Tory MP appeared to make ‘offensive' Irish potato famine remark, House of Commons told

A SENIOR CONSERVATIVE MP appeared to make 'offensive and insensitive' comments about the Irish Famine, the Commons has heard.
Shadow business secretary Andrew Griffith, responding to a question, said he was not sure if a person could 'subsist entirely on a seed potato' before adding it 'may have been tried historically and not with enormous success'.
Labour MP Adam Jogee said the words appeared to reference the mid-19th century tragedy, which resulted in around one million deaths after the potato crop failed in successive years.
Speaking during a Commons debate on the economy on Wednesday, Liberal Democrat MP Jamie Stone intervened to raise the seed potato industry.
He said: 'We have been crying out to get the best of Scottish seed potatoes into European markets, and therefore I do say thank you to the Government for this, it means a lot to farmers, and I have had very positive comments about it. I am being absolutely fair-minded about that.'
Advertisement
Griffith, in his reply, said: 'I am not sure if one can subsist entirely on a seed potato, I think that may have been tried historically and not with enormous success, but I congratulate the honourable member on the success of his seed potato industry.'
On Thursday, Jogee raised a point of order in connection with the remarks made by Griffith.
After Mr Jogee read out the words spoken by Griffith in the debate, one MP could be heard saying: 'Shocking.'
Jogee, who chairs the all-party parliamentary group on Ireland and the Irish in Britain, added: 'These words appear to be referencing the tragedy of the Irish potato famine which, if true, is of course offensive and insensitive and, of course, would have taken place at the time in the United Kingdom.
'So can you please advise on how best we can remedy any offence caused by outlining the process for an honourable member to withdraw such a statement?'
Deputy Speaker Judith Cummins replied: 'The chair is not responsible for the shadow secretary of state's remarks but the honourable member has put his point on the record.'
Griffith and the Conservative Party have been approached for comment.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Journal

an hour ago

• The Journal

Why are so few candidates dipping their toe in the water in the race for the Áras?

