Mediterranean migrant rescues suffer under lacking EU policy

"We rescued 68 people from two unsuitable boats on the night of May 1st," Marie Michel, a crew member of the sea rescue organization
, reported at a press conference marking the group's 10th anniversary.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
"Both boats were in the Libyan search and rescue zone at the time, but the Libyan rescue coordination center did not coordinate any of these rescues but said that they are not responsible," she added.
In Michel's view, this sums up how the European Union has successively outsourced responsibility for rescuing people from drowning in the Mediterranean to civilian organizations for more than a decade.
According to the
, almost 32,000 refugees have drowned in the Mediterranean since 2014.
This year alone, 500 have drowned, so far.
Controversial migration deals
Agreements worth hundreds of millions of euros between the EU and Libya in 2017, and the EU and Tunisia in 2023, were designed to reduce migration, and the many deaths in the Mediterranean.
The deals stipulated that the coastguards of both countries would take over border protection. However, these agreements have been heavily criticized, and reports on serious human rights violations are unabated.
"Many of the survivors from Libya who have been on board with us in the last five days bear signs of torture on their bodies," Michel said.
She added that migrants had recounted how they had been humiliated, forced to strip their clothing, doused with ice-cold water, beaten with wooden sticks, metal rods and plastic hoses, shot with pistols and raped.
The rescue organization's most recent report on the situation in Libya, Tunisia and the Mediterranean also shares the harrowing stories of 64 survivors.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
"After being severely beaten, three young men jumped into the sea. The Libyan coastguard let them die in front of our eyes and even insulted them as they drowned. They said to each other: 'Let them die, it's easier for us and for them'," one migrant recalled.
European sea rescue program
On May 4, 2015, four families founded the search and rescue organization SOS Humanity in Berlin. Since then, they say they have rescued more than 38,000 refugees in distress at sea along the Mediterranean route from North Africa to Italy.
"The first rescue we carried out on March 7, 2016, rescued 74 exhausted, injured and desperate men and women in a small, unprotected rubber dinghy far off the coast of Libya," SOS Humanity founder Klaus Vogel told DW, adding that "our expectation of getting European governments to see refugees as fellow human beings, and to recognize the rescue of
as Europe's natural duty has not been fulfilled."
The organization calls for German politicians to push for a collective European sea rescue program, and to end its cooperation agreements with Libya and Tunisia.
Meanwhile, the aid organization criticizes that Germany's incoming government does not even mention the term "sea rescue" in its coalition agreement.
'The world's deadliest border'
"For more than 10 years now, we have had a situation in Europe in which European governments have held repeated crisis summits, but they have not been able to put an end to the dying," Gerald Knaus, an Austrian migration expert and co-founder and chairman of the think tank
, told DW.
"The deadliest border in the world remains the deadliest border in the world. And this continuous dying is an expression of a complete and systematic failure," he said.
Knaus is the architect of the 2016 refugee agreement between the European Union and Turkey.
At the time, the deal included €6 billion ($6.42 billion) worth of aid for Ankara in return for Turkey sealing off the migrant route across the Mediterranean and agreeing to take back refugees.
According to the social scientist, the number of deaths in the Aegean Sea has fallen from 1,100 in one year to 80 as a result.
Human dignity instead of populism
According to Knaus, a deal with African countries could include issuing five-year visas for citizens who enter legally, increasing the number of scholarships available, and investing several hundred million euros to combat poverty.
In return, the countries could agree to take back refugees who are obliged to leave the country.
"The political signal would be that Europe does not have to elect far-right parties to control migration," he told DW.
"The fatal message on the other side of the Atlantic is that Donald Trump has stopped irregular migration, the numbers have fallen dramatically. But he is doing this at the expense of human dignity and is demolishing the rule of law," Knaus said.
"So, it is now extremely important for Germany's centrist parties and this coalition to urgently develop a solution based on the rule of law, with the necessary seriousness and without populism," he argued, adding that "blaming sea rescuers is populism and has always been populism."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Standard

an hour ago

• Business Standard

B-2 stealth bombers take off from US as Donald Trump weighs Iran strike

The moves, picked up by flight tracking services on Saturday, indicate that the administration is getting the Air Force bombers in position if needed for a strike on Iran Bloomberg B-2 stealth bombers have taken off from the US and are headed over the Pacific, multiple news outlets reported, as President Donald Trump weighs American involvement in the war between Israel and Iran. The moves, picked up by flight tracking services on Saturday, indicate that the administration is getting the Air Force bombers in position if needed for a strike on Iran, the Wall Street Journal reported. The planes, accompanied by refueling tankers, may be on their way to a base in Guam, according to the report. Speculation about a potential US strike aimed at Iran's nuclear program has focused on the B-2s, which would be needed to drop 30,000-pound bombs — so-called bunker busters — if Trump decided to target Iran's heavily fortified uranium enrichment site at Fordow. Israel, which is seeking to destroy Iran's nuclear capabilities, does not have such weapons. Multiple B-2s appeared to be airborne and heading across the Pacific from Whiteman Air Force Base in Missouri, the New York Times reported. The Times cited flight trackers' posts on social media and air traffic control communications. The Pentagon and the White House didn't immediately return messages seeking comment. Trump's is scheduled to return to the White House Saturday and meet with his national security team. The US president has sent mixed signals, discounting European efforts to secure a diplomatic solution between Israel and Iran while keeping possible US involvement in the conflict on the table. 'I'm giving them a period of time,' Trump told reporters Friday. 'I would say two weeks would be the maximum.'

