I'm a working mum. Here's why I oppose Labor's universal childcare
Like every other parent I know right now, one of the biggest expenses in my budget is childcare. Of course, I greatly value it because it allows my partner and I to work, and offers amazing benefits for my child. But seeing how much we fork out on this service every week makes my stomach drop.
Since 2006, the cost of childcare has risen across Australia by 48 per cent for couples and 76 per cent for single parents. In Victoria alone, the current average fee for childcare is $145 a day before subsidies. So it's hardly surprising that for years now, people have been desperately calling for more to be done.
And when you combine those numbers with the facts that I'm both a working mum myself and passionate about making women's return to work easier, you might think I'd be all for the government's plan to introduce universal childcare. But you know what? I'm actually not.
There are a few reasons for this, and the first one is simple: the government's plan ignores expert advice, something I'm a big fan of. When the Productivity Commission looked into the government's proposed model - which would see childcare fees cost no more than between $10 and $20 a day for all Australian families - they found it would cost taxpayers an extra $8.3 billion each year, taking the annual total cost of childcare to $21 billion.
They also found it would increase demand, potentially reduce the quality of care, cost taxpayers much more than the commission's suggested model, and would not be equitable.
Their report to the government spelt this out plainly, stating: 'A disproportionate share of the increased government support would go to the families whose incomes are in the top 25 per cent of income distribution.' In other words, those who need the least help stand to gain the most.
Surely the goal should be to have a policy that is universally beneficial, not just universal in name.
So what was the alternative proposal? The commission suggested maintaining the existing system but changing the eligibility criteria, so that families earning less than $80,000 with one child and families earning up to $140,000 with multiple children in childcare can receive three free days of care each week for 48 weeks per year.
They also recommended removing the subsidy for families with a combined income of $580,000 or more. This model would cost an additional $4.7 billion annually – $3.6 billion less than the government's plan.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
28 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Discount Pies: How these old champs are on low contracts
Loading Collingwood greats Scott Pendlebury and Steele Sidebottom are playing for less than the AFL's average wage for a senior-listed player this year, in what has become a major benefit to the premiership favourites. Pendlebury, 37, and Sidebottom, 34, are contracted for deals in the range of $400,000 in 2025, plus the normal bonuses players can receive for best and fairest finishes and All-Australian selection, according to industry sources familiar with the outline of the super veterans' 2025 deals. Even if either earned best and fairest or All-Australian bonuses, Pendlebury and Sidebottom would still fall short of the $500,771 that is the average for an AFL senior-listed player (not including rookie list players) in 2025. Like Sidebottom, match-winning forward Jamie Elliott, 32, has been in near-career peak form this year – sitting third on the AFL goalkicking table – and is being paid well below his level of performance, relative to the competition. To place Pendlebury's and Sidebottom's deals for this year in perspective, collectively they are paid close to half the amount offered to Carlton's Tom De Koning, by St Kilda, on an annual basis, should the free-agent ruckman take up the Saints' monstrous long-term offer of $1.7 million a year. The Magpies have indicated a wish to retain Pendlebury and Sidebottom, along with Elliott, in 2026. Assuming a reasonable run with injury, Pendlebury (414 games) would break the AFL games record of 432 held by Brent Harvey next year, should he sign on, as now appears likely, for a 21st season. Defender Jeremy Howe, too, is reportedly favoured to be offered a contract. That Pendlebury, Sidebottom, Elliott and Howe have been able to perform at high levels, despite being well into their 30s, has been of benefit to the ladder leaders, who had enough space in their salary cap to acquire Dan Houston from Port Adelaide and Harry Perryman from Greater Western Sydney.
