Labor reluctant to make changes to super proposal
Treasurer Jim Chalmers is remaining firm on proposed superannuation changes, as Labor goes back to the drawing board to negotiate with the Greens.
Under the proposal, the concessional tax rate would double to 30 per cent on the portion of super balances above $3 million.
The policy aims to curb the number of high net-worth individuals using superannuation for tax deduction purposes rather than for their retirement.
Dr Chalmers said the government didn't have the numbers in the Senate to pass the legislation and needed to engage with the crossbench.
"Our intention and our preference would be to legislate what we announced," he told ABC radio on Thursday.
"We've done years of consultation now.
"In this case, with the Greens in the Senate to try and legislate the plan that we announced all of those years ago."
With the median super balance for 60 to 64 year olds sitting at roughly $200,000 for men and $150,000 for women, the vast majority of Australians are unlikely to feel the impact of Labor's proposal.
It is estimated to affect 0.5 per cent of Australian savers, or roughly 80,000 people according to the Australia Institute.
The wealthiest 10 per cent are receiving 40 per cent of superannuation tax breaks, the treasurer says.
The 42 self-managed super funds with more than $100 million in assets receive more than $140 million every year in tax breaks, according to reports.
But the coalition has vowed to fight back against the policy, as they are opposed to any tax on unrealised gains.
Shadow treasurer Ted O'Brien said he didn't believe it was a "fair call" and said younger Australians would be caught in the net over time.
"Our belief as a coalition ... is that Australia should have lower tax, simpler tax, and fairer tax, and what Labor is putting on the table with its superannuation tax breaches all of those things," he told ABC's News Breakfast.
"Every aspect of this is looking awful, and it certainly does not align with our values as a Liberal Party, or indeed, a Liberal National coalition."
Critics say the policy's introduction of a tax on unrealised capital gains goes against the fundamentals of the tax system and would have unintended consequences, such as driving investment off-shore and threatening Australia's financial stability.
Unrealised gains are 'paper profits' - increases in the value of assets such as properties or shares that haven't been cashed in.
On Wednesday, Dr Chalmers said calculation of unrealised gains was not unique in the tax system, and that any losses can be carried forward against any gains.
Tax on unrealised gains is already part of the Australian tax system and is, for example, paid under land tax regimes.
The Greens support the legislation in principle but want the threshold lowered to $2 million and indexed in line with inflation.
Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young said the ball was in the government's court.
"We want a reform to the system that makes it stronger and fairer," she told Sky News on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
29 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
Major Queensland coal mine facing termination with hundreds of jobs on the chopping block
A Queensland coal mine may imminently 'pause' operations, which could result in 500 workers losing their jobs. The Burton coal mine, 80 kilometres northwest of Moranbah, was first opened in 2022 and despite fierce attempts to ramp up production and lower costs, a mammoth flood season and record low prices have put the facility in a perilous situation. Bowen Coking Coal Ltd, which owns the mine, released a statement to the Stock Exchange on Friday and revealed that the mine could 'pause' production within a matter of months if additional cash or equity was not immediately sourced. 'If immediate funding efforts are unsuccessful and/or coal market pricing dynamics do not improve, Bowen may seek to temporarily pause operations at part, or all, of the Burton Mine Complex,'' the ASX statement read. The company has been forced to close a number of its coal mines in recent years including the Bluff mine near Blackwater, with Bowen Coking Coal executive chair Nick Jorss blaming the crisis on soaring state royalties and catastrophically low prices. 'Bowen is the tip of the iceberg of the pain being felt by central Queensland,'' Mr Jorss told the Courier Mail. 'We're not the only ones on the edge. Quite a lot of mines in central Queensland are cash negative, meaning a lot of jobs are at risk." Mr Jorss, who has worked in the industry for close to two decades, said the company had paid $120 million in royalty taxes to the Queensland government, after the former Labor government introduced a new progressive royalty structure in July 2022. 'This super royalty is an ongoing tax on revenue irrespective of whether mines are making profit or can pay their wages or other costs.' Mr Jorss said, adding 'it's a really sad state of affairs for Queensland.' The Bowen complex which recently acquired a cash injection was initially given a 10-year life. The facility produces two million tonnes of coal per year, with the Bowen Basin itself holding the largest black coal reserves in the nation. Mr Jorss said that despite Queensland still holding the title of the largest producer and exporter of coal in the nation, tax pressures had taken their toll on the industry's ability to be commercially viable and competitive. '(Former Labor treasurer) Cameron Dick is still playing political games on royalties, but it's impacting real people's lives in central Queensland and beyond,' he said, adding it would be a 'real tragedy if it's taxed out of existence". Mr Jorss said that if the 500 jobs are cut and operations are ceased then surrounding cities as far as Mackay and Brisbane would feel the pinch due to a lack of local supply. Industry magnates have slammed the Commonwealth Grants Commission, which allocates GST revenue among the states, for listing Queensland's soaring revenues brought in from commodity royalties as the justification for it to not receive an estimated $5 billion in GST. Spot prices for coal used to produce steel which is the majority of Burton's output have experienced a steep decline in global prices in the last year, sinking 25 per cent to US$175 a tonne. Experts have put this down to global instability sparked by US President Donald Trump's sweeping tariff policies and a historic lack of demand in China and India. Thermal coal used in coal-powered fire stations have also plunged by 25 per since last June to US$66 a tonne as the nation shifts towards a renewables energy grid.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Workers' retirement nest eggs set for super boost