IT'S JUST A few months out from the presidential election, yet the public is none the wiser about who is interested in the top job, despite months of speculation about the runners and riders. The political parties have been very much in assessment mode trying to figure out who they might put forward, but the government parties do not appear to be in a rush to get the campaign going. Taoiseach and Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin confirmed this week that his party is still taking 'soundings' from people who might be interested in running. Yesterday, Martin said he was not aware of any engagement with former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood over becoming the party's candidate for the Irish presidency, despite Eastwood stating that he may be interested. MEP Barry Andrews has ruled himself out of running for the party, with some chatter that his colleague MEP Cynthia Ní Mhurchú might be interested. Former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern has long been talked about, but while some diehard fans of his within the party would only love to see him make a comeback, it is understood in party HQ, dredging up the past is not being viewed as a good move. In case you're wondering, Martin has also ruled himself out . Tánaiste and Fine Gael leader Simon Harris confirmed this week that presidential candidate nominations for the party will open in early July and will close in mid July. If there is more than one candidate, then a ballot will be held during the summer and the winner announced probably in September. Former European Commissioner Mairead McGuinness has not ruled herself out, with some party sources stating she is 'everywhere', which speaks to her drumming up support. However, others state that MEP Sean Kelly is also keen to throw his hat in the ring, even if it is only to spark hustings within the party. Harris told The Journal in March that he thinks competition for the candidacy would be 'healthy' for the party. So other than the two main government parties, who else is in the mix? While there had been talk that the united opposition would come together to nominate a candidate, they haven't been able to get their act together. Names such as Senator Frances Black and TD Catherine Connolly have been mentioned as possibilities. Advertisement However, Black told Newstalk recently that while she was initially approached about being a possible candidate, the senator said she has heard nothing since. Whether that was a message for the Left to pick up the phone and get a move on, it remains to be seen, as Black stated she is over 98% certain she isn't running . Connolly is understood to be a favourite among many Left-leaning parties, but some sources state the Labour Party have some issues with the nomination. One person who might fit the brief is MEP Luke 'Ming' Flanagan who has confirmed that running is something he might consider. Flanagan said that he believes he has a chance of winning the election, with his appeal across a number of different constituencies as a three-time independent MEP for Midlands North West. And what about Sinn Féin? Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill has not ruled out a run for the upcoming presidential election. When asked yesterday if she was considering putting her name forward, O'Neill said Sinn Féin is working its way through deliberations on putting forward a candidate. Not a no then. MEP Lynn Boylan also stated on RTÉ Radio yesterday that she wasn't going for the job. Party president Mary Lou McDonald has also ruled herself out . Who else might be runners in the race? Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín has said his party intends to run a candidate in the presidential election, though name has been forthcoming. Businessman Peter Casey has declared he wants to run again. He got 23% of the vote in the presidential election in 2018 but he didn't fare too great in the European Elections where he got 3% of the vote in the Midlands-North-West constituency. Other names that have been mentioned include Irish Times columnist Fintan O'Toole, who said he would not rule out a bid but that he would not do it alone. Former TD and co-founder of the Social Democrats Róisín Shortall topped a newspaper poll before Christmas as the favourite to be Ireland's next President at 32%. Related Reads 134 members of the Oireachtas say they will not nominate McGregor for the presidency Mairead McGuinness has 'made no decision' on presidential bid after Micheal O'Leary's endorsement Senator Frances Black 'open to the conversation' of running for president Shortall told the Mail on Sunday at the time that she 'hasn't decided' what her next move will be, so watch this space. There remains speculation about a few RTÉ stars who might run, such as Liveline's Joe Duffy, who is due to exit from his role with the broadcaster at the end of this month, which could be timely. Presenter Miriam O'Callaghan, who was talked about as a possible runner back in 2018, is also still in the mix, with some pointing to her new memoir that has recently been released. Comedian/actor and RTÉ presenter Tommy Tiernan was also quizzed in a recent interview with RTÉ's Brendan O'Connor, where he didn't categorically rule out the prospect. Of course, there's also MMA fighter Conor McGregor, who hasn't been shy about his ambitions to be the next president. The chances for his candidacy are slim though as candidates need the backing of 20 members of the Oireachtas or four councils to get on the ballot paper. This gives political parties a major advantage, given the numbers. While we generally have a better idea during the summer of who the candidates, things are moving at a slower pace this time around. It's understood that given the previous bloodbath presidential election campaigns, the main political parties are wary of a long campaign and what it might unearth about any potential candidates. A short, snappy campaign is being favoured. Michael D. Higgins, the current president was inaugurated for his second term on 11 November 2018, meaning the next presidential election is scheduled to take place on or up to 60 days before 11 November 2025. But at this rate, it could be late-August or early September before we finally see how the ballot paper might shape up. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

The Journal

an hour ago

• The Journal

Tánaiste confirms US threat to Lebanon peacekeepers and will liaise with EU states to save mission

AS THE US considers vetoing a renewal vote for the Lebanon peacekeeping mission, the Government has confirmed it is liaising with European countries to save the operation. As revealed on Thursday by The Journal there are just ten weeks ahead of a crucial vote in the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) – it appears that the US is considering ending its support for the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL). We discovered that US real estate mogul Tom Barrack, a close confidante of Donald Trump, was in Lebanon as fears are mounting that the US will pull the plug on funding for UNIFIL. Multiple sources, both here and in Europe, believe that this would have one of two possible outcomes – either a reduction in budget and troop numbers or a complete shutdown of the mission. One other possibility, according to a source, is that the Lebanese Government could invite certain countries to stay on should the mission end. The UNIFIL mandate ends on 31 August – this news website discovered that French diplomats were set to lead negotiations on trying to save the mission. Tonight that has been confirmed officially by a statement from the Tánaiste Simon Harris' office. The Minister for Defence and Foreign Affairs said he is beginning to liaise with EU counterparts to try and find a solution. 'The Tanaiste Simon Harris has tonight began to reach out to other European countries to ensure the renewal of the UNIFIL mandate in Southern Lebanon. 'He will travel to Brussels tomorrow where a high level meeting of Foreign Affairs Ministers is scheduled , amid deepening concerns in EU capitals. Advertisement 'It comes amid the escalation of violence between Israel and Iran with Simon Harris due to travel to Brussels on Monday to discussing the war with other European counterparts,' he said. UNIFIL began in 1978 to maintain peace and security on the border between Lebanon and Israel after a period of increased tension between the two countries. More than 300 Irish troops are part of a massive international presence of 10,500 troops from 50 countries to monitor both sides of the border. They patrol a fragile demarcation zone in South Lebanon along what is known as the Blue Line. Simon Harris visiting Irish troops in March. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo The statement added that he has received a briefing today from the Irish Defence Forces as tensions mount across the Middle East region. 'He will continue to discuss options in relation to the future of the mission with Chief of Staff of the Defence Forces, Lieutenant General Rossa Mulcahy. 'The Tanaiste will impress on his foreign counterparts on the absolute need for the mission to continue, in order to ensure stability and peace in the Region. 'Ireland has an unbroken record with UNIFIL for many decades and has over 340 troops deployed at Camp Shamrock. 'The French are due to lead the negotiations to extend the mandate with a decision expected to be made in August,' the statement added. Separately, the Tanaiste and has been briefed by the Chief of Staff on a number of incidents that took place in Southern Lebanon in recent days . All Irish Troops are accounted for and well. It is understood shelling in south Lebanon caused soldiers to take to bunkers, known as groundhog, in the last 24 hours. There was a dramatic interception in the sky above the Irish camp in recent days as Israel knocked down a suspicious drone. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Irish Times

