Los Angeles wildfires were 10 times bigger than utility's AI forecast
FILE PHOTO: A drone view shows workers cleaning debris from destroyed homes for residents of the Eaton Fire in Altadena, California, U.S., March 10, 2025. REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Photo
FILE PHOTO: An aerial view of the fire damage caused by the Eaton Fire is shown in Altadena, California, U.S. January 22, 2025. REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Photo
Southern California Edison's internal wildfire forecasts underestimated the potential size of the Eaton Canyon fire in Los Angeles by a factor of ten in the days leading up to a deadly conflagration in January, according to documents reviewed by Reuters.
The miss suggests potential weaknesses in the utility's fire modeling capabilities that factored into its response to the January wildfire threats, despite being upgraded with improved computing, datasets and artificial intelligence.
At the time, wildfires whipsawed through Los Angeles' western flank near Santa Monica and Eaton Canyon in the east as they consumed more than 34,000 acres (13,750 hectares) - or some 53 square miles - turning entire neighborhoods to ash.
Although no official cause for the Eaton Canyon blaze has been released, numerous lawsuits have claimed SCE's decision to keep power flowing to some lines and towers in the Altadena area led to the circumstances that triggered it.
SCE has said the cause and circumstances around the fire are under investigation and will be for some time, and defended its modeling capabilities.
"We are confident with our fire spread modeling and weather forecasting," Raymond Fugere, SCE's asset intelligence director, told Reuters in an interview.
Fugere said SCE's simulations could have shown higher estimates for acres burned in hard-hit areas. Variations in wind patterns and available fuels in hard-hit areas may not have been fully accounted for in the fire spread modeling, he said.
"But overall, we do feel confident with our modeling because it is giving us very actionable information to be able to make decisions," he said.
SCE's simulations predicted a Jan. 7 ignition in Eaton Canyon that could scorch about 1,000 acres within eight hours without fire suppression, according to an SCE fire potential forecast obtained by Reuters through a public records request. SCE told Reuters those fire spread simulations were factored into the utility's power shutoff decisions as strong seasonal winds and dry conditions escalated the looming wildfire threat.
The Eaton fire ignited as forecast on Jan. 7, but ultimately consumed some 14,000 acres, destroying around 9,400 homes and buildings, and killing 17 civilians – making it the centerpiece of one of the costliest natural disasters in U.S. history.
Joseph Mitchell, a scientist and wildfire expert witness for California utility regulators, said SCE's predictions missed the mark mainly because its models were only running simulations that extend eight hours after an ignition. The bulk of the Eaton fire's damage happened well after the eight-hour mark.
Michael Wara, a wildfire policy expert at Stanford Law School, said the wildfire modeling may also have erred because it is better tuned to simulating fire in dense shrubs and woodlands, instead of blocks of homes and businesses.
"Altadena was a wildland fire for about 20 minutes, and then it became an urban conflagration ... where houses are burning houses down, and where gardens are the fuel type not ... mixed conifer forests," Wara said.
SCE, a unit of Edison International, acknowledged it is evaluating changes to its wildfire risk models, including whether to use 24-hour fire spread simulations in the future.
"The January 2025 wildfires raise important questions regarding the spread of wildfires into built urban environments," the company said in a May 16 filing with regulators.
SCE has previously acknowledged that 24-hour simulations might capture more extreme events where firefighting resources are limited, according to regulatory filings with the California Public Utilities Commission prior to the fires. But SCE's Fugere said the longer simulations produce more uncertainty.
UPGRADED MODELS
SCE's forecast was the biggest test yet of upgraded forecasting capabilities since California Governor Gavin Newsom launched the "Wildfire Innovation Sprint" in 2019 – an initiative to encourage the use of AI to predict disasters and safeguard lives and property.
Since then, SCE has built four supercomputer clusters capable of generating 13 billion simulations across 400 weather scenarios and 29 million ignition points, according to regulatory filings.
The company also began using the services of Technosylva, a La Jolla, California-based company, which received $383,000 in state funding in 2019 to develop forecasting tools for utilities and emergency responders.
Technosylva Chief Executive Bryan Spear told Reuters his company's risk models captured the magnitude of the Los Angeles wildfire five days in advance, allowing firefighters to make better preparations for the looming catastrophe.
SCE's equipment has not been blamed for starting the massive Palisades fire, but the utility's forecast also vastly underestimated its potential size. The separate blaze started on the same day as the Eaton Canyon fire.
SCE's forecast projected up to 1,000 acres burned in the Pacific Palisades area, according to the document.
