‘Golden visa' shutting out Chinese investors, legal experts say
Photo:
RNZ
Legal experts have been left perplexed by Immigration New Zealand's interpretation of regulations related to the investment visa pathway for Chinese nationals.
The government upgraded the Active Investor Plus visa on 1 April to help encourage growth and make investing in New Zealand more attractive for overseas individuals.
The updated information on Immigration New Zealand's website in April noted that two Chinese investment programmes - Qualified Domestic Institutional Investor (QDII) and Qualified Domestic Limited Partner (QDLP) - were "not considered acceptable methods of transfer to meet immigration requirements" under the visa.
The Active Investor Plus visa was first introduced in 2022 by the Labour government, replacing the previous Investor 1 and 2 categories.
Due to the visa's high investment threshold and English-language requirement, it did not attract a lot of interest, immigration advisors and lawyers said, adding that questions over the exclusion of the Chinese investment programmes had yet to materialise.
After the April upgrade, the category attracted high interest from
applicants around the world
.
Peter Luo
Photo:
Supplied
However, licensed immigration advisor Peter Luo said interest from China quickly dried up after the government explicitly excluded the QDII programme from the upgraded "golden visa".
"I have quite a number of clients who wanted to apply, but they can't anymore," Luo said. "Some have signed a contract with us, but we had to pause the process."
QDII was introduced by the Chinese regulators in 2006 to allow individuals in China to invest in financial product markets overseas through approved domestic institutions such as commercial banks, security firms and trust companies.
It aims to increase the proportion of mainland China's privately held assets abroad in a managed way, according to the government's foreign exchange agency.
The QDLP programme is a separate investment scheme launched by Chinese authorities that has never been adopted by New Zealand.
Luo said QDII was virtually the only pathway for individuals from China to transfer capital overseas.
The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment told RNZ that QDII and QDLP had been excluded from the investor visa when it was introduced in 2022.
Stacey O'Dowd, border and funding immigration policy manager at MBIE, said the core objective of the Active Investor Plus policy settings was to seek active and ongoing investment to help grow the New Zealand economy.
"Funds passively invested in New Zealand which are subject to obligations or restrictions would not align with this objective, as there is no certain potential of the funds remaining productively invested beyond an investor's investment period," O'Dowd said.
However, Luo said he only became aware of the QDII programme's exclusion recently.
Luo claimed the QDII programme complied with the new investor visa conditions, and its exclusion was "baseless".
"If the government is genuinely interested in attracting Chinese money and talent, INZ should withdraw its improper interpretation and engage with financial institutions to develop a workable solution," Luo said.
Arran Hunt
Photo:
Supplied
Immigration lawyer Arran Hunt said the exclusion of the QDII pathway meant the Active Investor Plus visa was "shut off from almost all Chinese investors".
Some countries restricted the amount of funds that someone could move out of the country, and the QDII programme provided an option that appeared to work with the former investment visa categories, he said.
Hunt said Immigration New Zealand had not explained why funds transferred via the QDII programme were not acceptable.
"We expect it is because the QDII/QDLP funds need to be returned to China at some point, which would make any investment in New Zealand temporary," he said.
However, there was no guarantee that an investment under the new investor visa would remain in New Zealand after the investment term, he said.
Repatriation of funds was more likely to happen if the funds had been sent via the QDII programme, he said.
"This change would have an impact on applicants from China, as it removes the most common way to take money out of China lawfully," he said.
"This removal will leave the only possible way out being through a place like Hong Kong but, even then, it won't be simple."
Hunt said China did not allow unrestricted movement of funds out of the country, with such transfer constraints being outside of New Zealand's control.
Harris Gu
Photo:
Screenshot / Queen City Law
Harris Gu, an immigration lawyer who is also policy chair of the New Zealand Association for Migration and Investment, said the exclusion of QDII from the investor visa settings was unreasonable because immigration laws did not explicitly forbid it.
"I believe there has perhaps been a misconception on the government's part in terms of exactly what QDII is and how it operates," Gu said. "Nevertheless, their statements are not above the actual law."
Gu said the exclusion would negatively affect investment from Chinese institutions that might have ordinarily come through the QDII programme under the old Investor 1 and 2 visa categories.
O'Dowd said New Zealand investment settings were, and would remain, "country neutral".
"We welcome high quality and productive foreign investment from all investors, provided it meets our regulatory requirements," O'Dowd said.
"Active Investor Plus settings have been designed to incentivise active investment so New Zealand benefits from investor capital, skills, experience and networks over the longer term."
