'Flying On A Dreamliner? I'm On': Ex Aviation Minister Praful Patel After Crash

New Delhi:
There is no cause for worry after the Air India crash in Ahmedabad and if he was asked to fly on a Boeing 787 Dreamliner today, he would say yes immediately because the airline has a sound technical grounding and the country's aviation regulatory framework is strong, former civil aviation minister Praful Patel has said.
Speaking exclusively to NDTV on Friday, the NCP MP also said, however, that there is a need for better communication from airlines as well as the aviation watchdog and all vacancies should be filled up because, when it comes to flying, "it's either 100% safe or zero, there's nothing like 99.9%".
On the pace of the investigation after last week's Dreamliner crash in which at least 270 people were killed, including over 30 on the ground, Mr Patel said it has been satisfactory because a team from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) team in the US, teams from Boeing and GE, which manufactured the engines of the plane, and India's own Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) visited the site almost immediately and took charge.
Based on his experience as the civil aviation minister between 2004 and 2011, the investigation, he said, should be completed within three months but could take longer because all possible scenarios should be ruled out.
Mr Patel said the AAIB is very competent and the damaged black box of the AI 171 could be decoded in India itself, but there is no harm if this happens in the US either. "It doesn't really matter whether it's being opened in the US or it's being decoded in India. At the end of the day, what we really want to know is what went wrong," he said.
Air India Safety
Mr Patel pointed out that instances of flights being cancelled or having a technical issue happen every day, and are being amplified now because of the crash.
"Air India, irrespective of the ownership today or in the past, has always been completely safety driven, protocol driven. They follow every single process which has been prescribed either by the manufacturer or by the DGCA (Directorate General of Civil Aviation," he said.
"I would like to say that India does follow very good safety protocols. Air India has also had very tragic incidents, accidents in the past and they have been able to learn from them and overcome those kinds of issues. And I am sure even in the current context, Air India will be able to ride out of this crisis," the minister added.
Describing the current crisis as a "crisis of confidence", Mr Patel said he has been getting calls about whether it is safe to fly Air India and whether its safety protocols and maintenance are up to the mark.
"I can tell you, and I have no hesitation in saying this, that if I were to fly a 787 Dreamliner today, I would be the first person to say, fine, I'm on. There's no real issue, I wouldn't worry even for a second... only time will tell whether it's some kind of a failure of a machine or man or whatever. But these are all hypothetical things, we should not really be talking too much about them until we actually have the full report," he stressed.
"Air India itself has got very, very, very good technical people over the years. The legacy has been very strong in Air India," he added.
Passenger Confidence
Asked how the government could boost the confidence of flyers after the crash, Mr Patel said passenger confidence has been shaken badly, but it can also be easily restored.
Suggesting measures to do this, he said, "I feel that there needs to be better communication, both by Air India and by all the airlines of the country put together, even by the DGCA. And I can also sense that this is a time when any vacancies in the DGCA or even in airlines in terms of their engineering or safety departments should be filled up immediately... You see, in aviation parlance, either it's 100% safe or zero, there's nothing like 99.9%."
Pointing out that several helicopter crashes have occurred in the Char Dham area in the past few weeks, he said checks and balances should be put in place and "shortcuts" should be avoided.
"The operators take chances, the pilots also sometimes are confident or overconfident, they think that they can navigate through the mountains or the clouds and they know their way... And sometimes, I'm not blaming anybody, but there could be shortcuts which need to be avoided. That also shakes up confidence. After all, anything falling off the sky does rattle people.
Safety Focus
On whether India has too few players in terms of airlines, Mr Patel said the emphasis should be on quality, not quantity. India's track record, he said, has not been worse than advanced countries like the US or countries in Europe.
"And we also have very, very good overall safety standards and monitoring. But my last word to people would be, please do not be scared of flying. It's still the safest mode of public transportation, even in India or anywhere in the world. (Once) you sit on a plane, your chances of having something going wrong are really very rare. You are one of the real unlucky ones if you really encounter some major problem," he said.
"Otherwise, it is the safest and probably the best-managed public transportation (system) anywhere in the world," the former aviation minister emphasised.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

First Post

3 hours ago

• First Post

This Week in Explainers: Should a lunch between Trump and Asim Munir really worry India?