Australian workers can look forward to a bigger nest egg, with an increase to the superannuation guarantee to add tens of thousands of dollars to the average super account. From July 1, employers' minimum required contribution to employees' superannuation accounts will rise from 11.5 per cent to 12 per cent. It's the latest and last in a series of incremental increases from nine per cent over more than a decade since they were legislated by the Rudd-Gillard Labor government in 2012. With the latest bump, a 30-year-old earning $60,000 would have an extra $20,000 in super by retirement, according to the Association of Superannuation Funds Australia. It will add about $300 each year to the superannuation of a worker on a $60,000 salary, or $500 for someone on a $100,000 salary. "The system foundations are cemented for young, working people to have a comfortable retirement," ASFA chief executive Mary Delahunty said. "It's a moment all Australians should be proud of." The association says the cost of a comfortable retirement increased 1.6 per cent in the past year, while the cost of a modest retirement rose 1.7 per cent. A "comfortable" retirement includes top-level health insurance, a reasonable car and leisure activities. The cost of either outcome was increasing slower than Australia's current 2.4 per cent headline inflation but retiree budgets remained under pressure from rising food, energy and health costs. Couples on average need $73,900 annually for a comfortable retirement, while most singles needed $52,300 per year, ASFA says. For a modest retirement covering the basics, couples needed $48,200 each year, singles $33,400, or for renting couples, $64,250, and $46,660 each year for singles who rent. The figures underlined the importance of increasing Australia's housing stock, Ms Delahunty said. "They also illustrate how super can be the difference between hardship and stability later in life, especially for renters." For some workers, the extra contribution will come from their existing pay package, according to CPA Australia's superannuation lead Richard Webb. "It's a good idea to check with your employer to see how they view the changes and what it means for you," he said. Workers on contracts with a total remuneration package could see a slight drop in their take-home pay, while those on award or enterprise agreements would likely receive the contribution on-top of their current pay. When compulsory superannuation was introduced in 1992 - in part to reduce government spending on the Age Pension - only one in 10 Australian retirees listed super as a source of income. Nine in 10 people between 30 and 50 now have super. Government spending on the Age Pension is projected to fall from 2.3 per cent of gross domestic product in 2020 to two per cent by 2062/63, despite a doubling of the over-65 population and a trebling of over-85s over the same period. However the super guarantee increase wouldn't help those who missed out on paid work for extended periods, Super Consumer Australia chief executive Xavier O'Halloran said. "(For) people who have caring responsibilities or who have been locked out of the unaffordable housing market ... increasing SG further won't address those inequalities," he told AAP. Mr O'Halloran said there was more that could be done to support people struggling in retirement, when a significant portion of their autumnal years' savings were made. "Right now, there are no minimum standards for retirement products like there are for MySuper," he said. "There is also no performance testing of retirement products, so super funds can still sell poor products."
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
EU-Aust free trade deal: a "middle finger to Trump"
There is appetite for the European Union and Australia to signal a "middle finger to Trump" by uniting on a long-awaited free trade deal but some in Brussels are tempering expectations of a quick turnaround. Trade talks kicked off in 2018 but Canberra walked away about 18 months ago over unsatisfactory market access for beef and lamb producers, and a reluctance to give up naming rights on products for geographical origin reasons, including feta, parmesan and prosecco. Fast forward to 2025 and US President Donald Trump's tariff antics have brought both parties back to the negotiating table. There was speculation of a quick conclusion with the Australian Financial Review reporting European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen had flagged a trip to Australia for late July or early August in anticipation of signing a deal. This echoed the fact she had also been quick to flag an agreement while offering Anthony Albanese her congratulations on becoming prime minister via Twitter in 2022. But multiple EU spokespeople have declined to confirm the travel, telling AAP a Down Under trip is "not on the radar". Despite acknowledging renewed political will, various sources in Brussels are cautioning patience. "There is no rush," according to one inside the EU Commission. "I wouldn't even say the end of the year, I would say more next year." Jacob Funk Kirkegaard, a senior fellow with Brussels think-tank Bruegel, estimates it could take at least another six months to resolve outstanding issues on agricultural tariffs and quotas. "The broad contour of the deal is already negotiated," he told AAP. "They know where the skeletons are buried. It takes a political grand bargain to do it." He noted that if the EU makes concessions, it would likely encounter an angry backlash from French and Polish farmers, who also opposed the EU's deal last year with Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay. However tractor and manure street protests wouldn't be enough to block a deal with Canberra, he said. Amid Washington's shift to extreme trade protectionism, an EU-Australian free trade deal would send a strong message to the Trump administration, Kirkegaard said. "As two of America's traditional allies, if both the EU and Australia find themselves subject to US tariffs, what better way than to do a deal with each other," he said. "So perhaps both countries feel this political signal is kind of a middle finger to Trump as well." Back in Melbourne, Sicilian-born cheesemaker Giorgio Linguanti from That's Amore Cheese faces an anxious wait to find out whether he can continue to market his wares using generic terms like parmesan or mozzarella. Yet he is open to compromise. "We should call it Australian parmesan and Australian feta because Australian milk is the best in the world," he said. Canberra and Brussels announced on Wednesday separate negotiations on a defence pact to boost defence industry, cyber-security and counter-terrorism co-operation. But it would not have military deployment obligations.
