‘The only thing we can't do is hear': the deaf pupil who beat Fife council in court
The slogan on Niamdh Braid's powder-blue sweatshirt puts it plainly enough: 'I define my own deaf identity.'
'We're in a world that's built for hearing people,' says the 16-year-old from Glenrothes in Fife, 'and we have to navigate through it to find what works best for us.'
Earlier this year, the teenager won a legal battle with her local council to have a British Sign Language interpreter in lessons, after she realised how much of what was said in class she was missing out on.
Niamdh, who has been deaf since birth, wears hearing aids, but can struggle to follow in noisy environments and her preferred language is BSL.
As a younger child, she didn't have any deaf people she could look up to on TV or on the news. Now she hopes that through her advocacy 'younger deaf kids can look up to me and see that they can achieve anything'.
'A lot of people think that because we can't hear we can't achieve high-earning jobs and go into good professions,' says Niamdh, whose favourite subject is modern studies and who hopes to get into teaching then politics when she grows older. 'But the only thing we can't do is hear – there's nothing actually wrong with us. We can do anything that we put our mind to.'
Yet deaf children are eight times more likely to leave school with no qualifications, according to the National Deaf Children's Society, which financially supported Niamdh's legal action.
Niamdh was talking in advance of a report by MSPs that will reveal a significant fall in the number of specialist teachers of deaf people in Scotland. It is prompting the NDCS to warn of a 'growing crisis in deaf education' and lack of guidance from local authorities about what kind of support they should be providing deaf children in schools.
At high school, she explains, there was an assumption that she did not need support because she was still achieving decent grades.
But at Niamdh's tribunal, an independent assessment by a deaf education specialist found she was only accessing 70% of what was being said in class, even when her teacher wore a microphone transmitting to her hearing aids.
Her dad, Steve, chips in: 'If she was accessing 100% at the teaching, imagine what she could be achieving. Why should she settle for average just because she's deaf?'
Constantly struggling to hear came at a heavy price, and Niamdh was increasingly exhausted. 'I was always tired, asking to go to my bed at four o'clock before I'd had anything to eat.' At weekend she was too tired to go out with her friends.
After her request for a BSL interpreter was turned down, first by her school and then by Fife council, Niamdh felt she had no choice: 'At this point it was getting close to my exams and I'd missed so much class already. I wanted to launch the action under my own name because it was for me, and I can voice my needs without the help of my parents.'
Giving evidence, she explained that 'it's always a hearing person that makes decisions for the deaf person, and it shouldn't be the case. Because hearing people don't know what it's like to go through life in a world that's not built for them.'
Early last year the tribunal ruled that Niamdh was being placed at 'substantial disadvantage', but the appeals process was only concluded this spring.
'When the last appeal got thrown out, it was the biggest relief I've ever felt,' says Niamdh. She went out for a Chinese buffet meal with her parents and younger brother to celebrate.
The teenager, who takes part in taekwondo competitions and is a devoted fan of the hospital drama series Grey's Anatomy, says she's very lucky to have a close group of friends she's known since nursery school. 'It's all they've known with their friendship with me: if we're talking they need to face me, make sure there's not too much noise in the background.'
She feels strongly that young deaf people should be allowed to make their own choices about what support they access, and that they are not a homogenous group: 'Everyone has their own way of communicating. It's not up to anyone else to decide that.
'It's the kid's choice of what they want to be as a deaf person. If they want to go without aids, if they want to have the hearing technology, if they want to be involved in the deaf community, let them decide.'