The Age
33 minutes ago
- The Age
Discount Pies: How these old champs are on low contracts
Loading Collingwood greats Scott Pendlebury and Steele Sidebottom are playing for less than the AFL's average wage for a senior-listed player this year, in what has become a major benefit to the premiership favourites. Pendlebury, 37, and Sidebottom, 34, are contracted for deals in the range of $400,000 in 2025, plus the normal bonuses players can receive for best and fairest finishes and All-Australian selection, according to industry sources familiar with the outline of the super veterans' 2025 deals. Even if either earned best and fairest or All-Australian bonuses, Pendlebury and Sidebottom would still fall short of the $500,771 that is the average for an AFL senior-listed player (not including rookie list players) in 2025. Like Sidebottom, match-winning forward Jamie Elliott, 32, has been in near-career peak form this year – sitting third on the AFL goalkicking table – and is being paid well below his level of performance, relative to the competition. To place Pendlebury's and Sidebottom's deals for this year in perspective, collectively they are paid close to half the amount offered to Carlton's Tom De Koning, by St Kilda, on an annual basis, should the free-agent ruckman take up the Saints' monstrous long-term offer of $1.7 million a year. The Magpies have indicated a wish to retain Pendlebury and Sidebottom, along with Elliott, in 2026. Assuming a reasonable run with injury, Pendlebury (414 games) would break the AFL games record of 432 held by Brent Harvey next year, should he sign on, as now appears likely, for a 21st season. Defender Jeremy Howe, too, is reportedly favoured to be offered a contract. That Pendlebury, Sidebottom, Elliott and Howe have been able to perform at high levels, despite being well into their 30s, has been of benefit to the ladder leaders, who had enough space in their salary cap to acquire Dan Houston from Port Adelaide and Harry Perryman from Greater Western Sydney.
The Advertiser
37 minutes ago
- The Advertiser
Australian stock market snaps five-week winning streak
Australia's share market has given up a five-week winning streak, as investors grapple with military conflict, global growth concerns and lofty valuations. The S&P/ASX200 fell 18.2 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5, as the broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5. Over the week, the top-200 stocks fell roughly 0.5 per cent. The slump came after six sessions of surging oil prices amid escalating Israel-Iran conflict and as US President Donald Trump flagged potential American military involvement within two weeks. The broader investor uncertainty then collided with heavy falls in big miners after weak economic data from China, as Rio Tinto plummeted to its lowest close since 2022, IG Markets analyst Tony Sycamore told AAP. Five of 11 local sectors sectors improved on Friday, but a whopping 4.4 per cent drop in materials stocks over the week weighed on the bourse. "The big concern for the ASX200 going into the new financial year is the elevated valuations around these banks and that no one wants to touch these big miners," Mr Sycamore said. "There's been 23 months of falling house prices in China, and that doesn't augur well for the price of iron ore or for the price of the big miners, which remain an influential part of the index." Financials slipped 0.6 per cent on Friday to finish roughly flat for a second week, a day after CBA etched its latest record high of $183.31 a share. All four big banks closed in the red, with ANZ facing the sharpest decline with a 2.5 per cent slip to $28.39. In banking news, former federal coalition finance minister Simon Birmingham was appointed the Australian Banking Association's chief executive, replacing Anna Bligh after eight years at the helm. Australian energy stocks have had a massive week, surging almost 11 per cent since Israel launched air strikes on Iran last Friday. Woodside is up 7.7 per cent over the same period, while Santos has rallied 12 per cent. Oil prices hit their highest levels since January overnight as the conflict raged on, but eased to $US75.24 a barrel after Mr Trump's two-week decision window relieved fears of an immediate US attack. The IT sector had a surprisingly good week despite broader risk-off sentiment, edging 0.3 per cent higher since Monday's open. The Australian dollar is buying 64.76 US cents, up slightly from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm, coiling tightly near the mid-level of its recent range with the greenback. Looking ahead, while the Middle East conflict is likely to dominate headlines, it's also a massive week for macroeconomic data. Investors will be poring over local inflation figures, US economic growth, and manufacturing data for four of the world's seven largest economies. ON THE ASX: * The benchmark S&P/ASX200 index finished Friday 18.2 points lower, or down 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5 * The broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5 CURRENCY SNAPSHOT: One Australian dollar buys: * 64.76 US cents, from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm * 94.13 Japanese yen, from 93.99 Japanese yen * 56.24 Euro cents, from 56.43 Euro cents * 48.09 British pence, from 48.27 pence * 108.05 NZ cents, from 108.34 NZ cents Australia's share market has given up a five-week winning streak, as investors grapple with military conflict, global growth concerns and lofty valuations. The S&P/ASX200 fell 18.2 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5, as the broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5. Over the week, the top-200 stocks fell roughly 0.5 per cent. The slump came after six sessions of surging oil prices amid escalating Israel-Iran conflict and as US President Donald Trump flagged potential American military involvement within two weeks. The broader investor uncertainty then collided with heavy falls in big miners after weak economic data from China, as Rio Tinto plummeted to its lowest close since 2022, IG Markets analyst Tony Sycamore told AAP. Five of 11 local sectors sectors improved on Friday, but a whopping 4.4 per cent drop in materials stocks over the week weighed on the bourse. "The big concern for the ASX200 going into the new financial year is the elevated valuations around these banks and that no one wants to touch these big miners," Mr Sycamore said. "There's been 23 months of falling house prices in China, and that doesn't augur well for the price of iron ore or for the price of the big miners, which remain an influential part of the index." Financials slipped 0.6 per cent on Friday to finish roughly flat for a second week, a day after CBA etched its latest record high of $183.31 a share. All four big banks closed in the red, with ANZ facing the sharpest decline with a 2.5 per cent slip to $28.39. In banking news, former federal coalition finance minister Simon Birmingham was appointed the Australian Banking Association's chief executive, replacing Anna Bligh after eight years at the helm. Australian energy stocks have had a massive week, surging almost 11 per cent since Israel launched air strikes on Iran last Friday. Woodside is up 7.7 per cent over the same period, while Santos has rallied 12 per cent. Oil prices hit their highest levels since January overnight as the conflict raged on, but eased to $US75.24 a barrel after Mr Trump's two-week decision window relieved fears of an immediate US attack. The IT sector had a surprisingly good week despite broader risk-off sentiment, edging 0.3 per cent higher since Monday's open. The Australian dollar is buying 64.76 US cents, up slightly from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm, coiling tightly near the mid-level of its recent range with the greenback. Looking ahead, while the Middle East conflict is likely to dominate headlines, it's also a massive week for macroeconomic data. Investors will be poring over local inflation figures, US economic growth, and manufacturing data for four of the world's seven largest economies. ON THE ASX: * The benchmark S&P/ASX200 index finished Friday 18.2 points lower, or down 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5 * The broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5 CURRENCY SNAPSHOT: One Australian dollar buys: * 64.76 US cents, from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm * 94.13 Japanese yen, from 93.99 Japanese yen * 56.24 Euro cents, from 56.43 Euro cents * 48.09 British pence, from 48.27 pence * 108.05 NZ cents, from 108.34 NZ cents Australia's share market has given up a five-week winning streak, as investors grapple with military conflict, global growth concerns and lofty valuations. The S&P/ASX200 fell 18.2 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5, as the broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5. Over the week, the top-200 stocks fell roughly 0.5 per cent. The slump came after six sessions of surging oil prices amid escalating Israel-Iran conflict and as US President Donald Trump flagged potential American military involvement within two weeks. The broader investor uncertainty then collided with heavy falls in big miners after weak economic data from China, as Rio Tinto plummeted to its lowest close since 2022, IG Markets analyst Tony Sycamore told AAP. Five of 11 local sectors sectors improved on Friday, but a whopping 4.4 per cent drop in materials stocks over the week weighed on the bourse. "The big concern for the ASX200 going into the new financial year is the elevated valuations around these banks and that no one wants to touch these big miners," Mr Sycamore said. "There's been 23 months of falling house prices in China, and that doesn't augur well for the price of iron ore or for the price of the big miners, which remain an influential part of the index." Financials slipped 0.6 per cent on Friday to finish roughly flat for a second week, a day after CBA etched its latest record high of $183.31 a share. All