MPACT should sell Festival Walk or merge to get more Singapore-centric
SINGAPORE'S largest mall, VivoCity, with over a million square feet of lettable area, is much loved by shoppers. However, the mall's owner – Mapletree Pan Asia Commercial Trust (MPACT) – receives little affection from investors.
In terms of trading price relative to book value, MPACT is performing the worst among the seven real estate investment trusts (Reits) that are members of the benchmark Straits Times Index (STI).
As at May 6, MPACT, which owns properties owned primarily for office and/or retail purposes, traded at a 32 per cent discount to its end-March 2025 net asset value (NAV) per unit of S$1.78.
In contrast, peers on the STI which own mainly office and/or retail properties – CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust (CICT) and Frasers Centrepoint Trust (FCT) – trade at around their latest reported NAV per unit. Both have much more Singapore-centric property portfolios than MPACT does.
Perhaps, unitholders of Singapore-focused Mapletree Commercial Trust are ruing the aforesaid merging with Mapletree North Asia Commercial Trust, which owned properties in Hong Kong, China, Japan and South Korea, to form MPACT in 2022.
Is MPACT's poor market valuation largely due to its ownership of Festival Walk in Hong Kong's Kowloon Tong? Maybe, the trust should aim to get better valuation from investors by turning much more Singapore-centric.
A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU
Tuesday, 12 pm Property Insights
Get an exclusive analysis of real estate and property news in Singapore and beyond.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Festival Walk was valued at HK$23.8 billion, or around S$4.1 billion at end-March. The shopping and entertainment strip and VivoCity accounted for about 25.6 per cent and 24.2 per cent of MPACT's end-March property portfolio valuation, respectively. At end-Mar, VivoCity's valuation was up 14.8 per cent, but Festival Walk's fell 5.2 per cent in local currency terms from its level the year before.
VivoCity, located in Singapore's HarbourFront area, is way more productive than Festival Walk – the former's net property income (NPI) for the financial year ended Mar 31 (FY2025) of S$176.6 million was 18.7 per cent higher than the latter's NPI of S$148.8 million.
Amid a challenging environment for Hong Kong's retail landlords, tenant sales at Festival Walk fell 8.4 per cent year on year in FY2025. Rental reversion at Festival Walk was down 6.9 per cent, while VivoCity's climbed 16.8 per cent.
Selling Festival Walk
By selling Festival Walk, MPACT becomes much more Singapore-centric, which might help its unit price re-rate upwards.
At end-March, Singapore assets accounted for 56.5 per cent of MPACT's property portfolio valuation of nearly S$16 billion, with the properties in Hong Kong, China, Japan and South Korea contributing the remainder.
Excluding Festival Walk, the Singapore assets contribute about 75.9 per cent to the trust's end-March property valuation. Besides VivoCity, MPACT's other assets here are Mapletree Business City and mTower in the Alexandra area, and Bank of America HarbourFront in the HarbourFront area.
However, can Festival Walk transact at or above its latest valuation? If needed, MPACT's sponsor Temasek-owned Mapletree Investments could buy Festival Walk at valuation.
While acquiring Festival Walk may not be at the top of its agenda, Mapletree can show it is a strong sponsor who adds value to MPACT's unitholders by taking Festival Walk off the trust's hands.
Showing that it is a strong sponsor will enhance Mapletree's credibility in property fund management. The Temasek-owned group is active in managing Singapore-listed Reits and private equity real estate funds that own assets across diverse geographies and property asset types.
Moreover, as Mapletree is a major unitholder of MPACT, it gains from any improvement in the trust's trading price.
Divesting Festival Walk not only makes MPACT more Singapore-centric, but also raises cash to potentially make additional acquisitions in Singapore.
MPACT could possibly buy The Woodleigh Mall, in which Cuscaden Peak has ownership interest. Mapletree jointly owns Cuscaden Peak, alongside Temasek's CLA Real Estate.
Over time, MPACT might eye buying Paragon along Orchard Road, after a potential major asset enhancement initiative. Cuscaden Peak will fully own Paragon after privatising Paragon Reit .
Pursuing a merger
Alternatively, MPACT could add scale and Singapore-centricity by merging with another trust.
An MPACT- Suntec Reit merger can make sense. Suntec Reit owns properties that are used mainly for office and/or retail purposes in Singapore, Australia and UK, with a total valuation of S$11.8 billion at end-2024. The Singapore assets contributed about 78 per cent of the said valuation.
