Developer's evidence 'flatly contradicts' claims at the centre of penthouse overheating row

A development company at the centre of a dispute with a businesswoman over alleged overheating in her €6 million Ballsbridge, Dublin, penthouse apartment "flatly contradicts" her claims, the High Court heard.
Aideen O'Byrne claims that, due to a failure to maintain or repair the district heating system, temperatures in her Lansdowne Place apartment, thought to be the most expensive in Ireland at the time she bought it, have reached "unbearable" highs of 33 degrees. Temperatures in lobby areas have been recorded to reach 29 degrees, she says.
Advertisement
Ms O'Byrne was last week given an interim injunction preventing the developer from transferring its beneficial interest in the buildings and common areas to an owners management company until problems are resolved. The case is against the developer, Copper Bridge C 2015 ICAV, and O'Connor Sutton Cronin and Associates Ltd.
That application was made ex parte, or with only the O' Byrne side represented.
The case returned before Mr Justice Brian Cregan on Thursday, when Hugh O'Keeffe SC, for Copper Bridge, said his client has a full defence to the merits of this case and experts who "flatly contradict" the claims of Ms Byrne.
"We spent three years trying to address them without any progress," he said. He was seeking an early trial as his side wanted the matter determined as quickly as possible.
Advertisement
Counsel said it was also their case in relation to the substance of the injunction preventing a transfer of interests that the transfer had already happened in accordance with required standards upon the making of a statutory declaration of completion of the development under the Multi-Unit Development (MUD) Act.
The legal interest had previously been transferred, and the transfer in accordance with MUD takes place upon completion of the statutory declaration, he said.
Gavin Mooney SC, for Ms O'Byrne, said it was curious that the statutory declaration took place on April 3rd when his side had already been on inquiry into the matter.
Counsel said if he now has to seek to change his application to one of setting aside that transfer of beneficial interest, "then so be it".
Advertisement
Mr Mooney also said he was also seeking to join the Lansdowne Place Owners' Management Company (OMC) as a defendant in the proceedings.
While the first application was only against the developer, after "we did not get very far", his side approached the OMC to see if they would assist, he said.
"But it was not forthcoming, and the OMC has now targeted us because we seem to have annoyed them," he said.
Siobhán Gaffney BL, for the OMC, said her clients first wanted to set out on affidavit their position in relation to Mr Mooney's application, but it was their case that the OMC was now "being dragged into the proceedings" when it is only responsible for the common areas, and the issue in relation to overheating was a structural and engineering matter.
Advertisement
Ireland
Garda denies 22 counts of perverting course of jus...
Read More
Deirdre NíFhloinn BL, for the co-defendant, said they supported the developer's request for an early trial.
Mr Justice Cregan said that given that the overheating also allegedly affects the common areas and that excess heat is alleged to be coming from pipes and fittings, he was satisfied to join the OMC to the case. Ms O'Byrne would have to amend her papers, he said.
Mr Mooney asked that he be allowed to do so after a forensic engineer's report is completed shortly.
The judge, who continued the terms of the interim injunction, gave directions for exchange of papers and adjourned the matter to late next month.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

