Two big UK battery storage developers favour zonal pricing

Two of Britain's biggest battery storage developers have come out in favour of regional electricity pricing, despite opposition from their peers who argue that the radical shake-up will deter investment.
Gresham House and Statera both told The Times that zonal pricing would cut the costs of operating Britain's energy system, ensuring that batteries were built in the right locations to help deal with surplus wind power.
Ben Guest, head of energy transition at Gresham House, operator of the UK's largest battery storage fleet, said it believed zonal pricing was 'an essential step for the UK's electricity system' to help 'motivate investment where it is most needed'.
The government is expected to decide imminently whether to ditch Britain's national wholesale electricity price and introduce a system with about seven to twelve regional zones.
Prices in each zone would vary depending on the supply and demand balance in the area, ensuring that wind farms in remote locations could not sell their electricity to consumers at the other end of the country if there were not sufficient cables to physically deliver the power.
At present the National Electricity System Operator spends hundreds of millions of pounds every year dealing with such cabling constraints by paying wind farms to switch off and gas plants nearer demand to fire up and replace them.
Batteries installed near wind farms could address the problem by storing surplus power when it is windy and discharging it in calm weather, smoothing out supplies. However the national market does not always provide the correct price signals: batteries in Scotland might discharge because the national price is high, even if their area is already swamped with power. In a zonal system, the excess power would depress the regional price, encouraging the battery to charge up.
Zonal pricing is highly divisive in the energy industry, with wind farm developers and other generators generally opposed and some household suppliers and consumer groups in favour.
Guest said Gresham's analysis showed that 'a well-designed zonal pricing system can reduce wholesale energy costs and reduce the need for a lot of the planned electricity network upgrades and associated pylons'.
Zonal pricing would 'incentivise energy storage, the cost of which has been falling sharply, to store renewable energy when generation exceeds demand and then deliver it across zonal boundaries when renewable generation is low and constraint limits are not reached', he said.
Tom Vernon, chief executive of Statera Energy, which is building Britain's largest battery storage site at Trafford Park in Greater Manchester, said: 'Developing and dispatching batteries in the right locations is critical for cost-effectively balancing the grid. At Statera, we support zonal pricing because it will make the power system more transparent, and provide a clear price signal for the efficient operation and location of demand and generation.' He said he was 'confident that zonal pricing will lower costs in the long run'.
However, other leading battery storage developers said they opposed the change. Harmony Energy said it feared that 'the uncertainty created by such a fundamental shift in market design creates an unnecessary risk in relation to investor confidence at a time when the country needs to get on building out critical infrastructure'. And Amit Gudka, chief executive of Field, said zonal pricing would 'slow down investment' and building out the network should be the priority instead of 'tinkering with the market'.
Zenobe, another battery storage company, has claimed that even the prospect of zonal pricing has already 'slashed investor confidence and is inhibiting battery build-out', as the complexity and uncertainty of zonal pricing makes it harder to secure agreements to sell power.
A spokesman for the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero said: 'We are considering reforms to Britain's electricity market arrangements, ensuring that these focus on protecting bill-payers and encouraging investment. We will provide an update in due course.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Telegraph

27 minutes ago

• Telegraph

British rocket launch backed by Labour falls further behind in space race

A British rocket start-up backed by Labour has pushed back the date of its first launch and is hunting fresh funding as the UK faces falling further behind in the space race. Orbex, which in January received a £20m investment from the taxpayer, confirmed its first test launch from the Shetland Islands would be in 2026, rather than later this year as hoped. The start-up is building its 62ft Orbex Prime rocket at a factory in Scotland, which is intended to carry small satellites into space. After securing taxpayer support, Orbex is now seeking a further £120m in funding from private investors over the next four years to bring its ambitions to reality, it said in a submission to MPs. The company is also pushing for further government backing, calling for support for its bid to build a new, larger rocket for the European Space Agency. The space organisation, of which the UK is a member, is offering companies up to £144m for its European Launcher Challenge as Europe seeks alternatives to its current reliance on Elon Musk's SpaceX. Orbex has been lobbying for Labour's £7bn National Wealth Fund to back the space sector, which it said in a consultation filing to MPs could 'level the playing field and unlock significant value for the UK economy'. The delay to Orbex's mission comes after a series of setbacks for Britain's fledgling launch industry. After a failed launch from Cornwall in 2023, Sir Richard Branson's Virgin Orbit went bankrupt. Since then, no new attempts at an orbital mission have gone ahead. Now, a number of small rocket companies are seeking to launch from UK soil, largely from Saxavord, a spaceport on the Shetland Islands, although they have faced delays. German start-up, Rocket Factory Augsburg, is still targeting a mission this year from Shetland, although its last test ended with its rocket exploding on the launchpad. Skyrora, a Scottish start-up, is hoping to launch from Shetland next year. A spokesman for Orbex said: 'There are many factors at play in determining our launch schedule, including licensing and launch logistics. This is not unusual.' The spokesman added government support would be needed to build a European rocket: 'National funding commitments and private investment will both be needed for winning bidders. 'UK Government support for our sector will send a clear signal to ESA that UK orbital launch companies like Orbex are a smart choice and long-term partner.'

