Pendency has made justice a game of patience in India

By Shashank Maheshwari
In Franz Kafka's haunting parable Before the Law, a man waits all his life to gain access to the law, stopped by a doorkeeper who never denies him entry in clear terms, leading to an indefinite delay. As he dies, the man is told the entrance was meant for him alone. The gate shuts. He never entered.
This is the experience of millions of Indians today. The law isn't denied to them — it's simply never delivered. India's judicial system now groans under the weight of over 5 crore pending cases across courts. In subordinate courts, more than 50 per cent of these cases have been pending for over three years. According to government data presented in the Rajya Sabha in 2023, 1,514 cases in High Courts and 1,390 in subordinate and district courts have been pending for over 50 years. The pendency problem isn't just about bureaucratic inefficiency — it seems to be a constitutional breakdown.
The judiciary's burden is worsened by gaps in its capacity. According to the India Justice Report (IJR) 2025, the average judicial vacancy in High Courts is 33 per cent, with Allahabad HC at 51 per cent and Punjab & Haryana HC at 40 per cent. Subordinate courts fare no better, with an average vacancy of 21 per cent, and states like Meghalaya (43 per cent), Mizoram (39 per cent), and Ladakh (35 per cent) reaching alarming levels.
Meanwhile, there are only 15 judges for every 10 lakh Indians — a fraction of what the 1987 report of the Law Commission recommended: Fifty judges per 10 lakh people. The result? Cases pile up. Hearings are delayed. And justice remains out of reach. The Supreme Court, overwhelmed with its own backlog, has seen over 2,500 new pending cases added in early 2025 alone, as per SCC Observer. During the hearing of Amit Sahni v. Union of India, the Delhi High Court admitted that it was operating at just 60 per cent of its capacity, warning that delay at this scale 'virtually amounts to denial of justice'.
In February, the SC demanded a status report on all HC judgments reserved before January 31, highlighting the silent tragedy of cases concluded but undecided.
Nowhere is the pendency crisis more visible than in India's prisons. As of December 2022, 76 per cent of India's prison population are undertrials — people not yet convicted of any crime. Shockingly, 22 per cent of them have been detained for one to three years, and 2.6 per cent for over five years. In Uttar Pradesh, which alone accounts for 22 per cent of all undertrials, many have waited over half a decade in jail, often for petty charges.
Bihar reports the highest share of undertrials at 89 per cent, while Mizoram recorded a steep increase from 57 per cent to 66 per cent in just one year. Recognising this, the SC has recently recommended the digitisation of all criminal appeals, the appointment of registrars for case management, and prioritisation of cases involving imprisoned accused. These are necessary first steps, but the underlying system must be repaired if they are to have any impact.
Despite an increase in budget, there is considerable lag in infrastructural development. In 2022–23, India's sanctioned prison budget rose to Rs 8,725 crore — a 14.5 per cent increase. Seventeen states increased judicial spending more than their overall state expenditure. But systemic bottlenecks — vacancies, outdated infrastructure, and lack of digital capacity — continue to cripple outcomes. Staff vacancies in courts average 25 per cent in the HCs and 27 per cent in subordinate courts. In courts across India, e-Courts initiatives struggle due to poor connectivity, untrained personnel, and inadequate infrastructure.
Even technology, heralded as a panacea, remains a half-built scaffold. E-sewa Kendras, e-filing systems, and live-streaming of proceedings show promise, but their reach is uneven and often symbolic. As the IJR cautions, 'technology cannot substitute structural reform.' Moreover, India's justice system remains fragmented. Police forces remain understaffed, with only 155 officers per 1 lakh population, well below the sanctioned 197. Forensic science labs face over 50 per cent vacancy rates, delaying investigations. Legal aid is crumbling. Paralegal volunteer deployment has dropped since 2019, and access at the grassroots is weakening.
The proposed All India Judicial Services (AIJS) — a potentially game-changing reform to centralise and standardise judicial appointments — remains mired in political limbo. There is no national recruitment calendar, and many states fail to meet caste and gender representation quotas.
As Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, former SC judge, writes in the IJR foreword: 'Justice reform is too important to be left solely to institutions — it must become a societal demand.' Pendency is no longer just a delay — it is a denial of democracy. It weakens economic enforcement, deepens inequality, and erodes faith in the Constitution. While reforms like digital tools, fast-track appointments, and increased funding are steps in the right direction, they must be tied to outcomes, not optics.
The IJR makes it clear: Only a whole-of-system reform, touching courts, police, prisons, legal aid, and forensics, can break the pendency deadlock. This requires political will, administrative coordination, and civil society pressure. Above all, it requires a shift from courtroom firefighting to long-term institution-building. Justice in India must not remain a game of patience. It must become a guarantee — timely, fair, and real.
The writer teaches at Jindal global law school

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Hans India

37 minutes ago

• Hans India

Swift action sought on SC/ST cases

Bhongir: The SC/ST Commission Chairman, Bakki Venkataiah, has directed officials to resolve all pending cases related to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes across various departments. On Saturday, he conducted a review meeting at the Collectorate Conference Hall in Yadadri-Bhongir district, along with Collector Hanumantha Rao, DCP Akshansh Yadav, and Commission members. The Chairman proposed holding a Civil Rights Day on the last Saturday of every month, involving tahsildars and police officers to address village-level grievances. He instructed the formation of a quarterly DVMC (District Vigilance & Monitoring Committee) to ensure inter-departmental coordination in resolving SC/ST-related concerns. The Commission chief stressed strict adherence to the Rule of Reservation (RoR) in promotions and warned of disciplinary action for violations. Earlier, the Chairman visited the under-construction Ambedkar Bhavan in Singannagudem and urged speedy completion. He paid floral tributes to Dr BR Ambedkar and Babu Jagjivan Ram statues in Bhongir town. Public petitions were accepted directly by the Chairman.

