necessity for the mortgage. We eventually bought this great house in Shaftsbury, Vermont, for about $250,000, situated on a hill surrounded by mountain views, and we thought we would live there forever. It was a simple ranch, but gorgeous and we loved it. However, the public schools were not ideal for our family and kids. We tried them for a couple of years, and they weren't good at all. So, we started to enroll our kids in private schools, and we realized we're big public school advocates. We wanted the kids to have a bigger school experience. So we started to look at places where public school systems were known to be good. When we were looking for our next place to enroll the kids in public school, we wanted my husband to be able to keep his job in Bennington. It's a dream job, so it needed to be commutable. We had lived in Williamstown before we had children and absolutely loved it here. The Williamstown, Massachusetts, real estate market is competitive, but we knew what we wanted People love living here, and they don't want to leave — who can blame them? So it's rare that houses come up, and when they do, it's a very competitive market. We were looking for a place where the kids could go to the schools, but we also wanted to be in the town itself, and walk and have sidewalks and be able to let our kids have unplanned meetups — kids still knock on the door and say, "Can so-and-so come out and play," here. It's amazing, and we very much wanted that. When this house came up, we were the first people to see it. I think it was eight hours after it came on to market. It's right in the center of town, and we were like, "Oh my God, we need this house." We looked at 10 or 11 houses, but every single one had to clear a few hurdles for me: One of them being it had to be able to produce some form of income. The house was outside of our budget, but it had a two-car tandem garage attached to it. I literally was up in the attic space, and my realtor came in and I said, "This is where we'll put the guest suite." In our last house, we converted our basement into an office for me as well as a guest suite for our family who visited frequently. We did host the occasional stay on Airbnb, so I had experience, but I was not really thinking of it as a business. What I really wanted in our new home was consistent income that could be counted on throughout the year. I didn't know what that was, but I just knew that it would be consistent. In its first year, our unit made $35,000 We bought the home for $637,000. We both knew that long-term, living here wouldn't be comfortable for us on our salaries alone. It would be very difficult if we didn't have another idea about how we could use our space to make it more comfortable. We took out a $100,000 loan to do the renovation. It was a business investment and a home investment because we knew that it would increase the value of our home. The loan covered basically everything, soup to nuts: Building, driveway, furnishing, the whole bit. Obviously, we have to pay the loan, so it's like a small mortgage. Then anything after that is income. In 2024, it earned $35,000. That was its first year. This coming year, we will beat those expectations — we're already ahead. I was thinking, "What if I designed this space as this one-unit, deeply personal hospitality experience that wasn't about scaling it or just making a space someone could stay for the night? It was about intentionally reflecting this love letter to this town and to this community and place that we were so drawn to. We built something that was small — it's just under 500 square feet — but every choice I made, from the stone counters, to the radiant floors, to the fence, to when you arrive at the Ritz-Carlton bed, is a part of a story. I want you to come in and feel like you got to live inside of this story of Williamstown in the area and retreat and feel like you've not only gotten that experience outside in the town, but when you come back into the space itself. The exterior of the converted of Briee Della Rocca Community, especially this community, is so important to us. I couldn't be gladder to share this with people. It makes me so glad to be here and welcome people, and I love when our neighbors send guests over and we get to host their families. It just feels like an extension of making this community more comfortable for visitors and for the people that live here year round.

USA Today

2 days ago

• USA Today

Today is Juneteenth: Is there mail? Are banks closed? What to know about federal holiday

Today is Juneteenth: Is there mail? Are banks closed? What to know about federal holiday Show Caption Hide Caption New Yorkers honor lost African American holiday older than Juneteenth An African American holiday older than Juneteenth was almost lost. These New Yorkers are bringing back Pinkster, which was outlawed in the 1800s. Juneteenth will be marked on Thursday, June 19, 2025. Juneteenth commemorates the day — June 19, 1865 — when federal soldiers arrived in Galveston to take control of Texas and ensure the slaves were freed per the Emancipation Proclamation. It's known as America's Second Independence Day, and it's celebrated today, June 19. Juneteenth celebrates the end of slavery in the United States. It's the longest-running African American holiday, and it became a federal holiday a few years ago. Juneteenth celebrations across the High Desert will include food, music, dancing, art and other activities. Here's what to know about the holiday. Is Juneteenth a federal holiday in 2025? Yes, Juneteenth is a federal holiday in 2025, according to the U.S. Office of Personnel Management. It is one of 11 federal holidays observed every year. The others are: New Year's Day Martin Luther King Jr. Birthday Washington's Birthday/Presidents Day Memorial Day July 4 Labor Day Columbus Day Veterans Day Thanksgiving Christmas Day When is Juneteenth observed in 2025? Juneteenth will be marked on Thursday, June 19, 2025. Unlike other federal holidays, such as Memorial Day, Labor Day and Thanksgiving, which are observed on a specific day of the week, Juneteenth is celebrated on the actual day. What does Juneteenth celebrate? Juneteenth commemorates the day — June 19, 1865 — when federal soldiers arrived in Galveston to take control of Texas and ensure the slaves were freed per the Emancipation Proclamation, according to the History Channel. Juneteenth — short for June nineteenth — marks the end of slavery in the United States and is considered the longest-running African American holiday. Why is it called Juneteenth? Juneteenth is a portmanteau of June 19, the day Union troops arrived in Galveston. It became known as "Juneteenth" by the newly freed slaves of Texas, according to the National Museum of African American History & Culture at the Smithsonian. When did Abraham Lincoln issue the Emancipation Proclamation? President Abraham Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation on Jan. 1, 1863. But its effect was limited, according to the National Archives. It only applied to states that seceded during the Civil War, leaving slavery intact for slave states that stayed with the Union. It also could not be enforced until Confederate states were under Union control, according to the National Museum of African American History and Culture. Therefore, it took until June 19, 1865, for slaves in Texas to be freed. Slavery in America was formally abolished with the 13th Amendment, which was ratified Dec. 6, 1865. When did Juneteenth become a federal holiday? Juneteenth became a federal holiday in 2021. President Joe Biden signed legislation on June 17, 2021, according to USA TODAY, after Congress passed The Juneteenth National Independence Day Act that same month. Juneteenth began rising to prominence in 2020 after the murder of George Floyd, a Black man, sparked protests across the country against police brutality, USA TODAY reports. Sen. Ed Markey, D-Mass., first introduced the Juneteenth bill in 2020 following the killings of Floyd and Breonna Taylor of Louisville, Kentucky. His initial attempt to pass the bill was unsuccessful. Is there mail delivery on Juneteenth? Is the post office open? Does FedEx deliver? No. As a federal holiday, the U.S. Postal Service is closed that day, and there will be no mail delivered. FedEx pickup and delivery services will be available on June 19, according to the company's website. FedEx Office locations will also be open, USA TODAY reports. Are banks open on Juneteenth? Juneteenth is a Federal Reserve bank holiday, meaning the organization that regulates the nation's banking system is closed, according to Banks aren't required to close for Federal Reserve holidays, but they often do. Transactions made during these holidays won't be posted until the next business day. Branches of Capital One, Bank of America, PNC, Truist, CitiBank and JPMorgan Chase will be closed on Juneteenth, USA TODAY is reporting. Capital One Cafes will remain open. Is the stock market open or closed on Juneteenth? The New York Stock Exchange is closed on federal holidays and will be closed on Juneteenth, according to its website. Is trash pickup delayed for Juneteenth? Trash pickup may be delayed because of Juneteenth, depending on the hauler. Contact your municipality or private provider to learn more.