Pakistan's General Asim Munir visited the US and in what came as a surprising development had lunch with Donald Trump. It's unusual for a military chief to receive an invitation from a sitting US president. But should this meeting bother India? We analyse in our weekly roundup read more US President Donald Trump hosted Pakistan Army Chief Asim Munir for lunch at the White House on Wednesday (June 18). It is unusual for the president to meet a military head of a foreign nation, say experts. File photo/AP It's been over a week since Israel and Iran have been attacking each other. There is a possibility that the US might join Israel's war against the Islamic Republic; Donald Trump is considering his options. India has been treading cautiously; it has strategic ties with both nations. However, it is impossible not to be affected by tensions in West Asia – from oil to trade routes, there is a lot at stake. Also, there are thousands of Indians living in both countries. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD New Delhi has been keeping a close eye on West Asia. Last week, Prime Minister Narendra Modi received a call from his Israeli counterpart, Benjamin Netanyahu, where he shared 'India's concerns'. India also launched Operation Sindhu to evacuate its nationals caught in these conflict zones. This week has been a busy one for PM Modi. He first stopped at Cyprus, before he headed for the G7 summit in Canada. On his way back, he visited Croatia. The Air India plane crash continues to hold the interest of our readers. While the investigation is ongoing, it is too early to say what caused the accident. However, several theories have been doing the rounds, including one by an aviation expert about a possible cockpit error and the pilots deploying an emergency power system before the crash. Amid this speculation, the black box, which is crucial to the probe, has been recovered but is damaged . We talk about all this and more in our weekly roundup. 1. With each passing day, the Israel-Iran conflict has been escalating. The tensions have big implications for India. What could it mean for New Delhi? From oil prices to trade routes, from student safety to aviation, there are plenty of reasons to worry. This story explains. 2. Living in Iran is hellish as Israel continues to bombard it with missiles. Stranded in the Islamic Republic are thousands of Indian students. While India has launched Operation Sindhu to evacuate them, many students, still caught in the middle of the war, fear for their lives. Most of them are aspiring doctors. But why do so many pick Iran to study medicine? STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Indian students returning from Iran via Armenia, under an evacuation operation facilitated by the Government of India. They are seen exiting from the Indira Gandhi International Airport in New Delhi on June 19. More than 100 students from Kashmir Valley reached New Delhi early Thursday. PTI 3. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is known for his diplomacy. This week, before he headed to Canada, he visited Cyprus. He is the first Indian PM to visit the country in over two decades. Was the visit a message to Turkey, with whom ties are tense after President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan supported Pakistan during Operation Sindoor? Why does Cyprus matter to India? We explain . 4. Since 2023, ties between India and Canada have deteriorated. It looks like that is about to change under Prime Minister Mark Carney. The Canadian leader invited PM Modi to the G7 summit, and the two held a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the gathering in Kananaskis, Alberta. They have agreed to hit reset. Here's how . Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi shake hands before posing for a photo during the G7 Leaders' Summit in Kananaskis, in Alberta, Canada, on June 17. Reuters 5. More than a week after the Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad, the speculation over the cause of the tragedy continues. Many theories have emerged. Aviation expert Captain Steve wonders if the pilots may have accidentally retracted the flaps instead of the landing gear during the initial climb. Another possibility is that the Ram Air Turbine (RAT) might have deployed shortly after its takeoff. Our stories try to decode all of this. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 6. Air India remains under the scanner after the Ahmedabad plane crash. Questions are being raised about safety. This week, there were incidents of emergency landings and technical glitches. While one flight took a U-turn after takeoff, another asked passengers to deplane at a stopover. What's going on? The tail of an Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner plane that crashed is seen stuck on a building after the incident in Ahmedabad, India, on June 12. In the aftermath of the crash, Air India continues to cancel several flights. Reuters 7. The India-Pakistan water war is ongoing. After India suspended the Indus Waters Treaty, the neighbouring nation is struggling with lower levels of water in its dams. Now, India is mulling another big move – a 113-km canal to redirect excess water from Jammu & Kashmir towards Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan. Will it deal another blow to Pakistan? Water flows on the banks of Chenab River with the Baglihar hydroelectric project in the background, about 155 km northwest of Jammu. India is conducting a feasibility study to construct a 113 km-long canal to redirect surplus flow from the three western rivers of the Indus water system to Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan. File photo/Reuters 8. Talking about Pakistan, its army chief, Asim Munir, was in the US . While his invitation to Trump's military parade was a rumour, Munir had lunch with Potus. It's the first such instance of a sitting US president dining with the military chief of another country. Does it signal a tightening of ties? Should India be concerned? STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 9. The Meghalaya honeymoon murder case continues to unravel. Chilling details have emerged about how Raja Raghuvanshi was murdered. Police say that two machetes were used and three blows were struck at his body before he was dumped into a gorge in the East Khasi Hills. Find out more in this report . 10. Our last story is a heartbreaking one. Arrowhead, one of Ranthambore's famous tigresses, died after battling bone cancer. She was the granddaughter of Machli, arguably the most photographed tigress in the world. Like Machli, Arrowhead also slayed a crocodile… two days before she breathed her last. This is her story . Ranthambore's famous tigress died after a battle with cancer. She is the daughter of Krishna and the granddaughter of the legendary Machli. Image courtesy: Fotokatha These are our recommendations on stories about India that you shouldn't miss. Happy reading. You will find more such explainers here .