Fife council's head of education and children's services, Angela Logue, said: 'We are continuing to work very closely with Niamdh and her family to meet her needs as identified by the outcomes of the tribunal.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
a day ago
- Telegraph
SNP members get vast majority of online abuse of MSPs
SNP politicians have been showered with the most online abuse, according to figures that reveal more than 700 messages sent to MSPs across the political spectrum were deemed 'criminal'. The scale of online abuse directed at Holyrood politicians is revealed in a report released by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB), which claims it is 'readily apparent and growing'. Between June 2023 and March 2025, more than 31,600 abusive messages sent to MSPs on social media were logged. The vast majority – 22,370 – were directed at members of the SNP, followed by Scottish Labour (4,432) and the Scottish Conservatives (2,480). Scottish Green MSPs reported 1,440 abusive posts, the Liberal Democrats 843 and independents 52. Of these, 718 were deemed to potentially breach criminal thresholds and were referred to Police Scotland. In one case, it led to court action and a prosecution. The report states that another prosecution is in progress. 'Sobering' results The monitoring period includes a pilot project of the SPCB's online threat managing service for MSPs, which started in June 2023 and produced 'sobering' results, according to Lynsey Hamill, director of operations and digital at the Scottish Parliament. The service continues to deliver early warning of potential online threats for 69 MSPs – 33 of whom are female – who are currently signed up. The data also show that gender-based abusive posts went from seven in 2023-24 to 886 in 2024-25. However, the significant rise is claimed to be due to the improved recognition of misogynistic content directed at female members. Ms Hamill added: 'We can see the scale of online abuse of MSPs is now readily apparent and growing. This chimes with feedback we have had from members for some time now.' The SPCB initiated a review of personal security provision for MSPs and staff following the death of David Amess, the former MP for Southend West who was stabbed multiple times at a constituency surgery at a church in Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, in 2021. 'Rising threat level' The review led to more than 250 portable alarms issued to MSPs and their staff, £125,000 committed to make permanent the online threat managing service for up to 80 MSPs and 108 local offices being surveyed by Police Scotland. Security improvements were implemented on their recommendations and all MSPs were offered home residence surveys by Police Scotland. A Scottish Parliament spokesman said: 'The SPCB is acutely aware of the rising level of threat against elected representatives. Last year, the SPCB invested £125,000 to make permanent its online threat managing service. 'Under the service, potentially criminal threats are identified by the Parliament's security team and escalated to Police Scotland for its action.'
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
Back to school...now MSPs to be taught 'fiscal literacy' in bid to improve decisions
For those getting into politics, one would think it a basic requirement. But calls have been made to teach new MSPs about 'fiscal literacy' in a bid to improve decisions around tax and public spending. The Scottish Parliament's finance committee has released a new report which demands greater transparency from SNP ministers about budgets. It also calls for action to improve the ability of MSPs to make decisions and scrutinise them. It comes amid concerns about the damaging impact of the SNP's tax policies on the economy. The report, published today (FRI), highlighted that some witnesses told the committee that 'fiscal literacy' should be encouraged amongst all MSPs so that there can be a more 'mature' approach. It said: 'The committee agrees with witnesses that enhancing the fiscal literacy of all MSPs would help to support more effective scrutiny of budgetary matters and potentially encourage a more mature wider debate around the spending and tax decisions taken by Government. 'We therefore intend to write to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body to ask that a comprehensive fiscal literacy training programme be put in place through the induction of new MSPs elected at the 2026 Scottish Parliament elections, and through continuous development for all members throughout the five-year cycle.' The committee also concluded that improvements are required in the strategic financial planning by the Scottish Government, and that significant, long-term fiscal pressures in Scotland can no longer be avoided. Finance committee convenor Kenneth Gibson said: 'We believe the Scottish budget process, and its building blocks, remain fit-for-purpose. However, the way in which it has operated in practice this session has been far from ideal, and improvements are now needed. 'Our recommendations in this report are therefore intended to ensure that the objectives of the budget process - including improved transparency and awareness, responsiveness to emerging fiscal and policy challenges, greater influence and better outcomes - can now be fully met. 'Our view remains that improvements are also required in the Scottish Government's strategic, financial planning. This should be supported by an improved quality of data and key documentation published by the government, within the timescales expected by Parliament.' Scottish Conservative finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: 'This damning report from the committee needs to be an urgent wake-up call for SNP ministers.'
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
JOHN MACLEOD: An order of a burger and fries in the heart of the Highlands and proof the Gaelic tongue is in trouble...
