UK migrant carers 'owed huge sums' in visa scheme 'scandal'
Live Events
When Zimbabwean sales rep Zola landed a job in Britain as a care worker she was excited about forging a new career, but the mother-of-three is now homeless, jobless and trapped in debt.Labour rights experts say Zola is among tens of thousands of victims in an emerging national scandal that they say is a "shocking betrayal" by the government.In 2022, Britain launched an initiative to encourage overseas workers to plug massive staffing shortages in its struggling care sector following the COVID pandemic and Brexit.But reports of exploitation have soared, with rogue operators charging illegal recruitment fees and promising jobs to more people than they could employ.(Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates)In a crackdown on labour abuses, the government has banned hundreds of companies from hiring migrant workers.But carers like Zola, who had already been recruited by these firms, are now in limbo and at risk of deportation unless they find a new sponsor."This should be recognised as a national crisis," said Dora-Olivia Vicol, CEO of the charity Work Rights Centre "It's a shocking betrayal of migrant workers who came here in good faith to work when Britain called for help," she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.The Work Rights Centre has been inundated with calls from desperate migrant workers this year, many facing destitution.Vicol said they were owed "huge sums". The charity is calling for harsher penalties for employers who break the rules to help fund a compensation scheme.If Zola's story is typical, the Thomson Reuters Foundation calculated migrant workers like her would be owed hundreds of millions of pounds in lost earnings.With no access to financial support or compensation, most care workers in Zola's situation are homeless. A few are sleeping rough, while others rely on friends."This has changed our lives," said Zola, 45, who asked to use a pseudonym for fear of repercussions."The government should be held accountable. I came here through the proper channels ... and now I'm treated like someone who came through the back door."Zola, who arrived in Britain in July 2023, said she had paid 5,000 pounds ($6,752) for a company in the northern city of Leeds to sponsor her, unaware such charges are illegal. Other care workers report paying 10,000 pounds or more.Her contract promised an annual salary of 20,480 pounds, but she was barely given any shifts, forcing her to borrow money to survive.Zola believes her former boss had hired about 100 carers. If staff complained they were threatened with deportation, she said.In March, the government revealed more than 470 companies had lost their sponsor licences since 2022, affecting about 40,000 migrant workers.The government set up a job finding scheme for "displaced" workers in May 2024 and is encouraging care companies to hire them.But research by the Work Rights Centre suggests just 3.4% of those signposted to the initiative were reported to have secured a job.Vicol said the government response was "deeply inadequate"."I think they're trying to bury the problem. At the end of the day, all these thousands of people are victims of fraud," she said."If we were talking about thousands of people who had booked a cruise that never materialised everyone would be screaming for a compensation scheme."A spokesperson for the government said the job matching scheme was supporting thousands of care workers, but did not respond to questions about compensation.Zola has not had any luck finding a job through the initiative or elsewhere.She said companies providing home care often wanted driving licences, which many carers do not have.Further obstacles facing carers include difficulties in supplying references and the cost of relocating to a new area.Vicol said the government had opened the gates to exploitation by setting up a system that tied workers to their sponsors through their visas.It had also allowed care companies - including small inexperienced start-ups - to recruit large numbers of carers without checking they could provide sufficient work.Care workers who lose their jobs have 60 days to find a new sponsor before their visa expires.Labour unions and rights campaigners are calling for a new system to allow workers to switch employers within the care sector without putting their visa at risk, and an extension to the 60-day grace period.Last month, the government said it would end care worker recruitment from abroad. Critics say the move is a knee-jerk reaction to the rise of anti-immigrant party Reform UK Jane Townson, CEO of the Homecare Association which represents domiciliary care providers, said the decision was shortsighted as there were still more than 130,000 vacancies.She said a lack of funding was a major challenge.Most home care services are purchased by local councils or the health service, but Townson said many public bodies did not pay care providers enough to even cover their labour costs at the minimum wage.Providers were forced to compete for contracts which were awarded to the lowest bidder, squeezing out good employers.But she said councils were driving down prices due to inadequate government funding."What we've got is state-sponsored labour exploitation," she added. "This is a public scandal."The government spokesperson said it had boosted social care funding this year and would introduce a fair pay agreement for care staff under broader reforms.But Townson said the pay agreement was a long way off and would not work without a big injection of cash.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Indian deposits in Swiss banks down nearly 18% over last 10 years: Here's why
