Smartphone bans have little to no impact on education or bullying, study finds
Smartphone bans have little or no impact on education, online bullying and wellbeing among students, according to a study by Dublin City University (DCU).
Last week, new national guidance was issued to schools on restricting mobile phone use.
Primary schools now require a policy to ban the use of and access to mobile phones during the school day, while secondary schools require a policy to restrict mobile phone use during the school day.
€9 million in funding has been allocated for schools to look at a range of storage storage solutions including lockable boxes, cubby holes or drop-off and collection at the school office.
It followed opposition criticism of a plan to fund "phone pouches" across secondary schools.
Researchers from DCU's Anti-Bullying Centre found that the stricter the phone ban, the more students look for ways to subvert it.
A report published on Wednesday looked at existing international research as well as a new Irish study on the experiences of students.
In the DCU report, researchers examined existing international research on smartphone bans and related research on smartphones among children and adolescents.
It finds that that international research is "clearly mixed and somewhat conflicting", with most studies showing that smartphone ban policies can have "little or no impact on education and wellbeing among students" in different countries.
The study finds that no current research can be said to definitively demonstrate that smartphone bans completely protect children and adolescents from online bullying or harmful content.
The Anti-Bullying Centre is also recommending that online safety and digital citizenship education should be a compulsory topic in schools.
Researchers also conducted focus groups in six schools in the east of the country.
Students reported that they were not taught enough in school about online safety and digital citizenship, leading them instead to rely on their peers for guidance and skills.
Some pupils also reported that teachers cause distractions to the learning environment with their phone use.
Others were concerned that smartphone bans may inhibit students from learning resilience and skills for life beyond school.
The report also found that students' voices have not been included in decision-making on smartphone restrictions within schools.
Lead author of the report, Dr Megan Reynolds, said: "Our research shows that we need to listen to students on issues that directly impact them and ensure that they are included in the decision-making process regarding policies on smartphone bans and related issues.
"My hope is that this research will allow adolescents to finally have their voices heard and it will provide an opportunity for more nuanced conversations on smartphones."
Director of DCU Anti-Bullying Centre and Unesco chair on Bullying and Cyberbullying, Professor James O'Higgins Norman, added: "Students have also indicated that there are more pressing issues for students than smartphones in schools that they believe require action, including vaping."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
DCU researchers work on wearable sensors for stroke patients
Wearable sensors for stroke patients and chip-based cancer tumour simulations feature in a new €1 million transatlantic Dublin City University (DCU)-Arizona State University (ASU) research collaboration. The four-year projects have been funded in a new joint PhD programme, which marks the latest stage in a longstanding collaboration between the two universities. Researchers in Dublin and Tempe, Arizona are working to develop a lightweight wearable sensor system which could enable greater personalised care and home-based recovery for stroke patients, through precise brain and muscle activity data. The system will feature a brain and muscle imaging technique that uses light to measure brain activity more efficiently than large scanning equipment used in medical settings. By engineering ultra-thin artificial surfaces known as metasurfaces, sometimes thinner than the wavelength of light, it is possible to greatly reduce the size of imaging technology. Another team will use advanced 3D chip-based modelling of cancerous tumours to unravel how specific gene mutations in certain proteins make triple negative breast cancer harder to treat. The team will use these models to screen different drugs and identify new biomarkers to develop therapies that can restore precision to treatment in hard-to-treat breast cancers. The first project is led by Dr Shirley Coyle from DCU and Dr Sui Yang from ASU's Biodesign Institute, while the second features Dr Alex Eustace and Dr Paul Buchanan from DCU and Dr Mehdi Nikkah and Dr Jin Parks on the ASU side. "These innovative projects exemplify the mission of the ASU-DCU Collaborative Doctoral Programme - to tackle urgent global health challenges through world-class, interdisciplinary research," said Professor Nick Dunne, Executive Director of DCU Biodesign Europe. Professor Joshua La Baer, Executive Director of the ASU Biodesign Institute said it is committed to accelerating discoveries that improve human health, and that requires bold, collaborative science. "This programme with DCU creates exactly the kind of international, interdisciplinary environment where breakthrough ideas can thrive," Professor La Baer said.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Stroke survivors offered hope of ‘tailored' rehab at home thanks to Irish research
Irish researchers are working on developing a lightweight, wearable sensor system which will give new hope to stroke survivors and allow them more personally tailored rehabilitation at home.