an hour ago

• Irish Times

On Sanctuary Sunday, we share a responsibility to oppose hostility towards migrants and asylum seekers

Today many churches will be marking Sanctuary Sunday with prayer and action as part of their contribution to Refugee Week. The positive theme 'community as a superpower' stands in stark contrast to the examples of violence and hostility towards migrants and people seeking asylum we have witnessed across the island of Ireland in recent times. Violence and division harm communities, shattering the sense of safety and undermining efforts to address shared social and economic challenges. We all have a responsibility to speak out against these outrages, in particular our political leaders, who have been elected to serve the whole community. This year, we are encouraged to share the positive experiences of encounter and relationship-building with people who have come to our community from other backgrounds and cultures, particularly those who have come in search of safety. READ MORE Contributing to an informed and respectful public discourse about issues of migration and asylum is vital. No country should hesitate to answer the question of whether it will offer protection and safety to refugees. [ Ukrainians in Ireland succeeding in asylum applications at twice rate of other nationalities Opens in new window ] The UN Refugee Convention of 1951 is a universal obligation and affirms the need to work globally to protect refugees from violence and danger. The number of people seeking asylum in Ireland has been rising in recent years, as in other countries around the world, but is not disproportionate in European terms. As the UN High Commissioner for Refugees says, the vast majority of refugees displaced by the destruction and danger of war take shelter in neighbouring countries, and so what we are seeing in Ireland and the rest of the EU falls far behind the contribution that some Middle Eastern and African nations are making to the global response to the needs of displaced people. Ireland has the resources to respond with compassion to the desperate needs of people seeking asylum. This does not have to be at the expense of the wellbeing of local communities. The theme of 'community as a superpower' reminds us of the vital role of local communities as partners with the Government in this work, and of the importance of respect, consultation and engagement in that relationship. In my experience, local church congregations offer incredible strength in building community. We are neighbourhood based, we work at the street level and we know how to build partnerships. And we live where we work - we don't parachute in. We work with partners across all faiths and beliefs for community development and cohesion. [ Jim O'Callaghan's public theatrics mask the truth about asylum seeker deportations Opens in new window ] We know we are in for a long haul. We contribute to building better relationships and driving change. My current passion, working with Churches Together in Britain and Ireland, is the development of the idea of church of sanctuary. A church of sanctuary goes beyond welcome and stands with and supports vulnerable people such as those who are seeking asylum. It becomes part of the growing city of sanctuary and places of sanctuary networks in Ireland, a community-led movement committed to building cultures of welcome and hospitality with refugees. In a church of sanctuary all members of the congregation intentionally work together to learn about real-life stories of refugees and people seeking sanctuary, and engage with others to work from facts, not fiction and misinformation. They embed the values and cultures of welcome, hospitality and safety as part of being the congregation and use these to support refugees and people seeking sanctuary. They also share their vision, commitment and achievements, and let others know about the positive contributions of refugees to society and the benefits of welcoming others. At a time when vulnerable migrants and refugees are under attack, the church of sanctuary initiative is a constructive response that flows from the values of the Irish church as a Christian community. This Sanctuary Sunday, we pray for a renewed commitment to challenge hostility with hospitality, inspired by a strong local community vision and working together with people of all faiths and no particular religious belief. Inderjit Bhogal is founder of the City of Sanctuary and Church of Sanctuary initiatives