BreakingNews.ie

2 hours ago

• BreakingNews.ie

Schools have to send 'begging bowl' to parents due to inadequate funding

Three retiring principals say schools are living on 'a wing and a prayer and have to send the 'begging bowl' to parents to help pay for school running costs due to inadequate funding from central government. The three Co. Louth principals, from rural schools within a 10 kilometre radius of one another, said the cost of school insurance alone takes up almost a third of funding provided by the government to cover running costs. Advertisement Bryan Collins from Scoil Naomh Fechin in Termonfeckin, Edel Victory of Sandpit NS and Ambrose McGinnity of Callystown NS in Clogherhead will retire next week after spending almost forty years each in primary teaching and most of that time as school principals. "Schools are expected to give more and more but with less and less funding and in a lot of cases, the capitation grant for children is barely covering school insurance, never mind anything else," said Ms. Victory. "When we had chalk boards, we could afford the chalk," said Mr McGinnity. "Now we have interactive white boards, chrome books and other electronic devices and we are given money to buy these items but we aren't provided with ongoing financial support so that these essential devices can be maintained, repaired and replaced.' Advertisement "Schools are living on a wing and a prayer. There is a huge gap between the cost of running schools and what we are given and we have been asking parents to fill that gap by organising fundraisers but in reality, we are educators and not fundraisers. "It is a sad state of affairs." Mr Collins added: "We have been beating this drum for quite some time. I don't think that the general public realise that schools are getting the same level of capitation as we received 17 years ago and that annual grant is supposed to cover a school's day-to-day running costs, despite a significant increase in the cost of living over this period of time. "A primary school's Capitation Grant equates to just over €1 a day per child. That's completely inadequate in this day and age. Primary schools have always been very resourceful and we are very good at cutting costs and looking for savings wherever we can find them but if we can't pay for the daily running costs, then we have to go out with the begging bowl to parents and ask for assistance. Advertisement "The government needs to start listening to school leaders and embark on a systematic change in the way schools are funded and resourced. " Mr Collins also criticised the government for the lack of supports and services in primary schools for children with additional needs. "The lack of supports for children with additional needs is a different problem but no less important. Ireland How anti-immigrant activists tried to 'weaponise'... Read More "We (teachers and principals) spend a large proportion of our time fighting for the rights of the most vulnerable young children in our schools. Advertisement "The services and supports that these children deserve and should be entitled to automatically are not available and in a first world country like Ireland it is simply not acceptable to have an inadequate number of Special Needs Assistants (SNAs), support teachers and wrap around services like psychologists, speech and language therapists, occupational therapists, etc. available to schools. "It seems to me that once the Department of Education and the National Council for Special Education (NCSE) provide a classroom space for children with additional needs, they wash their hands of it and let schools make the best of any resources that they can get hold of. "It is hugely disappointing that not a great deal has changed over the last decade to cater for the needs of our most vulnerable pupils."

Daily Mail​

2 hours ago

• Daily Mail​

EXCLUSIVE Inside Ireland's unmarried mothers house of horrors - by historian whose discovery shocked the world: Church-run home 'didn't value illegitimate children', fed them 'bare minimum to survive' and 'dumped bodies in sewage system'

