Over 14,500 children, 180 media workers killed: Why Israel faces war crime accusations in Gaza

Israel's critics, including former allies and legal scholars, say the scale of destruction, the targeting of vital infrastructure, and severe restrictions on humanitarian aid violate international law. read more
More than 14,500 children have been killed in Gaza since October 7, 2023. At least 181 journalists and media workers have died, most of them Palestinians. And with more than 54,000 Palestinian fatalities reported overall, international lawyers, humanitarians and diplomats are raising urgent questions about whether Israel's conduct in its war against Hamas amounts to war crimes– or even genocide.
Those questions have now reached the highest levels of international justice. The International Criminal Court (ICC) has issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former defense minister Yoav Gallant, accusing them of using starvation as a weapon of war and committing crimes against humanity. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is also considering a genocide case brought by South Africa.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Israel firmly denies the allegations and maintains that it is acting in self-defence following the Hamas-led attack that killed 1,200 people, mostly civilians, on October 7. Israeli officials argue their operations are aimed at dismantling Hamas while minimizing civilian casualties.
But critics, including former allies and legal scholars, say the scale of destruction, the targeting of vital infrastructure, and severe restrictions on humanitarian aid violate international law.
Heavy toll on civilians and media draws global condemnation
Since the war began, Gaza has endured continuous airstrikes, ground operations, and blockades that have decimated infrastructure and left large portions of the population without access to food, water, or medical care.
According to UNICEF, at least 14,500 Palestinian children have been killed and 17,000 others are orphaned or separated from their families. The region now has the highest percentage of child amputees in the world. Aid groups say Gaza is on the brink of famine.
In addition to the staggering child death toll, 181 journalists and media workers have been killed, nearly all of them Palestinian, the Committee to Protect Journalists reports. Israel has barred international journalists from entering Gaza, making independent verification of battlefield conditions extremely difficult.
A British government minister told the BBC that Israel was using hunger as a 'weapon of war'– a term that international law defines as a war crime. Israeli Defense Minister Gallant stated in October that there would be 'no electricity, no food, no fuel' in Gaza, calling Palestinians 'human animals' as he ordered a complete siege.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Legal experts say evidence of war crimes is growing
The ICC arrest warrants for Netanyahu and Gallant mark a historic development. The court alleges that the two men bear responsibility for war crimes and crimes against humanity, including persecution, murder, and the use of starvation as a method of warfare.
Legal scholars say the case is credible. Lord Jonathan Sumption, a former UK Supreme Court justice, said Israel's actions fit the legal definition of genocide if the intent is to destroy a group in whole or in part. 'Statements by Netanyahu and his ministers suggest that the object of current operations is to force the Arab population of Gaza to leave by killing and starving them if they stay,' Sumption wrote. 'These things make genocide the most plausible explanation for what is now happening."
UCL professor of law Ralph Wilde agrees. 'Unfortunately, yes," he said. 'There is now no doubt legally as to that.'
Baroness Helena Kennedy, a senior British barrister and ICC advisor, cautioned against the casual use of the word genocide but said the case must be taken seriously. 'We're not seeing justice,' she said. 'We're seeing grievous crimes against humanity.'
Israel defends its actions, lashes out at critics
Israeli officials strongly reject the accusations, calling them politically motivated and antisemitic. Netanyahu has likened the ICC warrant to the infamous Dreyfus trial, in which a Jewish French army officer was wrongly convicted of treason in 1894. 'No war is more just than the war Israel has been waging in Gaza,' Netanyahu said in a recent statement.
Boaz Bismuth, a member of Netanyahu's Likud party, said Israel's actions are not genocidal. 'How can you accuse me of ethnic cleansing when I'm moving population inside Gaza to protect them? How can you accuse me when I lose soldiers in order to protect my enemies?' he said.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Yet many former allies are growing critical. France, the UK and Canada have openly questioned Israel's use of food blockades and its handling of the war. The U.S., Israel's closest ally, remains publicly supportive but has urged restraint and allowed some aid to flow into Gaza.
Critics say the American stance is increasingly isolated. On June 4, the U.S. vetoed a UN Security Council resolution calling for an unconditional and permanent ceasefire. The next day, Washington sanctioned four ICC judges involved in the arrest warrants.
Jan Egeland, head of the Norwegian Refugee Council and a former UN humanitarian chief, said the West's response has been a failure of leadership. 'I haven't seen a population being so trapped for such a long period of time in such a small, besieged area,' he said. 'Indiscriminate bombardment, denied journalism, denied healthcare. Very little has happened.'
Calls grow for accountability and access
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the guardian of the Geneva Conventions, has been vocal in its alarm. ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric said both Israel and Hamas are violating the laws of war, but the scale of civilian suffering in Gaza is without precedent.
'Humanity is failing in Gaza,' Spoljaric said. 'It is surpassing any acceptable, legal, moral, and humane standard. The level of destruction, the level of suffering. It should really shock our collective conscience… We are seeing things happening that will make the world an unhappier place far beyond the region.'
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
She stressed that 'a child in Gaza has exactly the same protections under the Geneva Conventions as a child in Israel.'
With both sides under scrutiny– Hamas also faces ICC warrants– human rights advocates say accountability must apply to all actors. But the growing body of evidence against Israel, combined with limited media access and a rising civilian death toll, has intensified the international spotlight.
What happens in Gaza will shape the legacy of this war — and possibly the credibility of the rules that are meant to protect civilians in conflict zones around the world.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Hindustan Times

