Wanted: Independent directors for PSU boards. But where is the approval?
Mumbai: Over three-fourths of India's listed public sector enterprises do not have the requisite number of independent directors, as these companies continue to wait for clearance from various government departments.
As many as 62 out of 79 listed PSUs lack the mandated number of independent directors, according to data from Prime Database. Despite repeated regulatory reminders, these companies await clearances from their respective ministries, delaying crucial appointments and inviting penalties from stock exchanges.
Government-owned firms, including Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd, Indian Oil Corp. Ltd, Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corp, State Bank of India, National Aluminium Company Ltd. and Steel Authority of India Ltd, did not have the minimum number of independent directors as of 2 June, according to Prime Database, a Mumbai-based market data tracking firm.
The list of non-compliant PSUs includes banks, oil and gas companies, metals and mining firms, power utilities, telecommunications, railways, and engineering firms.
According to the Securities and Exchange Board of India's listing regulations, at least one-third of a listed entity's board members must comprise independent directors. Additionally, if the chairman is an executive director, at least half of the board must consist of independent directors.
Also Read: HPCL gets new chief, four more large PSUs in queue
Boardroom bottlenecks
There are more red flags when it comes to board committees: 64 PSUs lack an independent director as chairperson of their audit committee, and 68 companies do not have independent chairs for their nomination and remuneration panels.
Additionally, 14 of the listed PSUs are yet to appoint a single woman director, despite gender diversity requirements, according to Prime Database.
'It's ironic that we are asking all private sector companies to comply with these requirements when government-owned companies themselves are non-compliant," said Pranav Haldea, managing director at Prime Database.
With PSUs failing to comply with the market regulator's rules, many have been fined by stock exchanges.
Last week, National Aluminium Company Ltd (Nalco) was fined ₹33.32 lakh for having only three independent directors—two short of the required five—on its 10-member board.
A spokesperson for Nalco said the company was continuously following up with the ministry of mines, its administrative ministry, for the appointment of the requisite number of independent directors.
The bottleneck lies in the approval process across various ministries, according to proxy advisory firms. 'The Prime Minister's Office should send a strong message to all concerned ministries and PSU companies that they need to be compliant, as non-compliance by PSUs doesn't send the right message to investors," said Shriram Subramanian, founder and managing director of InGovern Research Services, a proxy advisory firm.
'For instance, when the government, as a major shareholder, is involved in abusive transactions or there is trouble with key management, independent directors are the custodians of minority shareholders' interests," Subramanian said.
Also Read: India's PSU banks outshine private peers in arresting bad loans
Many of the largest money managers, including BlackRock and Vanguard, have voiced their concerns when these companies have sought shareholder approval for the appointment of directors, according to voting disclosures reviewed by Mint.
In August last year, Hindustan Aeronautics sought shareholder approval for the appointment of former chairman C.B. Ananthakrishnan. Nearly a fourth of public institutions opposed the decision.
'Nominee serves as chair of the board and bears responsibility for lack of independence. Nominee is an executive director on the audit committee," noted BlackRock, the world's largest money manager, with $11.6 trillion in assets under management.
In the same month, Hindustan Petroleum Corp. sought shareholders' approval for the appointment of Pankaj Kumar as a director, but 28.35% of public institutions, including Vanguard, opposed his re-appointment.
