Ryan Murphy's JFK Jr., Carolyn Bessette first look slammed by critics
Ryan Murphy has his work cut out for him.
The 'American Horror Story' creator, 59, took to Instagram over the weekend to share a first look at the actors portraying John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in his upcoming 'American Love Story' anthology series.
'Here are some stills from our LOVE STORY camera test,' Murphy wrote on Saturday, June 14. 'We started shooting this week in New York City and can't wait until you see the romantic and tragic love story between America's prince, JFK Jr., and fashion icon Carolyn Bessette.'
Advertisement
10 Ryan Murphy took to Instagram to share a first look at the actors portraying John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in his upcoming 'American Love Story' series.
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
10 But not everybody was impressed by the first look at Murphy's 'American Love Story.'
Getty Images
He then introduced fans to Paul Kelly (JFK Jr.) and Sarah Pidgeon (CBK).
Advertisement
'I am thrilled to introduce you to Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn and Paul Kelly as John F. Kennedy Jr,' Murphy continued. 'Over a thousand actors auditioned for each of these roles, and we absolutely found the perfect choices.'
However, not everybody was impressed by the first look at 'American Love Story,' and some fans slammed the 'Glee' producer for his surprising casting and costume design choices.
10 Paul Kelly has been cast as JFK Jr. and Sarah Pidgeon will portray CBK.
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
10 'There was nobody else who could play Carolyn?!' one disappointed person wrote.
Getty Images
Advertisement
'There was nobody else who could play Carolyn?!' one disappointed commenter wrote alongside the eight stills of Kelly as JFK Jr. and Pidgeon as CBK.
'She would never wear this,' another responded after seeing Pideon dressed in a leather overcoat, a black sweater, trousers and pointed-toe heels.
'Her blonde hair is all wrong,' wrote a third fan. 'She was famous for the varying blonde tones, the highlights and lowlights. It should be warmer. Not platinum. Please try again.'
10 Paul Kelly as JFK Jr. in 'American Love Story.'
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
Advertisement
10 'JFK Jr was gorgeous, this guy is average,' a critic wrote.
Getty Images
Other fans were equally disappointed to see how Murphy had Kelly portray JFK Jr. in the first look at 'American Love Story.'
'Her yes, him no,' one critic wrote. 'JFK Jr was gorgeous, this guy is average.'
'Usually the actors are better looking than the real people,' another JFK Jr. and CBK fan tweeted. 'The opposite is true here. Both are not good looking enough as the real people. How sad!'
'I think maybe Ryan Murphy should be stopped,' added a third, while a fourth commented, 'Ryan needs to take a break, seriously.'
10 Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in 'American Love Story.'
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
10 Other fans praised Kelly as JFK Jr. and Pidgeon as CBK.
Getty Images
However, some fans praised Kelly as the political prince and Pidgeon as the '90s fashion icon.
Advertisement
'Casting looks great,' someone wrote on Murphy's post. 'In terms of look-alikes, Elizabeth Debicki would've also been a great choice.'
'Wow, I knew who they were before even reading the caption,' added another impressed viewer.
While 'American Love Story' was first announced in 2021, it wasn't until September 2024 that Murphy revealed the first installment would chronicle JFK Jr. and CBK's whirlwind romance.
10 Paul Kelly as JFK Jr. in 'American Love Story.'
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
Advertisement
10 'American Love Story' will chronicle the rise and tragic fall of JFK Jr. and CBK's whirlwind romance.
Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images
JFK Jr., who was the only son of President John F. Kennedy and former First Lady Jackie Kennedy, first met Bessette in 1992. Bessette was working for Calvin Klein at the time and was tasked with giving the political scion a tour and fitting.
The pair married in September 1996.
Advertisement
Three years later, JFK Jr. and CBK both died when their private plane crashed off the coast of Massachusetts during a flight from New Jersey to Martha's Vineyard in July 1999.