Actual wildfire destruction there included 23,448 acres burned, 12 civilian deaths and nearly 7,000 structures destroyed, according to Cal Fire.
Together the Eaton and Palisades fires destroyed more than 16,000 structures and caused most of the $250 billion in economic losses estimated by AccuWeather.
SCE plans to spend another $8 million on upgrading fire science and modeling this year, up from $2 million in 2018, company disclosures show. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
Earthquake of magnitude 5.4 strikes near coast of Ecuador, GFZ says
Earthquake of magnitude 5.4 strikes near coast of Ecuador, GFZ says GUAYAQUIL - A magnitude 5.4 earthquake struck near the coast of Ecuador on Saturday, the German Research Centre for Geosciences (GFZ) said. The quake was at a depth of 44 km (27.34 miles), GFZ said. The tremor was felt in Guayaquil, Ecuador's largest city by population, though there were no immediate reports of damage. Key city systems were operating normally and inspections were ongoing to ensure public safety, the mayor of Guayaquil, Aquiles Alvarez, said in a post on social media. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
China warns of extensive flooding after heavy rains
Rescue workers evacuate residents stranded by floodwaters with a boat, following heavy rainfall in Huaiji county, Guangdong province, China on June 18, 2025. PHOTO: REUTERS BEIJING - Chinese authorities have warned of flash floods and swift currents in mountainous areas in the eastern, central, southern and south-western regions of the country after heavy rains there. The red alerts, the first for 2025, were issued late on June 19 covering areas in the provinces of Anhui, Henan, Hubei, Hunan, Guizhou and Guangxi region, state news agency Xinhua reported, citing the water resources ministry and national weather forecaster China Meteorological Administration. China is experiencing heavy and sudden rain in many parts, which meteorologists have attributed to climate change, leaving its huge population vulnerable to related disasters. In southern Hunan, heavy rainfall triggered the largest floods since 1998 in the upper and lower reaches of the Lishui River after its water levels breached the safety mark by more than 2m on June 19. In the hilly metropolis of south-western Chongqing, apartment blocks were submerged in muddy waters and some vehicles were swept away in flood waters gushing down streets, according to state broadcaster CCTV's footage and images from June 19. An image showed flood waters almost reaching the top of power cable lines. Water and power supply were also disrupted in some areas, CCTV said. Nearly 300 people were evacuated from towns and villages in Pengshui county, where cumulative daily rainfall had reached 304mm, and floods were made worse by precipitation from the mountains converging into the Ditang River which had swollen by 19m, according to CCTV. The water in several other rivers in Chongqing had also exceeded alert levels due to the extreme rainfall, Xinhua said. On June 18, power supply was disrupted in the city of Zhaoqing in southern Guangdong Province as floodwaters rose more than five metres above warning levels, breaking historical records, local media reported. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
Weather break and midday heat makes for difficult win for Palmeiras
Soccer Football - FIFA Club World Cup - Group A - Palmeiras v Al Ahly - MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford, New Jersey, U.S. - June 19, 2025 General view inside the stadium as the match is suspended due to adverse weather REUTERS/Susana Vera EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. - Palmeiras overcame a 50-minute weather interruption in their second game at the Club World Cup to beat Al Ahly of Egypt 2-0 at the MetLife Stadium and go to the top of the Group A table. But it was not the polished performance the Brazilian club's coach Abel Ferreira had hope for, as a midday kick off and then the severe weather delay made matters tough for his players before they secured victory to advance to four points and strengthen their chances of moving to the knockout stage. WHY IT'S IMPORTANT: South American clubs and their supporters traditionally attach much more importance to Club World Cup success than their European counterparts, and as one of the stronger of a four-team Brazilian contingent, Palmeiras carry a burden of expectation. They started the tournament with a goalless draw on Sunday against FC Porto, the other favourites in the group, and needed a win on Thursday over the record African champions to bolster their hopes KEY QUOTES: Palmeiras coach Abel Ferreira: 'We had a difficult opponent and I thought we played better in our first match against Porto. In terms of the flow of the game, we were better against Porto but today we had to take into consideration the weather. "The midday kick off impacted on our players and we weren't able to be as dynamic. But in the second half we adjusted a little bit and played a better game.' Al Ahly coach Jose Riveiro: 'It was an equal first half and we felt a goal could come for us at any time and that we had the game under control. "But in the second half we didn't have that good a half. We tried to go again after the weather break with different options and fresh legs but it didn't work out.' REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