As Suntec Reit trades at a larger discount to NAV than MPACT, Suntec Reit's unitholders may be happy to exchange units in it for units in a merged MPACT-Suntec Reit.
Another possibility is for MPACT to merge with CICT, which owns about S$26 billion of properties as at end-2024 and has Singapore assets accounting for nearly 95 per cent of property valuation.
A potential CICT-MPACT merger would enable MPACT's unitholders to hold units in a larger entity that is more Singapore-centric and likely to trade at a far superior multiple to book value than MPACT. Can Mapletree, which owns MPACT's manager, stomach possibly losing lucrative recurrent fund management income as part of this merger?
Reits have been a major success story on the local bourse. For them to continue to win the confidence of investors, sponsors and managers, they need to pro-actively create unitholder value.
MPACT has scale and a crown jewel in VivoCity. The mall's performance might improve further when ongoing major asset enhancements works are completed, possibly by end-2025.
However, managing VivoCity well is not enough. MPACT's manager must urgently address the trust's poor equities market valuation.
MPACT's manager should consider selling Festival Walk and/or a merger to help improve MPACT's unit price, thereby benefiting all unitholders.
The writer owns units in MPACT
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
Increased building height limits near airports could boost land values, unlock urban growth: Analysts
SINGAPORE: Relaxing height limits for buildings near airports could improve land values and unlock urban space for various types of developments, analysts say. Their comments came after Minister for National Development Chee Hong Tat said in May that height restrictions on such buildings could be revised later in 2025, potentially paving the way for taller residential and commercial developments. Speaking in his portfolio then as transport minister, Mr Chee said the proposed changes could enable buildings in various areas across Singapore to be built higher - by up to 15 storeys more for residential use and up to nine storeys more for industrial and commercial purposes. The Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore has been working on this with the International Civil Aviation Organization, which is reviewing its height restriction requirements for the first time since the 1950s. Creating high-rise urban districts closer to airports can boost growth in sectors like tourism, hospitality and aviation-related services, as well as promote broader economic diversification, said Mr Hsieh Cheng-Hsien, an associate professor from the Singapore University of Social Sciences (SUSS). 'Through the safe optimisation of airspace facilitated by advanced navigation technologies, Singapore is well-positioned to improve land-use efficiency while maintaining stringent flight safety standards," he added. 'Areas previously restricted due to aviation constraints may be transformed into dynamic, economically productive urban centres." Singapore has two airports in Changi and Seletar, and four military airbases in Paya Lebar, Sembawang, Changi and Tengah. While the area immediately surrounding Changi Airport may be kept for industrial and warehouse use, neighbouring estates such as Changi, Pasir Ris and Tampines could expect to see taller public and private housing developments, said real estate professor Sing Tien Foo of the National University of Singapore's (NUS) Business School. He noted however that the noise from busy airport activities could still prevent residential development from being located too close. As for Seletar Airport, which caters to smaller private planes, revised height limits could "intensify" industrial and housing developments in the northern and northeastern coastal areas, Prof Sing said. Prof Sing said that for areas near Changi and Seletar airports, land intensity and total land value may increase in the short term, but property prices could decrease if taller buildings can be built with improved construction technologies. 'In the long-term, when the supply becomes more elastic and new space can be developed in the same towns and estates, prices could be moderated and stabilised,' he said. Dr Chua Yang Liang, head of research and consultancy at JLL Southeast Asia, also said any potential impact on property values would also depend on factors like corresponding adjustments to land betterment charges, construction costs and other financial considerations. ADVANCEMENTS IN AVIATION As cities around the world become more densely populated, there has been increasing pressure to free up land closer to airports. Although this might have seemed like a safety risk in the past, improvements in technology have made it safer for planes to fly in denser urban environments, said experts. Assoc Prof Hsieh, who heads a joint SUSS-Singapore Flying College programme, noted that modern planes are equipped with advanced flight management systems that enhance climb and descent profiles, support steeper approach angles and improve obstacle avoidance capabilities. Satellite-based navigation methods, too, now provide pilots with 'extremely precise' flight paths that minimise risks, said Mr John Tan, lead professional officer of aviation management at the Singapore Institute of Technology. 