23 minutes ago

• Hindustan Times

BJP govt conspiring against minority institutions: Akhilesh

Lashing out at the BJP government in Uttar Pradesh, Samajwadi Party president Akhilesh Yadav alleged that it was conspiring to dismantle all minority institutions and target both Muslims and Christian organisations. Samajwadi Party president Akhilesh Yadav also alleged corruption in government departments. (HT FIle) Addressing a press conference at the SP headquarters in Lucknow on Friday, Akhilesh said: 'The BJP follows the British policy of divide and rule. Madrasas are being shut down, land records are being scrutinised, and bulldozers are being used on madrasa properties. The BJP is not just targeting Muslims, but is now trying to enter Christian institutions too. Lakhs of posts are vacant across departments, including two lakh in the education department. Yet the government boasts of a trillion-dollar economy and a developed India. Does this happen in a developed country?' On the inauguration of Gorakhpur Link Expressway by chief minister Yogi Adityanath on Friday, Akhilesh said, 'The trillion-dollar budget is not being spent on education, health and welfare for the poor, but on the highway of loot.' 'The 91-kilometre expressway has been built at a cost of more than ₹ 7,000 crore. It is not an expressway, but a four-lane highway. If you want to know the difference, pick up a book and see what the Indian Road Congress (IRC) says. Is this expressway built as per IRC standards? Will the government take action against those who flouted the norms?' asked Akhilesh. On the recent issue of alleged anomalies in transfers, Akhilesh said, 'There is a dispute as officers and ministers want to work as per their own free will. A deputy CM has complained that the officer of his department did not show him the list of transfers.' The SP chief alleged corruption in departments such as education, PWD, and urban development. 'There is a fixed rate for transfers. Despite Smart City funds from both Delhi and Lucknow, cities like Mathura, Agra and Unnao are struggling with clogged drains. The level of corruption in U.P. today is unprecedented,' he alleged. Akhilesh further alleged that the BJP was against PDA (Pichhda, Dalit, Alpsankhyak) and reservation. 'The rules of reservation are not being followed in recruitments. We all have to come together and protect reservation and the Constitution given by Baba Saheb Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar. PDA is our emotional slogan and it connects people,' the SP chief said.

Indian Express

24 minutes ago

• Indian Express

Fifty years on, we should recall how Indian democracy was tested by the Emergency

