Defence stocks rally shows FOMO taking over rationality, says Kotak's Atul Bhole
Agencies Studying or looking at history (of markets) over a longer period can help us manage behaviour in a much better way.
The recent ferocious rally in defence stocks post the recent skirmish is yet another example of greed or FOMO taking over the rational investing behavior, says Atul Bhole, EVP & Fund Manager, Kotak Mahindra Asset Management Company.
"Since Operation Sindoor, defence stocks bounced back significantly and are again trading at much higher valuations than can be justified by fundamentals. While companies could deliver sustainable growth over many years, the street seemed to have factored in a lot, in a very short period. Hence there can be some cooling-off or longer consolidation in stock prices," he said in a chat with ET Markets.
Edited excerpts:
Markets are dancing near lifetime highs. How much of this is driven by fundamentals and how much by FOMO?
India's macro fundamentals are in a really sweet spot & proving to be one of the strongest versus major global economies. Tightly controlled fiscal & current account deficits, lower inflation & stable currency while maintaining growth handle around 6-6.5% are attracting back foreign flows in a major way. While the macro fundamentals have been stronger for quite some time, the resilience & the sweet spot became more apparent during the current global trade war. While from the start of the year to mid-April, FIIs sold close to $15 bn, from mid-April the flows turned positive and since then FIIs bought around $5.5 billion of Indian equities. This buying, too, is happening largely from the secondary market than IPOs/QIPS or direct stake sales. Domestic flows have actually been very reasonable in activity with cash levels in mutual funds rising & retail participation also been in check vs. the recent past. While corporate earnings growth is still muted & valuations on the higher side, the strong macro fundamentals are directing robust foreign as well as domestic flows to Indian equity markets.
What's your reading of retail investor behaviour right now? Have most of them learnt lessons after playing with fire by chasing SME and momentum-heavy smallcaps?
Some SMID stocks had seen value erosion of 40-60% during June-July'24 to Mar-Apr'25 period. These stocks were in momentum with false support of narratives, illiquidity & greed/FOMO & were devoid of fundamentals or valuations. Institutional investors like mutual funds which invest with research & expert insights could avoid such pitfalls & protect the level of drawdowns. Few investors would have definitely learnt lessons in this episode & hopefully start appreciating the value mutual funds/advisors add in long-term wealth creation. However, the market is like a voting machine in the short term & keeps attracting new investors or making the same investors repeat newer mistakes. The recent ferocious rally in defence stocks post the recent skirmish is yet another example of greed or FOMO taking over the rational investing behaviour.
Operation Sindoor has also worked like an international defence expo showcasing the might of Indian defence companies. This is also reflected in the dramatic movement in share prices. How strong is the defence story on Dalal Street?
Indian defence equipment industry has gathered robust momentum in the past 3-5 years with strong indigenisation push by the Government as well as bigger & expedited orders. The eco-system is getting developed nicely with private sector companies emerging as credible component manufacturers. The stocks did extremely well post-Covid till mid of 2024 on these policy enablers & effective implementation. However, more than the earnings growth, valuation multiple or PE re-rating was the bigger driver of stock returns. From an average of 10-20x PE, these stocks went on to trade at 50-60x PE. As mentioned above, from mid of 2024 to Mar'2025, some stocks experienced 40-60% drawdown from extremely over-stretched levels. Since Operation Sindoor, defence stocks bounced back significantly and are again trading at much higher valuations than can be justified by fundamentals. While companies could deliver sustainable growth over many years, the street seemed to have factored in a lot, in a very short period. Hence there can be some cooling-off or longer consolidation in stock prices.With valuations stretched in certain pockets of the market, do you think the Q4 earnings season was strong enough to justify the rally that we are seeing?
Q4 earning season is turning out to be muted yet again in absolute terms, with 5-10% earnings growth depending on sectors or large cap/SMID etc. Market is not overtly disappointed as expectations were already lowered post 3 quarters of continuous low-growth & weak corporate commentaries. Markets are forward-looking and though Q4 is not up-to-the mark, going forward earnings are expected to pick-up with tax breaks, in-line monsoons, better wage & salary increases, continued capex etc & particularly with the help of low base. The current rally is largely driven by strong macro fundamentals & subsequent flows; the market may take a pause till corporate India starts to deliver better earnings growth.As an investor today, would you back consumption, capex, or financials in FY26?