Telegraph

43 minutes ago

• Telegraph

Morrisons orders head office staff to work full time

Morrisons has ordered staff working in its head office back to their desks five days a week as the supermarket battles to revive its fortunes. The supermarket is understood to have told its employees based at its headquarters in Bradford that they must work a full five-day week after abandoning a policy which allowed staff to work compressed hours. Previously, staff were required to work 37.5 hours over four and a half days under a flexible working week pilot which the supermarket kicked off in 2020. The decision to revert back to five day weeks, which came into force this month, comes as bosses step up a drive to reinvigorate the supermarket as it loses customers to rivals including Aldi. Rami Baitiéh, who took over as Morrisons chief executive in late 2023, has been spearheading a turnaround effort. Last week, the supermarket said sales grew 4.2pc to £3.9bn in the 13 weeks to April 27, versus a year earlier. Mr Baitiéh said the figures showed it had 'bounced back strongly' after cyber issues in November. However, data from Kantar showed Morrisons' share of the grocery market dipped to 8.4pc in May compared to 8.6pc a year earlier. The head office changes are expected to help Morrisons cope with mounting competition from rivals as they step up a price war. Both Asda and Tesco have said they are expecting profits to take a hit this year as they invest heavily on price cuts. A spokesman for Morrisons said the head office changes would improve customer service and make sure its shelves are better stocked in stores. They added: 'In the context of a relentlessly competitive UK grocery market and widespread increased cost pressures, we have taken the difficult decision to ask our head office colleagues to move their working pattern from 4.5 days to a full five day week.' Staff will still be allowed to work both from home and the office during the week, and individuals may be able to work flexibly if they need to do so. It marks the latest shake-up of Morrisons' office working policy. In 2020, the supermarket introduced a four-day working week for head office workers, saying the change would 'make Morrisons a place where more people will want to join and stay'. Under the scheme, head office workers were asked to work on Saturdays once every four weeks. However, last year, Morrisons said it was changing its requirements following complaints from staff over having to work over the weekend. As part of the update, head office staff switched to a four and a half day week and were not asked to work any Saturdays. Morrisons' rivals have also scaled back flexible working policies since the pandemic. Last year, Asda scrapped its pilot after managers said a 44-hour week over four days trial left them exhausted. Domestic & General, a household appliance specialist employing 3,000 people, said it had received similar feedback from staff following a test of a four-day week. However, a four-day working week policy has received support from some in the Government, with Deputy Prime Minister, Angela Rayner, previously saying: 'If you can deliver within a four-day working week, then why not?' The Government later said this would not be part of its policy plans. Meanwhile, last year, the UK's first medical trial of a four-day working week suggested that there could be benefits to compressing hours. In the study, conducted by the University of Sussex, the policy was found to make employees happier and healthier. However, the company involved in the trial, Thrive, opted against adopting a four-day week full-time after its business suffered. The study found that the policy created some problems 'at a business level, particularly when it came to providing customer service'.

BBC News

an hour ago

• BBC News

Concerns Staffordshire parish being 'plundered' for battery sites

An area of South Staffordshire earmarked for eight separate battery energy storage site applications is being "plundered", said a parish council leader. Three battery energy storage systems (BESS) applications have already been approved for Lower Penn, with a further three awaiting decision, said Lower Penn Parish Council. South Staffordshire Council also considered two separate BESS proposals for sites in Flash Lane, Orton, near Wombourne and The Roughs, at Dimmingsdale, in Lower Penn on Tuesday. Steve McEwen, chair of Lower Penn Parish Council, described the 100MW BESS site proposed for Dimmingsdale as a "monster". He said to planning officers: "We urge you to defer this decision to allow much more careful review and assessment – we need more time"It will impose huge detrimental changes to the community of Lower Penn. "This technology is still at an early stage of development – consequently, risks and safety are in question."Congestion is very serious in Lower Penn, just having 500 metres between these installations is so tight. We're being plundered in Lower Penn."The Orton application was approved by just one vote - but the planning committee agreed to defer their decision on the Dimmingsdale proposal after a site visit. This news has been gathered by the Local Democracy Reporting Service. Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.