March for Welsh independence warned they face 'uphill battle'

March for Welsh independence warned they face 'uphill battle'
Thousands of people took to the streets of Barry on Saturday for the March for Independence
(Image: Mark Lewis )
Over the weekend, more than 6,000 people took to the streets of Barry in a march for Welsh independence, sparking conversation among Wales Online readers. Supporters from all over Wales, some accompanied by their children, participated in the March for Independence, an event organised by YesCymru and AUOBCymru.
Since 2019, thousands have joined independence marches in various locations across Wales – including Caernarfon, Merthyr, Wrexham, Bangor, Swansea, Carmarthen and Cardiff. This time, it was Barry's turn to host the march.
‌
The organisers highlighted the town's significant role in the Cymru Fydd movement for Welsh self-government in the 1890s.
‌
Following the march, a rally was held in King Square, featuring speeches from supporters such as former Plaid Cymru leader Leanne Wood, Catalan campaigner Anna Arqué i Solsona, political activist Kiera Marshall, Wales Green Party spokesperson Tessa Marshall and singer-songwriter Eädyth Crawford.
The rally, hosted by Vale of Glamorgan Plaid Cymru councillor Mark Hooper, also featured live music from Emma Winter, known from Y Llais, the Welsh version of The Voice.
In a first for the March for Independence, all speakers and performers – with the exception of the MC – were women.
Article continues below
However, people commenting on WalesOnline were sceptical that independence was viable. Tannerbanc said: " I am as proud as anyone to be Welsh but compared to the past most industry has been lost in Wales, do we generate enough wealth here (GDP) to pay for the public services that are demanded ? especially by those who do not contribute towards it. Unfortunately we are far too much a a public sector and benefits country, who do these people think pays for that ? They should travel across the PoW bridge now and then and see there are far more areas of prosperity there and they are subsidizing Wales. Then there is the issue of government, has the Senedd really benefited Wales ? I think most people would say no, the Senedd could hold a referendum to ask that question to know for sure?"
Andypandy60 adds: "Whilst being a great country to live in and especially living in the Vale of Glamorgan, it is not a place that can support itself. We are half the size of Scotland and we depend on financial support from Westminster, without that we would be a third world country. The Senedd has not done us any favours. As for 25 years Labour has had the monopoly. Next year in the elections, it will be interesting to see how well Reform and Plaid Cymru perform.
‌
Barbarap states: "The clue is in the title United Kingdom which is what we need to be. Hopefully, to regain our place on the world stage. The money that has been spent on the Welsh assembly could fund face to face GP appointments and therefore relieve the amount of times A&E is being used."
Boyo1958 says: "I am strongly for the language but not PC on the whole. Where is the money coming from to resolve the issues that the Senedd has created over the past years? With only 3 million people, it is not enough to run the country. By all means, protect and encourage more Welsh language uptake but otherwise forget Independence."
Violentrevoltnow writes: "The Yes Cymru movement faces an uphill battle against a system that thrives on dependency, manipulation, and deception. Independence may sound empowering, but the reality is that the very industries sustaining the UK, those tied to crime, addiction, and poverty, are deeply entrenched and reliant on systemic dysfunction. Breaking away doesn't eliminate these issues; it risks amplifying them within a smaller, less resilient framework.
Article continues below
"Devolved governments have already demonstrated the flaws in this path, struggling to manage the balance between autonomy and dependency. The public, driven by surface-level narratives, demands change without realizing they're feeding the cycle that undermines true progress. Independence under these conditions isn't liberation, it's stepping deeper into a system designed to perpetuate control and dependency."
Do you think that Wales would prosper if they gained independence? Join in the conversation HERE or in the comments below.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Wales Online

3 hours ago

• Wales Online

Welsh Language Commissioner sets out five priorities in manifesto ahead of Senedd election

Welsh Language Commissioner sets out five priorities in manifesto ahead of Senedd election Efa Gruffudd Jones is calling on all political parties to adopt the proposals Efa Gruffudd Jones believes the forthcoming Senedd term will be pivotal for the language (Image: Welsh Language Commissioner ) The Welsh Language Commissioner has unveiled a manifesto, setting out key priorities she hopes all political parties will commit to ahead of the 2026 Senedd Cymru election. In the manifesto, unveiled on Friday, June 20, Efa Gruffudd Jones said she wanted to see an increase in the number of Welsh language services available to the public and establish a specialist unit to increase the use of the language in workplaces. Despite acknowledging the financial pressures organisations are under, Jones said she had identified five areas of focus that could make a "real difference to strengthening the position of the Welsh language". ‌ The proposals come as the current Welsh Labour Government have set out a target to reach one million Welsh speakers by 2050. ‌ However, according to the last census (2021), the number of people in Wales aged three and above who consider themselves to be Welsh speakers stands at 538,000 - 17.8% of the population, which is actually down 24,000 since the previous census (2011). Read more in our report on Welsh beyond the numbers However, the Welsh Language Commissioner believes the forthcoming Senedd term will be pivotal for the language. Read the biggest stories in Wales first by signing up to our daily newsletter here . Efa Gruffudd Jones said: "My ambition as Commissioner goes beyond a narrow interpretation of what is expected of me and set out in the Welsh Language Measure, and I am keen to lead a body that does more and contributes more significantly to wider language planning work. Article continues below "As a result this manifesto calls for action and guidance from the Welsh Government, whatever its political makeup, and support to facilitate the work of other key partners, including the Welsh Language Commissioner. "The next few years are extremely important for the Welsh language as the Welsh Language and Education Bill is delivered and as the recommendations of the Commission for Welsh-speaking Communities are implemented. "I am fully aware of the pressures on our public bodies and that is the reason for setting out five specific priorities in this manifesto. ‌ "They follow the path outlined in our strategic plan and I am convinced that these are areas where difference can be made in the use of the language. "We will now look to have discussions with the parties in order to present our manifesto and our rationale for setting out our priorities. "The hope is that the parties will be ready to adopt our proposals and for those to be adopted before the election next year." Article continues below The five priorities outlined in the manifesto are as follows: Language duties - increase the number of Welsh language services available to the public by extending Welsh language standards to priority areas. Community language planning – extend the Commissioner's influence by strengthening the promotion standards as a framework for the co-ordination of intensive community language planning. Workplaces - establish a specialist unit in the Welsh Language Commissioner's office to increase the use of Welsh in workplaces. Health and clinical care service - transform clinical care in Welsh through intensive investment and action in priority areas. The education workforce - establish a five-year Welsh language training framework as a mandatory element of training as a teacher in Wales.