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,' warned philosopher George Santayana in his 1905 work, The Life of Reason. Public memory is woefully short; that is why it is rekindled through anniversaries and other periodic events. One historic occasion that we must never forget is the Emergency, imposed by the regime led by Indira Gandhi in 1975. June 25 this year marks 50 years of the event that shook the foundations of our democracy. India is the world's largest democracy. It can also claim to be a successful democracy, except for those 22 months when its democratic credentials were subjected to scrutiny. Two generations have passed since that dark phase. India has learnt enough lessons. Yet, to ensure that Santayana's warnings don't come true, we must keep reminding new generations about that sordid past. Indians waged battles for decades to secure freedom from the British in 1947. B R Ambedkar, while drafting the Constitution, warned the Constituent Assembly that more than foreigners, we were responsible for the loss of independence. 'It perturbs me deeply to acknowledge that India has lost its independence multiple times… due to betrayal and treachery by its own people,' he said on November 25, 1949, poignantly asking, 'Will history repeat itself?? He was categorical that if political parties fail to raise above partisan interests, 'Indian independence will once again be in jeopardy'. His message to his countrymen was that they must resolve to fight 'to the last drop of our blood' to protect our independence. It did not take even two decades for the country to come face to face with that dangerous reality. It may be worthwhile to recall those tragic events. The Indian National Congress was split in 1969 and one faction under Morarji Desai became Congress (O-Organisation) while the other under the leadership of Indira Gandhi called itself Congress (R-Requisitionists). When elections were held to the Lok Sabha in 1971, the PM Gandhi-led Congress (R) secured a resounding victory with 352 out of 518 seats. A few months into that government came the victory in the Bangladesh War that catapulted PM Gandhi into a cult figure. The next few years saw PM Gandhi transforming from a democrat into an authoritarian and arrogant leader. With no Opposition in Parliament, PM Gandhi went about governing in a ruthless and dictatorial manner. Corruption and sycophancy became the hallmark of her governance. Then came two successive challenges to the regime, first in the form of popular agitations in Gujarat and Bihar in 1974 against corrupt Congress regimes, and an Allahabad High Court judgement in June 1975 setting aside PM Gandhi's election in 1971 on the grounds of electoral malpractices. She was disqualified not only from ruling but also from contesting elections for the next six years. With no relief from the Supreme Court and with Opposition parties, united under the leadership of Jayaprakash Narayan, leading a massive popular movement against her rule, PM Gandhi was left with two options: Follow democratic dharma and step down, or use the emergency provisions available under Article 352 of the Constitution to impose a dictatorship and continue to rule. She chose the latter. She cited a 'threat to internal security' as the reason. How was a challenge to her regime a national security challenge? The answer can be gleaned from the Congress party's mindset — its president, D K Barooah, had said 'Indira is India'. At midnight on June 25/26, 1975, PM Gandhi had emergency orders proclaimed by then-President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed. Her government suspended fundamental rights, arrested all the Opposition leaders and gagged the media. The courts were declared ineligible to hear petitions from citizens demanding the restoration of their rights. The saddest day was when the SC upheld the draconian law denying citizens the right to move a habeas corpus petition in its shameful verdict in ADM Jabalpur vs Shivkant Shukla (1976). Like all dictators, PM Gandhi, too, believed that she was invincible. 'To be human is to be free', Desmond Tutu, key to South Africa's freedom movement, once said. The people of the country reminded PM Gandhi of that profound urge when they went to the polls in 1977. While senior politicians languished in jail, a silent, leaderless movement, led by cadres of the RSS and other organisations, spread across the country to restore democracy. Not only was Congress defeated at the hustings, PM Gandhi and her son Sanjay Gandhi couldn't even win in their seats. The Emergency years saw dictatorship in its worst form. A year later, the J C Shah Commission, appointed by the Janata party government in 1977, submitted its report highlighting the excesses of the Emergency including abuse of power, violation of civil liberties, forced sterilisation, the compulsory retirement of 25,000 government employees over their alleged political affiliations and the arrests of more than 1,10,000 people. Many of those who fought that second freedom struggle against the Emergency five decades ago are in power today. They are committed to protecting the 'freedom, equality and fraternity' that summarised the spirit of our independence. Yet countrymen should always be alert to the warnings given by American jurist Joseph Story: 'Republics are created by the virtue, public spirit, and intelligence of the citizens. They fall when the wise are banished from the public councils, because they dare to be honest, and the profligate are rewarded, because they flatter the people in order to betray them.' The writer, president, India Foundation, is with the BJP. Views are personal

Mint

29 minutes ago

• Mint

Iran-Israel conflict: Donald Trump warns Iran has ‘two weeks' to avoid US strikes

US President Donald Trump warned escalating tensions on Friday, giving Iran a "maximum" of two weeks to avoid potential American air strikes. His remarks come as Israel asserts it has already delayed Iran's presumed nuclear ambitions by at least two years. Trump also dismissed European diplomatic efforts, saying it would be "very hard" to ask Israel to halt its ongoing military actions, according to a report by AFP. A series of blasts were heard in Tehran on Friday as Israel kept up the massive wave of strikes it says is aimed at stopping Iran from developing nuclear weapons -- an ambition Tehran has denied. 'According to the assessment we hear, we already delayed for at least two or three years the possibility for them to have a nuclear bomb,' Israel's foreign minister Gideon Saar said in an interview published Saturday. Saar said Israel's week-long onslaught will continue. "We will do everything that we can do there in order to remove this threat," he told German newspaper Bild. As Trump mulls the prospect of joining the war on Israel's side, top diplomats from Britain, France and Germany met their Iranian counterpart Abbas Araghchi in Geneva and urged him to resume talks with the United States that had been derailed by Israel's attacks. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot said "we invited the Iranian minister to consider negotiations with all sides, including the United States, without awaiting the cessation of strikes, which we also hope for." But Araghchi told NBC News after the meeting that "we're not prepared to negotiate with them (the United States) anymore, as long as the aggression continues." Trump was dismissive of European efforts, telling reporters, "Iran doesn't want to speak to Europe. They want to speak to us. Europe is not going to be able to help in this." Trump also said he's unlikely to ask Israel to stop its attacks to get Iran back to the table. "If somebody's winning, it's a little bit harder to do," he said. Any US involvement would likely feature powerful bunker-busting bombs that no other country possesses to destroy an underground uranium enrichment facility in Fordo. On the streets of Tehran, many shops were closed and normally busting markets largely abandoned on Friday. Since Israel launched its offensive on June 13, targeting nuclear and military sites but also hitting residential areas, Iran has responded with barrages which Israeli authorities say have killed at least 25 people. A hospital in the Israeli port of Haifa reported 19 injured, including one person in serious condition, after the latest Iranian salvo. More than 450 missiles have been fired at the country so far, along with about 400 drones, according to Israel's National Public Diplomacy Directorate. We will do everything that we can do there in order to remove this threat. Iran said on Sunday that Israeli strikes had killed at least 224 people, including military commanders, nuclear scientists and civilians. It has not updated the toll since.