Epic Games' Cravath team wins fees in Apple contempt ruling
May 1 (Reuters) - (Billable Hours is Reuters' weekly report on lawyers and money. Please send tips or suggestions to D.Thomas@thomsonreuters.com, opens new tab)
A federal judge's contempt ruling against Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab has created a major new legal headache for the iPhone maker, and also requires it to write a check to its adversary in the case: "Fortnite" maker Epic Games.
Jumpstart your morning with the latest legal news delivered straight to your inbox from The Daily Docket newsletter. Sign up here.
U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on Wednesday found Apple willfully violated an injunction she issued in Epic's 2020 lawsuit that was meant to open up the company's App Store to greater competition.
The decision, opens new tab immediately bars Apple from restricting App Store customers' use of third-party payment systems. The judge held Apple in civil contempt and referred the case to federal prosecutors to probe whether Apple was in criminal contempt of court.
Apple said it disputed the ruling and will appeal.
As a sanction, Gonzalez Rogers also said Apple must pay legal fees to Epic's legal team, led by Cravath, Swaine & Moore, for the many months the lawyers spent fighting Apple for information about its compliance with the earlier injunction.
Epic's team at Cravath was led by partners Gary Bornstein, Yonatan Even, Lauren Moskowitz and Michael Zaken.
Bornstein declined to discuss the size of the Epic's legal tab on a call with reporters. The fee sanction could be in the tens of millions of dollars, based on the number of lawyers working for Epic, and the all-out battle that was waged over trying to pry information from Apple.
Some Cravath litigation partners, including Moskowitz, have billed this year at $2,360 an hour, according to a Reuters review of U.S. court filings.
"Epic's obviously not out here for fees," Epic Games chief executive Tim Sweeney told reporters. "We're fighting for the freedom of ourselves and all developers to do business directly with our customers, freedom from Apple interference and Apple taxation."
Apple is represented by a team from Weil Gotshal led by Mark Perry. Lawyers from Gibson Dunn also represented Apple, which has denied violating the court's injunction.
The court's order faulted Apple's lawyers, without naming them, for not correcting what the judge called "obvious lies" in testimony by an Apple executive.
Two of Apple's chief lawyers in the Epic case did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Gonzalez Rogers' order also addressed a separate bid from Apple to recoup more than $73 million in legal fees from Epic for violating the App Store's developer agreement.
The court's ruling suggested Apple will not recover that much but is due some fees from Epic. Epic's legal team predicted any award would concern only a "small amount."
-- A founder of law firm Kramer Levin's Paris office has sued the firm, opens new tab in New York state court, accusing it of failing to make certain payments in breach of their partnership agreement.
Antoine Paszkiewicz, who had worked at Kramer Levin since 1999, alleged he is owed compensation following the firm's move in late 2024 to end its agreements with Paris partners as part of a plan to merge with law firm Herbert Smith Freehills.
Some of Kramer Levin's Paris team jumped to rival law firm Morgan Lewis. Paszkiewicz said he was excluded from those negotiations because he was over the firm's mandatory retirement age of 65. Kramer Levin, he alleged, then failed to pay him the full compensation he was due under their partnership terms.
Kramer Levin in a statement said it appreciated "the contributions of our former partners in Paris. The orderly winddown of the Paris office has fully complied with our partnership agreement."
A lawyer for Paszkiewicz did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
--Law firms including Constantine Cannon and Shinder Cantor Lerner said they will ask a U.S. judge to award them up to $76 million in fees as part of a $228 million antitrust class action settlement involving California's Sutter Health.
Employers and individuals who sued Sutter in 2012 filed the proposed settlement in the San Francisco, California federal court, seeking a judge's approval. Sutter, represented by Jones Day, denied any wrongdoing in agreeing to settle.
