Mother of two is first British Air India crash victim released to family

The first body of a British Air India crash victim has been released to her family.
A funeral was held on Sunday for 'sweet' and 'gentle' mother of two Elcina Alpesh Makwana, 42, just three days after she told her parents not to worry as she boarded the flight to Gatwick Airport.
Mrs Makwana, who was visiting India for dental work, is the first of 53 British nationals to die in the crash whose remains were returned by authorities.
Family described Mrs Makwana, who lived in Hounslow, London, as 'a gentle soul' and incredibly hard-working. Her body was formally identified through DNA testing and taken to Pensionpora Cemetery Vadodara in Gujarat on Sunday morning for funeral rites.
Her husband Alpesh, 52, and her two children, aged seven and 11, flew out to India and arrived on Saturday ahead of a Roman Catholic Service today.
Her uncle Joseph Patelia told The Telegraph she had called her father Edwin Patelia to say she'd boarded safely but her sister later learnt the plane had crashed on the news.
'Before take-off, she called her father to say she'd boarded safely and would call again once she landed in London,' he said. 'That call never came. She vanished just like that leaving us in shock, in tears, unable to believe what we were hearing.
'About 15 minutes after that call, her younger sister Anne saw the news of a plane crash. She ran to her father and said, 'Please check if Elcina was on that flight.' That's when our nightmare began.'
He revealed that Mrs Makwana, who previously ran a telecoms business with her husband, had come to India for dental treatment and to spend time with her parents.
'Elcina had come to India for dental treatment, it's quite expensive in the UK, and obviously to spend time with her parents,' he added. 'She'd been having frequent toothaches. She travelled alone, and her husband Alpesh and their two young children, an 11-year-old daughter and a 7-year-old son, arrived here just yesterday.'
'A truly gentle soul'
Paying tribute to his niece, Mr Patelia said she was a 'gentle soul' and supported poor children in India by paying for education.
'Elcina was incredibly sweet, kind and generous, a truly gentle soul,' he said. 'She had adopted two children back home and was paying for their education. She gave quietly, never seeking attention.
'She had struggled a lot in life, moving to London over 15 years ago, taking on part-time jobs to support her family there and her parents here in India. She had no brothers, so she took on every responsibility herself.
'Her loss is devastating. She was the bond that held our entire family together.'
Investigators are continuing to search the crash site in the Meghaninagar district of Ahmedabad 1.5km metres from the end of the runway at Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport.
The Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner headed for London Gatwick crashed into a hostel where medical students and their families were living just 30 seconds after take-off.
India has ordered urgent safety tests of Boeing 787s and the flight data recorder, known as the black box, had been recovered and was being looked into by investigators.
Only one of the 241 people onboard survived the crash. The sole surviving passenger, Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, from Leicester, was sitting in seat 11A.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Sky News

4 hours ago

• Sky News

How are investigators looking into the Air India crash - and how long could they take?