Immigration New Zealand received 45 applications for the Active Investor Plus visa under the new settings between 1 and 14 April.
Of those applications, eight were from Hong Kong and five were from Chinese nationals, according to MBIE statistics.
RNZ approached Immigration Minister Erica Stanford for comment but was told Immigration New Zealand, which falls under MBIE, oversaw such operational questions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Nearly 200 apply for 'golden visa' in three months
Nearly 200 applications have been received for the so-called 'golden visa' since changes were made to liberalise access. The government made changes in April to make it easier for wealthy foreigners to gain New Zealand residency through investment. Since then, Immigration New Zealand has received 189 applications for the visa. Economic growth minister Nicola Willis said that was significantly more than the 116 appliciations received over more than two and a half years under the previous settings. "Investor migrants are clearly attracted to New Zealand's growing reputation as a safe, pro-business, high-potential economy. In a world where countries compete for dollars and talent, it's great to see New Zealand's growth prospects being recognised," she said. The changes introduced a two-pronged approach to the visa, and liberalised what could be invested in. The Growth category requires a minimum investment of $5m over three years, into higher-risk investments including managed funds and direct investments in New Zealand businesses. The Balanced category requires a minimum investment of $10m over five years, with investors being allowed to choose lower-risk investments. Under the previous settings, $15m was required for a visa, with bonds and property investments not allowed. As at June 23rd, 100 applications have been approved in principal. Of those, seven have transferred and invested their funds in New Zealand and had been granted a visa. Five of those were invested in the Growth category, and two in the Balanced. The government said that was a total minimum investment of $45m. The new applications represented a potential $845m of new investment. Immigration minister Erica Stanford said she would have been happy with 200 applications in the first year. "As of this week we're almost at 190 after 10 weeks, and I think that shows you the level of interest from overseas, in lots of different markets we haven't seen before," she said. The strongest interest in the visa had come from the United States, China, Hong Kong, and Germany. Investors have six months to transfer their funds and start investing in New Zealand. Willis said the visa complemented the Investment Boost policy announced at the Budget, which allows businesses to deduct 20 percent of the cost of a new asset, on top of depreciation. "The Active Investor Plus delivers the capital. Investment Boost delivers the confidence to put that capital to work, and to ensure that people are making investments that will pay off in the long run."
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Labour Will Repeal Regulatory Standards Bill
Labour will repeal the Regulatory Standards Bill in its first 100 days in Government. 'The Regulatory Standards Bill has no place in a fair and democratic New Zealand and Labour is committed to repealing it in our first 100 days if elected next year,' Labour justice spokesperson Duncan Webb said. 'This Bill is another concession by Christopher Luxon to ACT that puts corporate interests ahead of the public good, making it harder to pass laws that protect people and the environment. 'Under the Regulatory Standards Bill, laws that would keep people healthy and safe, like requiring landlords to heat homes, limiting the sale of vapes, or keeping our air and water clean would be at risk. 'It allows David Seymour to create his own hand-picked 'appeals body of regulatory economists' to criticise laws that are out of line with his minority views. 'Put another way, it takes power away from communities and hands it to corporate friends of the ACT Party. 'Christopher Luxon was too weak to stand up against it, but Labour will repeal it,' Duncan Webb said.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nearly 200 people apply for 'golden visas' in 3 months
File photo: Nicola Willis and Erica Stanford. Photo: RNZ / Reece Baker Nearly 200 applications have been received for the so-called 'golden visa' since changes were made to liberalise access. The government made changes in April to make it easier for wealthy foreigners to gain New Zealand residency through investment. Since then, Immigration New Zealand has received 189 applications for the visa. Economic growth minister Nicola Willis said that was significantly more than the 116 appliciations received over more than two and a half years under the previous settings. "Investor migrants are clearly attracted to New Zealand's growing reputation as a safe, pro-business, high-potential economy. In a world where countries compete for dollars and talent, it's great to see New Zealand's growth prospects being recognised," she said. The changes introduced a two-pronged approach to the visa, and liberalised what could be invested in. The Growth category requires a minimum investment of $5m over three years, into higher-risk investments including managed funds and direct investments in New Zealand businesses. The Balanced category requires a minimum investment of $10m over five years, with investors being allowed to choose lower-risk investments. Under the previous settings, $15m was required for a visa, with bonds and property investments not allowed. As at June 23rd, 100 applications have been approved in principal. Of those, seven have transferred and invested their funds in New Zealand and had been granted a visa. Five of those were invested in the Growth category, and two in the Balanced. The government said that was a total minimum investment of $45m. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