Tuam has come to embody Ireland's shame. For decades, mothers who had fallen pregnant outside of marriage were sent to the home to give birth and hand their newborns over to the church. The young women would stay for a year, working for the nuns who ran the institution, before being released once they had 'paid for their sin'. Many of their babies however, didn't make it out alive. Thousands of children died in Ireland's notorious mother and baby homes, a 2021 enquiry found. The deaths were hidden from the world, with residents in the quiet town north of Galway unaware for years that as many as 800 babies had been buried at their local home. 'It was always late in the evening when the burials took place. We never knew what was going on because you couldn't see over the high walls,' historian Catherine Corless, who first uncovered the scandal more than ten years ago, told MailOnline. A baby died almost every fortnight, Corless said, with a damning 1947 report finding that as many as a quarter of the child residents died in a single year. A recent state-backed commission found the home's residents lived in 'appalling physical conditions', lacking basic sanitary facilities such as running water. Corless said the children lived in cold, crowded conditions, and only received very limited food. 'It was pure neglect. They would just give them the bare minimum to keep them alive,' she said. The 1947 report also revealed a harrowing picture of life inside the home, with children suffering from malnutrition and in many cases being described as pot-bellied – a sign of starvation. 'They didn't care, the illegitimate children didn't matter,' Corless said, 'The final insult to the ones who died was that they placed them in that awful sewage system.' The children were buried at first in 'box coffins', but were later placed 'one on top of the other' in the chambers of a former sewage tank, Corless described. After a long battle by the local historian, survivors of the home and their families, the site is now being excavated, with many hoping it will finally bring Tuam's dark past into the open. Despite growing up in the town and even seeing some of the 'terrified-looking' children at her school when she was very young, Corless like many others thought it was just an orphanage, and that 'the good nuns were looking after all those orphans.' That was until she began her research in 2011, and discovered that a site many dismissed as a burial ground for famine victims was in fact the final resting place of some of the home's children. The mother and baby home, which was run by nuns from the Bon Secours order, was demolished long ago and is now the site of a housing estate and playground. In 2011, as Corless embarked on a study of the site, she was alerted to a small garden in the area being a possible burial site. A man who had lived nearby for many years told how his two-storey house allowed him and others to see over the walls. 'He lived in one of the older houses on the site, they knew that there were burials because the houses had two stories.' 'He mentioned to me: "There were burials there, did you not know that?" He said he believed they were of the home babies so he brought me over to the site where he thought they were. 'I couldn't believe it because there was no sign, no headstone, no plaque, absolutely no indication whatsoever there was anyone buried there. I got very curious.' Corless dug deeper, and soon found that those high walls concealed a litany of other horrors too. 'The toddlers were just left in rooms with no toys, no stimulation, they had nothing. They were just crying all the time,' she said. 'They had no nappies and would spend an awful lot of time sat on potties, which the mothers trained them to do from a very early age.' She said much of the childcare was left to the women, with only only five nuns running the home which housed as many as 300 babies at any one time. According to the 1947 report, 34 per cent of children died in the home in 1943, and more than one in four living in the home in 1946, far higher than the average mortality rate at the time. The home remained open for almost twenty more years after the report was published, while other mother and baby homes stayed open until as late as the 1990s. Speaking to the Irish Mail on Sunday in 2014, an 85-year-old woman who survived the home in Tuam described the conditions she faced. The woman, who gave her name only as Mary, spent four years in the home before being placed with a foster family. She said: 'I remember going into the home when I was about four. There was a massive hall in it and it was full of young kids running round and they were dirty and cold. 'There were well over 100 children in there and there were three or four nuns who minded us. 'The building was very old and we were let out the odd time, but at night the place was absolutely freezing with big stone walls. 'When we were eating it was in this big long hall and they gave us all this soup out of a big pot, which I remember very well. It was rotten to taste, but it was better than starving.' She recalled that the children were 'rarely washed', and often wore the same clothes for weeks at a time. 'We were filthy dirty. I remember one time when I soiled myself, the nuns ducked me down into a big cold bath and I never liked nuns after that.' Corless has also recalled her experience as a young girl encountering the 'home babies' when they attended her school in the late 1950s and early 60s. 'I remember the children would come down to the schools hand in hand, a mother at the front and a nun at the back of the line. 'They were brought to school later and left earlier than us because they were not allowed to mix with children from the town, not allowed to talk to them, not allowed to play with them.' She said she believes this was done so the children would not ask them about their lives in the home. 'I remember them being miserable and afraid,' she said of the children's physical appearance. 'They were very skinny, they always had sores of some sort, some of them would have diarrhoea in the classroom and they would have to bring them out. 'They were really impoverished and always pale. I still remember the terrified look on their faces. They were treated like a species apart from the rest of us.' As well as the children, the mothers who were shamed and forced into the home also faced mistreatment. 'They were horrific places,' Labour MP Liam Conlon, who has long advocated for justice for mother and baby home survivors, told MailOnline. 'I've met survivors from right across Ireland, some of them were in the homes in the 1950s and 60s and some as late as the 90s. He said the 'emotional and physical abuse' many experienced there 'has had a huge impact on every aspect of their lives,' even to this day. 'Women were used as unpaid labour, it was seen as part of their penance. It was often very heavy manual labour.' While the Tuam mothers worked for 'very meagre means', Corless said, 'money was not scarce' and the nuns were paid by the state for every mother and child they took in. 'The mothers did everything, there were lots of jobs to do and each mother had to stay there for a year, work hard and then leave their baby there. 'They didn't employ anyone from the town, and that's how they got away with it, because there was no one to report what was going on,' Corless said. 'By working there, the women were paying for their sin. It was horrific. The whole thing was a money racquet.' Conlon said the separation of mothers and their children also often left both deeply traumatised, with babies often 'taken off them very soon after birth, adopted abroad and never seen again.' He said he had also heard testimony from survivors of nuns being 'very cruel' and unsupportive when the women gave birth, with many believed to have died in labour. 'They weren't supported throughout childbirth complications, it was often seen as a judgement from God,' Conlon said. Annette Mckay, who now lives in Manchester, told Sky News how her mother Margaret O'Connor gave birth to a baby at the Tuam home in 1942 after being raped aged 17. Annette described some of the treatment Maggie endured while being forced to work in the home. 'My mother worked heavily pregnant, cleaning floors and a nun passing kicked my mother in the stomach.' The little girl died after just six months, with Annette saying her mother recalled how 'she was pegging washing out and a nun came up behind her and said 'the child of your sin is dead'.' She has welcomed the exhumation, saying it will hopefully, at long last, expose the home's dark secrets. 'When that place is opened, their dirty, ugly secret, it isn't a secret anymore. It's out there.' Now, with the excavation underway, Corless, the survivors and families of those lost are at last hopeful that there is a light at the end of the tunnel. 'It's absolutely wonderful it's got to this stage,' Corless said, sharing her approval of the team behind the dig, which is headed by Daniel Macsweeney who has vowed to get 'every little bone out of that soil.' 'It's in good hands, the director said they are focussing on the families first, and what they want,' she said. 'I hope this sends a very strong message to Ireland and the world that this can never be allowed to happen again.' The Bon Secours sisters who ran the home issued an apology and acknowledged that children were buried in a 'disrespectful and unacceptable way' in a 2021 statement. The order said it did 'not live up' to its Christian values in its running of the Co Galway facility between 1925 and 1961. The Irish government also issued an apology in 2021 over the mother and baby home scandal, calling it a 'dark and shameful chapter' in Irish history.