Time of India

an hour ago

• Time of India

NATO breaking apart? Italy questions military alliance's existence after Macron shows Trump, France can secure Europe

The debate around the existence of NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) has again heated up after Italian Defense Minister Guido Crosetto said on Friday, June 20, 2025, that the military alliance no longer has a reason to exist. Crosetto made the remarks on the sidelines of a conference in Padua, according to Italian news agency ANSA.'Before, the US and Europe used to be the center of the world, now, there is everything else with which a relationship must be built,' Politico reported him as saying. He further stated, 'We often talk as if we were still living 30 years ago, but everything has changed.' In the last few years, the US' stance about sticking around with the alliance has also been seen shaking up as President Donald Trump has on several occasions warned that he is open to moving out of NATO. Trump, since his inauguration as the 47th President of the United States on January 20, 2025, has constantly complained for a long time the European and Canadian governments in the mutual-defense bloc are freeloading on military spending by Washington. In an interview in December 2024 after winning the US presidential election, Trump was asked if he would consider the possibility of pulling out of NATO. Trump indicated that was an open question. 'If they're paying their bills, and if I think they're treating us fairly, the answer is absolutely I'd stay with NATO,' he told 'Meet the Press.' On being asked about considering pulling the U.S. out of the alliance. Trump had said, 'Absolutely. Yeah, absolutely.' Live Events On the other hand, French President Emmanuel Macron said in May 2025 that he was ready to hold a discussion regarding the potential deployment of his country's nuclear weapons elsewhere in Europe. He had noted that the United States had already stationed nuclear-armed aircraft in Europe. Macron shared a post on X for the rest of Europe saying the Rafale fighter jet is calling. His post on Friday, June 20, 2025, showed an Apple iPhone with an incoming call from 'Rafale' and a close-up of the jet arcing over barren and rocky land. Now the Italian defense minister's comments ahead of the NATO leaders' summit in The Hague have raised fresh doubts about the unity of NATO partners. At the summit, the alliance is likely to give its agreement on a higher spending target of 5 percent of GDP to placate Trump. According to Crosetto, NATO has failed in its original mission. 'If NATO was created to guarantee peace and mutual defense, it must either become an organization that takes on this task by engaging with the Global South, and thus become something profoundly different, or we will not achieve the goal of having security within rules that apply to everyone,' he said. French President Macron's pitch to deploy nuclear weapons in Europe It all started in March 2025, when the French President proposed holding talks with European allies regarding how French nuclear weapons could help protect Europe. His comments had come at a time when many European leaders felt that they could no longer rely on Washington's nuclear commitment to Europe as Moscow's threat loomed large. The French President's X post made on Friday seems to be his latest attempt towards sending a loud and clear message to the rest of Europe about strengthening the combined defenses and acting independently on matters of continental security to reduce dependence on Washington.

Time of India

2 hours ago

• Time of India

3 booked for duping man of Rs 6 L for job abroad

Dehradun: Police in Rishikesh have registered a case against three individuals from a job consultancy firm for allegedly duping a man of Rs 6 lakh under the pretext of offering him employment abroad. The alleged fraud took place between Oct last year and March this year, but came to light after the victim, Rajkumar Rana, a resident of Dehradun's Premnagar area, filed a complaint on Friday. The accused have been identified as Somendra Chauhan, Chandra Prakash Chauhan, and Ayush Chauhan, all residents. SI Yogesh Chand Khumriyal, who is investigating the case, said the trio runs a job consultancy firm named 'Virmo International' in Rishikesh. "Rana complained that he came into contact with the accused at their firm last year. They initially promised him a job in Maldives and asked for Rs 3.6 lakh, which he paid. However, they kept delaying a job letter," said Khumriyal. He added that after a few months, the accused claimed the Maldives opportunity had fallen through and instead offered a job in a European country, demanding an additional Rs 7.5 lakh. Rana eventually paid Rs 6.1 lakh. "Later, the accused provided him with fake job offer letters and stopped responding to his calls. Realising he had been cheated, Rana finally approached the police," added Khumriyal. A case has been registered under BNS sections 316 (2) (criminal breach of trust), 318 (2) (cheating), 351 (2) (criminal intimidation), 352 (intentional insult to provoke breach of peace), and an investigation is underway.