Deposits of Indian customers in Swiss banks fell by around 18 per cent over the past decade, according to the latest figures released by the Swiss National Bank (SNB). The data shows a drop from approximately 425 million Swiss francs in 2015 to 346 million Swiss francs in 2024. The SNB data also showed that Indian deposits witnessed a sharp rise during the COVID-19 period, touching a 10-year high of around 602 million Swiss francs. However, the deposits started declining after the pandemic peak, ANI reported. In 2023, deposits stood at 309 million Swiss francs, whereas in 2024, they only grew by 37 million Swiss francs. Despite this annual rise, the overall trend over the last decade remains downward. The downward trend of deposits in Swiss banks can be due to various reasons like tightening regulations, increased scrutiny, and changes in international financial transparency norms, said ANI. The most significant drop was seen in deposits by American nationals. Their deposits in Swiss banks plunged from 64.2 billion Swiss francs in 2015 to 24.4 billion Swiss francs in 2024, a decline of about 62 per cent. For India, the trend clearly shows that over the last decade, deposits by Indian nationals in Swiss banks have declined, although a temporary hike in deposits was seen during the pandemic in 2021, the news agency reported. This declining trend in deposits is not unique to India. Several other countries also witnessed a reduction in funds deposited in Swiss banks by their nationals, the news agency reported. Among major economies, deposits by UK nationals fell from 44 billion Swiss francs in 2015 to 31 billion Swiss francs in 2024. Chinese deposits also saw a decline, reducing from 5.01 billion Swiss francs to 4.3 billion Swiss francs over the same period. The neighbouring countries of India — Pakistan and Bangladesh—also saw a decline. Deposits held by Pakistani nationals in Swiss banks have witnessed a steep decline over the last ten years. According to the data, deposits by Pakistanis stood at 947 million Swiss francs in 2015 but have dropped significantly to 241 million Swiss francs by 2024, a fall of nearly 75 per cent. A similar trend was observed in the case of Bangladeshi nationals. Their deposits in Swiss banks declined from 48 million Swiss francs in 2015 to just 12.6 million Swiss francs in 2024, marking a drop of over 73 per cent, as per data cited by ANI.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
RBI Governor pushes for growth-backed policies as global uncertainty clouds India's investment outlook: MPC minutes
RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra cautioned that rising global uncertainty could postpone business investment decisions. He noted that post-COVID recovery has been driven by public investments, with private sector investment remaining weak despite favorable conditions. Malhotra emphasized the necessity of implementing policies that actively support economic growth in the face of these challenges. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Growth and inflation outlook Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Rising global uncertainty may cause businesses to delay investment decisions, Reserve Bank of India Governor Sanjay Malhotra said, stressing the need for policies that support economic growth , in his statement, released on Friday, as a part of the minutes of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting.'On the investment front, the post-Covid recovery so far has been largely led by public investments, while private sector investments have been weak despite high capacity utilisation and improved corporate balance sheets. Moreover, heightened global uncertainties may put on hold investment decisions by businesses, underscoring the need for growth supportive policies,' Malhotra its June meeting, the MPC decided to cut the benchmark repo rate by 50 basis points to 5.5%. The committee expects that this dual-rate cut will significantly reduce lending rates, thereby, encouraging both investment and consumption, particularly in durable the decision, Malhotra said, 'It is expected that the front-loaded rate action along with certainty on the liquidity front would send a clear signal to the economic agents, thereby supporting consumption and investment through lower cost of borrowing.'The RBI had earlier indicated that investment activity is likely to improve, supported by higher capacity utilisation, better corporate balance sheets across both financial and non-financial sectors, and continued capital expenditure by the the overall investment landscape remains uneven. 'Domestically, the recovery of economic growth to 7.4% in Q4:2025 from 6.4% in Q3:2025 was a pleasant surprise. It helped to close the year 2024-25 with 6.5% growth overall. However, the recovery has not been broad-based. It was supported by the rural consumption and government capex. Private investment, especially in manufacturing, and urban consumption, have continued to remain subdued,' said MPC member Nagesh Kumar in his added, 'It is not clear that the growth momentum will continue in the Q1 of the current year, given the fact that consumption and investment growth is moderating. The survey of corporate performance shows that companies are deleveraging their balance sheets with rising profits. Despite the capacity utilisation crossing beyond 75%, the investment intentions in manufacturing have moderated in 2025-26. The difficult external environment is likely to further complicate the economic growth outlook for 2025-26, especially for the manufacturing sector outlook, with implications for job creation. It calls for supporting growth through both fiscal and monetary policy.'Despite the concerns around external volatility, the RBI's rate-setting panel in its June MPC meeting retained its GDP growth forecast for FY26 at 6.5%, with quarterly estimates holding economy grew at 7.4% in the March quarter, marking the fastest pace in the past four quarters. However, the full-year FY25 growth settled at 6.5%, slightly below the average of recent years. Governor Malhotra had acknowledged persistent external challenges such as geopolitical conflicts and changing trade policies, but remained confident in the domestic economic momentum, supported by a strong monsoon forecast and continued strength in the services central bank maintained its quarterly growth projections for FY26 at 6.5% in Q1, 6.7% in Q2, 6.6% in Q3, and 6.3% in Q4. 'Services sector is expected to maintain its momentum. However, spillovers emanating from protracted geopolitical tensions, and global trade and weather-related uncertainties pose downside risks to growth,' the MPC had added that the Indian economy is progressing well and largely in line with expectations, despite the headwinds from the global the inflation front, the RBI had revised its forecast downward for FY26 to 3.7%, from the earlier projection of 4% made in April. The downward revision came amid a sustained drop in price had highlighted that headline inflation fell to a nearly six-year low in April, driven by easing food prices and deflation in fuel. Core inflation remained stable despite global commodity market RBI's latest quarter-wise inflation projections were 2.9% for Q1, 3.4% in Q2, 3.5% in Q3, and 4.4% in Q4. The central bank had stated that risks to the inflation outlook were 'evenly balanced.'With inflation easing and the economy showing selective strength, the RBI and the MPC have chosen to support momentum while remaining cautious of evolving global dynamics.