Post-covid all sectors or themes had experienced rallies for particular duration of time & are trading at fair to high valuations at present. The triggers which worked on those sectors at that particular point of time had also played out well. As things keep normalising, we believe, returns would be driven by individual stock selection across sectors depending on earning triggers & valuations. At the sub-sector level, we like quick commerce, hospitals, power T&D, EMS, larger Pvt banks & NBFCs etc from the domestic side of the economy. As a contrarian investment, the IT sector can be evaluated with US corporates holding up better than expected & good dividend yield support for the stocks.
Given current earnings momentum, macro tailwinds, and political stability bets, is Nifty 30,000 a realistic target by end of FY26?
While at the macro level, most of the things are moving in the right direction for India, it has to start reflecting in corporate profitability as well. Post the recent rally, Indian markets are again trading at 21-22x PE on a 1-year forward basis. These multiples require earnings to grow at a much better rate than the current pace. While it can pick-up with better disposable income growth, continued capex & reforms etc. global trade war & global growth remains bigger variables. India appears to be in a better situation as of now, but larger economic blocks like China & Europe can start attracting large amounts of capital depending on tariff negotiations & changing fiscal / monetary policies given relative valuations advantage. US fiscal position & dollar valuation would also impact flows & hence asset prices.
Investors have been caught between two battlefronts lately — the global trade tariff war and the near war-like tensions between India and Pakistan. Now that both seem to be easing, what are the key takeaways for investors from this double dose of geopolitical anxiety?
Over a longer period, stock prices & markets are slaves of earning growth. In shorter terms, there can be under or over valuations depending on news flows & sentiments. In the past 5 years, we have probably experienced things which typically happen in a decade or century perhaps. Covid pandemic, wars, supply chain obstacles, outlandish progress in computing power & adoption of AI or the strategies of the mightiest sovereign (the USA) to get its balance sheet in shape etc. events have just happened or are still taking place. Markets continued & evolved in their journey throughout. Investors obviously need to adapt to new realities while keeping the hat of age-old investing principles intact. Studying or looking at history (of markets) over a longer period can help us manage behaviour in a much better way. Patience, systematic investing & exploiting episodes of greed & fear to our advantage helps in achieving the investing goals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
13 minutes ago
- Hans India
Weekly charts suggest positive momentum
The equities rebounded on the weekend and broke the 3-day losing streak. The Nifty gained by 393.80 points or 1.59 per cent. BSE Sensex also gained by 1.59 per cent. The broader market was weak, as the Midcap-100 and Smallcap-100 declined by 0.40 per cent, and 0.98 per cent. On the sectoral front, the Nifty Auto is the top gainer, with a 1.51 per cent increase, followed by IT with a 1.36 per cent rise. The Banknifty and FinNifty advanced by 1.36 per cent and 1.19 per cent, respectively. On the flip side, the Nifty Pharma is down by 1.69 per cent, and Metal fell by 1.30 per cent. The Energy and FMCG declined by 0.39 per cent and 0.19 per cent, respectively. The market breadth is mostly negative. The India VIX is down by 9.33 per cent to 13.67. The FIIs bought Rs3,897.21 crores, and the DIIs bought Rs56,786.30 crores worth of equities in this month. The Nifty has formed strong bull candles on the weekly and daily time frames. Before closing near the pivot, the index oscillated around the 20 DMA. A massive spurt in volumes on Friday indicates renewed buying support. The FIIs bought Rs.7940.70 crore worth of equities on Friday, which supports the volume spurt. The Nifty is still in the consolidation range, but closing near the pivot, indicates a probable breakout. The previous week's low of 24473, which formed on a negative(Israel-Iran War beginning) news. All the recent lows are formed on a negative news flow. The market discounted the war implications. During the consolidation, all the big bull candles were followed by a series of bearish candles. If the index closes above 24222 decisively, with a volume support, it will result in a massive rally. As stated earlier, the undertone is strongly bullish. The worry is... last week's weakness in the broader market. The midcap and smallcaps underperformed, showing poor relative strength and loss of momentum. On a weekly chart, the 10-week average is in a strong uptrend. The RSI is back into the above 60 zone, which is an indication of a strong uptrend. Interestingly, this trend strength is not reflected in the Directional Movement Index. The ADX, +DMI and -DMIs are declining. The daily ADX is also declining. This is an interesting technical development to watch. The India VIX is back to the lower range of 13.67. This volatility index has an inverse relationship with the benchmark index. In the recent past, whenever the VIX declines below 13, it tends to decline from the highs. For the last two weeks, the global