Deccan Herald

3 hours ago

• Deccan Herald

Of old friendships and cold shoulders

Good morning readers and welcome to another edition of DH's political theatre. This week a heavy silence hung above the country as families of those who perished in the tragic crash of AI171 waited in sorrow to receive the remains of their family members. There were many among this crowd who had tinges of hope that those who were termed 'missing' will be found somewhere out there. Sadly, this wasn't the case for many as DNA testing proved that the worst had come true. The aftermath of the crash saw an outpouring of grief and rage at the cruel tragedy which snatched the lives of more than 200 people in a single devastating moment. As India grapples with the calamity that had befallen, let's also turn our attention to events that dominated the political arena this week:.C-ing the world in 4 days .This week Prime Minister Narendra Modi embarked on an expedition beginning with Cyprus. In his meeting with President Nikos Christodoulides, he promised to uphold Cyprus' independence. By promising their recognition, and Canada ignited by the murder of Khalistani Sikh extremist Hardeep Singh Nijjar, both the countries have decided to respect each other and rebuild their relationship. In line with this, they have decided to return Indian and Canadian High Commissioners to Ottawa and New Delhi, respectively. Unfortunately, not all relationships are working. There seems to be a bit of snag in his burgeoning relationship with US President Donald Trump who too had come to attend the summit. But more on that attending the G7 summit, Modi made history by becoming the first Indian prime minister to visit Croatia. Here as well, the Indian prime minister held talks with Croatia's leadership and aimed to boost ties. .Frosty relations up North .PM Modi and Donald Trump's warm relationship, which many believed was achieved due to the Indian Premier's huglomacy, has taken a bit of a tumble. While India made amends with one country in North America, icy winds slowly shifted to the other. Modi and Trump were supposed to meet on the sidelines of G7, but the US president decided to leave the summit early due to the conflict in the Middle East. Moreover, a very interesting guest was making an appearance at the White House: Pakistan Army Chief Asim Munir. But prior to this meeting, Modi had dialled Trump and reiterated that India has never accepted and will never accept mediation by any third party to settle issues with Pakistan. Unfortunately, Trump didn't give any heed to Modi's clarification and once again stated that he being a 'harbinger' of peace had brought forth a ceasefire between the two 'warring' while meeting Pakistan's latest Field Marshall, Trump expressed his desire to do trade with the country. This meeting has come as a huge blow to PM Modi as earlier the United States of America had publicly claimed that Pakistan was a 'safe haven for terrorists' and now it seems they are making some sort of an 'alliance', leaving India alone to tackle with its notorious neighbour and leaving Modi sans a home, the Congress party wasted no time in pointing out Modi's flaws and criticising the 'fantastic man' (a term Trump recently called Modi). They said that Trump's lunch with Munir was a "huge blow" to Indian English egos and Hindi sparks a political debate—which can percolate to the masses— quite like language, and this week stands testimony to that. The week began with a controversial move by the Maharashtra government to make 'Hindi' a mandatory 3rd language in schools. But, after receiving intense backlash from both the opposition and literary bodies, the government 'amended' its order by saying that Hindi will "generally" be the third language. Amongst the people involved in the backlash was Raj Thackeray, who was leading the chant. He asked what was the need to "impose" Hindi on students and appealed to schools in Maharashtra to foil the government's "hidden agenda to deliberately create a language divide".While Maharashtra was grappling with such issues, Union Minister Amit Shah too dabbled in language politics, albeit with his own 'dialect'. Maybe in a bid to appease the masses, the home minister made a contentious statement which left many people puzzled at a book launch event. He said 'the time is not far that those speaking English in the country will start to feel ashamed'.This statement invoked a backlash from the opposition, with many saying it showcases a "restrictive and narrow-minded" political view. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi too retaliated and said that BJP-RSS doesn't want the poor to learn English as it empowers them to ask questions. .Tharoor's coup d'état? Tussle with Congress carries on .While Congress was busy packing a punch at the BJP, they too got a shock when one of their own made it to the limelight for openly defying the leadership. Shashi Tharoor, the man who recently led a delegation to the US and several other countries in the Americas, admitted that he doesn't toe the line of the ringmasters and does have a 'difference of opinion' with some colleagues in the party. This reaction comes on the heels of the Thiruvananthapuram MP claiming that his invitation got lost in the mail for the campaign at Nilambur by-poll in Kerala..'We were never apart': Bharat milap .Maharashtra isn't the only state privy to old family reunions. After Uddhav and Raj Thackeray's possible reunification, politicians from Rajasthan too followed suit. In a peculiar turn of events, Congress leaders Ashok Gehlot and Sachin Pilot have decided to let go of their feud and mend their differences Later on, Gehlot even feigned surprise and said, 'When were we apart? We were never apart.' .BJP, Congress at each other's throats, a move which BJP labelled as 'minority appeasement', the Karnataka government hiked the minority reservation in housing schemes from 10 to 15%. The party defended themselves against the naysayers by retailing, 'Why do you smell political motives?' But the BJP didn't back down and said that Congress was snatching the rights of SCs, STs, OBCs and EWS. In other news, the Tamil Nadu CM is at loggerheads with the Centre. M K Stalin made sharp remarks at the government for demanding additional evidence from archaeologist K Amarnath Ramakrishna on the Sangam Era site of Keeladi. Ramakrishna was relieved from his role as Director (Antiquity) in the ASI and transferred to Greater Noida. This comes in the wake of him being asked to rework on his report of the first two phases of excavation in Keeladi. DMK and the BJP are currently engaged in a tussle over the interpretation of findings from Keeladi excavation. Stalin remarked that demanding of more information is a 'blatant attack' on Tamil puts Israel's Iron dome to test.A week after Israel launched a barrage of missiles at Iran and eliminated its military top brass along with many of its scientists who were involved with the country's nuclear programme, Iran decided it had had the stewardship of Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the West Asian country appointed a new league of leaders and began retaliating with more missiles, including the Fattah-1 hypersonic ballistic missile, at its Jewish neighbour. These missiles were able to pose a challenge to Israel's Iron dome system and also succeeded in striking a hospital in Beersheba. This attack on the hospital came as a grave insult to Israel who vowed to eliminate Khamenei at all this midst of all this tension, India too had its worries. Many people who were stranded in the two 'warring' nations had to brought home, which led PM Modi to launch Operation of peace mulling to join the war .If we turn our attention to the North American superpower, the president of that country seems to be in a fix. During the initial days, Trump called for Iran's unconditional surrender, but Iran, in turn, retaliated by saying, 'US military intervention will have irreparable damage'. Moreover, it also emphasised that it would not discuss the future of its nuclear programme while under attack by Israel. Now the man, who claims to be the harbinger of peace, is himself mulling whether he should join the war or not. .That's all for this week, we will be back with more next week. Till then, stay safe and stay tuned to DH to catch all the breaking news and latest Stage Left,DH Newsletters Team

The Print

5 hours ago

• The Print

Carney is repairing what Trudeau left damaged. India and Canada are now on a path to reset ties