Besides Kelly and Pidgeon, 'American Love Story' will also star Naomi Watts (Jackie Kennedy), Grace Gummer (Caroline Kennedy), Sydney Lemmon (Lauren Bessette) and Alessandro Nivola (Calvin Klein).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Days of Our Lives Recap: Bo and Hope Celebrate Their Love
Days of Our Lives Recap: Bo and Hope Celebrate Their Love originally appeared on Daytime Confidential. On today's Days of Our Lives recap: Horton House – Present Day: Hope serves Bo breakfast in bed. He asks about why things changed in the house, and she tells him about the fire. Julie new their grandparents would have wanted it that way. Horton House – Early Days: Alice and Tom are discussing a washing machine having gone on the fritz. He says he has good news and tells her about running into Addie at the hospital because she's pregnant (Julie!). Horton House – Present Day: Hope wishes her father were still alive so he could see them together. Bo is certain he can see them ad Hope agrees. She asks her beloved if he is ready to become a full-time grandpa. He says he is and they engage in a kiss. Bo and Hope come downstairs and he is amazed there was ever a fire. She says not everything was replaced such as the scrap book she made her grandparents for their anniversary and the letter she wrote him on the day of their wedding. Flashback: Hope giving her grandparents the scrap book. Flashback: Hope reciting the letter to Bo. Horton House – Present Day: Hope tells Bo about the time capsule they found after the fire. She says Ciara Alice was the one to open it. Hope was amazed by all the treasures and how it made everyone feels so much closer to her grandparents. Bo thinks you can almost see Doc and Mrs H standing there, watching over them. Bo is amazed he is a part of this amazing family with his sketchy history and working-class family. Hope stops him and says he was and always will be a rebel. Bo notes getting his ornament on the Horton tree and is relieved to learn they survived the fire. Flashback: Bo and Hope kissing after putting his ornament on the tree. Horton House – Present Day: Hope recalls when they added another ornament to the tree when Shawn Douglas was born. She looks back at pictures of her grandparents when she remembers telling her gran she was pregnant. Flashback: Hope tells Alice she's pregnant. Flashback: Alice gives them the ornament for their new child. Horton House – Early Days: Tom and Alice have returned from him reading the Christmas Story at University Hospital. They look at their perfect tree and the family ornaments decorating the branches. Alice can't believe they are grandparents and quotes her own grandmother by saying their grandchildren are their pots of gold. Horton House – Present Day: Hope thinks back to when Julie started dating her father and how jealous she was. Alice helped her see the goodness in her half-sister and how good she was with her father. Bo sees a lot of Mrs H in Hope, and she wonders if she will help her grandchildren get out of tight spots the same way her grandmother helped them. Bo full-heartedly believes she will. Flashback: Alice, Hope and Bo on one of their many adventures. Horton House – Present Day: Hope notes how quiet the house is and Bo says he cleared folks out so they could be alone. He sends her off to put on something special (which he bought for her) as he has a celebration planned. Horton House – Early Days: Alice trips over one of Steven's toys. Tom is right by her side and says he had Bill and Marie take the grandchildren to the movies. They will be gone for about two hours which will give them time to turn the lights down and get romantic. With that, they kiss. Horton House – Present Day: Hope descends the stairs in a beautiful gown to find her beloved all suited up. She looks around and sees the living room has been set up for the occasion of their reunion. She is so grateful to have Bo back. He says he will never leave her side again. Bo wants to make Hope his wife again and she is in full agreement. With that, he takes a knee and asks his Fancy Face to marry him all over again and she says yes. Flashback: Hope and Bo are alone and speaking wedding vows from the heart. Bo puts the ring on Hope's finger. She says it's just like their love, a perfect circle that's never ending. Horton House – Present Day: Bo declares his love for his Fancy Face and takes her to be his wife now and forever. Hope declares her love for Bo today, tomorrow and always. Bo presents a ring box to Hope where she finds her mother's wedding ring. He places it on her finger, and she pronounces them married. With that, they kiss and embrace. Bo says he has one more surprise and pulls out a picture of the Fancy Face. Hope notes it belongs to Shawn Douglas. Bo says their son doesn't have much use for it at this moment and it is once again their ticket to sail away. Flashback: Bo and Hope the Fancy Face where they declare their love for one another. Horton House – Present Day: Hope can't believe Bo wants them to leave Salem so soon. He thinks living life as an adventure has always been their best look. Bo continues saying they need to live each moment as if it's their last. Hope gets on board thinking about all the folks around the world they can see. She is on board as long as they can return to Salem quite often. Bo agrees and the decision is made. Horton House – Early Days: Alice remarks to Tom how quiet the house is. She is surprised to note how she misses the chaos. Alice wonders if they should sell the house and move someplace smaller. Tom wants nothing of the sort, and they agree to stay put. They agree 545 Sycamore Lane will be the Horton House forever and generations to come. With that, they kiss. Horton House - Present Day: Bo thinks they should follow in Doug and Julie's footsteps by retiring at the Horton House. Horton Square: Bo and Hope sit next to Tom and Alice's plaque. They think about how hard it always is to say goodbye. Flashback: Bo and Hope's adventures in and out of Salem throughout the years (such great flashbacks). Horton Square: Bo and Hope say goodbye to Salem. Keep checking back for the latest Days of Our Lives recaps! This story was originally reported by Daytime Confidential on Jun 19, 2025, where it first appeared.
