Apple must face consumer lawsuit over iCloud storage, US judge rules

Apple must face a proposed class action accusing the iPhone maker of illegally monopolizing the market for digital storage and causing consumers to overpay for its iCloud service, a federal judge in California ruled on Monday.
U.S. District Judge Eumi Lee in San Jose, California, said the plaintiffs in the case had sufficiently alleged Apple violated antitrust law by requiring iPhone customers to use its iCloud data storage service to back up core data and device setting files.
Lee's new order revived the plaintiffs' lawsuit after she dismissed an earlier version of it. She said the consumers added substantial new allegations about the importance of data storage for all iPhone files, including restricted ones like settings data.
Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The company has denied any wrongdoing.
An attorney for the consumers had no immediate comment on the ruling.
A Los Angeles resident who said she was paying $2.99 monthly for an iCloud storage plan filed the lawsuit last year.
Apple allows third-party storage for photos and videos but not for some users' data files that are needed to "restore" an Apple device.
Apple has defended its policy as designed to guarantee high levels of security. The company also urged Lee to dismiss the plaintiff's claims as untimely. Plaintiffs generally face a four-year window to bring claims under U.S. antitrust law.
In her ruling, Lee said it was premature to dismiss the claims as time-barred, but suggested the issue could be revisited later in the litigation.
The plaintiff's lawyers want to represent a nationwide class of at tens of millions of consumers who purchased iCloud storage plans.
The case is Felix Gamboa v. Apple Inc, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 5:24-cv-01270.
For plaintiffs: Steve Berman and Ben Harrington of Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro
For Apple: Belinda Lee and Sarah Ray of Latham & Watkins
Read more:
Apple loses bid to pause app store reform order in Epic Games case
Google taps top Obama Supreme Court lawyer for search antitrust appeal
Apple hit with app developer class action after US judge's contempt ruling
US judge rules Apple violated order to reform App Store.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

India Today

33 minutes ago

• India Today

Apple sued, investors say company mislead them with Siri hype tanking iPhone sales and stock

Apple was sued on Friday by shareholders in a proposed securities fraud class action that accused it of downplaying how long it needed to integrate advanced artificial intelligence into its Siri voice assistant, hurting iPhone sales and its stock complaint covers shareholders who suffered potentially hundreds of billions of dollars of losses in the year ending June 9, when Apple introduced several features and aesthetic improvements for its products but kept AI changes did not immediately respond to requests for comment. CEO Tim Cook, Chief Financial Officer Kevan Parekh and former CFO Luca Maestri are also defendants in the lawsuit filed in San Francisco federal court. Shareholders led by Eric Tucker said that at its June 2024 Worldwide Developers Conference, Apple led them to believe AI would be a key driver of iPhone 16 devices, when it launched Apple Intelligence to make Siri more powerful and they said the Cupertino, California-based company lacked a functional prototype of AI-based Siri features, and could not reasonably believe the features would ever be ready for iPhone said the truth began to emerge on March 7 when Apple delayed some Siri upgrades to 2026, and continued through this year's Worldwide Developers Conference on June 9 when Apple's assessment of its AI progress disappointed shares have lost nearly one-fourth of their value since their December 26, 2024 record high, wiping out approximately $900 billion of market case is Tucker v. Apple Inc et al, US District Court, Northern District of California, No. 25-05197.

Time of India

40 minutes ago

• Time of India

Apple executives held internal talks about buying perplexity: Report

Apple executives have held internal talks about potentially bidding for artificial intelligence startup Perplexity, Bloomberg News reported on Friday, citing people with knowledge of the matter. The discussions are at an early stage and may not lead to an offer, the report said, adding that the tech behemoth's executives have not discussed a bid with Perplexity's management. "We have no knowledge of any current or future M&A discussions involving Perplexity," Perplexity said in response to a Reuters' request for comment. Apple did not immediately respond to a Reuters' request for comment. Big tech companies are doubling down on investments to enhance AI capabilities and support growing demand for AI-powered services to maintain competitive leadership in the rapidly evolving tech landscape. Bloomberg News also reported on Friday that Meta Platforms tried to buy Perplexity earlier this year. Meta announced a $14.8 billion investment in Scale AI last week and hired Scale AI CEO Alexandr Wang to lead its new superintelligence unit. Adrian Perica, Apple's head of mergers and acquisitions, has weighed the idea with services chief Eddy Cue and top AI decision-makers, as per the report. The iPhone maker reportedly plans to integrate AI-driven search capabilities - such as Perplexity AI - into its Safari browser, potentially moving away from its longstanding partnership with Alphabet's Google . Banning Google from paying companies to make it their default search engine is one of the remedies proposed by the U.S. Department of Justice to break up its dominance in online search. While traditional search engines such as Google still dominate global market share, AI-powered search options including Perplexity and ChatGPT are gaining prominence and seeing rising user adoption, especially among younger generations. Perplexity recently completed a funding round that valued it at $14 billion, Bloomberg News reported. A deal close to that would be Apple's largest acquisition so far. The Nvidia-backed startup provides AI search tools that deliver information summaries to users, similar to OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Gemini.

Hans India

an hour ago

• Hans India

Apple Weighs Potential Bid for AI Startup Perplexity Amid Growing Industry Interest

Apple Inc. is reportedly exploring the possibility of acquiring Perplexity, a fast-rising artificial intelligence startup, as part of its broader push into AI-powered search technologies. According to Bloomberg News, internal discussions have taken place among senior Apple executives, although no formal offer has been made and the talks remain at an early stage. The report suggests that Adrian Perica, Apple's head of mergers and acquisitions, has informally discussed the potential deal with services chief Eddy Cue and top AI strategists. However, sources indicated that Perplexity's leadership has not yet been approached, and Apple has not issued any public comment on the matter. In response to media inquiries, Perplexity stated it is unaware of any ongoing or upcoming M&A discussions. This news comes on the heels of mounting interest from other tech giants in Perplexity. Meta Platforms also reportedly explored acquiring the startup earlier this year, underscoring the growing competition in AI-driven search. Meta recently committed $14.8 billion to Scale AI and appointed its CEO Alexandr Wang to head a new superintelligence division, reinforcing the urgency among tech giants to secure AI talent and infrastructure. Founded with backing from Nvidia, Perplexity is valued at $14 billion following a recent funding round. Its core offering is an AI search tool that delivers concise, context-aware answers to users, positioning it as a strong alternative to traditional search engines like Google. As Apple considers enhancing its Safari browser with AI search capabilities, integrating technology similar to Perplexity could serve as a major step in reducing its dependency on Alphabet's Google—currently Safari's default search engine. The U.S. Department of Justice has proposed regulatory measures to curb Google's search monopoly, including banning it from paying companies to secure default search status. This regulatory backdrop may accelerate Apple's shift toward developing or acquiring in-house search solutions. While the traditional search market remains dominated by Google, new AI-powered platforms like Perplexity and OpenAI's ChatGPT are rapidly gaining traction, especially among younger users who favor faster, more intuitive information delivery. If Apple moves forward with an acquisition close to Perplexity's reported valuation, it could mark the company's largest-ever deal—a sign of how seriously the iPhone maker is taking the AI arms race.