markets have also been weak and have failed to sustain the opening gains. The crude oil prices will influence the equity markets. The closure of the Hormuz Strait will impact the oil supplies. Keep an eye on geopolitical events and crude oil movements that can affect the equity market. For a decisive uptrend, the Bulls must close above the 24222 - 307 zone of resistance. If it sustains above this zone for a week, we will test the new high. The new target is at 26800. In any case, the index declines below the 10-week average of 24570, will be negative and will resume the downside. It is better to stay with a positive bias as long as it is in the consolidation range, as the internal strength is strong. The sector rotation is perfectly going on as the traditional defensives are in the limelight. The India Defence stocks are in focus too. As the RBI pushes liquidity in the market, the Banks and financials are also in focus. (The author is partner, Wealocity Analytics, Sebi-registered research analyst, chief mentor, Indus School of Technical Analysis, financial journalist, technical analyst and trainer)
Economic Times
18 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Indian rupee, bonds under pressure as US strike on Iran deepens Middle East conflict
The Indian rupee and government bonds are poised to face pressure this week following a U.S. strike on Iran, raising concerns of higher oil prices and potential retaliation that could deepen the conflict in the Middle East. ADVERTISEMENT The rupee had closed at 86.5850 against the U.S. dollar on Friday, down 0.6% on the week. U.S. President Donald Trump said late on Saturday that the country had struck Iran's main nuclear sites, aligning with an Israeli offensive in a significant escalation of the ongoing Middle East tensions. Tehran called the attack a grave violation of international law and vowed to defend itself. In a televised address, Trump warned Iran against retaliating, stating that any response would trigger further attacks unless Iran agreed to pursue peace. Concerns over a potential escalation of the conflict had already driven oil prices higher this month, and analysts now anticipate an additional increase of $3 to $5 per barrel in reaction to the U.S. strikes. ADVERTISEMENT Brent crude oil futures closed at $77 per barrel on Friday, up nearly 4% on week. Elevated energy prices are a pain point for the Indian rupee and government bonds, as oil is a major component of India's import bill. ADVERTISEMENT A "flight to safety is likely to reinforce the dollar's strength against the Indian rupee and other major currencies," said Dilip Parmar, a foreign exchange research analyst at HDFC Securities. The rupee could weaken towards 87.50 in the near-term, Parmar added. Traders reckon that the Reserve Bank of India would likely step in to curb excessive volatility. ADVERTISEMENT The rupee may find immediate support around 87.50-87.60 but will remain acutely sensitive to developments in the Middle East, said a trader at a state-run bank. Foreign portfolio flows related to a upcoming large IPO alongside remarks from U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, scheduled for Tuesday, will be among other cues in focus for the rupee this week. ADVERTISEMENT Meanwhile, India's 10-year benchmark 6.33% 2035 bond yield ended at 6.3087% on Friday. Traders expect it to move in a range of 6.30% to 6.40% this week. "A $10 per barrel rise in crude could widen India's current account deficit by 0.3% of GDP and elevate inflation, eroding real yields," CR Forex said. Earlier this month, the RBI reduced its inflation forecast for the current fiscal year to 3.7% and cut its key lending rate by a steeper-than-expected 50 basis points. A big rate cut would assure stakeholders of India's focus on economic growth and aid in faster transmission, members of rate setting panel wrote in the June policy minutes. However, it reverted to a "neutral" stance from "accommodative", prompting analysts to forecast an end to the monetary easing cycle. "International uncertainties make RBI think it is necessary to front load the monetary easing to boost growth. But RBI may take longer to see the impact before implementing another cut going forward. Looking forward, we see RBI to stay on hold for next few months, said Alaa Bushehri, head of emerging market Debt, BNP Paribas Asset Management. KEY EVENTS: ** June HSBC India manufacturing, services and composite Flash PMI - June 23, Monday (10:30 a.m. IST) U.S. ** June S&P Global manufacturing, services and composite Flash PMI - June 23, Monday (7:15 p.m. IST) ** May existing home sales - June 23, Monday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** June consumer confidence - June 24, Tuesday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** May new home sales units - June 25, Wednesday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** May durable goods - June 26, Thursday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** January-March GDP final - June 26, Thursday (6:00 p.m. IST)(Reuters poll -0.2%) ** Initial weekly jobless claims for week to June 16 - June 26, Thursday (6:00 p.m. IST) ** May personal consumption expenditure index, core PCE index - June 27, Friday (6:00 p.m. IST) ** June U Mich sentiment final - June 27, Friday (7:30 p.m. IST)
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
Rs 1 lakh crore FII selloff in 6 sectors! Are you still holding the wrong stocks?