The devastating Air India plane crash which killed 229 passengers and 12 crew has been labelled a "mystery" by experts. The Gatwick-bound flight, which was carrying 53 Britons, came down just after take-off from Ahmedabad airport in western India on Thursday 12 June, leaving only one survivor and also killing people on the ground. CCTV footage was captured of the crash, but experts say it has led to more questions than answers. An ongoing investigation will be reviewing the footage and other key evidence left in the crash's wake. But what are investigators looking at - and how long could it take? What is unusual about the crash? Air India Flight 171 took off from Ahmedabad Airport at 1.38pm local time on Thursday, and was only in the air for around half a minute. CCTV footage shows the plane struggling to gain altitude and it quickly begins to descend towards buildings, with its wheels still out and its nose raised. 0:56 It crashed into a densely populated neighbourhood in Ahmedabad, killing at least 29 other people on the ground. According to flight-tracking website Flightradar, the aircraft reached a height of just 625ft before crashing. The plane was a 12-year-old Boeing 787 Dreamliner, of which there are currently around 1,200 in operation worldwide. While other Boeing planes like the 787 Max have been plagued by high-profile safety incidents, this was the first deadly crash in 16 years of the Dreamliner model's operation, according to experts. 1:16 Several experts have told Sky News that they spotted potential anomalies in the footage. One of them was the landing gear, which appears to remain open throughout the clip. Former British Airways pilot Alastair Rosenschein and Paul Edwards, an aviation security analyst and fellow at the Royal Aeronautical Society, have told Sky News the landing gear should have been up and that this remains a mystery. 6:51 Mr Rosenschein is also among the experts who have called into question the aircraft's flaps, which need to be set correctly as they extend the shape of each wing and create vital extra lift at lower speeds to enable the plane to take-off and climb effectively. Some have also suggested a bird strike could be linked to the crash, but experts have pointed out that the aircraft has two engines and is designed to be able to fly on one, making this unlikely. What are investigators looking at? The investigation is being carried out by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) with assistance from the UK, the US and officials from Boeing. Anti-terror squads have also been part of the investigation teams, according to Reuters. Aurobindo Handa, former director general of AAIB, told Sky News that any theories about what may have caused the incident are at this point purely speculative. He says the most crucial thing for investigators was to retrieve the black boxes - or Digital Flight Data Recorders (DFDR) - from the crash site. Black boxes have two components - the flight data recorder and cockpit voice recorder - and provide crucial insights for crash investigators. They include altitude, airspeed, the status of controls and pilot conversations which help determine probable causes of crashes. They also store essential information about the configuration of the aircraft, including the flaps and landing gear. Mr Handa said that when there is a crash, the retrieval of the black boxes becomes the "primary focus" straight after first responders have carried out their rescue mission. It took investigators more than a day to recover the black boxes, longer than it took in many of the investigations Mr Handa oversaw, and he said this would have been because the aircraft was badly charred from fire. Indian newspaper The Economic Times reported that they were due to be sent to the US so the data could be extracted, as they had suffered fire damage and could not be analysed in India. The government said in a statement that the AAIB would decide where the recorders would be examined after making a "due assessment" of all technical, safety and security considerations. Mr Handa said analysing the boxes' raw data will take some time. "There are hundreds of components and instruments giving feedback to the DFDRs," he explained. "All the control services, all the engine parameters - everything goes into this." Investigators are also looking at the plane's remnants from the crash site, which they compare with the flight data when coming to conclusions. But Mr Handa said the investigators will likely be particularly reliant on the black box data in this instance because so much of the plane will be unrecoverable due to the fires. They will also be scanning CCTV footage of the nearby area and speak with witnesses to get to the root cause of the crash, according to Amit Singh, a former pilot and an aviation expert. Reuters has reported that investigators are assessing why the landing gear was open, citing a source "with direct knowledge", and that they are also looking at any possible operational issues with flaps. A possible bird strike is not a focus of the investigation, Reuters has reported. How long could the investigation take? Investigators across the world follow a standard UN-prescribed Manual of Accident Investigation, also called DOC 9756, which outlines detailed procedures to arrive at the most probable cause of a crash. In the case of a high-profile investigation of a major accident, countries are encouraged by the manual to publish a preliminary report within 30 days of the incident, but this is not mandatory. The guidance says the state should aim to release its final report "in the shortest possible time and, if possible, within twelve months of the date of the occurrence". It adds that if this is not possible, the state should release an interim statement on each anniversary of the incident detailing the progress of the investigation and any safety issues raised. Mr Handa told Sky News the findings will likely not be published anytime soon, even if the investigators believe they have found the probable cause of the crash early on, because they must examine and analyse every possibility and every piece of data available to them. He added that it is not just a case of finding the cause of the crash, but also uncovering the chain of events that led to that failure.