four big banks closed in the red, with ANZ facing the sharpest decline with a 2.5 per cent slip to $28.39. In banking news, former federal coalition finance minister Simon Birmingham was appointed the Australian Banking Association's chief executive, replacing Anna Bligh after eight years at the helm. Australian energy stocks have had a massive week, surging almost 11 per cent since Israel launched air strikes on Iran last Friday. Woodside is up 7.7 per cent over the same period, while Santos has rallied 12 per cent. Oil prices hit their highest levels since January overnight as the conflict raged on, but eased to $US75.24 a barrel after Mr Trump's two-week decision window relieved fears of an immediate US attack. The IT sector had a surprisingly good week despite broader risk-off sentiment, edging 0.3 per cent higher since Monday's open. The Australian dollar is buying 64.76 US cents, up slightly from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm, coiling tightly near the mid-level of its recent range with the greenback. Looking ahead, while the Middle East conflict is likely to dominate headlines, it's also a massive week for macroeconomic data. Investors will be poring over local inflation figures, US economic growth, and manufacturing data for four of the world's seven largest economies. ON THE ASX: * The benchmark S&P/ASX200 index finished Friday 18.2 points lower, or down 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5 * The broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5 CURRENCY SNAPSHOT: One Australian dollar buys: * 64.76 US cents, from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm * 94.13 Japanese yen, from 93.99 Japanese yen * 56.24 Euro cents, from 56.43 Euro cents * 48.09 British pence, from 48.27 pence * 108.05 NZ cents, from 108.34 NZ cents Australia's share market has given up a five-week winning streak, as investors grapple with military conflict, global growth concerns and lofty valuations. The S&P/ASX200 fell 18.2 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5, as the broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5. Over the week, the top-200 stocks fell roughly 0.5 per cent. The slump came after six sessions of surging oil prices amid escalating Israel-Iran conflict and as US President Donald Trump flagged potential American military involvement within two weeks. The broader investor uncertainty then collided with heavy falls in big miners after weak economic data from China, as Rio Tinto plummeted to its lowest close since 2022, IG Markets analyst Tony Sycamore told AAP. Five of 11 local sectors sectors improved on Friday, but a whopping 4.4 per cent drop in materials stocks over the week weighed on the bourse. "The big concern for the ASX200 going into the new financial year is the elevated valuations around these banks and that no one wants to touch these big miners," Mr Sycamore said. "There's been 23 months of falling house prices in China, and that doesn't augur well for the price of iron ore or for the price of the big miners, which remain an influential part of the index." Financials slipped 0.6 per cent on Friday to finish roughly flat for a second week, a day after CBA etched its latest record high of $183.31 a share. All four big banks closed in the red, with ANZ facing the sharpest decline with a 2.5 per cent slip to $28.39. In banking news, former federal coalition finance minister Simon Birmingham was appointed the Australian Banking Association's chief executive, replacing Anna Bligh after eight years at the helm. Australian energy stocks have had a massive week, surging almost 11 per cent since Israel launched air strikes on Iran last Friday. Woodside is up 7.7 per cent over the same period, while Santos has rallied 12 per cent. Oil prices hit their highest levels since January overnight as the conflict raged on, but eased to $US75.24 a barrel after Mr Trump's two-week decision window relieved fears of an immediate US attack. The IT sector had a surprisingly good week despite broader risk-off sentiment, edging 0.3 per cent higher since Monday's open. The Australian dollar is buying 64.76 US cents, up slightly from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm, coiling tightly near the mid-level of its recent range with the greenback. Looking ahead, while the Middle East conflict is likely to dominate headlines, it's also a massive week for macroeconomic data. Investors will be poring over local inflation figures, US economic growth, and manufacturing data for four of the world's seven largest economies. ON THE ASX: * The benchmark S&P/ASX200 index finished Friday 18.2 points lower, or down 0.21 per cent, to 8,505.5 * The broader All Ordinaries lost 17.9 points, or 0.2 per cent, to 8,723.5 CURRENCY SNAPSHOT: One Australian dollar buys: * 64.76 US cents, from 64.71 US cents on Thursday at 5pm * 94.13 Japanese yen, from 93.99 Japanese yen * 56.24 Euro cents, from 56.43 Euro cents * 48.09 British pence, from 48.27 pence * 108.05 NZ cents, from 108.34 NZ cents