New York Post

6 days ago

• New York Post

NYC recycling center crop dusting neighborhood with ‘choking' stink that has state fuming: ‘Literally gag'

A Long Island City asphalt recycling plant is spraying a 'choking' stink along the Newtown Creek — leaving state regulators fuming and residents plugging their noses. State regulators first raised a stink about the noxious fumes from Green Asphalt back in January 2024, when the company was accused of spewing emissions that 'unreasonably interfered with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property' in violation of the New York State Air Pollution Control Law. 7 New Yorkers living near Newtown Creek are calling on an asphalt recycling plant to stop releasing smelly, noxious fumes that 'choke' nearby residents. X / Blissville Civic Association 7 The Green Asphalt recycling plant on Railroad Avenue in Queens. Brigitte Stelzer But locals said take a whiff of the air along the Newtown Creek and the chemical odor has only gotten worse since then. 'At first it was a choking smell – I'm talking about how you would literally gag when you go outside,' said Tom Mituzas, a longtime resident of the Blissville section of the neighborhood and member of the Blissville Civic Organization. 'Your eyes would tear because the smokestacks are so low,' Mituzas said of the plant, which opened in 2011. 'The smoke would stay at street level, and you'd go out of your house and you'd breathe [fumes] in, and you'd just choke.' The resident told The Post he moved his 95-year-old aunt from her childhood home last summer because he was afraid 'she was going to die in the house' due to the fumes that seep indoors. The state Department of Environmental Conservation has continued to receive 'numerous' complaints about the odor — and its potential health effects, officials wrote in a letter to the plant Wednesday. 'The department has continued to regularly receive numerous community complaints and inquiries regarding both the odor emanating from the facility and potential human health implications associated with emissions from the facility,' the DEC wrote in a letter issued to the plant Wednesday. Regulators are now demanding the plant increase the height of its smokestacks from 45 feet to 90 feet by Dec. 11, its letter showed. The company will also have to test for air contaminants and an elemental analysis of the recycled asphalt materials it handles. 7 'Your eyes would tear because the smokestacks are so low. The smoke would stay at street level, and you'd go out of your house, and you'd breathe it in, and you'd just choke,' Mituzas said of the plant, which opened in 2011. Brigitte Stelzer 7 Blissville, Queens resident Tom Mituzas told The Post he had to evacuate his 95-year-old aunt out of her home last summer due to the smelly emissions. LinkedIn / Thomas J Mituzas A rep for Green Asphalt told The Post it has been 'working diligently to address any odor complaints' and strives to be in 'good standing with the community as we have over the last 14 years, and we continue to engage with local stakeholders in Greenpoint and Long Island City to resolve this as soon as possible.' Asphalt fumes can cause serious injury and permanent damage, including throat irritation, cough, fatigue and skin cancer, according to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. 7 The Blissville Civic Association is calling on elected officials to help assuage the stinky fumes in Queens. 7 Billowing emissions from the Green Asphalt facility in Blissville, Queens. X / Blissville Civic Association 7 Council member Julie Won said she is advocating for air quality testing near the plant site. Stefan Jeremiah for New York Post Green Asphalt in Long Island City once touted a $50,0000 sub-contract with the DOT and has helped pave major Big Apple roadways like the Whitestone Expressway. It recycles asphalt to be used in city sustainability projects, and brands itself as the first 100% recycled asphalt plant in Gotham. The DOT stopped asphalt recycling operations with Green Asphalt 'around the time' the January 2024 violation was issued and has been waiting for a 'corrective plan before allowing operations to resume,' City Council member Julie Won's office told residents in an email shared with The Post. Won told The Post she and state pols are now working to make sure the DEC regularly tests air quality near the plant site, as well as enforces state environmental regulations 'appropriately to improve the situation.'