Powys County Times

7 hours ago

• Powys County Times

Rules for cattle relaxed in the new Bluetongue rules

Cattle moving from England into Wales WILL be permitted if they are vaccinated for bluetongue, the Welsh Government says - but sheep must still be tested before crossing the border. In a new announcement on Friday, the Welsh Government confirmed it will allow cattle fully vaccinated with Boehringer Ingelheim's Bultavo-3 vaccine, to move under licence, from a Restricted Zone to Wales without a pre-movement test – however this will not apply to sheep. There has been outrage amongst Powys farmers about rules being brought in from July 1 which would mean that any sheep that crossed the Welsh border would require a test for the bluetongue virus. Tests for Bluetongue cost anywhere from £40-£70 per animal meaning some farmers would be faced with bills of tens of thousands to move livestock across the border for grazing or for going to market. The Welsh Government confirmed that 'all sheep must be pre-movement tested and require an accompanying licence to move into Wales to live from the Restricted Zone (RZ) in England, as no vaccine products currently meet the requirements for protecting sheep from BTV-3 to allow them to move out of the RZ.' Deputy First Minister with responsibility for Climate Change and Rural Affairs, Huw Irranca-Davies, said: 'My goal at this stage remains to keep Bluetongue out of Wales for the benefit of our animals and those who keep them. 'The economic and farmer wellbeing concerns caused by dealing with severe Bluetongue are first and foremost in my mind. "I also want to allow more time to observe the severity of the disease in England, and for keepers to vaccinate their herds and flocks. Help support trusted local news Sign up for a digital subscription now: As a digital subscriber you will get Unlimited access to the Oswestry Advertizer website Advert-light access Reader rewards 'I have made clear the thinking behind my decision in the Senedd this week, but I want to keep it under review. Should the evidence change, and we need to alter the policy, we will revisit and review this in a dynamic way. 'Our shared priority over the coming weeks is to promote vaccine take-up. All representatives at the Roundtable I recently convened were unanimous in their support for vaccination as the best method of protecting livestock and reducing the impacts of Bluetongue." 'I cannot in all conscience invite Bluetongue into Wales, but we are prepared to adapt to the evolving disease situation.' In the announcement, the Welsh Government also confirmed that as a response to increased risk of Bluetongue, including 'temperatures that are consistent with the active transmission period,' these measures will come into force as of today (June 20) in relation to the current Restricted Zone in England, which covers the east of England.

ITV News

8 hours ago

• ITV News

Assisted dying bill passed by MPs - but what does this mean for Wales?

Plans to change the law to legalise assisted dying in Wales and England have come a step closer with an historic vote in the Commons, but there remain huge questions over how it will actually affect Wales. MPs voted to pass the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill by 314 to 291. Of Wales' 32 MPs - 24 backed the bill, seven voted against and one did not vote. Health is devolved, so the implementation of any assisted dying service would be carried out through the Welsh NHS which is controlled by the Welsh Government and ultimately answerable to the Senedd itself. In a vote last October on the principle of assisted dying, Senedd members including the First Minister and Health Secretary voted against it, which means there is every chance that MSs could vote to block it. That in turn raises the prospect of assisted dying being legalised here in Wales but Welsh doctors prohibited from providing the service. An earlier attempt to give the power to decide whether or not to allow the law to be changed here in Wales to the Senedd was overturned via an amendment to the Bill. One of the MPs behind that bid, Plaid Cymru's Liz Saville Roberts, said: 'It is regrettable that the House chose to remove the Senedd's power to commence this Bill in Wales. "Health is devolved, and I firmly believe that the Senedd must take responsibility for the services available to people at the end of their lives. I am concerned that we could face a situation where assisted dying is permitted only through the private sector in Wales. 'I am also disappointed that no Welsh MP was called to speak in today's debate. Scottish and Northern Irish MPs were given the opportunity to contribute, despite the Bill not extending to those jurisdictions. 'I am nevertheless pleased that this Bill has passed its third reading. We are a step closer to granting people dying of terminal illnesses dignity at the of their lives, and the safeguards have been strengthened to protect vulnerable people.' I understand that there will be a vote on the aspects of the bill that are devolved, particularly as it affects the health service which is the means by which any assisted dying service will be provided here in Wales. It will come in the form of a Legislative Consent Motion (LCM) whereby Senedd members agree or disagree to allow UK Parliament legislation to affect Senedd law. The Health Secretary, Jeremy Miles, has already tabled an LCM although it might have to be altered now that the bill has been altered. An updated LCM has to be laid by 4th July. The Welsh Government says: 'We remain neutral on the issue of assisted dying. 'We have been working constructively with the UK Government and the Bill sponsor to ensure devolved interests are taken into account and the devolution settlement is respected.