World coming up short on promised marine sanctuaries

Less than 10 per cent of the ocean has been designated as marine protected areas, despite the global target of 30 per cent by 2030. PHOTO: AFP
BREST, France - A global target of having 30 per cent of the oceans become protected areas by 2030 is looking more fragile than ever, with little progress and the US backing away, conservationists say.
'With less than 10 per cent of the ocean designated as MPAs (marine protected areas) and only 2.7 per cent fully or highly protected, it is going to be difficult to reach the 30 per cent target,' said Dr Lance Morgan, head of the Marine Conservation Institute in Seattle, Washington.
The institute maps the MPAs for an online atlas, updating moves to meet the 30 per cent goal that 196 countries signed onto in 2022, under the Kunling-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework.
The ambition is notably at risk because 'we see countries like the US reversing course and abandoning decades of bipartisan efforts' to protect areas of the Pacific Ocean, Dr Morgan said.
That referred to an April executive order by President Donald Trump authorising industrial-scale fishing in big swathes of an MPA in that ocean.
Currently, there are 16,516 declared MPAs in the world, covering just 8.4 per cent of the oceans.
But not all are created equal: some forbid all forms of fishing, while others place no roles, or almost none, on what activities are proscribed or permitted.
'Only a third of them have levels of protection that would yield proper benefits' for fish, said Dr Joachim Claudet, a socio-ecology marine researcher at France's CNRS.
Dr Daniel Pauly, a professor of fisheries science at Canada's University of British Columbia, said 'the marine protected areas have not really been proposed for the protection of biodiversity' but 'to increase fish catches'.
A proper MPA 'exports fish to non-protected zones, and that should be the main reason that we create marine protected areas – they are needed to have fish', he said.
When fish populations are left to reproduce and grow in protected areas, there is often a spillover effect that sees fish stocks outside the zones also rise, as several scientific journals have noted, especially around a no-fishing MPA in Hawaiian waters that is the biggest in the world.
One 2022 study in the Science journal showed a 54 per cent increase in yellowfin tuna around that Hawaiian MPA, an area now threatened by Mr Trump's executive order, Dr Pauly said.
For such sanctuaries to work, there needs to be fishing bans over all or at least some of their zones, Dr Claudet said.
But MPAs with such restrictions account for just 2.7 per cent of the ocean's area, and are almost always in parts that are far from areas heavily impacted by human activities.
In Europe, for instance, '90 per cent of the marine protected areas are still exposed to bottom trawling,' a spokesperson for the NGO Oceana, Alexandra Cousteau, said. 'It's ecological nonsense.'
Dr Pauly said that 'bottom trawling in MPAs is like picking flowers with a bulldozer... they scrape the seabed'.
Oceana said French MPAs suffered intensive bottom trawling, 17,000 hours' worth in 2024, as did those in British waters, with 20,600 hours.
The NGO is calling for a ban on the technique, which involves towing a heavy net along the sea floor, churning it up.
Governments need to back words with action, or else these areas would be no more than symbolic markings on a map, said the head of the World Wildlife Fund's European office for the oceans, Jacob Armstrong. AFP
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Straits Times

