SCA dismisses 'meritless' appeal by two environmental organisations
Because the company required the water use licencee to commence mining, it engaged various experts and obtained several specialist reports, including a hydrological, socioeconomic, geohydrology impact and a biodiversity baseline and impact assessment.
It also obtained a numerical groundwater model report and conducted a public participation process as part of the application for the licence. These assessments informed the licencee conditions.
In July 2016 the director-general (DG) of the department of water & sanitation issued the licence, valid for 15 years, to Atha-Africa. The licencee authorised specified water-use activities in relation to the mining to be conducted.
In the same year, the two organisations appealed the DG's decision to issue the licence to the Water Tribunal.
They claimed, among others, that the DG failed to consider the effect of the proposed water use on the water resource; that the DG failed to authorise certain water uses associated with the closure of the mine; that the consent of the owner of a farm regarding the use of underground water had not been obtained; and that the DG failed to apply environmental principles in the National Environmental Management Act.
In 2019, the tribunal dismissed the appeal, concluding, among others, that the findings and scientific reviews by the appellants' experts were unsubstantiated and were demonstrated in evidence to be shallow. The tribunal found that sound methods were used in the Atha-Africa's wetland and hydrological studies.
The SCA said the organisations appealed the tribunal's decision to the Pretoria high court in terms of section 149(1) of the NWA, which permits an appeal only on a question of law.
The high court dismissed the organisations' appeal with costs. The SCA granted the appellants special leave to appeal.
The SCA found in its judgment that most of the appeal grounds did not raise questions of law.
It said these were questions of fact based on the evidence before the tribunal, and could not form the subject of an appeal in terms of the NWA.
'The appeal lodged by the appellants has little or no basis in law.'
The court also noted the appellants lodged the appeal regardless of the consequences, including the inconvenience to and exorbitant costs that would be incurred by the department and Atha-Africa.
The court said in 2011, Atha-Africa was invited to invest in South Africa. It has made an investment of US$40m in equity and prospecting rights to engage in coal mining. It has spent US$61m solely on specialist studies, to secure the necessary authorisations.
'More than 10 years later no mining has started and (Atha-Africa) has not realised any return on its investment.'
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
3 hours ago
- The Herald
Harmony on track to meet production guidance
Harmony Gold, SA's biggest gold producer by volume, said it remains on track to deliver its production and cost guidance as the gold price continues to add shine to its performance. Harmony, which paid a record R1.4bn dividend in the six months ended December 2024, said it expects to meet the 2025 financial year guidance of between 1.4m ounces and 1.5m ounces 'comfortably' between the guided range of R1.02m/kg to R1.1m/kg. CEO Beyers Nel said underground recovered grades will be higher than the guided 6g/t while total capital expenditure for the year will be slightly below the guided R10.8bn. 'We have a firm grip on our costs, which are predominantly rand based and comprise mainly labour, consumables and electricity. We continue to benefit from the high rand per kilogram gold price and maintain a high level of certainty and predictability as it relates to our planning parameters,' Nel said. Harmony, which operates some of SA's deep level gold mines, also has operations in Papua New Guinea and Australia. The company has been on an acquisition path and last month announced the potential $1.03bn (R18.6bn) acquisition of MAC Copper in New South Wales, Australia, which is expected to produce more than 40 000 tonnes of copper annually and contribute immediately towards increasing free cash flow generation. 'Over the past three years, Harmony has transformed into a geographically diversified specialist mining company with a compelling gold and copper story. We continue creating meaningful value for our stakeholders through safe, profitable ounces and improving margins by delivering on our strategic objectives,' Nel said. He said Harmony will continue to allocate most of its project capital to its higher-grade, higher-quality, and lower-risk assets. 'This includes the extension projects at Hidden Valley, Moab Khotsong and Mponeng. We are also finalising the Eva Copper project's feasibility study and will provide an update on the outcome thereof when we release our year-end results in August 2025,' he said. The company is scheduled to release its 2025 financial results on August 28. TimesLIVE
The Herald
3 hours ago
- The Herald
Malema vows to build houses for families of KZN bus crash victims
EFF leader Julius Malema has committed to building houses and boreholes for the families of 10 party members who died in a bus crash last week while returning from a Youth Day rally in Durban. Malema addressed the mass funeral service in Vryheid on Sunday. 'We are going to honour these 10 fallen heroes, each one of them with a house that has all the facilities,' he said. 'If there's no water in those yards, we'll make sure we put [in] boreholes so we restore the dignity of those families. We will build those houses and put [in] those boreholes because we want to build a permanent relationship with these families. We don't want to forget you and don't forget us.' He assured the families they are not alone. 'Your loss is our loss. Your tears are our tears. Your children are not forgotten. The EFF will walk with you, we will support you and we will continue to fight in their name. 'As the EFF, we say their death must not be in vain. Their passing must become a turning point. We must honour them not only with flowers and words but with action. We must fix our roads, regulate the transport industry and demand accountability.' The accident happened on June 17 when the group was returning from the rally. A bus carrying EFF supporters collided with a truck on the R34 near Vryheid. Malema described the members who died as 'soldiers', drawing a parallel to the youth of 1976 who died for freedom. 'These are not just names in headlines or numbers in a report. These were young people who had dreams. They were full of life, full of promise and full of courage that defines the children of working-class and oppressed families. They died while in pursuit of life. They were travelling with hope in their hearts, but the journey that should've taken them towards opportunity ended in tragedy.' He said their parents should be proud that their children did not die from drug or alcohol abuse but on the 'battlefield'. 'Your children are soldiers; they are martyrs and the names of your children will be called when the names of the martyrs are called. Be proud that your children have inspired many generations to come.' TimesLIVE
The South African
6 hours ago
- The South African
How rich are South Africa's 7 billionaires this week?
It's comparatively 'easy' to make money – when you have money to start with. Compound interest is indeed the eighth wonder of the world! As they say, the rich get richer, while the poor stay, well, poor. Money makes money – and these seven South African men have made a lot of it over the years. And by a lot, we mean a LOT ! According to Forbes' real-time tracking of billionaires, Johann Rupert and his family are the richest in South Africa, with a net worth of $13.7 billion. The Ruperts are followed by diamond magnate Nicky Oppenheimer, who boasts a net worth of $10.4 billion. They are followed by Koos Bekker, Patrice Motsepe, Michiel Le Roux, Jannie Mouton and Christo Wiese. South Africa's seven dollar billionaires all made their money in different ways – from luxury goods, diamonds, mining, media, banking and retail. Last week, Rupert was the big 'loser' as his net worth dropped by $300 million (R5.4 billion). Oppenheimer, Motsepe, Mouton and Wiese all lost $100 million (R1.8 billion) to their net worths. Cumulatively, South Africa's seven dollar billionaires are worth $36.7 billion (R663 billion). Meanwhile, in terms of the overall world list, South Africa-born Elon Musk remains the world's richest person with a reported $409 billion. Below, the list of the top seven richest South Africans in the world as of 23 June 2025. Rank Name Last week This week Source 183 Johann Rupert & family $14bn $13.7bn Luxury goods 271 Nicky Oppenheimer & family $10.5bn $10.4bn Diamonds 1 049 Koos Bekker $3.6bn $3.6bn Media, investments 1 174 Patrice Motsepe $3.3bn $3.2bn Mining 1 506 Michiel Le Roux $2.5bn $2.5bn Banking 2 056 Jannie Mouton & family $1.8bn $1.7bn Retail 2 149 Christo Wiese $1.7bn $1.6bn Financial services TOTAL $37.4bn $36.7bn Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