Economic Times
2 hours ago
- Economic Times
RBI Governor pushes for growth-backed policies as global uncertainty clouds India's investment outlook: MPC minutes
RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra cautioned that rising global uncertainty could postpone business investment decisions. He noted that post-COVID recovery has been driven by public investments, with private sector investment remaining weak despite favorable conditions. Malhotra emphasized the necessity of implementing policies that actively support economic growth in the face of these challenges. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Growth and inflation outlook Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Rising global uncertainty may cause businesses to delay investment decisions, Reserve Bank of India Governor Sanjay Malhotra said, stressing the need for policies that support economic growth , in his statement, released on Friday, as a part of the minutes of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting.'On the investment front, the post-Covid recovery so far has been largely led by public investments, while private sector investments have been weak despite high capacity utilisation and improved corporate balance sheets. Moreover, heightened global uncertainties may put on hold investment decisions by businesses, underscoring the need for growth supportive policies,' Malhotra its June meeting, the MPC decided to cut the benchmark repo rate by 50 basis points to 5.5%. The committee expects that this dual-rate cut will significantly reduce lending rates, thereby, encouraging both investment and consumption, particularly in durable the decision, Malhotra said, 'It is expected that the front-loaded rate action along with certainty on the liquidity front would send a clear signal to the economic agents, thereby supporting consumption and investment through lower cost of borrowing.'The RBI had earlier indicated that investment activity is likely to improve, supported by higher capacity utilisation, better corporate balance sheets across both financial and non-financial sectors, and continued capital expenditure by the the overall investment landscape remains uneven. 'Domestically, the recovery of economic growth to 7.4% in Q4:2025 from 6.4% in Q3:2025 was a pleasant surprise. It helped to close the year 2024-25 with 6.5% growth overall. However, the recovery has not been broad-based. It was supported by the rural consumption and government capex. Private investment, especially in manufacturing, and urban consumption, have continued to remain subdued,' said MPC member Nagesh Kumar in his added, 'It is not clear that the growth momentum will continue in the Q1 of the current year, given the fact that consumption and investment growth is moderating. The survey of corporate performance shows that companies are deleveraging their balance sheets with rising profits. Despite the capacity utilisation crossing beyond 75%, the investment intentions in manufacturing have moderated in 2025-26. The difficult external environment is likely to further complicate the economic growth outlook for 2025-26, especially for the manufacturing sector outlook, with implications for job creation. It calls for supporting growth through both fiscal and monetary policy.'Despite the concerns around external volatility, the RBI's rate-setting panel in its June MPC meeting retained its GDP growth forecast for FY26 at 6.5%, with quarterly estimates holding economy grew at 7.4% in the March quarter, marking the fastest pace in the past four quarters. However, the full-year FY25 growth settled at 6.5%, slightly below the average of recent years. Governor Malhotra had acknowledged persistent external challenges such as geopolitical conflicts and changing trade policies, but remained confident in the domestic economic momentum, supported by a strong monsoon forecast and continued strength in the services central bank maintained its quarterly growth projections for FY26 at 6.5% in Q1, 6.7% in Q2, 6.6% in Q3, and 6.3% in Q4. 'Services sector is expected to maintain its momentum. However, spillovers emanating from protracted geopolitical tensions, and global trade and weather-related uncertainties pose downside risks to growth,' the MPC had added that the Indian economy is progressing well and largely in line with expectations, despite the headwinds from the global the inflation front, the RBI had revised its forecast downward for FY26 to 3.7%, from the earlier projection of 4% made in April. The downward revision came amid a sustained drop in price had highlighted that headline inflation fell to a nearly six-year low in April, driven by easing food prices and deflation in fuel. Core inflation remained stable despite global commodity market RBI's latest quarter-wise inflation projections were 2.9% for Q1, 3.4% in Q2, 3.5% in Q3, and 4.4% in Q4. The central bank had stated that risks to the inflation outlook were 'evenly balanced.'With inflation easing and the economy showing selective strength, the RBI and the MPC have chosen to support momentum while remaining cautious of evolving global dynamics.