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Country music star Kacey Musgraves postpones show after breaking a rib: ‘This s‑‑t is no joke'
Kacey Musgraves has shared some startling news. The 36-year-old country music star took to Instagram on Friday, June 20, to announce that she had to postpone a show scheduled for Sunday in Nashville because she broke a rib in Mexico earlier this week. 'Sooo, I'm in Mexico with a f‑‑king broken rib,' Musgraves wrote on her Instagram Stories alongside an X-ray image of her torso. 'Wednesday night it was raining and I was running to grab some towels and had an extremely hard fall on some very slick tile I didn't see.' Advertisement 6 Kacey Musgraves had to postpone a show scheduled for Sunday night in Nashville because she broke a rib in Mexico. Getty Images 6 The country music star shared a picture of her X-ray with fans on social media. spaceykacey/Instagram 'Thankful I didn't smack my head but I landed very hard on my back left ribcage and broke rib number six,' she continued. 'This s‑‑t is no joke. I'm in a lot of pain and doing ANYTHING is extremely difficult. But I'm managing and being well taken care of.' Advertisement The 'Follow Your Arrow' hitmaker then apologized for having to reschedule her concert at Sing for Science's 'The Magic of Mushrooms' event at the Ryman Auditorium on Sunday night. 'There is no physical way I can get on a plane and fly back to Nashville for the Sing for Science event,' Musgraves said. 'I am extremely bummed to have to reschedule as I have been looking forward to this for months.' 6 'Sooo, I'm in Mexico with a f‑‑king broken rib,' Musgraves wrote on her Instagram Stories. spaceykacey/Instagram 'But there is literally no other option,' she added. 'I'm so sorry for the inconvenience.' Advertisement The event has been rescheduled for Sept. 18, according to Musgraves, and original tickets will be honored for the new date. 'Fans have up to 30 days if they can't make it to the new date,' she concluded her message. 6 'I am extremely bummed to have to reschedule as I have been looking forward to this for months,' the Grammy-winning artist said. Christopher Peterson / 6 Musgraves revealed that she slipped and 'landed very hard on my back left ribcage' and 'broke rib number six.' spaceykacey/Instagram Advertisement The Post has reached out to the country singer's rep for comment. Musgraves' shocking injury this week comes months after the 'Deeper Well' artist made headlines for her 'pissed' reaction at the 2025 Grammy Awards in February. Although 'Deeper Well' was nominated for Best Country Album, Musgraves lost out to Beyoncé's 'Cowboy Carter' record. 6 The event has been rescheduled for Sept. 18, according to Musgraves, and original tickets will be valid for the new date. WWD via Getty Images 'Is Kacey Musgraves mad that Beyoncé won?' one viewer wrote after the 'Slow Burn' singer's reaction went viral. 'She sure looks it.' 'Kacey musgraves is looking pissed after losing to beyonce,' another person tweeted. However, Musgraves later broke her silence to shut down the rumors that she was mad about losing the Grammy Award for Best Country Album to the 43-year-old superstar. 'It's a sensationalistic false narrative meant to pit two talented female artists against each other,' her rep responded in a statement. 'There was simply no scowl or expression made.'
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Meghan Markle Reacts to As Ever Restock Selling Out Again
Meghan Markle's second collection of products from her As ever brand sold out on the first day of availability, and she reacted on Instagram Fans still have a chance to purchase the brand's first-ever alcohol product, As ever rosé, which will be available on July 1 As ever's first line of food items sold out in under an hour on April 2Meghan Markle is heading into the weekend on a high note. The Duchess of Sussex's As ever brand had its second-ever drop of products on Friday, June 20, restocking teas, flower sprinkles and other items that sold out in under an hour when they debuted on April 2. But once again, the products sold out. A post on As ever's Instagram page said, "Cheers, dears! Wishing you a wonderful weekend! You've certainly made ours wonderful. We sold out…again!" Meghan, 43, reacted to the news by sharing the post on her personal Instagram page with the note, "Sip sip hooray!" along with a sun emoji. Just hours earlier, the Duchess of Sussex shared a video to her Instagram Stories encouraging anyone debating a purchase to act fast. "We spent so much time making sure we had so much more inventory, that's why we took the time, and you guys are doing it again," she said. "We're nearly sold out on everything, and I can't believe it." Meghan added that even flower sprinkles, which she made sure to have extra inventory of, were almost sold out at the time. "Thanks, everybody!" she said at the end of the clip. For those who missed out, there's another chance to own a piece of As ever in the coming weeks. Along with Friday's product drop came the announcement of Meghan's first-ever alcoholic offering from the brand. A rosé wine from Napa Valley will go on sale July 1 at 8 a.m. PT/11 a.m. ET. According to the product description, "With soft notes of stone fruit, gentle minerality and a lasting finish, this bespoke blend is launching just in time for summer entertaining." In addition to favorites from the debut drop, As ever's second batch of products included two new items: an apricot spread and orange blossom honey. The apricot spread, which sold out at $9 for the jar or $14 for the jar in keepsake packaging, "balances a delicate sweetness and a gentle brightness that lets this beautiful stone fruit shine," according to the product's description. "Spoon it over yogurt, swipe it onto toast or nestle it into a cake," the description continues. "Beautifully packaged in our signature glass jar with our emblematic brushed gold lid, this delightful addition to your home is presented in keepsake packaging that is crafted to look beautiful on any counter or kitchen shelf." The orange blossom honey, which sold for for $28, boasts a "beautiful golden hue, an enticing aroma, delicate floral notes and subtle citrus undertones." Can't get enough of PEOPLE's Royals coverage? to get the latest updates on Kate Middleton, Meghan Markle and more! The other products included in the sold-out summer sale were herbal hibiscus tea ($12), herbal lemon ginger tea ($12), herbal peppermint tea ($12), crepe baking mix ($14), shortbread cookie mix ($14) and flower sprinkles ($15). Read the original article on People