US lobbying firms see early revenue boost in Trump's second term
Bitcoin miner accuses K&L Gates of botching bankruptcy claim, overbilling
Former top Trump diplomat settles legal fee fight for $1.1 million
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
7 hours ago
- Metro
What the 'i' in iPhone and other Apple products stands for
Phone users have been wondering what the 'i' stands for in iPhone. Apple has long used the class of i before its products, including iPod, iPad, and iMac. The single letter has been taken for granted, but some online users have given various explanations as to what the brand's lowercase signature could represent, with some suggesting information, intelligence or even individual. Before his death in 2011, Apple co-founder Steve Jobs revealed what the elusive letter meant. He explained that the 'i' in fact signified the internet, access to which was the primary purpose of a computer when Apple's first iMac came on the market in 1998, prior to which its predecessors were named Macintosh. Launching his game-changing product, Jobs explained: 'An iMac comes from the marriage of the excitement of the internet with the simplicity of Macintosh. But he added: 'i also means some other things to us. We are a personal computer company in all this. The product is born to network. It is also a beautiful stand alone product.' But Jobs later elaborated on the subsequent meaning of 'i' – which has since been applied to the name of nearly all of Apple's products. As rivals caught up on the internet front, Apple's USP shifted elsewhere and the i began to represent several new concepts. According to Jobs, these were Apple's core missions: individual, instruct, inform, and inspire. However, he suggested the letter i before products also has another more personal meaning for consumers. It can refer to the first-person pronoun 'I', an allusion to the products being one's personal property and an essential companion – after all, who leaves the house without their phone these days? Finally, i can also mean instruction – a reference to the educational aspect of Apple's portfolio and how the user instructs devices to do what they want (or maybe with the advent of AI, vice versa!) More Trending The letter i was not just used as a marketing moniker either. Apple also uses it for job titles. In fact, Jobs himself became iCEO of Apple in 1997, with the i in this case representing interim. The first iPhone was released on June 29, 2007, in the US. It came out in the UK in November 2007, with an estimated 30,000 sold on the first day alone. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page.
Scottish Sun
9 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
I tried Samsung's posh new mobile that makes iPhone look like an expensive BRICK – there's a way to save on upgrading
All recommendations within this article are informed by expert editorial opinion. If you click on a link in this story we may earn affiliate revenue. The Galaxy S25 Edge makes two key sacrifices for its lighter, thinner new model FEELING THIN I tried Samsung's posh new mobile that makes iPhone look like an expensive BRICK – there's a way to save on upgrading Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SAMSUNG has had a pretty packed year in smartphone world. First, we had the usual Galaxy S25 launches at the start of the year - and then there were some great budget-friendly models too. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 6 Only two cameras are now on the back as Samsung looks to slim things down Credit: Jamie Harris / The Sun 6 Familiar but slimmer new design Credit: Jamie Harris / The Sun And now we're back to the Galaxy S25 again with a new category. This time it's all about thin, thin, thin. All the tech packed inside ever-powerful phones make it tricky business to stop them from becoming almighty hunks of metal. What with chunky batteries, all that processing power needed for AI tools, the list goes on. But Samsung is determined to give it a go with the new Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge - even if there are some sacrifices. As The Sun's main Android smartphone reviewer I get hands-on with all sorts of devices all the time. Here's why you might want to consider the Galaxy S25 Edge if you're fed up with chunky mobiles weighing down your pocket. Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge: Look and feel How the Galaxy S25 Edge looks and feels is arguably the most important first bit of information you want. And the good news is, it's immense. I can't remember the last time I held a phone of this size and power that felt this light, at only 163g. Samsung insider reveals top tricks every user needs to know about to save battery and storage A website on the weight of items tells me that's about as heavy as an average hockey puck. The Galaxy S25+ and iPhone 15 Plus are the fairest comparisons to note, because they both have a 6.7inch display like the S25 Edge. A Galaxy S25+ weighs 190g, while the iPhone 15 Plus is 201g. But it's not just the weight, the Edge is super thin at 5.8mm - Samsung's thinnest ever phone. Looking for objects around the house, the nearest item I could