Extra.ie
21 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Kerry Condon: 'Champagne was all I knew about F1'
Banshees of Inisherin star Kerry Condon admits she knew little to nothing about Formula One before her lead role in the Brad Pitt F1 film. Condon stars alongside Pitt in the new blockbuster F1, opening in Irish cinemas this week. The 42-year-old received an Oscar nomination for her role as Siobhán, the long-suffering sister of Colm Farrell's character, in The Banshees of Inisherin. She is also known for playing Octavia in the hit HBO series Rome (2005-2007); Stacey Ehrmantraut in Better Call Saul (2015-2022); and as the voice of the AI entity F.R.I.D.A.Y. in various films in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Kerry Condon in F1 Pic: Warner Bros/Apple But she says the learning curve for her latest role was so steep, she thought she would have to go and get a degree in aerodynamics. 'I didn't know anything about Formula One, not a thing at all. I only knew about the podium and the champagne celebrations. That was the height of my knowledge. 'I had to learn a lot. about the engineering side of making the car and the physics of it. I got to a certain point where I said, 'I have to go to college to learn this properly!'' But instead, Condon wisely focused on 'the particular scenes that I was in' and explained to the audience what was going on, so if you are not a Formula One fan, you'll understand what is happening in the movie. Kerry has been nominated for an Oscar for her previous work. Pic: Rob Latour/Shutterstock 'So trying to walk that fine line between being very normal with a lot of the terminology, but yet in a way that people will understand.' Over the past 20 years, Condon has established herself as one of the most sought-after character actors in Hollywood, but the Tipperary star said she only now feels comfortable in her new role as a 'leading lady? acting opposite Brad Pitt' no less. Speaking this week ahead of the release of F1, Condon said she felt confident taking on the leading lady role in what is set to be this year's big summer blockbuster. Brad Pitt and Damson Idris in F1 Pic: Warner Bros/Apple 'I can be a character actress, but I can also be a leading lady? It wasn't a fluke, I got an Oscar nomination [for Banshees], and I felt I was up for acting opposite Brad Pitt. I think I've enough experience. I think I know what I'm doing,' she said during an interview with the US showbiz platform Entertainment Tonight. In F1, Condon plays Kate McKenna, race director of the fictional APX GP team and the first female technical director in Formula One. Her character is influenced by Northern Ireland's Bernie Collins, a former Formula One strategy engineer. Condon has also revealed she and Hollywood A-lister Pitt share 'a bit of romance' in the movie. Appearing on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert this week, she shot the host a suggestive look when he asked if depicting a romance with Pitt's character was 'part of the draw' for her to take part in the new movie. 'They scheduled it for half eight on a Thursday morning,' she said of her call time for those scenes with Pitt. 'I was like, 'Ah, come on.' So I had a vodka orange juice for my breakfast that morning. 'We were supposed to be in Vegas on a night out or whatever,' she added, before telling Colbert: 'You're giving it all away!'' And at a red-carpet event this week, the down-to-earth Thurles-born star gave a rather Irish answer when asked to reveal her most memorable moment during the high-profile, global blockbuster shoot. Instead of nights out or parties with fellow cast members, which also include Javier Bardem and Damson Idris, Condon recalled walking around casinos in Las Vegas at 5 am when filming had finished, 'drinking tea' that cost $15 (€13). She also rubbished reports circulating online that she is about to return to the Marvel Cinematic Universe in a real-life reprise of her F.R.I.D.A.Y. character in the upcoming Disney series, Vision Quest. 'It's not true!' Condon said emphatically. 'I saw [the reports], and I was like, 'Who's saying this?!' It's not true, no, no, no? 'I wouldn't say absolutely 'no chance', but at the moment it's not in the cards for me.'