'Additionally, improved radar systems, advanced air traffic management tools and automated alert systems greatly improve pilots' situational awareness and allow quicker responses," he added. However, he warned that there were still risks with allowing taller buildings closer to airports, and that careful assessment would still be needed to guarantee safety. 'Taller buildings could increase risks such as obstructions in flight paths, disruption of radio navigation signals and complications during emergency situations," said Mr Tan. 'Buildings can also influence wind patterns, potentially creating turbulence during take-off and landing.' Any changes in height restrictions will require flight procedures to be updated for arriving and and departing flights, Mr Tan noted. Airport zoning maps, flight manuals and navigational charts must also be 'thoroughly revised". He said Singapore's approach so far to managing urban density near airports mirrored successful global cities like Hong Kong, Tokyo, and London. But Singapore stands out for its "integrated city planning, strict adherence to aviation safety standards and strategic use of advanced technology, all of which set an international benchmark for handling limited land around airports'.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Wilmar slips in S'pore after anti-graft action in Indonesia; Singtel falls on Optus penalty settlement
Shares of Singtel fell 2.28 per cent last week, closing at $3.86 on June 20. ST PHOTO: TARYN NG Market Insights Wilmar slips in S'pore after anti-graft action in Indonesia; Singtel falls on Optus penalty settlement SINGAPORE – Shares of Wilmar Group's Singapore-listed entity Wilmar International fell some 3 per cent last week after the Indonesian authorities seized 11.8 trillion rupiah (S$925.2 million) from the group in a palm oil graft case. The stock slipped below $3 for the first time since March 2020, closing on June 20 at $2.92. Indonesia's Attorney-General's Office said on June 17 that the seizure was part of efforts to recover state losses from corruption tied to the issuance of palm oil export permits in 2022. This comes as the Indonesian authorities are appealing against a court ruling that had cleared Wilmar and two other palm oil companies, which they accuse of paying bribes to obtain such export permits. Wilmar said the money would be returned if Indonesia's Supreme Court cleared the company of wrongdoing in the ongoing case, but would be forfeited in part or in full if the court ruled against it . Shares of Singtel fell 2.28 per cent last week, closing at $3.86 on June 20. Its Australia subsidiary Optus Mobile said on June 18 that it had reached a settlement with the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, after the competition watchdog in October 2024 filed court proceedings against Optus over allegations of sales misconduct. The settlement includes a proposed A$100 million (S$83 million) penalty, subject to approval by the Federal Court, as well as an enforceable undertaking requiring Optus to address the misconduct. These include making changes to its retail processes, systems and sales incentives. Optus added that it has apologised to affected customers and is providing them with remediation. Stocks react to escalating Israel-Iran conflict Several Singapore Exchange (SGX) stocks saw increased volatility last week amid escalating tensions between Israel and Iran, which also pushed crude oil prices higher. Shares of jet fuel trader China Aviation Oil closed 4.8 per cent higher at 88 cents on June 20. Crude oil and jet fuel are directly related because jet fuel is refined from crude oil. While rising oil prices can pressure fuel consumers, traders like China Aviation Oil tend to gain from wider margins and trading opportunities. In contrast, shares of Singapore Airlines, for which jet fuel is the largest operating cost, declined, falling over 1.7 per cent during the week to close at $6.79 on June 20. SGX-listed oil and gas companies rose, with Rex International up 4.8 per cent through the week to close on June 20 at 22 cents, while RH PetroGas inched 0.5 per cent higher to close at 20 cents. Offshore and marine stocks gained, too. Mermaid Maritime rose 3.6 per cent to 11 cents, Marco Polo Marine added 2.2 per cent to 4.6 cents and Seatrium inched 0.5 per cent higher to $2.06. All of Fu Yu's independent directors resign Shares of Fu Yu Corp fell more than 5 per cent last week, closing at nine cents on June 20. All independent directors of the components manufacturer resigned, leaving the company's chief executive as the sole remaining board member, according to SGX filings released on June 15. Independent directors Royston Tan and Christopher Huang resigned on June 11 following persistent attempts by former director of strategy Victor Lim to remove them from the board. Mr Lim is also the group's largest shareholder, holding some 29.5 per cent of Fu Yu shares as at Jan 9. He has been calling for Mr Tan and Mr Huang's resignations since January, citing the need for a 'strategic reset' of Fu Yu due to poor performance