The Independent

7 hours ago

• The Independent

Indian tigress dies after long battle with bone cancer

One of India 's most iconic wild tigers, Arrowhead of Ranthambore, has died after a long battle with illness, shortly after her daughter was relocated following fatal attacks. Arrowhead, also called Lady of the Lake for her crocodile hunting skills, was found dead near Jogi Mahal in the Ranthambore reserve in western India on Thursday. She was around 14 years old. The tigress, officially designated T-84, had reportedly suffered from a bone tumour. She had stopped eating on Monday and appeared extremely thin and weak in her final video. An autopsy confirmed multiple organ failure. Forest officials cremated her body following National Tiger Conservation Authority protocols, with a gathering of wardens, wildlife photographers, and local conservationists present. The tigress, named for the distinct arrow-shaped mark on her cheek, was known for her fierce independence and unusual hunting skills, including eating crocodiles. Just days before her death, she was reportedly seen taking down a crocodile near Padam Talab, in a powerful echo of her grandmother, Machhli, Ranthambore's most famous big cat and original 'crocodile hunter.' Arrowhead's final moments were captured by Sachin Rai, a wildlife photographer who had tracked her since she was a cub. 'It was heartbreaking to see her struggle, attempting to rise and take a few feeble steps before collapsing again,' he wrote in a post accompanying video footage. 'Eventually, she reached a tree and lay beneath it. In that quiet moment, I knew in my heart that the end was near.' Arrowhead was the daughter of tigress Krishna and had inherited a prime territory in the reserve around Padam Talab. She raised ten cubs from four litters, and six of them survive her. She had several confrontations with male tigers over the years and even her own daughter, Riddhi, who eventually displaced her. Arrowhead's death came just hours after another of her daughters, Kankati, was tranquilised and relocated to the Mukundra Hills Tiger Reserve. Kankati had recently been involved in fatal attacks on a forest ranger and a 7-year-old child. 'It is a disheartening coincidence that she passed away on the same day when her daughter was being shifted,' field director Anoop K R said, according to the Hindustan Times. Arrowhead's death sparked an outpouring of tributes. Ranthambore's Instagram account posted: 'She was a symbol of grace, strength and motherly spirit.' Mr Rai echoed the sentiment, calling her 'a true tigress in every sense'. 'Arrowhead was a symbol of wild grace, of power tempered by patience, of survival against all odds,' he said. For many in India's wildlife conservation community, Arrowhead's death marks the end of an era – another link to Machhli lost. Her legacy, though, is being carried forward by the next generation of big cats.

The Sun

8 hours ago

• The Sun

The exact moment I realised I was a gay gypsy terrified me – but it was family's reaction that really shocked me