compare it to is a tiny bit thicker than my passport. Again, the Galaxy S25+ is 7.3mm thick and the iPhone 15 Plus is 7.8mm. This makes the iPhone - and just about every other smartphone, even Samsung's other models - look and feel like a brick. Despite all this, the titanium body and hardened glass on the S25 Edge feel pretty tough, though I'd worry it might bend if I accidentally sat on it a few times too many. 6 The Galaxy S25 Edge on top of the iPhone 15 Pro Max Credit: Jamie Harris / The Sun Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge: Performance and software From a software and performance perspective, the Galaxy S25 Edge feels just like the other phones in the series. It runs on Samsung's own version of Android, One UI. One UI has a consistent, clean and easy look that I like. All the S25 devices run on Android 15, One UI 7, which is the very latest version of both, straight out of the box. And once again, Samsung offers a whooping seven years of security and software updates. Look after the handset it could last you quite sometime thereby saving you money on upgrades. Who offers free updates longest? The longer you receive updates, the longer you can safely continue using your smartphone - with the latest features thrown in too for free. Samsung For the Galaxy S25 series, Samsung said it would provide at least seven generations of OS updates and seven years of security updates. OnePlus At the launch of the OnePlus 13, OnePlus committed to at least four years of Android updates and six years of security updates. Xiaomi Xiaomi offers four years off Android updates and five years security updates. Google For the Pixel 9 series, Google said that devices would receive at least seven years of support. Like the other S25 devices, the Edge version uses the same powerful Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Elite chip on the inside to keep things running super smooth. As such, apps, games and anything else you throw at it glides through without any issue or lag. Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge: Features The Galaxy S25 Edge carries all the same great features as the other models too, with a large focus on AI tools this year. Samsung moved closer to Google and its Gemini digital assistant. Though not exclusive to Samsung, it's worth mentioning that Gemini is really handy - I was using it to identify problems with my plant the other day. As for Samsung's own newer features there's Now Brief, an AI companion that acts as a central hub for everything going on in your day. This keeps you in check with not only your calendar and weather but learns about your habits so will warn you about things such as traffic. Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge: Battery Now battery is the big one I was most curious about given that it's the part that takes up a lot of physical space in phones. Sticking to its nearest comparable sibling, the S25+, the battery on the Edge is smaller. The Edge has a 3,900 mAh, compared to the S25+'s 4,900 mAh. And seeing as I mentioned the iPhone 15 Plus before, it's worth noting that the battery there is 4,383 mAh. The battery and camera sacrifices are bold to say the least So, physically speaking the Edge is much lower. Samsung has done some performance optimising to get around this but there's still only so much they can do. With general on and off usage throughout my day - using apps like WhatsApp, checking emails, watching the odd video and going on social media - I could get a day out of it. But constant power users watching loads of videos probably won't make it through the day without help. What's more, the Galaxy S25 Edge doesn't charge as fast as it's sister handsets either. Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge: Camera The other big difference is on camera with only two on the back of the S25 Edge. There's no telephoto sensor to take clear photos from a distance - which is something you would expect from a phone that costs upward of a grand. But the 200-megapixel main camera and 12-megapixel ultrawide camera do manage to take some detailed pics popping with colour. 6 Snap from a recent holiday taken on the Galaxy S25 Edge Credit: Jamie Harris / The Sun 6 I zoomed in on a church in the distance - here is the normal distance and below you'll see the zoomed photo Credit: Jamie Harris / The Sun 6 The zoomed photo is pretty good given the distance but you do lose some quality Credit: Jamie Harris / The Sun Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge: Pricing The Galaxy S25 Edge starts from £1,099 / $1,099. But there is a new way to keep the cost of expensive phones down in the form of Samsung Club. For a lower monthly cost, you can get the latest Galaxy every year rather than buying outright each time, plus other perks. The Galaxy S25 Edge is the first phone being offered as part of the scheme from £33.31 per month.
Reuters
14 hours ago
- Reuters
Bitcoin falls 4% to $99,237
June 22 (Reuters) - Bitcoin, the world's largest cryptocurrency by market value, was down by 4.13% at $99,237 at 10:52 a.m. ET (1452 GMT) on Sunday. Ether, the second-largest cryptocurrency, was down by around 8.52% at $2,199.