and falling shareholder value. Independent director Daniel Poh also resigned on June 11, citing differences in opinion over Fu Yu's direction on matters unrelated to the company's day-to-day business. Mr Tan and Mr Huang also gave the same reason for resigning. In an update to shareholders on June 17, group CEO David Seow said that the company is actively seeking to appoint new independent directors to the board and has reached out to the Singapore Institute of Directors to invite suitable candidates to apply. SGX listing rules require at least one-third of the board to be independent and that the group has at least two independent non-executive directors. In a June 20 filing lodged on the SGX after the market closed, Fu Yu said four proposed directors have been assessed by an independent party, with no findings made against their suitability for the role. Earlier on June 20, in response to questions from the Securities Investors Association (Singapore), or Sias, Fu Yu noted that its 'day-to-day operations and decision-making processes remain unaffected' by the resignation of all its independent directors. The update comes ahead of Fu Yu's annual general meeting on June 27. Other market movers Thakral Corp declined some 4 per cent last week, closing at $1.42 on June 20, even as an initial public offering (IPO) by its associate GemLife is expected to significantly uplift the group's financial position and unlock growth opportunities. Thakral announced on June 17 the IPO of GemLife Communities, an Australian over-50s lifestyle resort operator, to raise up to A$750 million at an implied post-money valuation of A$1.58 billion. The stapled securities are expected to be listed and quoted on the Australian Securities Exchange upon successful closing of the IPO on July 3. Thakral, which holds a 31.7 per cent stake in GemLife, intends to subscribe to additional stapled securities via the IPO. Post-dilution, Thakral's effective interest in GemLife will be about 16.8 per cent, the company said. CNMC Goldmine fell 6.52 per cent last week after gold prices tumbled following the US Federal Reserve's decision to keep interest rates unchanged at 4.25 per cent to 4.5 per cent. The stock closed at 43 cents on June 20 as the US Fed forecast higher inflation from US tariffs and cooler growth in 2025. Thai Beverage saw strong trading volumes throughout the week, when its stock slid some 3 per cent to close at 44 cents on June 20. The beverage-maker reported in May that net profit declined 9.2 per cent year on year to 17.8 billion Thai baht (S$699 million) in the first half of 2025. In an annual information meeting for shareholders in Singapore on June 20, Thai Beverage said its spirits business' net profit fell due to lower sales and higher raw material costs. Net profit for its non-alcoholic beverage and food businesses also declined. However, its beer business delivered an increase in net profit, thanks to strong sales and favourable raw material costs. What to look out for this week Watch out for further market volatility as the conflict in the Middle East continues to unfold. Over the weekend, US President Donald Trump said the US completed strikes on three nuclear sites in Iran, prompting a fresh barrage of missiles from Iran towards Israel. Additionally, keep an eye out for Singapore's consumer price index and manufacturing output for May, which are a key gauge of inflation and industrial momentum amid ongoing tariff uncertainties. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
CNA
4 hours ago
- CNA
CNA938 Rewind - A Letter to Myself: Jolene Tham carries family curry puff business forward with grit and gratitude
CNA938 Rewind - A Letter to Myself: Jolene Tham carries family curry puff business forward with grit and gratitude Jolene Tham, 25, is the third-generation owner of Rolina Traditional Hainanese Curry Puffs, located at Tanjong Pagar Market and Food Centre. She took over the family business in 2023, under difficult circumstances — soon after her father, the second-generation owner, was diagnosed with late-stage cancer. Jolene and her husband, Kwan Wei Lun, share how they had to quickly adapted to the heavy demands of the hawker trade and why they're grateful for having each other as they take the family business forward. 37 mins CNA938 Rewind - A Letter to Myself: How Aminah Abdul Latif teaches children to find themselves in nature Aminah Abdul Latif is the co-founder of the Hundred Paths forest school, which uses immersive experiences in Singapore's natural environment to help children discover invaluable lessons about their abilities and instincts. Aminah, who spent 13 years in the early childhood education sector, shares how her own love for nature began when she was a child, and how she realised that her ability to empathise deeply with others — especially children — has become her "superpower". 37 mins CNA938 Rewind - #TalkBack: How can we attract more people back to Pulau Ubin? Singapore could be looking to make Pulau Ubin more modern and accessible, without losing its natural charm. Lance Alexander and Daniel Martin discuss more with Dr Shawn Lum, Senior Lecturer at Nanyang Technological University (NTU) Asian School of the Environment. 28 mins
