Joe Hart reveals what REALLY happened when Carlos Tevez refused to come on for Man City against Bayern Munich... and claims treatment of his old team-mate was 'unfair' after infamous clash with Roberto Mancini
Joe Hart has offered a fresh take on one of Manchester City 's most explosive controversies — claiming Carlos Tevez was wrongly portrayed as the villain in his infamous row with Roberto Mancini during a Champions League game in 2011.
The incident unfolded during a group-stage clash with Bayern Munich in September of that year, when then-manager Mancini accused Tevez of refusing to come on as a substitute with City trailing 2-0.
The Argentine forward had already been left on the bench in the previous league game and was clearly unhappy, but the fallout stunned the football world.
Mancini told Sky Sports post-match: 'He refused to come on. One player refused to go on – I can't accept this.' The Italian added that Tevez was 'finished' at the club.
Tevez denied flatly refusing to play, insisting: 'I had warmed up and was ready… I wish to state that I never refused to play.'
Despite that, he was suspended, placed on extended leave and did not appear again for the club until March 2012.
Now, more than a decade later, Hart has reflected on the chaos of that night in Germany — and believes the truth behind the row was more complex than it appeared from the outside.
'The whole drama surrounding Carlos during that Bayern Munich game, I felt was very unfair,' Hart said on BBC podcast Football Daily.
'I think Carlos did make himself available to come on the pitch, but he was asked to warm up, having already warmed up for 20 or 25 minutes, and then he was asked to warm up again to come on. I'm pretty sure he said, "I am warm."
Hart, who was City's No 1 at the time, believes the chaos stemmed from a combustible clash of personalities and poor communication on both sides.
He added: 'Both very, very hostile characters, which was part of why they were both good at what they did, but at that moment it clashed and it didn't work well.
'Mancini was very aggressive, very animated. He had a go at Edin [Dzeko] for some reason. Dzeko didn't really know what was going on, but it was like, "whatever".
'And then he went wild at Carlos. Both in broken English, didn't really understand each other. And I could see Carlos trying to find out what was being said to him. When he realised what had been said to him, he felt really wronged.
'It was a classic case of two alpha males having a different version of the same event and neither being able to say, look, we both need to calm down here and just sort this out — because they were both right to an extent.'
Despite being cast aside, Tevez returned later that season and helped City dramatically secure their first Premier League title in May 2012.
Now 41, Tevez was back in the spotlight at Old Trafford last weekend as he produced a headline-grabbing display at Soccer Aid.
Former City team-mate Joe Hart also took part in last weekend's charity game at Old Trafford
The former United and City striker scored four goals in 15 minutes to help the World XI overturn a two-goal deficit and beat England 5-4 in the charity game.
He was loudly booed before he'd even kicked a ball — a reflection of lingering resentment among Manchester United fans after his acrimonious 2009 switch to rivals City.
Tevez, who won six trophies at United including two Premier League titles and the Champions League, famously featured on a 'Welcome to Manchester' billboard after making the move across town.
At Soccer Aid, he revelled in the pantomime villain role — cupping his ear and showing off the back of his shirt after each goal.
He was also booked for cynically dragging down Aaron Lennon late on — with the referee playfully allowing Lennon to show him the yellow card — and clashed with YouTuber Angry Ginge, who was left with a nasty gash on his leg after a crunching collision.
Ginge later posted a photo of the wound on social media with the caption: 'Cheers, Tevez, t***'.
Hart also featured at Soccer Aid last week, starting for the England XI at Old Trafford.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Marc Guehi 'prepared to see out Crystal Palace contract' amid interest from Liverpool, Spurs and Newcastle
is said to be willing to bide his time at Crystal Palace despite widespread interest in his signature from elsewhere. Guehi was courted by Newcastle United last summer but Palace rejected an offer worth around £50million, before Tottenham Hotspur failed with a bid in January. Both Newcastle and Spurs remain keen on the 24-year-old centre back, while Liverpool are also now listed among his admirers. But according to The Guardian, Guehi is prepared to see out his Palace contract, which is due to expire at the end of June 2026. That might not suit the decision makers at Selhurst Park, though, as it would likely mean losing their star man on a free transfer. Guehi — who has been capped 23 times by England and is expected to play a crucial role at next year's World Cup — featured in 35 of Palace's 38 Premier League matches last season. The former Chelsea academy star also played in all six of Palace's games in their triumphant FA Cup campaign, including the 1-0 win over Manchester City in the final. Liverpool's interest may intensify following the expected departure of Jarell Quansah to Bayer Leverkusen. But Guehi is among several defenders being monitored by the Reds. Meanwhile, Tottenham's need for a new centre back could hinge on whether Cristian Romero stays or leaves this summer. It is no secret that the Argentina star is wanted by Atletico Madrid.