7 hours ago

• Straits Times

French scientists find new blood type in Guadeloupe woman

A woman from the Caribbean island of Guadeloupe is the only known carrier of a new blood type, dubbed 'Gwada negative". PHOTO: ISTOCKPHOTO BASSE-TERRE - A French woman from the Caribbean island of Guadeloupe has been identified as the only known carrier of a new blood type, dubbed 'Gwada negative', France's blood supply agency has announced. The announcement was made 15 years after researchers received a blood sample from a patient who was undergoing routine tests ahead of surgery, the French Blood Establishment (EFS) said on June 20. 'The EFS has just discovered the 48th blood group system in the world!' the agency said, in a statement on social network LinkedIn. 'This discovery was officially recognised in early June in Milan by the International Society of Blood Transfusion (ISBT).' The scientific association had until now recognised 47 blood group systems. Dr Thierry Peyrard, a medical biologist at the EFS involved in the discovery, told AFP that a 'very unusual' antibody was first found in the patient in 2011. However, resources at the time did not allow for further research, he added. Scientists were finally able to unravel the mystery in 2019 thanks to 'high-throughput DNA sequencing', which highlighted a genetic mutation, Dr Peyrard said. The patient, who was 54 at the time and lived in Paris, was undergoing routine tests before surgery when the unknown antibody was detected, Dr Peyrard said. This woman 'is undoubtedly the only known case in the world,' said the expert. 'She is the only person in the world who is compatible with herself,' he said. Dr Peyrard said the woman inherited the blood type from her father and mother, who each had the mutated gene. The name 'Gwada negative', which refers to the patient's origins and 'sounds good in all languages', has been popular with the experts, said Dr Peyrard. The ABO blood group system was first discovered in the early 1900s. Thanks to DNA sequencing, the discovery of new blood groups has accelerated in recent years. Dr Peyrard and colleagues are now hoping to find other people with the same blood group. 'Discovering new blood groups means offering patients with rare blood types a better level of care,' the EFS said. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

Straits Times

2 days ago

• Straits Times

Up to 50 times more microplastics in glass bottles than plastic, study shows

A researcher inspecting pieces of microplastic collected from the River Rhone in Arles, southern France. PHOTO: AFP Up to 50 times more microplastics in glass bottles than plastic, study shows PARIS – Drinks including water, soda, beer and wine sold in glass bottles contain more microplastics than those in plastic bottles, according to a surprising study released by France's food safety agency on June 20. Researchers have detected these tiny, mostly invisible pieces of plastic throughout the world, from the air we breathe to the food we eat, as well as riddled throughout human bodies. There is still no direct evidence that this preponderance of plastic is harmful to human health, but a burgeoning field of research is aiming to measure its spread. Dr Guillaume Duflos, research director at French food safety agency Anses, said the team sought to 'investigate the quantity of microplastics in different types of drinks sold in France and examine the impact different containers can have'. The researchers found an average of around 100 microplastic particles per litre in glass bottles of soft drinks, lemonade, iced tea and beer. That was five to 50 times higher than the rate detected in plastic bottles or metal cans. 'We expected the opposite result,' PhD student Iseline Chaib, who conducted the research, said. 'We then noticed that in the glass, the particles emerging from the samples were the same shape, colour and polymer composition – so therefore the same plastic – as the paint on the outside of the caps that seal the glass bottles,' she said. The paint on the caps also had 'tiny scratches, invisible to the naked eye, probably due to friction between the caps when they were stored', Anses said in a statement. This could then 'release particles onto the surface of the caps', it added. Wine fine For water, both flat and sparkling, the amount of microplastic was relatively low in all cases, ranging from 4.5 particles per litre in glass bottles to 1.6 particles in plastic. Wine also contained few microplastics – even glass bottles with caps. Dr Duflos said the reason for this discrepancy 'remains to be explained'. Soft drinks, however, contained around 30 microplastics per litre, lemonade 40 and beer around 60. Because there is no reference level for a potentially toxic amount of microplastics, it was not possible to say whether these figures represent a health risk, Anses said. But drink manufacturers could easily reduce the amount of microplastics shed by bottle caps, it added. The agency tested a cleaning method involving blowing the caps with air, then rinsing them with water and alcohol, which reduced contamination by 60 per cent. The study released by Anses was published online in the Journal of Food Composition and Analysis in May. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