The Independent

4 hours ago

• The Independent

US strikes on Iran an ‘extraordinarily dangerous escalation'

The US strikes on Iran represent an 'extraordinarily dangerous escalation' of the conflict in the Middle East, the Irish foreign affairs minister has said. Simon Harris, who is also Ireland's deputy premier, said an escalation in the 'tinderbox' region was more likely than ever and that the international community were at risk of 'losing all control' of the conflict. Irish premier Micheal Martin and Mr Harris both called for an 'urgent' de-escalation and a negotiated solution on Iran's nuclear facilities. They said they are in close contact with their European counterparts before a meeting of EU foreign leaders on Monday and of EU leaders later in the week. ' Diplomacy and dialogue is ultimately the only way to resolve these issues,' Mr Martin said. 'Iran should commit not to develop nuclear weapons and disavow its nuclear and uranium enrichment programme. 'Nuclear safety is an issue here, modern warfare is very destructive. It is civilians who ultimately suffer, and that is why we need an end to these wars and bring an end to conflict.' Mr Martin said the escalation on Sunday should not draw attention away from the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza. 'We shouldn't lose sight of the catastrophe that is still unfolding in Gaza while the war between Iran and Israel continues,' he said. 'What is happening in Gaza is appalling and a breach of international humanitarian law, and again, innocent civilians and children are being starved there, and we need that to come to an end.' Staff from Ireland's embassy in Tehran left the country on Friday as the embassy was closed, and updates are being provided on over 300 Irish peacekeepers stationed in Lebanon. Mr Harris said there were no plans to withdraw Irish troops and that 'decisions are being made constantly' to ensure their safety. When asked whether he supported Donald Trump's strikes on Iran, Mr Harris said: 'I think it's resulted in an extraordinarily dangerous escalation of a conflict that already best be described as a tinderbox. 'We're now entering a moment of particular danger, because I think the chances now of a spiral of escalation are more likely than ever before, and there is a real prospect now of the international community losing all control of this very, very volatile conflict.' He said there was only a 'very small' number of Irish citizens, many dual nationals, seeking an evacuation, and they were working with European counterparts. He said a significant update on this would be available in the hours ahead. 'Thank god we woke this morning to the International Atomic Energy Agency saying they haven't detected any increase in radiation,' he told RTE Radio. 'But imagine if we were waking up this morning to a situation where radiation levels were extraordinarily high, and the health and human danger that that would have presented far beyond Iran as well. So this is an extraordinarily dangerous time.' He said that it was 'sadly true' that international legal norms are not being adhered to, citing the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Israel's 'genocidal activity' in Palestine and now the Iran-Israel conflict. He said there was a diplomatic process in train and his understanding from readouts was 'there was a commitment from the Iranian side to further talks'. Mr Harris said Ireland and Europe are 'fully united in the clear view' that Iran should not be allowed to possess nuclear weapons. 'The way to address this was always through a negotiated solution. Any alternative to that is simply too dangerous for civilians, for the Middle East region and for global security. 'Together with my EU counterparts, we will in the coming hours and days discuss and review the latest developments and consider the next steps Europe can usefully play to support de-escalation.' Minister for Culture Patrick O'Donovan said people woke up on Sunday 'terrified, really, to be quite honest, about the prospect of what's unfolding'. He told RTE's The Week In Politics it is 'terrifying' for citizens in Iran and Israel. 'It does take great people to make leaps of faith in particular places in time to come forward, whether it was in relation to (Anwar el-Sadat) in Egypt, and later on in relation to Bill Clinton and what he did, we do now require people to actually get people around the table,' he said. 'Because ultimately, as the Taoiseach said, this is terrifying, not only for the innocent communities that are living in both countries, but as well as that for the neighbouring countries in the Middle East, who we obviously all hope are not drawn into a much bigger conflict.'