In his first few weeks at the helm of affairs, Prime Minister Mark Carney has seemingly been able to reset ties with New Delhi, which had been downgraded with the expulsion and withdrawal of respective High Commissioners around eight months ago. And that is why the reset of India-Canada ties is ThePrint Newsmaker of the Week. After the high of 2015, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi was feted by his then-Canadian counterpart Stephen Harper, the relationship completely unravelled under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who sought his 15 seconds of fame by cratering ties with India to protect his own government in September 2023, undoing over two decades of careful diplomacy. New Delhi: The Carney-Modi meet earlier this week signalled a rapprochement between India and Canada, two countries inextricably linked due to the large Indian community in Canada. Also read: India-Canada diplomatic detente, and probe into Air India crash focuses on emergency power generator Snapping of India-Canada relationship Carney's victory in the April federal elections led to the view in New Delhi that a rapprochement is on the cards, with the appointment of High Commissioners, the logical first step. During election season, Carney referred to Canada's relationship with India as 'incredibly important' while deflecting any questions regarding the major irritant in ties — the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar. Nijjar, an India-designated terrorist, was gunned down outside a gurdwara in Surrey, British Columbia, on 18 June 2023. Trudeau, three months after the killing, informed the House of Commons that Ottawa was investigating 'credible allegations' that linked Indian officials to the killing of Nijjar. New Delhi called these allegations 'absurd and motivated'. There was no off-ramp for either New Delhi or Ottawa to de-escalate the diplomatic tension, especially as Trudeau's domestic struggles by then were an instrument of foreign policy. By October 2024, ties had effectively been snapped, with India expelling six Canadian diplomats, while withdrawing its High Commissioner and five other diplomats from Canada. Trudeau's minority government, being propped up by the New Democratic Party (NDP), supported Sikh separatists to wield large influence on Ottawa's foreign policy vis-a-vis its ties with India. The NDP at the time was led by Jagmeet Singh, who had in the past indicated support for Sikh separatism. In 2017, he had refused to link Sikh extremists to the 1985 bombing of Air India Flight 182, which left 329 people dead. For New Delhi, these separatists being given space in Canada to promote and fundraise their anti-India plank had real security ramifications – concerns that Ottawa ignored. Carney's approach to this has been to leave the matter of Nijjar's killing and associated irritants to the law enforcement agencies of the two countries, a measure welcomed by New Delhi. Modi's dash to Alberta further indicated the interest in both India and Canada to reset ties in an increasingly unstable world. With the return of Donald Trump to the White House, and the collapse of the NDP, ties between India and Canada were finally given the space for a reset. Also read: Collapse of Jagmeet Singh-led NDP & the waning political clout of Sikh separatists in Canada Trump and the waning star of Sikh separatists Trump's return upended the politics of Canada. For Canadians, the rupture in ties with the US, which accounts for over 70 per cent of Canada's trade, became an existential crisis. If elections were to be held in January 2025, the Conservative Party led by Pierre Poilievre was set to win a large majority, while the Liberal Party led by Trudeau would have potentially collapsed to its lows of 2011. However, Trudeau's resignation and Carney's rise gave the Liberals, which has governed Canada for large parts of the 20th century, a chance to rise in the polls. The question at the time was no longer just the domestic situation in Canada — the affordability crisis or immigration — but rather who would be the better candidate to handle Trump. Poilievre, who ran a Trump-esque campaign, saw his favourability drop in the polls. The Liberals rose, while the NDP support collapsed. With the Liberals winning a large number of seats, a few short of the majority, it meant they no longer had to rely on the NDP to govern the country. From 24 seats in the House of Commons, the NDP fell to 7, which helped stem the power of Sikh separatist groups in the Canadian parliament. The Conservative Party, looking to build a big tent, had sought votes from the Sikh separatists as well. But it seems all that was for nought. In this scenario, Carney, who was elevated to a saviour-like status, has been able to make a break from having domestic vote banks influence foreign policy. For Canada, the need of the hour is to diversify itself from the US. Carney, earlier this month, announced his intention to boost Canada's defence spending, while promising to reduce Ottawa's strategic dependence on the US. The two factors – the collapse of the Sikh separatist leaning parties and the return of Trump – has led to a retooling in Ottawa's approach to New Delhi. The current Liberal cabinet has a number of faces from Trudeau's government. Melanie Joly, who as foreign minister under Trudeau led the charge against India, retains her government role under Carney. Chrystia Freeland, the former deputy prime minister in the previous government, has returned with an important role in Carney's cabinet. However, despite continuity in members, Carney has been able to stamp his authority on foreign policy, with Anita Anand appointed as the new foreign minister, who spoke to External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar within days of her appointment. The challenges Ottawa faces has allowed it to approach New Delhi more effectively, and return a sense of maturity to India-Canada ties. However, as politics is never static, the Sikh separatists may rise again in Canadian politics, but maybe at least this time, the irritants would be dealt with at the appropriate levels, without the need for political brinkmanship from either administration. Views are personal. (Edited by Aamaan Alam Khan)