Straits Times

14-06-2025

• Straits Times

Study shows mercury levels in arctic wildlife could rise for centuries

Previous research has shown that mercury can persist in oceans for more than 300 years. PHOTO: AFP Levels of mercury in Arctic wildlife could continue to rise significantly even as countries curb their emissions, a new study suggests. Researchers analysed more than 700 samples of fish, mammals and peat collected across Greenland over the past 40 years and found evidence that the mercury in them was distributed by ocean currents. The finding, published this week in the journal Nature Communications, helps explain why levels of mercury contamination have continued increasing in the Arctic even as global emissions have begun to plateau. 'We got a lot of surprises when we analysed the data,' said Dr Jens Sondergaard, a senior ecological science researcher at Aarhus University in Denmark and lead author of the study. 'It's a really striking trend.' Exposure to high concentrations of mercury, a potent neurotoxin, can lead to neurological and other health-related effects and the study confirms that mercury emitted today could continue posing a large threat to humans and wildlife in the region for centuries. By analysing mercury isotopes, a unique kind of chemical signature that can be matched like a fingerprint, the researchers traced the spread of mercury contamination to the patterns of ocean currents around Greenland. Previous research has shown that mercury can persist in oceans for more than 300 years. The results indicate that large, century-old stores of mercury in the ocean could actually be the dominant means by which the element proliferates through marine ecosystems in the Arctic, Dr Sondergaard said. This poses a problem for people who live in the region, particularly Inuit communities that hunt large marine mammals with high concentrations of mercury, like seals. 'It's a quite unique situation. This population that ought to be, you know, in a clean environment, has some of the highest concentrations,' said Professor Rune Dietz, a professor at Aarhus University and a co-author of the study. Mercury is primarily spread through the environment by human activities such as burning coal or mining heavy minerals, like gold. According to a 2023 estimate by researchers at the Harvard School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, atmospheric mercury concentrations have risen nearly sevenfold since the 1500s. Mercury emissions in North America and Europe began falling in the 1970s, following the enactment of a series of environmental regulations like the Clean Air Act. Other countries with high levels of pollution, like China and India, began curbing their emissions a little more than a decade ago, after signing a global agreement known as the Minamata Convention. Earlier this week, the Environmental Protection Agency began moving to loosen limits on mercury emissions, along with those on other pollutants, from power plants. There is no known safe level of methylmercury, the toxic form of mercury that can form in aquatic environments. In high bodily concentrations it can cause neurological problems, kidney damage and affect fetuses in the womb. Despite hosting almost no mercury-producing industries, the Arctic has become a hot spot of contamination, in part because of the natural pattern of the Earth's atmosphere and oceans, which tend to circulate pollutants toward higher latitudes. Large predators that eat significant amounts of contaminated prey end up ingesting the most mercury. Studies have shown that such marine mammals, like ring seals and pilot whales, can carry concentrations of mercury up to 50 times greater than some smaller fish, like herring. The new paper found that concentrations of mercury found in polar bear tissues have doubled in the last 40 years. Professor Niladri Basu, a professor of environmental health sciences at McGill University in Canada who was not affiliated with the study, said that Indigenous groups with hunting practices are most at risk for exposure to mercury. 'The species that drive exposure in communities are not species that are harvested for global transport and trade,' he said. Prof Basu added that mercury advisories have led to some Inuit communities cutting back on traditional food sources, representing a significant cultural loss. Emissions aren't the only mercury contamination threat in the Arctic. In 2024, a study found that the region's frozen soils, known as permafrost, have been accumulating mercury for centuries, reaching levels estimated to be higher than the atmosphere, oceans and life-forms combined. As climate change continues to warm the planet, scientists worry that these stores of mercury could be released. In November, international delegates will meet for the Minamata Convention's sixth major meeting. 2025 also presents the first deadline for the more than 120 countries who signed on to the treaty, to begin phasing out mercury use in certain types of production. Even in light of the global action on mercury, Prof Basu said, it could take centuries for the Arctic to recover. 'On one hand, we want to take action, and we have to recognise that mistakes are made and that we can't continue as business as usual,' he said. 'But on the other hand, we have to recognise that it's going to take a long, long time to undo all the damage.' NYTIMES Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.