MAIL ON SUNDAY COMMENT: Dogma cares little for the state of Britain's economy
This country's economy is now in serious peril. This is not only because the Government is nudging at the very outer limits of what it can raise in tax and borrowing – though it is.
It is also because that government is increasingly driven by ferocious dogma which cares little for such concerns.
It may be that some in the Cabinet can see the danger, yet others do not even view it as a danger, but as an opportunity for yet more upheaval and dramatic change.
The extraordinary developments of last week, in which the current very large Labour majority in Parliament brought about revolutions in abortion law and in assisted dying, are a warning that we are now in uncharted waters.
It may possibly be that we have never had a government whose parliamentary forces are so radical. And the uncrowned queen of those forces is the Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, increasingly influential and remarkably effective in the Commons and in Whitehall.
It is true that there has always been a role for disruptive and troublemaking men and women near the top of the Labour Party.
In the Tony Blair years, a similar position was filled by the late John Prescott, a majestic steam-powered Dreadnought originating in the (now remote) days of real class war. Let nobody underestimate Lord Prescott's considerable influence on the government he served.
But Tony Blair, Gordon Brown and the apparatus of New Labour kept him under control. In this case, it looks very much as if a confident and popular Ms Rayner has slipped free of any restraint by the Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer.
Her Employment Rights Bill, which is alarming businesses all over the country, would have been strangled at birth in the days of Blairism.
The unions would have been told – rightly – that the public had grown heartily sick of their overmighty antics in the past, and did not want to see them given back the unrestrained power they had rightly lost.
And while Sir Keir and his Chancellor Rachel Reeves must know this, they seem either powerless to act, or surprisingly untroubled by the danger of it.
Speaking to The Mail on Sunday last week, Ms Reeves simply evaded the question of Ms Rayner's plans. When a successful businessman such as Sir James Dyson accuses you of being 'vindictive' and of 'waging a war on aspiration', you really ought to listen.
It is on the success of such businessmen that any future economic growth must be based. Without that growth, where are the taxes to come from to pay for the advanced welfare state in which we live?
So we must applaud the open letter to British businessmen sent out by Shadow Business Secretary Andrew Griffith, in which he does what Sir Keir and Ms Reeves will not do, and makes it plain just how dangerous Ms Rayner's plans are.
He warns those business chiefs that they are being sleepwalked into disaster, that the Rayner Bill will fundamentally change the balance of power in workplaces, at huge cost.
Coming after the idiocy of the National Insurance increase, this a grave threat to the jobs of trade union members, as well as to the economy as a whole.
We can only hope that the Prime Minister and his Chancellor will listen and act, for the nation's sake as well as their own.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
7 minutes ago
- BBC News
Bristol in Pictures: It's a new dawn, it's a new day
Temperatures have risen in time for the summer solstice this people have been out soaking up the rays and we have had some gorgeous sunny scenes to wake up to. Early start: Paddleboarders took to the water just after 04:00 BST on Saturday to mark the solstice with a mass dawn paddle organised by watersports company SUP. Making a splash: It was only last Sunday that thousands of people lined the harbourside to watch teams enter their homemade creations in the first ever Bristol Birdman competition. Winners: The specialist debt team from Citizens Advice South Gloucestershire has been named the Debt Team of the Year by the Institute of Money Advisers. It is the third year in the row the Yate-based team, made up of Yvonne Parks, Eliza Hirst, Linda Mullholland and Angus Macdonald, has either been shortlisted or won an award. Ahoy: This group of sailors made the most of the weather and took to Bristol harbour in their boats. A young endangered Philippine spotted deer has been photographed at Bristol Zoo Project. Maliit is an extremely rare and tiny deer fawn. There are thought to be fewer than 700 Philippine spotted deer left in the wild. It has been a scorcher of a week, and as we approached the longest day of the year one of our Weather Watchers sent in this beautiful picture of a late sunset over homes in Weston-super-Mare. University of Bristol students celebrated taking part in a programme of specialist start-up training at a special event on Wednesday evening. Participants in the scheme have the opportunity to pitch their business idea, with the winners granted £8,000 of funding.
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
Housing bill "catastrophic for wildlife"
A new bill which the government says aims to speed up housebuilding has been described as "catastrophic for wildlife" by a nature Wildlife Trust's chief executive Nick Bruce-White has said it will give developers an open door to pay "cash to trash" the environment. Labour says it wants to build 1.5 million homes during this parliament and 150 large infrastructure projects. The government says the new Planning and Infrastructure Bill will deliver a "win-win" for the economy and nature by ensuring builders can meet their environmental obligations faster. Devon Wildlife Trust has said it wants part three of the bill, entitled Nature Restoration Fund, Bruce-White said it would be "catastrophic for wildlife by effectively giving developers licence to trash wildlife habitats". He said it "represents one of the most significant threats to nature that we've faced in decades"."We've worked really hard with government to try and make sure environmental protections are kept within the planning system, so we can both grow the economy and restore nature at the same time. "All our work behind closed doors has been met with platitudes and false reassurances and we feel like we are being completely ignored," he added. 'Environmental improvements' The government says the Nature Restoration Fund "will ensure there is a win-win for both the economy and nature by ensuring builders can meet their environmental obligations faster.""These changes will remove time intensive and costly processes, with payments into the fund allowing building to proceed while wider action is taken to secure the environmental improvements we need."At the bill's third reading, the Minister for Housing and Planning, Matthew Pennycook said: "To those who believe this government might buckle and scrap part three of the bill entirely, I simply say, "You have underestimated the resolve of this government and this minister." "The case for moving to a more strategic approach that will allow us to use funding from development to deliver environmental improvements at a scale that will have the greatest impact in driving the recovery of protected sites and species, is compelling." Devon Wildlife Trust says often great crested newts and bats are blamed for delaying planning developments, but its own research shows they represent just 3% of planning application appeals. The charity says sensitive and protected nature sites could be at high risk of damage or destruction under the new planning framework, with species like curlews, water voles, and the High Brown Fritillary butterfly at risk. Members of the House of Lords will now debate the bill.
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
States to decide on lottery funds for Jersey Sport
The States Assembly is set to decide on the redistribution of £857,410 from the Channel Islands Lottery proceeds to include Jersey Sport. Since 2020, the proceeds have been successfully managed by the Association of Jersey Charities (AJC) and the Jersey Community Foundation (JCF), supporting numerous local charities and organisations including the sports funding distribution to Jersey Sport is being proposed to reduce administrative costs and provide better access for sporting organisations to seek support, according to a proposition to the Jersey Sport and the JCF which has funded sport, support this transfer, the proposition said. Under the new allocation plan:50% (£428,705) will go to the AJC, solely for registered charities.30% (£257,223) will be directed to the JCF, with funds split between arts, culture, heritage (65-75%), and applied sciences or research (25-35%).20% (£171,482) will be allocated to Jersey Sport to support sports and active lifestyles.