India Gazette

an hour ago

• India Gazette

'Op Sindhu' not only homecoming, but live example of Modi govt's 'nation first' policy: Tarun Chugh

New Delhi [India], June 22 (ANI): Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) National General Secretary Tarun Chugh on Saturday praised Prime Minister Narendra Modi for the successful evacuation efforts under Operation Sindhu, calling it a unique example of the Central government's 'nation first' policy. 'Under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, even during a global crisis, India prioritises ensuring its citizens' security. In the middle of an ongoing war, a conflict-ridden country like Iran opening its airspace is a big win for India's foreign policy, diplomacy and India's reliability,' Tarun Chugh said while speaking to ANI. ''Operation Sindhu' is not only a homecoming of Indian students but is a live example of the PM Narendra Modi government's 'nation first' policy. Even earlier, during the Russia-Ukraine war or any natural calamity, India has given priority to security for its citizens,' he said. Meanwhile, a special flight carrying 290 Indians stranded in conflict-hit Iran landed safely in New Delhi on Saturday night, bringing the total number of evacuees under Operation Sindhu to 1,117. This marks the fifth batch of Indians evacuated from Iran as part of the ongoing operation. In a post on X, the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) stated, 'Operation Sindhu gains momentum. 290 Indian nationals have returned home safely from Iran on a special flight from Mashhad that landed in New Delhi at 2330 hrs on 21 June 2025.' 'With this, 1,117 Indian nationals have been evacuated from Iran,' the MEA added. The evacuees, including students, shared their experiences of the tense situation in Iran and expressed deep gratitude to the Indian government and embassy officials. An Indian national from Bihar's Siwan, studying medicine at Tehran University of Medical Sciences, said, 'I am from Siwan, Bihar. I have been in Iran for the last 2 years. I study medicine at Tehran University of Medical Sciences. The situation in Tehran is critical. Other places are normal. I am thankful to the government (for the evacuation).' Another evacuee, Naveed, a second-year MBBS student, added, 'I am from Kashmir. I am a 2nd-year MBBS student. I feel very good now. I am thankful to India. They evacuated us.'Describing the fear they faced, one evacuee said, 'I feel very good. There were missiles firing. We were feeling very afraid there. We were stuck there for 1 week.' Momin Ushtaq from Kashmir praised the government's efforts, saying, 'I am from Kashmir. The situation is not good there. We are very thankful to the government of India, Kashmir, and the Embassy. They deserve a special thanks, as they evacuated us and brought us back home.' Gratitude was also directed to Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Parveen, another evacuee, said, 'I am very happy. I am thankful to PM Modi from the bottom of my heart. Our government helped us to get back here.' Indira Kumari added, 'We have returned. I am thankful to the Indian government and the Prime Minister of India.' Earlier on Saturday, a special flight from Mashhad carrying 310 Indian nationals landed in New Delhi at 4:30 PM. Meanwhile, Israeli airstrikes targeted a significant nuclear facility in Iran's Isfahan province, as reported by Al Jazeera. As per Al Jazeera, citing an Israeli military spokesperson, the air force struck the main complex as well as buildings involved in centrifuge production. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) confirmed that a centrifuge manufacturing workshop was hit but clarified that no nuclear material was present at the site, so there were no radiological impacts. (ANI)

Hindustan Times

2 hours ago

• Hindustan Times

CM Saini visits Vij , asks after his health

Haryana chief minister Nayab Singh Saini on Saturday visited the residence of energy minister Anil Vij in Ambala Cantonment, to inquire about his health and wished him a speedy recovery. Haryana chief minister Nayab Singh Saini during his vistit to energy minister Anil Vij's residence in Ambala on Saturday. (Sourced) Vij, 71, has been advised rest by doctors due to a fracture in his left foot. Earlier, upon Saini's visit, he was welcomed by Vij's brothers Rajinder Vij and Kapil Vij, uncle Wing Commander (retired) SD Vij, other family members as well as a large number of BJP workers. Saini spent nearly 45 minutes at the minister's residence, discussing his injury and other issues, while also personally meeting Vij's nephews Gaurav Vij and Shubham Vij, sources said. Earlier in the day, BJP Rajya Sabha MP Subhash Barala also paid a visit to Vij's residence at Shastri Colony along NH-44. Vij, a seventh-time MLA, sustained the injury about a month ago, but despite that he continued to oversee developmental work in his constituency and chaired departmental meetings at the Chandigarh Secretariat and other locations. Even during the period, he spent seven continuous hours inspecting flood preparedness in Ambala Cantonment on June 12, issuing directives to officials from district administration, municipality, cantonment board, irrigation department, railways, highways and others. Although he took medication as per medical advice, the increasing pain prompted an X-ray on Friday, which revealed a fracture in the toe, following which doctors advised him to rest for a few days, a statement from the minister's office read. The chief minister's unscheduled visit while returning to Chandigarh from Yoga Day celebrations at Kurukshetra, gathers significance given the past sour relations between the two leaders. This was Saini's first personal meeting with Vij at Ambala, since he was served a party show-cause notice in February, for his utterances targeting the chief minister as well as against state unit chief Mohan Lal Badoli.