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Tyreek Hill gives vulgar verdict on Buffalo Bills players amid feud with team
Tyreek Hill has offered a brutal verdict on Buffalo Bills players as he continued his feud with the team. The wide receiver has previously called the team's fans 'stupid as hell' and claimed they had CTE because of their propensity to jump through tables. And the wide receiver had more fighting words for the franchise on Saturday at Fanatics Fest as he referred to their players as 'a bunch of b****es.' Speaking about the way they set up defensively, Hill reportedly said: 'Whenever we play the Bills, those guys typically play Cover Four because they're a bunch of b****es.' Cover 4 is a zone-style defense that aims to prevent deep completions down the field. And that strategy has mostly kept Hill in check, as he's averaged just 57.7 receiving yards in six games against Buffalo while playing for Miami. Hill has mostly been kept in check by the Bills while suiting up for the Miami Dolphins In fact, the speedy receiver has never topped 100 yards against the Bill dating back to his time with the Chiefs. Hill previously criticized Bills supporters when asked by streamer Adin Ross if there was a fanbase he disliked. 'I don't f*** with the Bills. F*** — every time we — bro, when I used to play in Kansas City, bro it was always "f*** the Bills" every time we played against them. And we f***ed them up every time,' he said. Hill had a down year in 2024 as he dealt with a wrist injury, failing to top 1,000 yards for the first time since 2019 (when he played just 12 games). However, he still believed in his speed enough to agree to race Olympic sprinter Noah Lyles in a 100-meter race. The competition had been in the works for months but Lyles revealed this week that he had pulled out of the race for 'personal reasons. 'We were very deep into creating the event. In fact, it was supposed to happen this weekend,' Lyles said from Stagwell's Sport Beach at Cannes Lions on Monday. 'Unfortunately there were some things, complications, personal reasons that it just didn't come to pass, but we were full on. 'We were gonna have a big event, we were going to shut down New York Times Square and everything, we were gonna have all the billboards for the event, it was going to be a lot of fun.' Hill, who recently posted a 10.15-second 100-meter performance at the Last Chance Sprint Series, subsequently took to social media to mock the gold medalist sprinter. First, the former Super Bowl champion posted the famous Homer Simpson meme, showing the beloved Simpsons character disappearing into some bushes alongside the caption: '[Lyles] after seeing me race last weekend.' Hill also posted pictures of himself on a track with a sign reading: 'Noah Could Never.'
Daily Record
22 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Benjamin Nygren signs for Celtic as bargain transfer fee, contract details and stunning scouting report emerge
Celtic are set to snap up the Sweden international in a cut-price deal but could be quids in further down the line according to Marc Rieper. Benjamin Nygren has been hailed as the 'full package' after sealing an initial £1.3m move to Celtic on a four-year deal with an option until 2030. The winger has agreed a cut-price movefrom Danish side Nordsjaelland, with official confirmation expected in the coming days, as Brendan Rodgers beefs up his attacking options. And according to former Hoops hero Marc Rieper the Parkhead club are getting top class talent who will coin in a massive profit further down the line. Nygren netted 16 goals across all competitions last season and his form didn't go unnoticed back home, earning him a first senior call-up under Sweden boss Jon Dahl Tomasson in March. He has since won four caps and scored twice for his country. Now the 23-year-old, currently on holiday, looks set to complete his move to Parkhead and have a first crack at the Champions League after snubbing interest from Anderlecht, Copenhagen and the MLS. And Denmark legend Rieper told Mail Sport: 'I've seen Nygren a number of times. He is the full package. A really good player. 'He has tremendous speed, good passing ability and is a really, really good finisher - and from long range. 'When you play for Nordsjaelland you need to be able to keep the ball and he is really good in that sense. 'Celtic have got a really good player in Nygren. He is top class.' Nygren was one of the Danish Sperliga's most effective attacking threats over the last two seasons and had interest from across Europe a year ago. With just six months left on his contract at Nordsjaelland the Danes have accepted the knockdown fee rather than lose the player for nothing in December. But Rieper expects Celtic will make a huge profit on Nygren further down the line - with the former defender tipping him to be the latest star to become a £10m-plus player at Parkhead. He said: 'If you do well at Celtic and in Europe then you are very easily a £10million-plus player. 'The way prices are going in Italy, Germany and the Premier League then £10million - as ridiculous as it is to say - is not even a big number any more. 'Look at Matt O'Riley, he's on the verge of leaving Brighton for crazy money as well. I think they will make a good profit on Nygren one day. 'He is a young player and he has got really good ability. But they can look forward to enjoying him in a Celtic shirt for the next few years first.' Tune in to Hotline Live every Sunday to Thursday and have your say on the biggest issues in Scottish football and listen to Record Sport's newest podcast, Game On, every Friday for your sporting fix, all in bitesize chunks.