Whenever I nip south for time with my mother and memory-lane rambles around G13, there is one enjoyable ritual: I always pause at Fort William for a scoff at McDonald's. Though not for several years have I been able to make my manly stride to the till and order three cheeseburgers, a large fries and a large Coke. These days you have to jab at faintly ridiculous touchscreens, pay by card, note your order number, and then loiter hungrily till some tray-brandishing teenager hollers it out. But, on May 22, something caught my eye. Here in the heart of the Highlands – in a landscape where every bump on every mountain still has a Gaelic monicker; in a community where someone once observed to my father, a local minister, and without a hint of humour that a certain family had been at the root of all the trouble thereabouts since the '45 – this Stateside fast-food touchscreen generously offered me the option to order in Welsh. Indeed, I was short-changed; in many corners of this realm, I am reliably informed, you also have the opportunity to order your Big Mac in Polish. I recalled this wryly the other day when MSPs solemnly passed the Scottish Languages Bill into law – with the accompanying spin that this now makes Gaelic and Scots official languages of the land. Actually, it does no such thing. Indeed, it is difficult to spot any clause in the Act that allows you to do anything you could not do already. Parents have been able to lobby for a local Gaelic-medium school for 40 years now; cosy little quangos like Bòrd na Gàidhlig have never wanted for public wonga and the Kirk was able to dub a given pastoral charge 'Gaelic Essential' long before the new, devolved Scotland. But you still cannot fill out your tax-return in Gaelic. Nor testify in court in Gaelic (with the right to an interpreter). And – if only to underline that, fundamentally, this new law amounts to no more than the square root of hee-haw – newly elected MSPs next May will still have to take the Oath of Allegiance in English. Some do, for a social media moment, take it again in Gaelic, French, Irish, Catalan and, for all I know, Serbo-Croat, but in law Geraldine Dreadful, MSP for Kilhammer and Sickle East, must swear (or affirm) in English. As for Kate Forbes's extra £5.7million 'to promote Scots and Gaelic', that – in terms of public spending – is chickenfeed. Just enough to build 46 yards of motorway. That is before I even get started on Scots. Despite the best efforts of Alistair Heather in a 2020 BBC Scotland documentary, Scots is not a language. Even if, as Heather did, you try to drag everything under its umbrella from ra patter o' Glesga to the 'Jings! Crivvens! Helpmaboab!' of Oor Wullie's Dundee. It would be inaccurate to describe the Doric as a dialect of English, but it is certainly a cognate of it – a cousin, sharing near-descent from the tongue of St Margaret and the Venerable Bede – as Gaelic is a cognate of Irish and Manx, and Welsh a cognate of Cornish and Breton. Scots has the same grammar as English, a vast vocabulary in common with English, and even rather a lot of loanwords from Gaelic. (English has sadly few: I'd struggle to get much beyond 'galore' and, in the complimentary sense, 'smashing'. Respectively, gu leor and 's math sin.) And behind this, of course, is a deeper tension. The Highlander's historic foe has never been the Englishman: since at least the Battle of Harlaw, it has been the Lowland Scot. From the Edinburgh factors who directed the Clearances to the sort of honk-honk Glasgow cabbie who cackles that Gaelic was never spoken here – this in the city of Yoker, Balshagray, Bellahouston and Auchenshuggle and many more incontestably Gaelic placenames. As for the Morningside Drive wits who chortle at Hebrideans treating their children to piotsa before a night in front of an telebhisean, we may but coyly ask what is the English for bandana, bangle, bungalow, jungle, loot, chutney and pyjamas, shampoo and thug and veranda. All, my child, loanwords from Hindi. But there is desperation beyond my scorn. At the edge of living memory, Gaelic was still spoken on the banks of Loch Lomond. When I was born, six decades ago, there were still Gaelic speakers in Perthshire, Aberdeenshire, Arran and well east of Inverness. As late as 1970, the reluctant Free Presbyterian minister of Applecross stood for and won election to the county council, because no other local had confident command of written and spoken English; and Galloway's last native Gaelic speaker died only around 1760. For that matter, there are more Gaelic placenames in Fife than there are on Lewis. Yet this is now a tongue in desperate trouble. It is no longer a community language anywhere in the Scottish mainland. It survives, perhaps, in bits of Islay and some extremities of Skye. Even here in the Outer Hebrides, according to the 2022 Census, only in two parishes – South Uist and Barvas – is it still spoken by a majority of residents. And when, as Irish experience attests, those locally fluent fall below the tipping-point of 66 per cent and you must perforce daily use English to communicate, the position tends to be irretrievable. You end up not with a community language of hearth and home, but a 'network' language, largely used by those who make money out of it – educationists, broadcasters and so on. Like Esperanto, or Klingon. Less a mother tongue than a quaint hobby. Gaelic is all but beyond intensive care. It lies on the slab, is being readied for arterial embalming, and nothing in the involved and windy Scottish Languages Act amounts to a hill of beans in that regard. Labour MSP Michael Marra hit the nail on the head on Tuesday: 'This Bill does nowhere near enough to protect the Gaelic language. 'Without economic development in the heartlands, we know that the prospects for Scotland's ancient language are bleak. 'In the face of a Gaelic crisis, the SNP chose to bring a Bill of limited scope that will, at best, make modest improvements.' There are obvious villains. The imposition of compulsory, English-medium schooling from 1872. The catastrophic impact on Gaeldom of the Great War; the awful, flattening cultural force of television. But there were also the landlords who cleared the glens, the East Coast trawlers who laid waste our fishing, the emptying of Harris and Assynt, Uig and South Lochs and the accelerating inrush of settlers from the South, some of whom are not ten minutes in a given Hebridean community when – take the traditional Sabbath – they are shrieking to overturn its way of life. It is like watching a great barn pitiably ablaze, flames shooting high in the sky, roof-timbers already tumbling – helplessly beholding the collapse of your culture.