MARRYING a woman and having lots of children is how those in the traveller community expected my life to play out. So when I finally found the courage to break from the Romany Gypsy 'normal' and face the fact that I wanted to be with a man instead I was terrified about how they would react - and I was right to be concerned. 10 10 10 I come from a family of travellers and men who confess they're gay face the wrath of the community. I've known some take their own lives because the struggle to admit the truth is too difficult. It's so rare to come out as gay I felt frightened. Now, I am married to a man - we have four kids together with two more on the way. From an early age I knew I was different but when I was 18 and kissed a man for the first time I knew there was no turning back. During my childhood the other boys loved nothing more than mucking about on the Piddlehinton traveller site, near Dorchester in Dorset, where I spent most of my youth. I wasn't like them - they'd climb trees, make dens and mess about mending cars. I joined in because I was expected to but at the slightest excuse I'd creep back to my mum's caravan, and help her with the cooking. I loved the warmth and the delicious smells - I even liked helping her clean by doing the mopping. I'd watch my older relatives who were so capable and comfortable cutting down trees or working in gardens unable to imagine ever being like them. They'd say I'd soon be working with them - they'd teach me the skills - but I felt suffocated. I'm a gypsy & there's strict rules about how me and my man behave in public As I grew up other traveller boys left school at 11 or 12 and started helping out round the site and going out washing cars. I was so grateful my mum was determined I'd get an education – even though teachers told her I'd never be academic and the most they could expect was that I'd leave being able to read and write. It was a double-edged sword though because I didn't fit in at school and was mercilessly bullied. I was called 'gypo' or 'the gypsy boy'- I never felt like I belonged. I desperately tried to be like the other traveller boys. I started dating a traveller girl when I was 12 which was arranged and I had to talk to her father before we could date. When she moved on a year later I pretended to be upset, but in reality I was glad. Though back then I really didn't know why. Until I was about 14, I admitted to myself I might be gay - but even then I hoped it was a matter of finding the right girlfriend and my feelings would go away. I forced myself to date girls from school and when I was 16 I even slept with a few of them. I've always loved women but I'm not attracted to them and I remember my brain telling me 'you will like it', but going through the motions during sex felt like torture. I'm one of the only men I know who was pleased to discover that one of my teenage girlfriends was cheating on me – it felt as though her secret boyfriend was doing me a favour. It was when I was 18 that I started tentatively exploring being with men. By then I was studying an access course to get into university and become a paramedic – something I'd longed to do after helping to care for my grandfather in his later years. The course was based in Weymouth but other students lived in Bournemouth so I'd socialise there, away from the eyes of the traveller community. I felt safe that I wouldn't be found out. 10 10 Kissing a man for the first time at 18 was the defining moment that put me on the path to where I am now. Filled with terror But I was filled with terror. There were no gay gypsy role models I could look up to, no one I could confide in. It was meeting Andy, now 30, through friends that gave me the impetus to 'come out'. I was 21 and he was 18 and I fell in love and trusted him and knew he'd support me through the inevitable turmoil. It was exhausting hiding him from my family and in 2013, six months after we started seeing each other, I confided in my aunt. She was like a second mum so when she asked me why I was so miserable I blurted out the truth. Her response was incredible and beyond unexpected – she told me that as long as Andy made me happy that was what mattered. But she also said it was a secret too big to keep and she offered to break the news to my mum - her sister - for me. While they were talking I packed my bags, shaking with anxiety as I stuffed my clothes into four bin bags, so convinced I couldn't stay. Mum returned from my aunt's house shocked and crying which made me feel both guilty and sad. She told me she loved me but needed space. I went to live with Andy in Bournemouth and I never went back to the traveller site. There was gossip, and one person even refused to share my drink in case he 'caught' being gay. That comment made me more determined than ever to succeed. I avoided traveller gatherings for two years because I didn't want to cope with any other comments. Mum didn't really talk to me for three months – I understood, she had to wrap her head around it and she was so worried for me and how my life would play out. I knew only too well how hard it was for her to grasp – in some travelling communities men are forced into marriage rather than coming out and I was worried that the whole community would turn not only on me, but on my mum too. I didn't fear physical attacks, but I didn't want to be shunned either. During the months that followed I concentrated on my relationship with Andy. He was so supportive and reassuring and I focused on my studies and ambition to become a paramedic. It's terrifying breaking out from what's normal in your family. Though I was happy with Andy, our happiness was tainted because I felt I was letting everyone down. However as with so many things, time was a great healer. 'They watch me' Gradually, mum and I started talking again and while it took a couple of years for her to accept Andrew into her heart, she now refers to him as her 'second son'. I always say being a traveller is like being a member of the Royal Family - both are steeped in tradition and rules. It's more acceptable to get a girl pregnant at 15 in my community than come out as gay. I knew mum really accepted who I am seven years ago. Andy, an electrician, and I bought a four-bedroom house in Bournemouth and she moved in with us. Though she now accepts us fully and the three of us still share the same house we are careful when we mix with the community at weddings and funerals. I wouldn't dream of kissing or holding hands with Andy because I know it would make people feel uncomfortable and in turn I would feel the same. And I accept that – I don't blame them, it's hard to let go of your 'normal' and adjust. Fellow guests sometimes look at me with curiosity as if I've sprung two heads and a tail - they watch me all the time. After Andy proposed on a beach in Gran Canaria in 2013 we finally married in September 2022. We decided to go abroad to Cyprus to combine a wedding and a holiday. We invited over a hundred guests but only 60 came - 15 from the travelling community. I think some genuinely couldn't afford it but I'm sure others didn't feel comfortable - but that's OK. I wonder if subconsciously I went abroad as I was worried people wouldn't join us. Being a dad is something I've always wanted. Two years ago we adopted four children and we're in the process of adopting two more – so at least I'm going to conform with the gypsy community that way, because they too love a big family. Life is chaotic, but wonderful. I look back on that scared, confused young boy who was terrified he'd never fit in and I wish I could tell him how amazing his life would turn out to be. 10 10