Live Events Valuations at Tipping Point Earnings Under Pressure Where the Smart Money Is Moving Bottom Line: What Should Investors Do? (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) have gone on a selling spree, offloading nearly Rs 1 lakh crore worth of Indian equities in just six months across six key sectors of consumer durables FMCG , and IT . The sharp pullback, concentrated in segments once considered defensives or structural bets, underscores rising concerns around valuations, global macro uncertainty, and a shifting earnings biggest casualty is the IT sector, which alone has seen Rs 33,479 crore in net FII outflows, or a third of total selling. This is followed by FMCG (Rs 17,819 crore), auto (Rs 16,058 crore), consumer services (Rs 14,417 crore), power (Rs 12,231 crore), and consumer durables (Rs 11,296 crore).'We continue to maintain our underweight stance in the IT sector, as we foresee a slowdown in overall IT spending in the US market and a probable delay in discretionary spending,' said Neeraj Chadawar, Head of Fundamental and Quantitative Research at Axis Securities. 'Guidance and commentary remain critical for the sector going forward.'The broad-based nature of the selling suggests a structural de-risking rather than just profit-taking. Even construction (-Rs 9,322 crore) and healthcare (-Rs 9,048 crore) have witnessed sharp outflows. In contrast, only a handful of sectors have seen net FII inflows, including telecom (Rs 23,065 crore) and financials (Rs 9,456 crore).Despite the bounce-back in domestic equities since April, foreign investors remain wary. FIIs were net sellers in four of the six months this year, including massive outflows of Rs 78,027 crore in January and Rs 34,574 crore in February. Even June, so far, has seen a net selloff of Rs 5,404 crore (till June 15).'Export-facing sectors will be in a wait-and-watch mode… domestic-facing sectors will likely lead from here,' Chadawar added, highlighting the impact of reciprocal tax measures and global macro retreat comes amid a strong equity rally that has made valuations appear frothy, particularly in mid- and small-cap segments. According to Jefferies' Chris Wood, the Nifty Midcap 100 Index now trades at 27.1x forward earnings, even as the Nifty itself is at 22.2x—well above its historical median.'Valuations have become an issue again, particularly in the mid-cap space,' Wood wrote in his GREED & fear report. 'The equivalent of $7.2 billion of equity supply was raised last month and $6 billion so far in June. It is this supply which poses the main risk to the market.'Wood noted that domestic flows and sentiment remain strong, especially in consumer finance stocks. However, FII positioning indicates growing concern about over-valuation and saturation in parts of the valuation, earnings downgrades and growth moderation are another red flag. HSBC, in its Q4 review, flagged weak topline performance in consumer staples and slowing credit growth in banks.'Demand for consumer staples was subdued, while competitive intensity remains high… Growth for banks moderated to a single-digit rate amid margin pressures,' the HSBC note said, adding that 'a sustained recovery in earnings growth is still a few quarters away.'The IT sector, despite posting 6% net income growth, continues to suffer from poor visibility in US demand, weak discretionary spend, and macro uncertainty in export markets. This aligns with Chadawar's view that export-oriented sectors remain underweight, pending clarity on reciprocal trade not all foreign investors are pulling back entirely—they're simply rotating. FIIs have made significant investments in telecom (Rs 23,065 crore) and to a lesser extent in financials (Rs 9,456 crore), services (Rs 7,351 crore), and chemicals (Rs 4,863 crore).'From a long-term valuation and earnings visibility perspective, our portfolio is currently tilted towards cyclicals,' said Chirag Mehta, CIO, Quantum AMC. 'We believe the global macro challenges do not derail India's domestic cyclical recovery. Sectors like banking, consumer discretionary, materials, and utilities appear attractive.'While Mehta remains cautious on IT, he believes continued correction could create long-term entry opportunities, especially in high-quality names with consistent earnings Jefferies' GREED & fear India portfolio is shifting gears. Positions in L&T, Thermax, and Godrej Properties are being exited, replaced with TVS Motor, Home First Finance, and Manappuram Finance. Additional exposure is also being added to PolicyBazaar and Bharti Airtel, signaling a shift to consumption- and credit-focused domestic flows remain robust, the intensity and concentration of FII selling, especially in IT, FMCG, and auto, should not be ignored. With nearly ₹1 lakh crore of outflows in six months, the foreign money is clearly betting on earnings downgrades, valuation fatigue, and a global demand slowdown.'We seek out quality, high-integrity businesses at reasonable valuations… Our value-conscious approach often leads us to sectors that may be out of favour but possess strong fundamentals,' Mehta investors navigating this turbulent landscape, the data suggests a clear bifurcation: domestic-oriented sectors like telecom and financials are attracting foreign capital, while export-dependent sectors face sustained selling pressure. The challenge lies in timing entry points as valuations remain elevated despite the sectoral rotation.(Data: Ritesh Presswala): Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)