Despite governance lapses, investor interest in PSUs has surged. The BSE PSU Index, which comprises 63 companies, has outperformed the Sensex over the last five years. The index has gained 301% between 5 June 2020 and 3 June 2025, while the Sensex has risen by 135.5% during this period.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Tour operator told to refund elderly couple for cancelled tour in Covid times
Ahmedabad: A consumer commission here has ordered a tour operator to refund the full amount with interest, along with Rs 55,000 compensation, to an elderly couple whose tours to Japan and Europe could not take place due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The couple was reluctant to go to the UK, Ireland, and Scotland upon the operator's insistence three years later. This case involved Asha and Yogesh Doshi, residents of the Ambawadi area, who paid Rs 5.30 lakh in 2019 to Mumbai-based Neem Holidays Pvt Ltd for two tours — Japan and Europe in 2020. Due to the Covid pandemic, the tours were cancelled. When normalcy returned, they requested the same tour package, but the operator could not arrange it. Considering that people were still reeling under financial stress due to Covid, the couple did not demand their money back. In 2022, the tour operator offered them a 13-day package for Australia. They agreed and paid Rs 10,000 extra, but this did not take place. A year later, the operator offered the couple a tour to the United Kingdom. The couple refused this trip, yet their tickets were booked. They requested the company not to force them to accept this package tour and demanded their money back. As the operator did not respond, the couple sued it with the District Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission, Ahmedabad City to get the refund. The operator's lawyer appeared, but the reply was not filed. The commission said that since the money was lying with the operator, the complainants did not have any choice but to agree to the unreasonable request. However, compelling them for another tour against their wish was harassment. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now "The complainant's money has been wrongfully withheld by the opponent, and therefore the complainants are entitled to receive the full money of the package tour from the opponent," it said. The commission ordered the operator to return Rs 5.40 lakh with 8% interest, along with Rs 55,000 extra towards compensation for causing "physical harassment and mental agony" and towards the expenditure the couple incurred on litigation.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Three-wheeler EV adoption gains traction in Tamil Nadu
Three-wheeler electric vehicle (EV) penetration in Tamil Nadu so far in the calendar year 2025 has already surpassed the numbers for 2024, data show. As per data available on Vahan portal, a total of 2,802 electric three-wheelers have been registered in 2025 till May. EV adoption or penetration (measured in terms of EV sales as a percentage of the total vehicle sales) stood at 16.07% in 2025, as compared to 13.92% for the entire 2024. 'In Tamil Nadu, there has been consistent rise in the penetration of EVs, with 'Passenger Autos' rising from almost 4% in 2023 to above 8% in 2025. The penetration in the cargo vehicle segment is above 27%,' Roy Kurian, business head – last-mile mobility, Montra Electric, said. Montra Electric is the electric mobility brand of the Murugappa Group. 'State-level incentives — road tax exemptions and registration benefits — have helped lower the entry barriers for drivers. At the same time, availability of more reliable products has opened up a wider market,' Mr. Kurian said. Tamil Nadu has also been at the forefront in the usage of EVs, such as e-carts being used in waste management activities. The fast pace at which the government is focused on developing Public Urban transport like Metro Rail will also support growth of the last-mile EV solutions, he added. Montra Electric has seen strong traction for its EV three-wheelers in Tamil Nadu, with demand emerging from not only Chennai but also being driven by cities such as Madurai, Kanniyakumari, Coimbatore, Tirunelveli, and Tiruchi. Most of the initial customers being those who can charge the vehicles at their homes. Smaller towns, where travel distance is less, are quickly picking up EVs, Mr. Kurian said. The cargo segment is being driven by the logistics and e-commerce players, who have realised the benefits of EVs over internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles for better profitability. They can also set up the charging and service infrastructure to support the fleet relatively easily, he said. However, Mr. Kurian said there was a long way to go for both the industry and government to come together on specific areas, including: affirmative actions to discourage purchase of ICE three-wheelers and actively move to EVs and earmarking space for charging stations in the key market areas, Mr. Kurian said. Ragavendra Ravichandran, co-founder and chief operating officer, Plugzmart, a Chennai-based EV charger manufacturer, said the increase in adoption was mainly driven by economics — rising fuel prices and the much lower running cost of EVs. K.P. Karthikeyan, chief executive officer and director of Zeon Electric Private Limited, said even though three-wheeler adoption was rising, the numbers were still below the national average (which is at 45.27%). With the State government looking at improving charging infrastructure, the numbers will go up, he added. Sriram J, senior manager, charging infrastructure at said availability of more product options and drivers' comfort level had been driving the three-wheeler EV adoption. K.P. Karthikeyan, CEO and Director of Zeon Electric Private Limited said even though three- wheeler penetration is picking up, still the numbers are below national level (which is at 45.27%). With the State government looking at improving charging infrastructure, the numbers will go up, he said. Sriram J, senior manager, charging infrastructure, at Bolt. Earth said availability of more product options and drivers comfort level is driving the three-wheeler electric vehicle penetration.
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Indus water pact with Pakistan ‘will never be restored', says Amit Shah
India has made it clear that it will not reinstate the Indus Waters Treaty with Pakistan, which was suspended following the April 22 terror attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir. The attack, which killed several civilians, including tourists, was backed by Pakistan-based groups, though Pakistan has denied any involvement. In an interview published Saturday in the Times of India, Union Home Minister Amit Shah ruled out any possibility of resuming the 1960 treaty, terming it unfair to India. 'It will never be restored,' Shah said. 'We will take the water that was flowing to Pakistan to Rajasthan by constructing a canal. Pakistan will be starved of water that it has been getting unjustifiably.' The Indus Waters Treaty, brokered by the World Bank, allocated the three western rivers (Indus, Jhelum and Chenab) to Pakistan and the three eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas and Sutlej) to India. It also provided for cooperative arrangements on hydropower and irrigation between the two neighbours.
